Large order delivered on time and food quality was excellent. Would definitely recommend and order from them again in the future.

Figured I would start with the lowest on the OBX totem pole. The pizza was average at best. Thankfully I have other pizza places in the area to recommend, bc this ain't it. The pizza felt low quality. High bread density, cheap sauce, and overall bland. If you live there and never venture out to any pizza beyond this block I understand the reviews. Otherwise, come on people?! Mediocre! Do not recommend. Venture out to Nags Head for far better options. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

See all

Looking for really good NY style pizza that tastes great. Here you go. You will have to take it outside to eat if you want to sit, or a little counter can fit a couple people to stand and eat. This is an order and go place for pizza and salads. I have only tried their pizza, regular and thick crust pizza several times and then eat it in the car in the parking lot. Service is quick and you will not have to wait to order or receive a couple slices for lunch, dinner or just a mid-day snack. Located next to Outer Banks Brewery. read more

Proper NY Pizza! By far the BEST pizza in the OBX. We got the slices of cheese, margarita, deep dish, and a couple specialties. Prices are about normal for what the pizza economy is. The restaurant is fun and great outdoor seating! Highly recommend if you're in search of good pizza. It's a kind of pizza you'd be happy with eating once a week. The boneless wings were very good, crispy, and tangy. Great size too. Service is very attentive and fast. Great service. This is the spot to grab OBX pizza! read more

See all

I haven't been to this place in almost a decade. That being said when I came home to visit my best friend's birthday this was the number one on our food list. Did not disappoint. The service is quick and he even helped me with ordering as I didn't remember what things could be ordered or how they could be ordered for just slices. Very nice chill location they have outdoor seats and allow for pets as well. read more

Food allergy conscious! Any place that can do that with good food is automatically five stars. Fast service, reasonable prices for allergy friendly dinner for 6 at OBX. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Used to be a semi decent pizza joint but turned to thick, disgusting crust pizza. A real shame what this place has become.

Good pizza at a reasonable beach price. Major issue we had is that they do not answer their phone and make you either order on-line or in person. It is impossible to make changes or special requests from the on-line menu. For example we ordered a pasta dish, along with a salad and several pizzas, and we wanted the sauce on the side. That can not be requested when ordering over the internet. Even when ordering inside the restaurant they are very rigid with the menu. A person in our party wanted grilled chicken on their pasta and they would not do it. However another member of our party ordered a salad and they were able to get grilled chicken on the salad. We then asked to get the grilled chicken on the side and gave it to the person who wanted it on their pasta. There really was no reason to go through all of that. read more

It's just another doughy pizza! A few years ago we got our first pizza from Slice and raved about it. Not anymore! Ordered a large meatball/onion pizza. Nit much sauce, mostly thick dough. We remember it to be a thinner crust and tasted much better years ago! read more

Pizza? FIRE... Coke? GAS. It kinda exploded tho.) Come here after school. Absolutely Banana was cracked read more

I really enjoyed Slice to satisfy my pizza craving. The service is spot on and the pizza is delicious. It was a beautiful day so I opted to sit outside. I love that the pizza is saucy, hot and fresh. They have pizza by the slice ready when you walk in. I hope they continue to do well in the Outer Banks. read more

I noticed that they have a really thick deep dish pizza (pepperoni and cheese). I don't know how long they have had this for but I tried it and it is really good. Reasonably priced too. Also the key lime cheesecake is really good too. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

I got a slice of "Natural Gourmet", Margarita, and 2 deep dish pepperoni! They don't skimp on the sizes! All of that and 2 bottled Cokes was only $22. They were busy, but efficient. Honestly, worth a try! They have outdoor seating as well. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Our pizza described in the the original post. - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

See all

Decent pizza for a reasonable price. We stopped in Friday on our way out of town for two slices. My son wanted mushrooms on his - girl said not possible. Not sure why they couldn't throw some mushrooms (it is a topping they have) on a slice and heat it, but whatever! read more

Wasn't horrible. The pizza crust had a good cruspiness and consistency. It was not as flavorful as I thought it would be. Took a little longer to get a slice that was already cooked. The staff was very friendly. read more

See all

We was looking for a pizza spot with slices for the kid but with other options because I'm not really a pizza person. I checked their menu out and of course yelp reviews lol. Parking was easy and thankfully there wasn't a line to order we did 2 slices od cheese, single baked ziti, Cesar salad, buffalo chicken sub and a philly cheesesteak. The food was yummy. I liked most the Prices and portions was good. read more

Absolutely delicious. especially "The Buzz", the hot honey pushed it over the edge into a must-eat

Pizzas are delicious as well as the salads, freshly made. Service is good too. Never eaten in always order to go so I can't really judge the ambience. Definitely recommend. read more

Best prices for sliced pizza I've ever seen and it's delicious as well. Fast service. No indoor seating. Confusion bathroom door lock.

Fantastic pizza! We ordered and had delivery. Best in NC for sure. Deep dish not really like Chicago pizza but delicious just the same.

Great pizza, friendly staff, very organized, good sauce, big garlic knots-my son is a big fan!

All in all not that tasty. Cheap Sauce, Cheap Ingredients. Seating is limited. Garlic Bread is the best thing about this place.

slice used to be my favorite but now they're stingy with cheese on a cheese pizza and the crust is thick and chewy. past two chances we gave them they burnt the calzones too. did their cook leave them??? not worth the money! read more

I love the gluten free pizza here. The sauce is excellent and the crust is perfection! I added lots of toppings and appreciated how fresh everything was. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Gluten free pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

I ordered Slice before I left my house to grab some groceries. It said 30 mins and I got the text 11 minutes later that the food was ready! I ordered the cheesesteak and a large pizza with half mushroom and green peppers. The cheesesteak was great! The bread was soft and flavorful. The cheese half of the pizza was great! It was well cooked and had tons of cheese. The mushroom pepper half of the pizza was just ok. The mushrooms tasted spiced or something. Overall was good for a lazy night meal and was ready extremely quick! read more

Slice Pizzeria - Pizza with half cheese, half green peppers and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

I asked some locals where to get the best pizza in Nags Head/Kitty Hawk and this place was on everybody's list, so I gave it a go. Ordered the Margherita and was exceedingly pleased. The chewy crust, fresh ruby-red plum tomatoes, and fresh basil were excellent, but to me the stars of this pie-show were the fresh garlic, which was very liberally applied and immensely satisfying, and the fresh mozzarella. You know how real, fresh moz feels pillowy when you bite it? And how it has that mild but distinctive and unmistakable, beautiful flavor? BAM. This moz was as good as any I've had in NYC or anywhere else. Didn't really expect to find pizza this good in the OBX, but hey, good surprises are part of what makes life such a great ride. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Margherita pie - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

When we get into town, this is our first stop. Pizza by the slice! Yummy! Service is wonderful! The outside sitting area is nice too when there is a breeze! read more

Slice is a must anytime we come down to OBX. They never disappoint! Pizza is always great and the prices are good too! Living in Virginia Beach, we pay at least $25 more for basically the same order! Love Slice and will be back read more

Really good pizza by the slice! Tried the Pepperoni, Cheese and Margarita and were not disappointed. Staff needs to explain how to order for Non Locals but outside of that it was delicious. Also tried an order of their Boneless BBQ Chicken Wings and they were also very good. read more

See all

Fantastic menu. Great pizza and garlic knots. Friendly staff and prompt, courteous service always

Told pizza would be ready 20-30 min. And I would get a text. Came inside at 30 min , no text. Waited then server asked my name. Pizza cold. Pizza crust nothing special. Toppings sparse. I honestly don't know how it gets the rating it has. So glad that I didn't add tip when I paid ahead read more

This food was unfathomably delicious and we completely chowed down to the bone of this pizza we couldn't resist from eating almost all of it and the service was quick and it was fantastic being able to sit outside and feel free to move around and it was very quality weather as we enjoyed ourselves outside. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Have eaten here several times. Great specials and the slices are generous. If you like pizza, make this a go to place.

The food was good, fast service and nice restaurant too. No sit down option inside but if you like sitting outside it's a good place for that. 5 different sitting tables outside. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Pepperoni and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Not sure why but I expected more. Not the best cheese on this pie, but I have definitely had worse. Pres score of 7.2

Delicious food! I love their homemade, thick, and super garlicky Garlic Knots. I highly recommend to try the pizza and cheesesteak! If you like huge slices of pizza and foods with lots of ooey gooey cheese, this is the place to try. Parking was easy, they only have an outdoor eating area. Some employees were friendly. I am impressed by how well they handle the long line. I don't think I've every been here when it is not crowded, so definitely patience is key! I'd recommend this place for a tasty bite to eat! And I repeat, you must try the Garlic Knots! read more

Pizza was pretty good. Definitely better than most. Lack of indoor seating and wait-time were not great! We ordered slices that were right there ready to be boxed up. But it was a good 15 min before they did it. Probably great pizza if it was fresher. read more

Visiting from Maryland and we were looking for a nearby place to eat. This place was packed but service is great and the wait for food wasn't long at all. So don't let the busyness deter you! Get. The. Garlic. Knots. SO GOOD. I initially thought of just getting one for .60 but then I was like--treat yo'self, so I ordered six for $2.95. Worth it, not only based on value but your taste buds will thank you. We ordered the Chicago style pizza with pepperoni and sausage as the toppings--delicious! Our pizza order was put in wrong so what came out was a regular pizza. We were hesitant but we decided to let them know, and the person we spoke to (who we assumed is the owner) was extremely kind and corrected the order immediately (the Chicago style). He went above and beyond even though we were already super satisfied by the service, and gave us complimentary Knots and a $10 giftcard. I could tell they value their customers, which is so nice. I also thought it was super sweet he was training his son to work here. (His son was being trained when we put our order in.) Now I have a go-to pizza place in the area. read more

See all

Good and clean pizzeria in kill devil hills. If you are looking for good pizza that can fill up your family for not too expensive, this is a great place. Fairly thin crust (I'm not a big fan of thick crust) but they also have options for Chicago style deep dish pizza. Although they are only allowing take out or delivery during COVID, they still have seating outside that is nice. Most of their pizzas are 16", some you can order smaller, or you can get it by the slices. The pizza was good and the topping seemed more fresh than usual. It did seem a little overpriced- $25 for a 16" pizza, but I guess that was because they were their "supreme pizzas." One recommendation, don't get the garlic knots. They looked way better than they were. They turned out to be a little dry. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

See all

I had high hopes for this place based on the other reviews and I wanted try a local, rather than chain, pizza place. We ordered a large meat pizza and small Margherita pizza for delivery. It took over an hour, but was expected since we ordered during a peak time. We liked the thin crust on both pizzas and the meat toppings were good. The Margherita had chunks of tomatoes rather than slices which I was not a fan of. Rather than tasting the mozzarella, I got mouthfuls of tomato instead. I think we will try again and maybe dine in next time. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Margherita goodness - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina