It saddens me to write this review of a restaurant with so many positive reviews, but sadly this restaurant missed on just about all of the food that we got. The service was pretty good, I can admit, however even that could've been better. We got started with our evening with a bottle of wine which was reasonably priced. The house arancini was chicken stuffed, which we were only told about after we ordered the dish. Sadly, the chicken pieces were large and there was just not enough cheese to really make this dish work - nor enough sauce. I even got a piece of bone in my arancini, which just ruined my appetite. We then had decided on the chicken parm for the main course (which later we realized was rather similar to the arancini). The first chicken parm piece that was got was rather large in size, however as we cut into the dish we noticed that half of the meat was still pink and cold to the touch. We showed our waiter, and instead of treating us with some empathy, we were told that "well its not our fault, but I've been trying to tell the guys in the back to pound the meat before cooking it." We were given another piece of chicken, and it was only slightly better than the first piece, but we ate a few bites and called it an evening. It's too bad, I'd be willing to try this place out for other dishes but I don't know if I'll choose this place again, knowing there are other options nearby. The best part of the evening was the ambiance and the wine, so maybe a happy hour in the future is in order. read more

Unfortunately, I didn't love this place like I was really hoping. I'll start with the good - friendly service and cute ambiance, definitely feels like a nice place to visit for date night. Our night unfortunately took a bit of a downturn when it came to the food. The stuffed Arancini for me had a weird texture with the chicken and overall tasted bland. The Chicken parmesan was raw when I cut into it which was off putting. When this was brought to the attention of the staff, I was asked if I wanted it "warmed up" or redone which seemed odd to me as the chicken was literally raw in the center and not just a little under. My experience didn't leave me wanting to revisit sadly, but hopefully this was just an off night. read more

This was our first visit, and while the ambiance and service were both pleasant, the food unfortunately did not live up to expectations, and we probably won't return based on this experience. The atmosphere felt inviting and our server was attentive, but the dishes themselves were underwhelming for the price point. The Arancini, crab cakes, and bolognese all lacked depth of flavor and seasoning, and none offered the layered, memorable taste you would expect from a restaurant in this price range. Presentation could also be improved to better match the upscale positioning. Based on the overall lack of flavor in the meal, we decided to skip the $12 dessert. The check was difficult to justify considering the disappointing food quality. Here is what we ordered: 2 glasses of prosecco - $12 ea Still bottled water - $9 Arancini - $16 Beet Salad - $18 Crab cakes with Orzo, kale and squash - $48 Bolognese with pancetta and prosciutto - $38 Total with tip: $200! The ambiance and service show potential, and we truly hope the food quality improves so this restaurant can reach the same level as the many wonderful dining options nearby: The Purple Olive, Llama, Blackfly, Bea's, and The Black Molly Grill. read more

If you're looking for authentic Italian cuisine Sogno is a must. The atmosphere is amazing warm and welcoming and making you feel like you're at home. The food is delicious and the service is wonderful. read more

Sogno Restaurant - Wine Bars Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Elegant beautiful atmosphere. Tastefully decorated for the holidays. The bread was piping hot and accompanied with a pesto dip oil. The chicken parm was delicious and the special ...rigatoni bolognese made your mouth water. We both tasted with a peril spritzers . The service was perfect, professional and attentive. read more

Sogno Restaurant - Chicken Parm - Wine Bars Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

I wanted to get to this review as quick as possible while the exceptional experience procured was fresh in my mind! However, as time can do, it got away from me and here I am. We went up to St. Augustine for the weekend of Valentine's Day. I had planned the whole trip down to a tee, but somehow I forgot the most essential part! Before I knew it, it was a few days away from VDay and I had NO restaurant reservations. Prior to the trip, I had made a list of spots in St. Aug that piqued my interest the most and I wanted to try. Sogno was on that list and still had seating available, so I jumped on it! The interior was quite lovely. Posh, but was still inviting. A look that in my mind would be tricky to create. There were ornate chandeliers yet wainscoting adorned the partitions. Pieces of fine art hang on the walls, yet there's a charming antique sideboard used as a wait station. We were seated right in front of a piano. It had a gentleman playing it most of the night creating a swanky yet traditional romantic ambience. I did not catch our waiters' name, but let me just tell you, his service was some of the very best! He was suggestive but not overbearing. Attentive, but in a subtle, classy way. Genuinely felt like fine dining service. My boyfriend and I were both very impressed and extremely pleased. I ordered the Caprese salad right away. It had tomatoes and fresh burrata on a bed of arugula that was drizzled in truffle oil. DE-LISH! I think its terribly notable when a chef can take such a simple dish you've had a bunch of times and re-create it in a way that has you saying "WOW" to every bite. That seems to be their bread and butter here at Sogno. Speaking of bread and butter - Sogno's is STELLAR. The bread tasted so fresh and came out piping hot. It was a rustic loaf. Ultra crispy crust on the outside, and unbelievable softness on the inside. The butter that came with it had a hint of garlic which I absolutely adored. Choosing my entrée was a tough decision! After much debate, I ended up picking the Rigatoni Filetta. Braised, tender, filet mignon chunks served in a tomato herb sauce over a bed of rigatoni. Chef's kiss! My honey had Pan Seared Cod served with pancetta lemon risotto and grilled broccolini. Of course, I had to taste his but preferred my dish. Being that everything we sampled throughout the night was utterly divine, dessert was a must! We were so stuffed; I got it to go. However, my indulgence took over and it didn't even make it to the car! Their tiramisu was so light, decadent, and delicious it really never stood a chance! I enjoy the atmosphere Sogno offers immensely. I loved watching the owners bring each customer's plate to their table. They exuded pride and relished in the personal touch that was being brought with each delivered dish. This was the best Valentine's dinner we have experienced all around. Everything was perfect. The ONLY complaint I would have about Sogno is that it's not where I live in Orlando! Sogno is a rare gem. If you find yourself in their area, stop in for an impeccable and memorable meal you'll be raving about how I have. read more

See all

Ate here this month. Superb experience. Service was top notch from the moment we arrived. The food was great. Chicken Parmesan was thick tasty and massive. The shrimp scampi was delicious. Super place. Highly recommended read more

The food here is amazing. I would say hands down my favorite new restaurant in all of St. John's County here in Florida. Tried the arancini for an app and was impressed. The pan seared salmon was melt in your mouth and cooked to perfection. It's cozy and beautiful inside. I cannot wait to come back and enjoy more amazing food. Truly impressed overall and the staff is awesome. I promise you, you'll not regret stopping in read more

I dined at Sogno last night with my husband and his family, a party of 7 including one four-year-old. The restaurant was surprisingly empty for a July 3rd evening, with only two other tables occupied when we arrived at 7 PM. Sogno has a nice ambiance, clearly geared towards finer dining, with a welcoming atmosphere following its recent renovation. Our waitress was prompt in taking our drink orders; my rosé was enjoyable as were the dirty martinis, but the old fashions ordered by my sister-in-law and husband were overly sweet and had to be sent back--something unprecedented for my husband in our eight years together (for food or drink). They tasted like simple syrup. For appetizers, we shared a delightful watermelon salad special and octopus, which is a personal favorite of mine. The octopus portion was generous, though the size of the tentacle was a bit off-putting visually, it was well-cooked and tasty. The meatballs were praised, while the fried calamari received mixed reviews. The mussels were also a hit, served in a delicious spicy tomato broth - only complaint is the crostini's it was served with were not a significant enough vehicle to sop up the incredible broth. The bread service, available upon request, was a highlight for me, surpassing the rest of the meal outside of the watermelon salad. Served warm with a crunchy exterior & soft interior, and ended up ordering about 5 rounds haha. Moving on to the entrees, the branzino was disappointingly salty, tasting too much like the sea, and came with a small portion of green beans (thankfully, they accommodated my dairy allergy by omitting the polenta cake). The lamb chop was undercooked--surprisingly, my husband felt fine the next morning--and the gnocchi was unfortunately very hard. We were starving so cleaned our plates, but I'll be honest, both dishes were terrible. On the flip side, the cod and lobster ravioli dishes were enjoyed by those who ordered them! Our overall impression is that Sogno is overpriced considering the quality and portion sizes, especially compared to other nearby restaurants. Despite the pleasant ambiance and some good dishes, the inconsistencies in food preparation and flavor leave us with no plans to return. 3 stars is generous. read more

See all

First visit, was very excited to see the menu, the staff was great, the food very good however the special was Crab cakes, $44.00, then they charge for credit cards without disclosing until you receive the bill. Very disappointing, won't return. read more

The chicken Marsala and osso bucco we ordered lacked any flavor which is especially disappointing considering the price point here.

Went here for dinner before a show at the St Augustine Amphitheater. It is a cute place! We had reservations but were running a little late, but they were very accommodating in making sure we still had a table, and the service in general was lovely. We started with drinks - i had a Vino Rosa Spritz and it was fantastic. My friend had Tramonto Toscano followed by a Mediterraneo. Each of these drinks tasted super fresh and the right amount of sweet. They were like drinking summer. They brought out bread, and at first I was excited broke off a piece and steam came out. However, it turns out the middle of the bread was ice cold - literally. That was a bummer but not a huge deal. For an appetizer, we had fried calamari. It was very good. Came with lots of peperoncini - which I love. For dinner I had the linguini with clams. The clams were pretty good, and the garlic bread on the side was decent. But the linguini itself and the broth it was served in had no flavor at all. My friends meal was redeeming. She got the Bistecca alla Fiorentina. The steak was properly cooked and well flavored. Green beans were on point and very good! Smoked confit potatoes were not for me - the smoked flavor was weird on potatoes, but she liked them! One downside (as is expected in this area) is the parking situation. The parking lot is tiny. Street parking is very limited. Overall, I debated between 3 and 4 stars for this - but I found myself thinking I'd still definitely go back for, at the very least drinks, and would likely try some other menu items since the app and one entree was good, as well as excellent service. So definitely 4 stars. read more

See all

Fantastic meal at Sogno with server, Lily. She was excellent -- sweet, patient and able to describe dishes and drinks very well to help us make final selections. Wedge, Caesar and Caprese salads were all solid. And for entrees, the Oxtail, Osso Bucco, Chicken Parm, and Cioppino were all off-the-charts tasty. It was pretty dead on a Thursday night and this place is better than that! St. Augustine has a great Italian restaurant here and needs to give it some more love. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

I don't normally write a review on a glass of wine, but this place has a certain vibe. They made nice changes on the inside, Al fresco dining is an option. The decent size bar is the same configuration, although it's been updated. My glass of Chardonnay was excellent. The menu isn't overwhelming but diverse enough to hit most palates. Prices, as others have mentioned, are higher than you'll see in most local spots so proof will come when I eat here. I will. I'll be back for dinner. read more

Boy you have to love the cranky food critics on here or the egotistical person from CA that won't even post their photo and claims all 5 stars are fake. Pitiful. Im a local and have dined here on two separate occasions and the food and service were outstanding . We've frequented Italy 6 times and the food here is just as fresh, the drinks are amazing, and the service is oit of this world. Do yourselves a favor amd judge for yourself. Theres a lot of great reviews here. Dont let sad people deter you from a great dining experience. read more

Totally overpriced, service good, food good, portions for the price ridiculous. Capellini with bolonaise 38 dollars, 9.00 bottle of water no gas, 4.00 for 1 Oz of goat cheese, one beet salad $18. read more

Sorry no pics but it was so delicious we ate before I could raise my camera. Probably the best meatballs I have ever tasted! The garlic shrimp was delicious and the fried calamari was also a good choice. My husband and I shared the 3 starters and our only regret is not having room to try the chicken parm which I believe is fantastic. Highly recommend, truly a great find! read more

Food is good but limited selection and pricey. Service was good also. Looks like when crowded the ambiance would be very cool. Quiet when we were there early. read more

Sogno Restaurant - Dining room and bar - Wine Bars Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Delicious food excellent service wonderful ambiance! Our 2nd visit. Definitely recommend for intimate dinner or a celebration. read more

Sogno Restaurant - Wine Bars Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

The food is excellent and the portions are more than plenty. The staff and owners are delightful. It is obvious they have a good flow and great energy. Very relaxing atmosphere with great food and wonderful ambiance. read more

Sogno is a beautiful restaurant, perfectly appointed in the style of an upscale NY restaurant. Service is excellent and the food is better. Sogno isn't a place to "go eat," it's a destination to enjoy your company, good food, and good service. Nightly, you will see both Brian and Stacy (owners) delivering plates or making drinks. They went out of their way to make it a great night. Prices are excellent, considering the high quality. Highly recommend. Very few restaurants in St. Augustine provide this sort of experience. read more

Sogno Restaurant - Wine Bars Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Recently went with wife and four children - I had the Bolognese, my daughter had the chicken parm - excellent food, my wife had a shrimp and pasta dish ! I grew up with fresh baked bread, fresh made home made noodles - pasta made from the garden... - so I have a clue. Excellent food and service was superb and friendly. The vibe is very clean and relaxing. My wife and I were tourists to St. Augustine and wanted to find something less touristy - worth the drive over the lion bridge from old St. Augustine. read more

We followed them when they moved from downtown to the island, food is on top along with great service. We are all New Yorkers and know great Italian when we have it. read more

the food was not very good for the price. I had the eggplant parm I had to send it back it was not fully cooked. the other five guests were very disappointed in their food also. don't think we will be eating their again read more

Overpriced, service good, food good, ambiance was very elegant. I won't be going back. A bowl of bolognese capellini $38. I could have fed 25 people. read more

We love this place so much! Just finished another fantastic meal starting with a featured watermelon, salad with feta and fresh mint and an arancini appetizer served over marinara. We dine here frequently because the atmosphere and service is always on point in addition to the exceptional meal. Tonight arrived early, sat at the bar and also split the cod entree which was served with risotto and green beans. We never forget to order bread served piping hot with delicious sweet salted better *chefs kiss to the whole experience. read more

My granddaughter made me give the extra star for the gelato and tiramisu!Ambiance and a welcoming atmosphere were definitely missing; Apps: real deal meatballs- wd recommend. Unfortunately the quality of calamari was not on point. The marinara was the highlight of the dinner for me.. a spicy diablo Yum!! The chicken piccata barely edible.. no sauce, a bone in thigh with no breading and a sandy, vinegar chard.yikes Veal Parmesan? My husband had to send it back; so tough he couldn't cut it, much less chew a bite. Caesar salad was delicious but beware of hard as a rock croutons! Our server looked to be running the entire bar and high tops at opening.. a tough job to pull off for sure. We booked the day of and could only get a high top in the bar at 4:30. Management absent throughout our entire dinner.. we had high hopes for this neighborhood local place,but sadly could not recommend for SA! read more

All about the apps tonight and a great selection of IPAs and wines to pair with! Those meatballs and this endive dish, look forward to getting back to the island to try more. read more

See all

Stacy, Brian and Graham you hit a grand slam! Your restaurant is beautiful, your food is outstanding, and the service by your staff was attentive but never intrusive. Dined last night and everything was amazing. Of course the wine, but everything we ordered was amazing. The flatbread and grilled octopus apps to the Branzino, seafood carbonara and the stellar seafood risotto which brought us back to one of the best we had in Venice. The Tiramisu rounded out the evening. Congrats and nothing but the best as word gets out. Sogno is a fantastic addition to St Augustine. We'll definitely be back. read more

Wow! New restaurant with seasoned chef, kitchen , bar, wait staff and management. The restaurant has a wonderful vibe. Food and service were spot on. Our appetizer, two entrees and dessert were all well prepared and presented. Ok they were all amazing. Portions are ample but not overwhelming. Service is attentive without being intrusive. Great for date night, couples night out or quiet solo visit. read more

If you make a reservation for an event, e.g. birthday, don't expect Stacy to do anything. I was a fan until I learned that "value" with Sogno is a one-way street. read more

Stacy and Brian have hit a home run in their new restaurant, the food and service are what St. Augustine needed. Here is hoping they are around for many years to come. read more

First time diners at this quaint place about a mile from the Bridge of Lions and worth every step. The service, the food, the ambiance... were all impeccable. We liked it so much we came back on Day 2 for just wine and dessert! Definitely put this spot on your list. read more

FOUR Times and counting! Definitely a dream come true for St Augustine. Finally a fine dinning experience with old world charm. Service staff trained to assist you in what ever you need to make your meal perfect. Owners Stacy and Brian are hands on ready to share thier hospitality as if they have invited you into thier home for dinner. Appatizers creative and delicious, hard to choose which one we want each time we are there. Seafood Risotto is beyond delicious, can't wait to have it again. I've had The Branzino is creatively served with a yellow tomato gastrique sauce, PERFECT! Had it twice. Our friends had Grilled Octopus, they were dazzled. And the Creme brulee, my favorite dessert, is the best I've had anywhere . We can't wait to make our number 5 visit ! Angela and Brian read more

Based on reviews, I guess we were expecting a little more. The ambiance was very nice. When we walked in and saw the piano we were excited; however, the style of music was completely inappropriate. While I am not certain of how to categorize it, at one point I said to my husband that it sounded as though we were at a piano recital. For an Italian restaurant, we would have expected soothing and romantic. The food was good but not exceptional. Service was good except that our waitress, who was very nice, after taking our drink order, didn't ask if we wanted an appetizer or anything like a salad to go with our entree. It appeared other customers did not have this problem so I think the young lady just forgot. read more

The wife and I decided to try Sogno and absolutely loved it! From the moment we walk in, the cozy atmosphere makes us feel right at home. The staff was friendly and attentive and went out of their way to make our dining experience special. The menu is not overwhelming and everything we had was cooked to perfection. The branzino was very flavorful (wife said it was the best she's ever had) and the octopus was done perfectly, very tender with a bit of char on the outside. I will suggest anyone planning on going try the burrata caprese. Topping it with the truffle oil just takes it to another level. We will definitely be back! read more

Sogno Restaurant - Caprese - Wine Bars Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

A wonderful evening. Attended a wine tasting last night at Sogno. It was a 5 course dinner with specialty wines (whites and reds) that complemented each course. Each of the courses from the charcuterie board to the dessert was absolutely delicious. The 3rd and 4th courses were especially noteworthy (lemon risotto and scallop) (braised rib with pappardelle). The presentation of each course and the service was wonderful. A good night was had by all! read more

We spent our Valentine dinner at Sogno and unfortunately had the worse meal that we have ever had at a fine dining restaurant anywhere. We ordered a wedge salad that I can only describe as the lettuce being old, tight & tough. It had very little dressing and a scattering of condiments. It was non-edible. We sent it back and were asked if we would like a substitute however, we said we'll wait for our entrées. We waited quite a long time for them to arrive. My husband ordered the Rigatoni Filetta . I had the Veal Florentine. After taking four bites of the veal of which each bite I had to remove because it was so tough I couldn't chew it, I asked the waiter to remove my plate and told him I could not eat it. The Cappellini was also dry. I was not offered an option and ate off my husband's plate which was at best over sauced and acidic. The salad and Veal were removed from our bill and I went home hungry and very disappointed. We had four wonderful glasses of red wine. Our waiter was very nice and the atmosphere lovely. It was our second meal at Sogno. The first being better. This one my husband said was awful. read more

We come to ST Augustine from the Atlanta area once a year and love the restaurants. But, we felt like trying something new this year. I googled and found this place. So happy I did. The service was very welcoming. We had a cocktail which was fabulous and the bread they bring in from New York. The bread was warm, crusty and soft, perfect. The calamari appetizer lightly breaded We had the baked cod with lemon risotto and broccolini. It was all cooked to perfection. The glass of wine was a good balance that paired well with our cod. All in all I would say everything was perfectly curated from the music selection to the wine list. I hope to return here next year. Thanks read more

Very New York Italian. Great service, food was cooked perfectly and instructions on my entree followed. Away from tourist...local place. I will recommend and also go back. read more