The owner couldn't be nicer - he's such a kind person. Very good pizza. The cannolis are superb. Fresh and crispy shell and creamy fillings. I got a traditional one, a salted carmel one and the cherry and amoretto filled cannolis. Loved! read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Cannolis - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

After seeing this place for years, I finally got the chance to stop in. Very yummy and the staff- including owner- were the literal sweetest!! So warm and welcoming. Great pizza options and loved it even more after learning it's all made on their homemade sourdough bread. Real family owned business meets tends Hoboken pizzeria vibes in terms of their offerings. The space is upper small and no bells and whistles. Yes, a few people can sit and eat but largely it's a take out business. They offer more than just pizza. Check out their menu. Great option for non-pizzeria but also not coal fired pizza, as well as other eats. read more

I ordered out so I cannot comment on ambiance or service, but let me say that the "Classic Jersey" pizza (their most popular to-go pizza) for $30 was quite a disappointment. The crust was thick and chewy, not pleasant at all. The toppings were a mess of tomato and cheese to the edges and in a large rectangle and well, not worth $10 much less $30 based on taste and experience. I wish I had better things to report and maybe I will try them again but for now, avoid the Classic Jersey! read more

Visiting family in NJ from DC for Thanksgiving, we parked near Teglia Pizza during a holiday festival. On the way back, my dad and I stopped in for a quick bite. The Chef/Owner was patient, welcoming, and very passionate about his craft. He walked us through the pies, highlighting plenty of vegetarian options. I chose the mushroom and caramelized onion, and after chatting about his family's cooking history from Sicily and five‑day dough fermentation process, he generously offered a vegan slice on the house. The Roman‑style crust reminded me of focaccia, soft on top yet crisp around the edges, sturdy enough to hold the toppings. The roasted vegetables were fresh, the squash creamy and rustic, and the marinara sauce was hearty, a truly memorable experience. This place is highly rated for a reason, it's authentic and the perfect slice. Definitely worth a stop if you're in Northern Jersey. I'm rooting for this place and can't wait to return! read more

See all

I'm a firm believer in the universe never failing me so, me landing at Teglia was meant to be bc I went to a different pizza joint but they were closed and Teglia was literally down the street. Super small shop but I guess that's why they call in a pizza bar bc there are only like 2-3 stools near the window with a thin wooden bar to post up and eat your slice. Was greeted the minute I walked in and the gentleman at the counter answered all my questions regarding what was what as far as the pizzas went bc there weren't any labels and nothing was "obvious". Landed on the chicken parm slice (which says a lot bc I am not a fan of chicken on pizza but this looked really good) and a drunken nonna slice both of which I asked to be heated up so I could take them to go and enjoy at home. Within a matter of minutes I secured the pizza bag and that drive home was so tempting bc the smell of the slices was like heaven and I wanted to pull over to eat them lol but I didn't. I decided to have 1/2 of each slice and save the rest for later ... when I tell you both slices were BOMB ... I mean BOMB BOMB OMG BOMB!!!! Not one single recommendation or complaint ... and as I mentioned earlier I'm typically not a fan of chicken on pizza ... Teglia changed that because I'd try any slice they have with chicken on it going forward bc the chicken farm slice was AMAZING! Can't wait to either grab slices here again or to order pies when I have company .. either way I'll be back! read more

See all

Came here for pickup before the big blizzard of this week hit the area. We ordered a half marinara/ half artichoke, pesto and basil and it was very solid. Pizza was flavorful, fresh ingredients, and a crust that was respectable and had the right amount of crunch. Ordering and pickup was easy enough and staff were friendly. Recommend if you are nearby. read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

I was looking for a pizza shop that I hadn't been too. Something that offered variety. & I found it! This small pizza shop , although small. It's a little hidden gem (in my opinion). Something that stood out to me , is that all of their slices and pizzas are Sicilian style. Which I LOVED! The guy who greeted us, which I assumed is the owner , was super sweet and showed us all of the options they had available. He was friendly and welcoming. The crust was perfect. Not too doughy and chewy.. it was soft with the perfect flakiness to it. It was able to hold the toppings and sauce. I absolutely loved it lol They offered a lot of variety which is why I opted to take a few and me and my hubby just shared. Our favorite was the spinach artichoke. Super flavorful and just perfect in every bite! They have veggie options and also stuff for meat lovers or those who like a little bit of both worlds. I'll be coming here again for sure! *Things to know.. -Parking sucks (it's in the Montclair area so that should tell you enough lol ) -Small place. Only a few bar stools to sit and eat. So not good for big groups -Lots of varieties -Good for vegetarians -Good Prices - Make sure you have a few different kinds like we did lol read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Different kinds of pizzas. We just shared all of them. - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

A cute spot for a nice slice of to go pizza. The place is small and cozy but does have a few seats If you like to sit down. It's a nice laid back spot with quick service , the pizza is thick and very tasty they have different flavors I had pepperoni and cheese and really liked it ! read more

See all

Teglia pizza bar montclair is sooo good omg. roman pan sourdough pizza crispy fluffy n tasty. u can even do half n half which is fire. chef joseph makes amazing pies def worth!! read more

See all

We wanted to love this place but Roman style it is not. We ordered a pizza to go and the dough had not fully proofed and was raw throughout. Or maybe it was due to many toppings on top when cooked the dough did not cook!! Less is more...good pizza doesn't need so much stuff . read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Still 5 stars; this may be one of the most underrated pizza places in New Jersey. Got the Taleggio, with Talegio cheese, Guanciale, caramelized onions, Ricotta crema, and Honey thyme drizzle. Just outstanding. This guy really understands flavor. read more

First timer and the food was amazing. Pasta's were great and the pizza was money And definitely like that it's byob. Staff was amazing waiting on & accommodating us. read more

A great, crispy slice. Either your first thought is "only squares?" or "I'd like to see if this pizza rating is real". But whatever your reason is for stepping into the shop is, be sure to grab a slice. The pizza has a nice crisp bottom layer, followed by a soft cheesy middle layer and topped with some delicious selections like truffle with mushrooms, pepperoni cups and roasted garlic. Everything on each slice works wonderfully together. Seating is tight as there is only a few located against the wall, if eating in is your preference. The staff are very chill and can help with choosing a slice or two based on what you are in the mood for. You won't regret giving one of their slices a try. read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Good pizza, but it's definitely a hole in the wall. Not a place where you can sit down and eat, only take out.

Love it. Amazing hospitality and culinary skill! Sourdough crust, makes his own ricotta... can't go wrong here.

Years ago this location used to be Mancini's pizza and I never thought I would say this, but I'm glad Teglia replaced them. This may be my favorite pizza in NJ. We did an order pickup and the pizza was ready when we got there. Staff are friendly! They focus on being a grab and go place. But they also a small counter along the walls of the place that you can eat if you want. We got the Caio e Pepe lasagna and the angry Nonna pie. The Caio e Pepe lasagna wasn't soggy, which was surprising considering how hard it is to get lasagna right. They gave it to us in an aluminum tin which was very convenient for heating it up. The angry Nonna was a Spicy pizza with Vodka sauce, mozzarella and provolone blend, Sausage, hot sopressata, Hot cherry and calabrian pepper relish, and fresh Basil. The pizza had a good crisp on the crust but is still pillowy soft. There's a ton of breading underneath the toppings which is how I like my pizza! read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Angry Nonna - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

This place is THE SPOT. The owner is always in the front working his pants off. He not only knows what he's doing, he loves it and it's clear. He is excited to tell you about the slices and they sound like combinations he made because he genuinely wanted to eat them. And they're GOOD good. Bubbly sourdough base gives you that crispy light airy magic with criiiiispy crispy crust okay like I'm talking nice cheesy cheesy edges like you get on a good lasagna. He is a pizza wizard. Now they also have a cannoli bar. This gentleman offered me a cannoli filling sample on a spoon like it was ice cream and I just felt like yes, this is a place for me. I had the Italian cheesecake cannoli which has homemade Italian cheesecake smashed into homemade whipped ricotta cannoli filling with those hints of citrus and a beautiful tiny preserved strawberry on each end. It was magical. I wish I had one right now as I write this. Listen, you don't find a lot of "legit" spots like this in places like Montclair-- this is an owner-run, real deal spot. It's as Jersey and home-grown as it gets. Do it because it's delicious, and do it for the principle. read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Our go to pizza spot in Montclair. DO NOT BE PUT OFF BECAUSE ITS A SMALL STOREFRONT! This is real pizza made by a real Italian with real pizza stories ! You want REAL PIZZA ..... This is the place! read more

Pizza was amazing. Thick, fluffy crust and so many different pie options. They just started a cannoli bar which was also delicious. Owner is super friendly and helpful. read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Drunken nonna - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Holly Shi!!!!!. This pizza is amazing... Crispy yet soft. perfect amount of cheese and pepperonis, and the hot honey gives an amazing kick.... This is in the top two pizzas I have ever had... The airy dough read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Pepperoni with hot honey - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

The pizza is so good!!! I am a weird person who doesn't usually want to eat pizza but I can never resist the pizza from here.

Easily in the top ten pizza I've had to date. I had a classic and a white slice. These slices are all exclusively square/Sicilian. The crust was thick, had incredible bite, but wasn't at all heavy in its volume. After exchanging a few words with the owner, who is incredibly affable, humble, and does what he does with pride and expertise, I found he uses a slow-rise technique for the dough. Flavor profile was incredible as well. Beautifully savory without any lingering taste, and all the ingredients went well together without one ingredient overpowering the other. There was no excessive oil or grease, and when you life a slice in your hand it feels so substantial you can't help but appreciate the weight of it. Crust was just buttery enough with just the perfect amount of chew. Ambiance is humble and cozy, and it adds to the charm of the family run eatery. I could go on. Try the classic, and the white slices and leave absolutely satisfied. Maybe stop by to chat with the owner, he's incredibly down to earth. He's also a pro chef so the guy knows what he's doing!! Make sure to tell him what you thought of the pizza! 5 out 5. Enough said. read more

Normally, we just order pizza from Teglia, but the sandwiches are not to be missed! I had the eggplant parmigiana sandwich yesterday (from Uber eats) and wow! Absolutely delicious and huge (saved half) It also came with a small side salad. The bread though was outstanding - nice crispy crust and perfect for the generous filling. I'll try the chicken next time! read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Eggplant parm sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Just delicious! We have never been disappointed when ordering from Teglia. Truly one of Montclair's best pizzas.

Pizza was great, dough is so good. Real pizza, good ingredients, and a lot of outside the box choices to select from

Solid 3 stars. Pizza is good sometimes but their topping game is always weak especially when you are charging over $10 to throw some olives and basil on. Just moved to the area. Will continue looking for my go to spot because this ain't it! read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Jersey with olives and basil - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

This is way, way better than any pizza in Montclair. There's no comparison, sorry. Square slices with the crispy bottoms. Highly recommend.

I came into this pizza bar with high hopes of having a good slice of pizza. Unfortunately, it wasnt quite the experience i was hoping for. First of all, the place is crammed up, with minor seating areas, only 4 on one bar. The slice is ready pretty fast, although not sure if its because of the oven or whatever, but the pizza has a strange taste on first bite. The slice wasnt overly bad but it also was not very good, i didnt finish it. The main kicker in which i thought was crazy, was i ended up paying 8 dollars for a slice and a can of soda! Thats a 6 dollar slice and it wasnt even good, and it was literally the size of a normal sicilian slice. Overall i didnt think this place was special and i certaintly will not be coming back. I can get 2 slices and a can for 5 dollars in my hometown. Bye! read more

This pizza became my mainstay when I was working in downtown Montclair. The pizza is fast, delicious, and the employees are lovely. Could not recommend more. read more

Ambiance is not really a thing. Just a few stools but the pizza is awesome. We had the mushroom and it was tasty. I wanted to try the butternut but I think it's seasonal only. read more

A really small dive pizzeria that has a small counter with a few stools, a few vintage magazine clippings on the wall and some pretty frigging spectacular pizza. And isn't that the point? It's the pizza, damn it and this ranks among the very best. Again, nothing fancy and typical shitty Montclair parking but the pizza was on point. Kudos. read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

This hole in the wall pizza place does not disappoint. Their pizza crust is made with sourdough, and the ingredients used are fresh and imported from Italy. The owner, Joe is very friendly and fun to talk to. They offer pizza by slice as well which is great too. It's a must try for all pizza lovers. read more

One of the best pizzas in Nj always great we love the white and the margherita are always our go to

We can't stop getting pizza here. Been doing the Roni Cup for so long, so we decided to try something new to us, the Pomodoro. It did not disappoint! read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Roni Cup pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

See all

Got 2 half and half's and everything was great! The texture is outstanding and the flavors are bold.

We ordered from DoorDash and got the Marinara Pie, Arugula Salad with Strawberries, Meatballs, and Tiramisu. The pizza has a really nice crust, but we just weren't fans of the flavor. I honestly can't even pinpoint what the problem was. Just the combination of flavors was off putting. Maybe we just ordered the wrong one. The salad would have been great if it wasn't drowning in dressing. It was ruined by that, which was disappointing. The meatballs were fine. The almond flavored tiramisu was excellent, but the portion was so small for $15 that I felt ripped off. I assumed for that price that it was going to be a very generous serving. It was just "meh" overall. read more

Got some pizza delivered for a late night snack. We got the pizza with all three sauces. Each bite was scrumptious. This is clearly high-quality and made with love. We got the wings too. That were pretty good but not memorable. Delicious but expensive pizza, worth it to us every once in a while! read more

We grabbed takeout a few weeks ago from here. Pizza was ready when promised and still hot when we go it home. I tried the butternut squash pizza for $23. Absolutely delicious with the a nice sweetness contrast. This was a 5/5. Highly recommend! It was even good a few days later warmed up. The Margarita that we also tried for $23 was good but nothing too special so more of a 3/5. read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Butternut Squash Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Love this little pizza joint with a "hole in the wall" feel. I'm not the biggest fan of Roman style pizza but this place might have convinced me to give it more of a try. Ingredients were fresh and the crust was substantial without being heavy. read more

Teglia Pizza Bar - Pizza Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

This location is fantastic, food is always on point , the pizza is on a whole new level, the staff is excellent and when I asked for contributions for the local elementary school they were beyond helpful and generous. Truly a town favorite and well deserved. read more