Opened the Montclair Times today and saw the review on the best chicken parm dinners in NJ. I have been to a few of them but none of them top Soho Pizza, especially if Chaz the owner is cooking. The chicken parm is perfect every time and a side of pasta with his plum tomato sauce makes the perfect compliment. Tremendous meal every time over many, many years. Montclair Times missed this one as nothing close on there list! read more

Wow! A double dose of amazing Coal fired pizza. What a find!! The crust was thin and crispy in all the right places and thick and chewy when you want it to be. The sauce and cheese were plentiful and high quality. Nice customer service during Covid. In and out in a flash. Very kind man on the phone and in person. Parking was surprisingly easy but I could see how that would be a challenge in better days. But well worth the park and walk. Heck, I would walk from New York to this spot for a slice of their pie. I see the posts about no masks, that's a serious matter. But in this visit, the guy had a mask on so it wasn't a problem. read more

Soho Pizza & Grill - The double sized-slice - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Delicious and Authentic Great food!! Also at a great price with healthy portions!!! I really enjoyed my meal. The atmosphere is cozy and the people are really friendly. A great place to enjoy wonderful Food!!! :) read more

Soho Pizza & Grill - I ordered this to go but it was a Delicious dinner when I got home. YUM!!! - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Would have liked to have tried this place, but after ordering online & being told pickup was until 8pm, lwe arrived at 715 and the place was locked up! Called and would have liked at least an apology the next day, but nothing. If I could give 0 stars I would. read more

This was my first time ordering from this restaurant. I ordered a pizza and an appetizer of shrimp in garlic sauce. This was a contactless delivery order. The order was delivered sooner than they estimated, the delivery person followed the contactless guidelines, and he rang my doorbell and waited at his car to ensure that i knew my order had arrived. The pizza is a smaller, 6-slice pie. I thought it had a little too much cheese on top and cornmeal on the bottom. The shrimp in garlic sauce tasted delicious and came with a few slices of Italian bread for 'dunking'. I appreciated that the menu tells you 6 pieces. I was expecting smaller shrimp but they were a nice size and butterflied. read more

Awesome food and Chaz is super nice. Pizza and pasta is amazing and the chicken park is to die for.

Stopped in to grab a slice only to realize that they don't believe in masks there. Not a mask in site. Asked if they wore masks and was told no. Will not be returning ever. read more

Pizza is nothing special and the place is dirty. Also discovered they refuse to wear masks ( but I had already paid for my order). The guys who run it put brawn before brains. read more

Ordered delivery for the first time today and this is what arrived. I called to ask what happened to the calzone and the same person who took my order told me,"that's how it should look to make sure it's cooked all the way through. What a joke lol read more

Soho Pizza & Grill - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

The service in this place atrocious! The guy practically threw the the pizza at me. Do not order the grilled buffalo wings, they are overly breaded and fried, to top it off, you get nacho cheese on the side. I kindly asked "I thought your menu said they're grilled buffalo wings" his response "yeah, that's what you got." Is this a joke? When I asked for buffalo sauce, he got pissed and tossed it my way. Perhaps there is a disconnected between the online menu and what you actually offer. The pizza is actually decent but the attitude of the gentleman and the service received is horrible! Regardless of convenience of distance, never coming here again. (Wish I took a picture of the wings). read more

Ok - if you're not a pizza person or if you are not sure what to try: get the Sausage Parm sandwich. It's amazing, and the sausage they use there is addicting. Very good people and very good food. There's a reason that Soho is our go-to place. read more

Ordered delivery from here for the first time. Was less than impressed and will not order from again. A simple order of pizza and french fries and nothing about it was good. The fries came greasy, soggy and underdone. This wasn't your typical soggy fries that were victim of getting soggy from the steam in the container during delivery. These were clearly under-cooked to begin with and were limp and greasy upon arrival. For the pizza, we ordered the Prince St. Pizza which is listed on the web site as having "grilled zucchini, eggplant and portabello mushrooms". First off, they decided to throw a ton of yellow squash on the pizza as well. Fine, I personally didn't mind the extra veggie topping. However, it was clear that none of the veggies on this pizza were "grilled" prior to going on the pizza. In fact, they were straight up raw. For anyone who has cooked yellow squash before, you know that you need to cook it for a while especially if the skin is extra tough. Much longer than the 8-10 minutes that it typically takes to cook a pizza. However it was clear that these veggies were put on the pizza raw to begin with and none of them were cooked enough in the amount of time that the pizza was in the oven which left us crunching on semi-raw squash on our pizza. Yuck. Also, I specifically requested in the instructions (ordered through Grubhub) for the pizza to be "slightly well done" and I swear that must've been read as "slightly UNDER done" because this pizza was in fact, very underdone. Was not a fan. Will stick to my usual go-to pizza places in town next time. read more

Delicious food, good portions, friendly service, welcoming atmosphere, and very reasonable prices! Great location, too!

The food is always excellent and worth the trip over! Chaz and Frankie run a great pizza shop and I'm glad to continue supporting them.

They make a delicious plain pie pizza, hits the spot everytime. Very friendly and appreciate owners/staff.

We recently discovered this Montclair gem. The food is fantastic. HOWEVER, I am forced to take away what should be five stars because when we picked up our order tonight, none of the staff were wearing masks. Just don't know what to do with that. read more

Absolutely DELICIOUS pizza and Can't say enough about Joey!!!! The customer service was impeccable- they def go above and beyond!!! Highly recommend!!!! read more

Won't be returning here. Service: my receipt and pen were thrown at me. I wasn't spoken to, but rather ignored while the man then picked up his phone and started chatting. Pizza: how can you go wrong with pizza in Jerz? No taste, bland sauce, nontastiest pizza I've ever had. It was so dry I could barely eat it. I'm really surprised at the good reviews this place has received. Also, got in the car and opened the box to check it out- the pizza had clearly been thrown around bc it was all smushed on top of itself. No Taste Pizza = No Returning Customer Andrea read more

Cute and rustic little pizzeria in the heart of Upper Montclair . Service is fast and excellent , recommend dining in, Newly renovated and very clean ! Joey treats you like family! Food is cooked to perfection , it's like eating a dish on a true Italian family Sunday dinner . Pizza slices always hot and ready to go! The BEST rigatoni vodka slice !!! **Recommend checking out their Instagram page for their daily special dishes or any dishes they may post from the menu . 5/5 ** read more

Meh food. Better than average marketing and convenience. Our workplace received a flyer for a ton of items for $6 during lunch. Salads, sandwiches, wraps, pastas and entrees. They all look yummy on the menu, it's well laid out, and the $6 price for anything makes it easy when collecting orders. I have to say I like the pasta. Both the penne vodka and the fettuccine alfred sauces stick to the pasta. You get a good mouthful of both pasta and sauce - not just pasta. Entrees don't come with pasta. Not too bad as you can score some free bread. The wraps and salads are a bit meh. Lots of greens, but not much else. The buffalo chicken wrap is a spinach tortilla stuffed with lots of lettuce and two pieces of heavily breaded chicken fingers. The $10 pizza is very thin and lacking just about everything - taste, texture, cheese, sauce. Bottom line: I would not order this stuff at home, but they make it really easy to order for the work place. read more

It's too late to post a picture of my chicken cutlet sandwich but trust me it was delicious and worth a little extra wait. The food is fresh and tasty and very good I will be a return customer! Thanks! read more

Was looking for a local restaurant with online ordering and loved Soho Pizza & Grill's variety. I ended up ordering the mushroom chicken with a side of meatballs. Online ordering through yelp/delivery.com worked seamlessly. Delivery happened within 30 mins and with a smile. The meatballs came in a very tasty sauce that was simple and not overly spiced (hate that) The mushroom chicken was very tasty and i found myself saving the gravy to use over a pasta dish the next day. All in all, a first experience from a restaurant I have never tried and will definitely be ordering delivery from again. Keep it up guys! read more

Joey and Chaz make catering so very easy! They are easy to work with, always have the order ready, and the food is delicious!! Highly recommend their chicken with wild mushrooms and Madeira wine, and their eggplant parmesan is perfect! Try their arugala salad with strawberries and candied walnuts!! Wish these guys continued success! Susan and Bruce read more

Got a pizza (half plain, half pepperoni & sausage) and two salads (chicken Caesar & buffalo chicken) to go with my niece. Loved it all! Very nice guys behind the counter and everything was really good. We will be back! read more

Best pizza in the area! Quality and fresh ingredients and a very attentive owner. Great atmosphere and the owner (Joe) clearly takes pride in his restaurant. We've been to many Italian/pizza places in Montclair area and Soho is clearly one, if not the best we have been to so far. We look forward to going back. read more

I still don't know how these people are open for business. This place have a lousy customer service. the pizza is old, its taste is unpleasant and the prices are expensive read more

Delish! The chicken francese sandwich is amazing. Idk why nobody ever thought of it before (maybe someone did think of it but I've NEVER seen it on a menu before). It's outstanding. The carbonara is great too. Love it! Also, I was running super late to pick up my order but they went out of their way to keep it nice and hot. Can't wait to order again! read more

I can't tell you how many times I've ordered from Soho Pizza, and the delivery is so consistently fast and the quality so consistently good that, after order No. 100-and-something, I feel compelled to offer this review. I don't live far from the shop -- which, oddly, I've never stepped foot inside -- but it's become the go-to delivery because, from phone call to table, the two large pies routinely get to us in 20 minutes or less. Yes, I remember that was the old Domino's slogan, but unlike Domino's, it doesn't suck. It's really, really good. A nice, crispy crust with a high-quality sauce, thin but not too thin. I haven't written many reviews but these guys deserve five starts and then some. read more

Soho is small, clean and honestly a great place for everyone. I ordered the calzone and its worth the money. To say "it was huge" is an understatement enough for 2 to 3 people. The ricotta and mozzarella poured out and the sauce was perfecto!! Absolutely recommend Soho Pizza & Grill!! The cook was friendly, professional and a great host. Give it a try!!! read more

Not only is the food on their regular menu great but Soho Pizza and Grill's catering services are outstanding. Aside from the delicious food, they are super patient and helpful with planning what to choose for your party menu. Case in point, I had no idea what to select for a summer salad for a barbecue we were having that included vegetarian and non vegetarians. That's all I had to say, I left it their capable hands and they created a salad that was perfect, it was the hit of the party! I've used Soho Pizza and Grill to cater my parties in the past and they've always done a great job. I highly recommend them, you definitely won't be disappointed. Debbie F. read more

I think this place is the best kept secret in Montclair. Quick delivery and hot delicious food is what to expect here. While their pizza is very good, I am hooked on their homemade soups especially the escarole and bean or their minestrone. They make fresh salads and serve their sandwiches on extremely delicious bread. Their chicken cutlets are perfection. I've never been disappointed. read more

Ordered 3 pizzas. Showed up with a perfectly valid coupon and the manager refused to accept it! It was a coupon printed by the restaurant and it wasn't out of date, guy simply said "we're not accepting these" and wouldn't budge. That's enough for me to never come back. read more

Tried to order on delivery.com. They called to say they dont have a delivery person and after saying cancel the order they say the will will bring it to me. Wait over an hour and call and they say "oh we canceled it.". Um, thanks for lying dude. Wont be ordering from them EVER. If you dont have a delivery person then dont let people order. Thankfully delivery.com refunded my money. read more

Had to make an account just to review this place. I went in once in 2016 and got the baked ziti, it was absolutely terrible. I decided to give them another shot since they are so close, I ordered cavatelli and broccoli. I honestly threw it out after two bites. The broccoli was barely cooked (it literally crunched when i chewed it), the chicken was breaded and tasted like tyson chicken tendies (they probably were), the sauce was even worse. The only redeeming quality was the bread it came with, but that is some expensive bread for 16$! Most of the people posting postive reviews here are probably shills. They probably have their friends post positive reviews so the ratings don't tank. Place is probably a front for the mob, no idea how they have been in business so long. Had to use a fake name for this account so those goombas dont come after me! read more

Just moved into neighborhood and I'm very particular with pizza. Tried another place that was avg at best. The plain pie here was pretty good but not great. Its not Ralph's in Nutley but its good enough. The meal we had and chicken fingers were solid. Used a coupon for a pizza, entree, chk fingers ans a salad for 30 bucks. it was a great deal. I'm sure I will start coming here often if I keep finding those coupons. read more

I am starting to wonder if the negative reviews are from competitors. I've gotten take-out from Soho three times and found the food to be great. The Bruschetta Pizza is FANTASTIC! My daughter and I almost ate the whole pie in one night. I've ordered the Chicken Blossom (chicken and roasted red peppers in balsamic sauce) twice and enjoyed it very much. Salad was fresh and LARGE. (No watery lettuce at all). Best part of their pizza is the crunchiness. I hate soft, doughy crust and even after sitting in the box for more than half an hour while I was driving around it still had some crunch left in it. After reheating a bit (in a skillet) it was absolutely perfect. read more

The pizza was unbelievably salty. No one could eat it in our family. I had to drink so much water afterwards. The only good part was that the guy at the counter was really nice but that's about it. read more

It pains me to see that no one else has reviewed Soho's wonderful pizza! This is probably the best pizza in Montclair. The crust has a beautiful crunch, the sauce is herbalicious and the ratio of sauce to cheese is just about perfect. I also heartily recommend their rigatoni vodka pizza, which is full of flavorful sauce and all the carbs you could ever need. read more

I am also surprised that Soho pizza is not more popular than it is. I think this may be that they are not in the middle of all the other stores in the busier part of Valley Road, but u can usually find parking easily and it is not crowded. The food here is great though!! The pizza is the best in the area!! We've had a few other dishes there and everything has been delicious! Their pasta, eggplant, chicken dishes and sandwiches were cooked perfectly and all of the ingredients taste so fresh!! The owner and staff are all pleasant and friendly. read more

I recently moved to Upper Montclair and have tried just about every pizza establishment in town and Soho Pizza stands above the rest. Delicious Pizza and salads, and to top it off, great customer service. read more