We ordered the French Onion soup, Utica Greens and the tomahawk steak. While the steak came out a little overcooked the flavor was amazing. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. Finally the place gives off great vibes. You can't beat the price point at this place. I will be back. read more

See all

Food 3/5 Service 3/5 Ambiance 4/5 I went into Sloan's as part of a business trip - and I certainly wanted to splurge with my plus one. The atmosphere looked promising - rustic, simple - all the signs of a good, comforting restaurant. I took one look at the menu and something truly stood out - a 3 pound tomahawk steak. Perfect for sharing with a friend or two! When the steak came out, I was in shock. I have never seen that much meat on a single platter, let alone a single tomahawk - it was truly a big steak. The steak itself was done nicely - I have no complaints. It's meat, grilled - and to the doneness I expected. My problem was the sides, which honestly could have been a bit better. The potato didn't really come with much more than a slice of melted cheese and bacon (would have liked chives or sour cream, or even a noticeable amount of butter), and the onion rings were fairly lackluster. The "seasonal vegetables" that came with the steak were also a very modest portion of... carrots. Just carrots with a sweet glaze. Not necessarily bad carrots (maybe slightly underdone), but I expected... at least one other vegetable. I think some more variety to the veggies (plus just more to eat alongside this monstrous steak) would have made this much more of an enjoyable experience. I definitely walked out that night feeling full, but not truly satisfied. My partner-in-crime and I did finish almost the entire steak, after all. Next time, maybe I order less - but I'm still going to be wary of the overall quality of the food coming out of the kitchen. read more

Sloan's New York Grill - Tomahawk Steak - Barbeque Near Me - Oneonta, New York

The food was great and the service was amazing! We weren't a fan of their "11 BBQ" sauce. But, that is a personal preference. It basically tasted like ketchup! All of the grilled chicken were cooked perfectly! So tender and juicy! The Beef on a Weck and Brisket sandwiches were delicious! The only thing we didn't like were the Salt Potato sides. The potatoes were undercooked and they were not traditional salt potatoes. There was no garlic butter to speak of. On the other hand the baked potatoes were perfectly cooked! The French Onion soup has basically no flavor. I think it was a chicken stock base. Otherwise it was a nice lunch all around! read more

Sloan's New York Grill - Brisket sandwich! - Barbeque Near Me - Oneonta, New York

See all

Service was great, food was awesome. This is a family friendly restaurant so don't expect a quiet atmosphere.

We came in after a baseball game at ASV and couldn't have been happier with the food and service. As a party of 17, sometimes that can be a challenge. The food was delicious and the desserts were amazing. I was impressed with their Philly sandwich and the burgers looked delicious. Reasonable prices and great service. Can't ask for much more. read more

We visited Slaon's while in town for my son's baseball week at AllStar Village. They have a comfortable and casual environment that was just right for us. First they were great in accommodating our large group of 14 for dinner, but definitely recommend reservations if you have a large group. We had friendly and efficient service from Carla, she answered all our questions about the menu and specials they had that night and took great care of us for the entire meal. We tried the brisket puppies and onion rings with the horseradish cream to start, both were great. The starter salad was just a basic salad but good. For the main entree I personally ordered the Utica Chicken with pasta and was absolutely delicious! I had a few bites of my son's clam and crab chowder and his Denver steak with mushrooms, onions and peppers and both were really good. Tried a bite of my friend's BBQ smoker platter and the ribs and pulled pork was good but the brisket was a little dry A few friends ordered steaks, and they all said it was good steak, but not the best they're ever had. So I give Sloan's a 4/5 overall. read more

See all

If your there for a steak best in town! Ask for Emma and tell her about her tattoo if her daughter dog Otis! Best NY steak!

We're from CA visiting for Cooperstown baseball. The food was so amazing and our waitress was amazing. There were 18 of us. The brisket portion is huge. Appetizers were good! Loved the wings! Onion rings were fresh. Apple pie was so good!! read more

I got the pulled pork and I can describe it in one Word delicious highly recommended great family restaurant

5 stars? Nope! 10 stars!!! We had reservation for 9 people and came in straight to the table. They were so full and very crowded as it was 4th of July weekend. They have a big parking so it was easy to find a spot. First off, our server was amazing! Very very attentive to us, she ask us for our drinks every time she sees its almost empty. She also informs us of their specials and most requested orders. (Ambiance is also great, feels cozy and the place is clean and well-maintained!) We got the bread with a very nice dip, first time we tried that kind of dip (has dill)We then ordered our appetizers, we ordered Ringers (onion rings), then potato skin and their special Garlic Parmesan Buffalo wings. It was amazing and was very flavorful! Then came our entree, we ordered the tomahawk with turkey noodle soup and salad with coleslaw and rice pilaf. Every order of tomahawk you get two sides and two salad or soup of your choice. Some of our family ordered same. Oooftttt! By this time we are already so full but their dessert menu looked so good so we had to take it home! We paid almost $625, that includes the tip! Are we coming back!? Oh absolutely!! Will definitely be back again and order the tomahawk!! (some pictures were not taken as we devoured it immediately!) read more

Sloan's New York Grill - Barbeque Near Me - Oneonta, New York

See all

Food was great and server was very nice and helpful. We purchased meat to take home from them as well and they packaged it up and carried it to the car for us. read more

Figured I'd try again after a few years. Wish I didn't waste my money. Steak was grizzly and tough. You got two little pieces of potato with it and the vegetables looked like mush that was previously frozen. The salad was horrible. That's it. I'm done. read more

Wife explicitly asked for no salt on her steak and server wrote it in the order, but steak came out terribly salty. Manager suggested a different steak could be cooked quickly, but then tried to charge extra for the steak she had pushed. Steaks also were not particularly good. read more

Great steaks and the service was really great! The overall staff was good as well. I

Horrible food, horrible service. We moved to town from Florida and people said to try out Sloan's. Well, it wasn't as they made it seem. The food was bad/dry. The service was mediocre. And they charged for everything. Want extra dressing?? you're gonna pay for it. I ordered a cocktail. I don't even know what she brought me. When I told her that that's not how you make a Cosmo. She said because that's the way "they " make it. Did I want another one? No! was my answer. It was my birthday, and I was kind of hoping for something special. But even the atmosphere was not special. No one was in there, and the hostess had the audacity of asking me did, I have reservations. I looked at her and the empty tables and said do I need reservations? Don't act like you're fine dining especially when you're not. Won't go back. read more

My son goes to school there and says he loves the food. I called today and Emily? (Might be Emma?) told me I should have thought further ahead before asking for a reservation there. I'm from Manhattan and have never been treated by a restaurant here the way I was there. What do you think you are, Ruth's Chris? Seriously, get that attitude queen off your payroll before she costs you more business. I'll be going to Toscana from now on. read more

Was greeted rudely by someone named Emma. Was told that, because I called too late to get a reservation, I should be better and think what. Never experienced someone treating me like that in my years of eating there. Would be zero stars if I could because of that. Get rid of her and I'll come back. read more

Went with friends for the Easter buffet. The shrimp were absolutely delicious, but that was all. The prime rib was almost raw, and we all had all we could do to saw through ours with a steak knife. The portions were about 1/4 inch thick....at best. Extremely disappointing. read more

Everything I have had at Sloan's has been exceptional. Their appetizers are yummy, their entrees are very good too.

As first time visitors to Cooperstown, we were always on the lookout for a good meal. The staff is sweet but I feel it's to make up for the lackluster of the food. We waited 20 minutes for our food. When you have a child that has to be fed due to type 1 diabetes, believe me, you speak up. I ordered the roast beef. The dish looked unappealing. Sent it right back. The side portions were so small I was insulted. My son-in-law had the brisket so I got that instead. It was very fatty & the baked potato was lukewarm & could've been baked longer. This place doesn't live up to its full potential. It could be a goldmine. As a business food owner, I take great pride in satisfying my customer base. So much potential but there's a disconnect somewhere & it needs to be fixed. read more

Cute ambiance for a small town restaurant but the service was forever slow (but was really nice) and the food subpar. The roll to my burger was all wet from sitting in the juice. And the mocktail was beyond awful. It could always be worse tho. read more

My review is based solely on the fact that while the restaurant is huge, you could fit the bar in a closet. On my visit half the restaurant was empty and you couldn't find a seat at the bar. So I left. Sorry management. Smarten up. read more

We really enjoyed Sloane's! From the moment we walked in they were friendly and welcoming. The vibe was very comfortable. Loved the farm mosaics and big fireplace! We ordered the brisket hush puppies and the BBQ sampler. The food was fresh, tasty, and well seasoned. The portions were large and we had more than enough for two of us. The desserts also looked yummy but we didn't have room after a delicious dinner. Our server Kathy was kind, knowledgeable, friendly and efficient. Would definitely eat here again. And next time I'll try to save room for dessert! read more

Really love the steak here! The loaded bake potatoes are always made on point. I ordered the Tomahawk steak which fed two! It's was $95 and came with two sides and salads. The Cesar salad is my go to an the lettuce is fresh and dressing isn't too much. The bread whole was a must and that night they had the cinnamon butter and it tasted just like Texas Roadhouse I was elated! The steak was absolutely amazing! The clams appetizer is the best order for seafood lover because they put a nice amount of garlic in the sauce and it's perfect for dipping bread. Dessert we ordered the peanut butter chocolate pie and this is the only place I ever order this dessert. They make it's light and just right. Highly recommend to steak and carb lovers! read more

Sloan's New York Grill - Tomahawk steak with onion rings and loaded baked potatoe - AMAZING - Barbeque Near Me - Oneonta, New York

We waited 1 hour and 20 minutes for our food that never came, despite being told multiple times that our order was "next." Several customers who arrived after us were served before us. When we brought this up, the manager and owner were rude and dismissive, showing no concern or accountability. To make matters worse, we were still charged for soft drinks, one appetizer, and the salads that were supposed to come with our meals. The service was disorganized and unprofessional. We will not be returning and do not recommend this place to anyone read more

This was a decent meal. Many meat choices and a few fish ideas. I did the liver n onions with bacon. It was a thin tender slice with more bacon than onions in a great gravy. A baked potato was very very dry or over cooked and corn off the cob. No bread. Good for me. The cheese burger had to be re cooked, was med rare and not med well. Unsalted fries came salted. Out of ten. A six. The health dept scores are below 88 out of 100. Not good. I should have looked. The interior was shabby chic western and cute enough. Not cute enough for a second visit. read more

I loved Sloans! In town for CASV and needed a place for a late lunch/early dinner. We had seen great reviews on this place and decided to try it out. We shared a Tomahawk steak at $99 between two adult and one child. Sides could be a little bigger but the steak is definitely the star of the show. We had great service and the restaurant had a nice ambiance. I did try calling earlier to reserve space for a large party and they turned me down. I had to lower my party to 6 people. There was definitely space in the restaurant but I understand its best so the servers dont get too overwhelmed. I would definitely be back. 100% DELICIOUS read more

See all

The steaks? Fantastic. The brisket sandwiches were good but dry. They desperately needed a BBQ sauce. The chef stopped with "sauce no. 10," but he should have kept searching for sauce no. 11 because those were lame. All the other food: entirely mediocre. The buns- meh. The salad had good dressing but gross greens so, again, a wash. The house wine I had (cab sav) was good for $7. The beer my husband had--meh. The roasted vegetables? Again, fairly meh. But the French fries? Great. Waitress was nice, informative, and helpful. Ambiance on the inside is way cuter than the outside. A little cool so you might want to bring a sweater. read more

The service was fantastic, super nice and accommodating. The chicken was good as well as the steak and fish. The smoked menu could probably use some love and attention, I ordered the smoked sampler and at $30 a plate; I was disappointed. The brisket was dry and ribs where like rubber. However when I brought it to their attention and they took it off the bill, and offered an alternative. I will say the sides and apps where great. Again service was fantastic! Thank you! read more

Ok, food frequently comes out incorrect or incomplete. Some nights are hit or miss, but when it's good it is good. Not really worth the gamble for the price point. Can make a better steak at home. read more

Amazing service and very good food the best place I got to eat at while I visited ambiance was lifting read more

Sloan's New York Grill - Appetizers and the steak sandwich - Barbeque Near Me - Oneonta, New York

See all

We were four for Sunday lunch. Our waiter Albert was great, very helpful with recommendations. We all loved the nostalgic appetizer we shared of potato skins and our sandwiches. Great atmosphere with a nice bar toward the back of restaurant. Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Terrible service. They were super slow. The food was way too expensive for the amount given.

Consistently good food, especially the steak. Polite staff and a pleasant relaxing atmosphere.

Friendly staff, great food and plenty of room for large groups. I had the pulled pork sandwich, ribs, and a Reuben sandwich on three separate visits and I'm planning on a roast beef dinner any day now. read more

Not accommodating or welcoming from the beginning. These restaurants should expect Teams coming in and it started at the beginning with their preference not to put tables together. Waitress was outstanding but the so called manager was rude and honestly should not be in the service restaurant business. Team was trying to take a picture and she was annoyed that we were by the window sill and using it for our little guys while we took the picture right quick. We spent lot of money collectively as a team to be treated poorly. Lost our business and we will post throughout All Star Village. read more

Great place, great food, great service. We had dinner here tonight and Kathy was our server and took very good care of us. I would highly recommend you give this place a try! read more

Sloan's New York Grill - Heaven with salt potatoes and carrots - Barbeque Near Me - Oneonta, New York

My gluten free heart and belly was in heaven. They have a delicious gluten free bread! I had the Rueben and it was amazing. My uncle had liver and onions and onions and said the best ever. We came in with our whole baseball team, sat at different tables. Everyone said the food was amazing and the staff was kind! read more

Food was delicious. Our waitress, Delaney, was such a dear and provided great service. Super charismatic girl who really turned this meal into an experience. I would return just to be serviced by her again! read more

Nice Ambiance ,fair price and good food. We went there for dîner and we did not get disappointed read more