During a busy work day I found myself craving pizza and happened to be in the area of Slugger's so I stopped in for a quick bite. Parking is on the street but I easily found a spot. They offer a two slice and fountain drink lunch special which I opted for. I added toppings to my slices for an additional charge. My slices came out warm and delicious. The size of the slices is impressive as well. read more

Went here with my son off the Amtrak train at the Lancaster station. Everyone here was very accommodating and friendly. We loved the pizza and fresh chicken tenders. Would gladly come back next time we visit Lancaster read more

Great neighborhood place with kind staff and some great pizza. A variety of choices at a great price, good service, and good portions!

I've lived in the city for years and have always wanted to check this place out. Very clean upon entrance. We ordered food to go and waited, not the fastest service. Subs were mediocre. Hopefully I'll enjoy the pizza better next time. read more

Slugger's Pizzeria - Crispy Chicken Sub (large) - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

The pizza was actually pretty good. I'm not from Lancaster area, this was recommended. We had it delivered. Chicken fingers were not that great. I would try other things. read more

Consistently good pizza. The dough is consistently thick, it doesn't get too thin/floppy towards the center. I ask for well done and they always get it right. And they don't skimp on toppings. read more

On this past day of Thu., 30 July, 2020 at approx. 6:05PM -E.s.t-, my elderly friend and I had called Slugger's to place a takeaway order for a large pie. She wanted extra cheese, I wanted extra pepperoni and extra sauce. I had specified exactly what I wanted very clearly over the phone, and the order was promptly handled. I had been told on the phone that the order would take approx. 40min. till delivery. To my friend's and my pleasure, the order was approx. ten min. early, so I had gone downstairs to meet the delivery lady by the entrance to my bldg. I had paid her the Mount due for the large pie, which amounted to $18.00+, and proceeded back upstairs to dine. Upon my friend and I revealing the contents of the nice hot box, I had taken keen note of a few details. 1) No extra sauce 2) No extra peoperoni There was however a little bit of extra cheese on it which looked OK, but would have preferred a bit more, considering I had specified extra of everything, that included. I had called the establishment, and spoke to the manager, and had very politely let her know that there wasn't what I had specified on the pie. The lady knows me by name, as I am a traditional, frequent (before the pandemic) and a valued customer, since 2005. Her response was: "NO Andrew, I promise you that I did put extra sauce and extra pepperoni on the pie..." The reason why I'm annoyed is bec. the employee had promised me that she had put the extras into my order, when I clearly saw no extras on there. And that is one of the reasons why I am unable and unwilling to trust practically anybody. And when I am charged the exorbitant fee for a pizza pie of over $18.00, I fully expect--as a valued customer to see exactly what I ordered. I'm not interested in promises, handshakes, or word-of-mouth! And nor am I interested in being given some type of a confrontational attitude or double-talk like I'm dealing with an arrogant social worker when I raise an issue with a manager or another employee of an establishment about a clear discrepancy with my order. And that right there would be a strong signal for me to not return to that establishment. Although overall I was happy with the taste and temp of the pie this past evening I was anything but pleased with the arrogance and denial which I had experienced. Let me be very clear on this point... I am not a ten year old child. I am an adult man who is alert and educated enough, and who has the discernment to gauge the amount of food or material on a product(s). This is clearly one of those occasions where the cusromer was clearly right. Just a little critique for the management of Slugger's on the customer service thingy... In the future, when a customer calls with a concern about the quality of what you sell them, it is incumbant upon you to arrive at a plan to either replace the product, or issue a refund. Not to make promises that you were positive you had done yer job right. Because my photos tell a different story, altogether. So... in reality, the job wasn't done right. Im sure I shall return in the future but... not for a long time. Not impressed. Charge for a service? Deliver. End of story. read more

See all

While Sluggers admittedly looks a little sketch from the outside, the pizza that is offered up inside is sooo worth it to stop in! It was our first night in Lancaster and we were looking for something within walking distance of our AirBnB that was suitable for a variety of differing palettes. The menu is basic pizza shop-subs, pizza, and fried foods dominate the menu. There are a couple of tables inside, but this is mostly a takeout and delivery operation. Staff was friendly and very vigilant when anyone attempted to enter without a mask (which, unfortunately, happened at least 4-5 times while we were there). When I saw they had buffalo chicken pizza, I knew I had to try it. I convinced my spice-averse Mom to go in on it with me, while I ordered my son chicken tenders (which, of course, he barely touched). The chicken tenders portion was large and was very hot on arrival. My picky son ate some of the chicken that I separated from the breading. On to the highlight of the meal, the buffalo chicken pizza! If you are spice-averse, do not worry; it's really not that spicy. We say my mom is "born to be mild" and she could handle it like a pro. The toppings were delicious and well spread across the entire pizza. All the slices were also cut equally so there were really no outliers in monstrous size pieces or teeny tiny pieces. The crust was DELICIOUS! I normally don't even eat crust but this was light, crisp, and airy and worth finishing! The pizza also heated up well in the oven the next day for lunch-always a bonus! I'd definitely suggest Sluggers for pizza if you are in the area and looking for a yummy pie! read more

Slugger's Pizzeria - Chicken Tenders - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

The pizza is always a 10/10!! Would recommend if you're in the area. Right around the corner from the baseball stadium.

Huge slices of pizza. Very much mall'ish. We ordered a slice of anchovy , tomato and capers and a slice of Hawaiian pizza. Some toppings on both slices seemed like they did not go thru the oven. read more

Just ordered a pizza for delivery and I barely have my 2nd slice down before I had to get on to review it! It was amazing! Toppings, sauce and crust was perfect! We will definitely be having this again! read more

Idk what kind of castle some of these other reviewers were spoon fed in as a child, but Slugger's rules. It's everything you want in a neighborhood joint: great pizza, amazing hoagies, salads, wings, sports specials throughout each season, etc. The employees are so friendly and always seem like they genuinely love working there. I moved to Lancaster from Philly and missed being able to grab a quick hoagie and Slugger's are now my fav, their bread is SO good, better than any of the hoagie rolls I've had anywhere else. They go above and beyond on a basic house salad and add great toppings, and the prices are cheap. This is exactly the place that you want to support in your neighborhood to stick around. read more

The pizza they offer is pretty good. The crust is always cooked well and is some of the better crust I have had. The toppings are good and evenly spread as well as the sauce. My complaint comes with the cheese as I have def had better at numerous other establishments. They offer numerous other food items like most places all of which are generally average. read more

great pizza and excellent service! it's my go to for lunch, their slices and drink combo is not only delicious but also affordable

I wanted a large turkey sub for my Thanksgiving meal. I ordered a sub with NO MAYO. Went to eat only to discover the sub was LOADED WITH MAYO. Slugger's gets no more of my business. Thank you for spoiling my Thanksgiving Slugger's. read more

great amazing food and I'm a food guru especially the cheese steaks simple amazing and great consistency throughout ever bite!

Not the best pizza in town. Crust isn't my preference. But the service is quick and they're friendly enough. Great for a quick pizza slice or if you're ordering a lot for a party they are reasonably priced. read more

No complaints about the pizza. I ordered a sausage and black olives for take-out, it was very good, loved the crust, just the right amount of sauce. Inside the establishment however, was incredibly hot, worse than outside. I have no idea how people were able to sit and eat there in such uncomfortable conditions. I feel bad for the people working there. read more

Fantastic!!! Literally a corner pizza place. When we first walked in it was packed and I knew it was going to be good with the fact that all the locals were placing orders; even the local police on a well deserved dinner break. We ordered a Slugger pizza and a pepperoni pizza. If I am ever back in Lancaster I will make a point to stop in for a pie!! AMAZING! read more

See all

Great local place we found! Good food, friendly fast service, definitely worth checking out.

I order a pepperoni pizza and mozzarella sticks for delivery. The staff is kind and the delivery was fast. The pizza however wasn't very good. It was bland and the dough was undercooked. Wouldn't order from here again. Two stars for courteous staff. read more

I am a sucker for good service, and this place has it. I love mom and pop shops and the friendliness you get from places like this. My family ordered two pies and both were good. The crust is by far the best part of their pizza as it is the right part chewy, and other part crispy. Everything seemed fresh, and high quality and they make the pizza right in front of you. However, back to the service. Everyone was extremely friendly however they went above and beyond for my family. During a visit to a family member in the hospital, we went here to get some pies. While we were waiting to get the pizzas we noticed he had Phillies Bobble head on a shelf. My family is all big Phillies fans and on our way out he handed us the bobble head. This doesn't sound like much, sure, but he didn't have to do it and the gesture made our night. I hope to visit here again, and will be raving it up for a long time. read more

Pizza here is really good. Are lunchtime special 2 slices and a drink is a great deal. First time ever here and I will be returning. Employees were very professional and nice. Greeted me on the way in. read more

I got a coupon in the mail for a free 14" pizza and decided to take them up on their offer. It wasnt bad! I got a 14" mushroom and green pepper pizza that was good hot, and good after a day of sitting in the fridge. I give their pizza 3 M's. mmm. Sluggers is a block over from Clipper magazine stadium on arch and queen. All credit cards accepted. Street parking. Be warned tho, if theres a game at the stadium, you may not be able to find a place to park. read more

I've had less than optimal results when buying by the slice; slices seemed reheated to a crisp and toppings were unimpressive. Called in today for and got a fresh pizza to go for the first time, and it was completely different. Phone service was professional. After pickup, I could smell the olives the entire way home. When I finally ate, it was fresh, tasty, and the dough was perfect. I'll definitely be a repeat customer! read more

As a native Pennsylvanian, this place has the most New York style pizza in Lancaster. It's a thinner crust. The pizza's cheap and good. When I went there, my pizza was even too big for the box! The customer service is great, you can tell the owner really cares about his business. read more

I saw the reviews and thought I would try it. I ordered a calzone with no meat and a slice of pizza to be delivered. The minimum was $10, my order came to $9.98. The computer would not allow it, so I ordered a drink. Not too bad yet... The girl says I will call you and you can meet me in the lobby. Okay, I guess bringing it to my room is not going to happen. After I give a decent tip I ask if utensils are inside, I was told, no, you have to ask for them. HUH? You are delivering to a HOTEL! I do not carry utensils with me. This was a first for me and I am in a hotel 300 nights a year! I look at the bill up in my room, $1.00 for delivery. Funny, it is not listed on the web site anywhere. It is only $1 but it is the point. Then the food...The calzone was decent, a little under cooked for me, but not too bad. The slice of pizza was not good at all. Rubbery, almost like they put it in a microwave. So, I would not order from them again with everything that happened. Overall disappointed! PS. I am a pizza junkie from Brooklyn. I eat pizza 2-3 nights a week, sometimes more. read more

Tasty pizza; nice staff. This was the first time staying in Lancaster with my wife and two kids. We were starving and we're looking for something quick to feed our very cranky kids so we decided on pizza. All the reviews prior mine were pretty spot on with our experience. When I ordered the food the person spoke with was very courteous. I did ask if I could use their coupon from their website (a large 1 topping pizza + 4 fountain drinks for $11.99) if I simply showed them the coupon on my phone or did I need the physical coupon. I was told they wouldn't honor me showing them the coupon in my phone and I would need the actual coupon, but I wasn't going argue the detail (I'd recommend watching the video "give em' the pickle"). We ordered a large pizza, half cheese half mushroom and sausage. The price of the pizza was great and came in under $13. The pizza was a little heavy of the dough side, but delicious nonetheless. I wasn't a fan of the canned mushrooms used on the pizza because I prefer the fresh sliced ones (not a criticism, per se, just personal preference). If staying in Lancaster again I would order from Slugger the next time. read more

Slugger's Pizzeria - Large pizza, half cheese, half sausage and mushroom. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Ate there 1x when I was 7 months pregnant and ordered a cheeseburger sub and I end up with food poison!! My husband did not however but he ordered pizza! Ghetto inside and the people were not friendly.. Not recommended!! If you're at a game and want food go elsewhere!! read more

I've been to Sluggers countless times and the Pizza has always great. Awesome neighborhood spot run by a super nice guy who's always welcoming. Recently came back to visit the area after moving away 5 years ago and it's just as good as the day we left. read more

Slugger's Pizzeria - a woman standing in front of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

So I ordered a pizza from here last week.... Very good! Decided to try something different and get a chicken sub with mozzarella cheese versus American cheese.... The refuse to switch out the cheese with" that's what the owner wants". Owner needs to grow set and allow the customer a reasonable request....so needless to say I will no longer be a customer. They draw one line I will draw another and take to social media..... Feel free to avoid based on the principle the owners way or no way. read more

I order from Sluggers often. I tend to mostly get pizza delivered. I like it. There are a number of options in the city and I keep coming back to Sluggers. I like the sauce, the toppings are good and plentiful, and the delivery service is typically fast. I have also had wings, salads, and subs. All of the items have been very good. For pizza delivery in the city you can't go wrong with Sluggers. read more

Good pizza. Wings are ok...sometimes inconsistent though. Prices are decent for what you get, especially their 2 slices and a drink for $3.49. 2 thumbs up read more

Pizza is good. Cheesesteaks are good. Great lunch special and wonderful, happy, and pleasant employees.

Not really sure how this establishment is still in business. One of the worst take out pizza's I've ever tasted, The crust is under-cooked and almost tasteless. The sauce is bland also. The cheese is very obviously the cheapest, most inexpensive bottom shelf "mozzarella". If you want low tier cheapest of the cheap pizza you're getting ripped off at Slugger's. If you want rubbery cheese, dry - cardboard tasting crust and bland - flavorless sauce, save a few dollars and order from Metro Express. read more

The ONLY pizza I ever crave. Nice New York Style pizza baked to perfection. Super friendly staff and the best lunch special in town, two huge slices and a drink for less than $5. Can't beat Sluggers! read more

I enjoyed the lunch special 2 slices of cheese pizza + drink for $3.99+tax. The slices were large and the pizza sauce tasted nice. I liked the crispness of the crust. Great deal. read more

You guys ROCK! Thanks for always bringing a tasty and consistent product. Best chicken tenders in Lancaster City! :)

This is my favorite pizza in town not only do they give you a really big slice for the price of a regular one but it's actually delicious, the only thing I would say that needs to change in order to get a 5 star rating is the fact that they use canned mushrooms please switch to fresh mushrooms the prices for mushrooms are always cheaper when buying fresh do yourself a favor and make your pizza better you guys are better than canned mushrooms!!! read more

We are out of towners and heard about Sluggers. Very pleased with the pizza. They had a special of 2 pizzas for 16.99 and we ended up taking a lot home and leftovers were good too! I especially liked the bacon topping as it was real broiled slices of bacon! Yum! read more