Didn't know what to expect from a pizza joint, but the wife spotted a Sunday lobster special so.... Well gotta say (well write) I was pleasantly surprised. The lobster special was very good, but the lobster/shrimp/corn bisque was just about the best I ever had. My dinner was the seafood fra Diablo- shrimp, clams, mussels, squid over pasta....one of the very few 5 stars I'd give out. Portions are substantial, bear lying leaving room for the home made peach cobbler. Outstanding! read more

Had a cute and fun experience at Spaghettini! We booked a pizza making lunch. They gave us hats, aprons and tiny rolling pins, 1/2 of the ladies used the chefs hats. Other 1/2 did not want to mess their hair! They started us off with garlic knots and bread. Both very good! We had a choice of wine, sangria, sodas or iced tea. I was driving so I passed on the alcohol. Then we got our individual pizza set ups and a lesson. It was fun! They gave us some toppings, pepperoni, mushrooms and peppers. We made our pizzas and they took them away to be cooked. We then had a choice of salad, Caesar or house. Everyone liked the salad and the dressings. We got our pizzas back in pizza boxes so we could eat some and take some home. Then they came around with a plate of cookies! The owner came over to talk to us, she said that they were planning to have pasta and mozzarella making in the future and told us about the other events that they have. Live music, bingo etc. She was one of the nicest people I've ever met. Sweet and genuine. She also showed concern about the parking situation and offered a reimbursement for the parking garage. We declined that offer, it was only a couple of dollars for the time that we spent there. If I had to be very picky the only one suggestion that I have would be that they add some basil/ oregano/garlic/pepper to the sauce or on the table, the sauce was very plain. Other than that, everything was amazing and so much fun, well worth the price that we paid ($40 pp including gratuities) for everything that we got! read more

See all

Cuisine: 6 Service: 7 Decor: 6 Value: 7 Overall: 6 I ate at the restaurant once before a few years ago. It would have received three stars based on the pizza I had. This review is based off the most recent taste of their food that my friends catered. They moved into the neighborhood and hosted a meal from Spaghettini. We tried a bunch of their food, and it did not get a better rating. The best thing I had was definitely the Italian Meatballs, which were tender and quite good. However, the sauce was a bit thin. The Chicken Francaise was pretty decent too, but nothing special. Pizzas were fine, but I did not enjoy the crust on either. Rigatoni w/ Vodka Sauce and Steamed Vegetables were average. The worst was probably the Buffalo Wings. Can't imagine the rest of their menu gets much better, so I'll stick with Taglio nearby. read more

See all

I came here for a friend's baby shower this weekend and it was a very lovely experience, no notes! We had the back tent, lots of space heaters so it was quite toasty. The service was excellent - very attentive staff - at least as a guest. The food was superb and very filling. The bread was fluffy and flavorful. The calamari was crisp, salad had roasted red peppers. The pasta alla vodka was reminded me of why it's one of my favorite dishes! Plus putting a huge bowl of parmesan cheese right in front of me without even asking haha. How did they know? I was so full I had to take my entree chicken parm home. I had it as a left over and it was so good too - sauce, cheese, breading everything about it. Everything was very well seasoned, nothing too salty. Finally the cannoli's were soft and delightful! I would be happy to go back. read more

Spaghettini Pizza Trattoria - Rigatoni Alla Vodka - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

Great place. Had a luncheon with 10 women and we made our own pizza. Came with a salad , cookies and either a glass of wine or soda. Staff were very friendly , and attentive. Pizza was delicious. I had onions and mushrooms on mine. Others had pepperoni . Your choice of toppings. Parking can be a little challenging. Street meter parking and I heard a parking lot to the left of the restaurant. They have special nights with live music and games etc. seems fun. They also gave us aprons and paper chefs hats. Was a fun afternoon. They have lots of pizza slices available. Sorry no pics this time. read more

Food here is consistently good for both dine in and take out. They have a brunch menu for the weekend that includes $10 drinks or $25 for bottomless. Their chicken parm is very good. The sauce has a little kick to it. They cook the spaghetti to perfection. The pancakes were delicious. Overall the staff is friendly and the quality of the food is good. We will be coming back! read more

Came here for lunch and we both liked our pizzas. Unfortunately dinner the other day was a different story. Both of our veal francese dishes were full of gristle and the sauce was way oversalted. Server forgot my hubby's Peroni and brought me the wrong salad dressing. Cramped space with uncomfortable bridge chairs. A hard pass... read more

Everything was so perfect. Food was delicious, ambience was adorable, attentive staff and price was right. We haven't been in a decent restaurant that has all the checklist checked . Everything was fresh and seasoned well. So tasty! Staff was so attentive and kind especially the owner Wendy. Charming and clean decor. We ordered so much food for 3 people and the bill was quit low especially for these days . We definitely will come back and they are super dog friendly during warm weather. read more

See all

Everyone is really nice at this place. Delicious food and full bar with a nice pour. The vodka sauce can run a little watery...that's my only complaint. Overall, great place for food with friends or family. Has an outdoors too but haven't done that yet. read more

Excellent food and service! Never knew they were here and live so close. Entertainment was a plus. I've now gotten emails with specials during week and will definitely go back! Mangia! read more

Came during the restaurant week and for $39 per person for the pre-fix menu they have is such a great deal! The restaurant is so clean, the staff are so friendly especially our server, Angela. We also met Wendy who is the owner of the restaurant and she was so sweet and almost made me feel like she's hosting us at her home. She even gave us a complimentary cookies. I had the chicken milanese and the chicken is perfectly seasoned and just the right amount of breading. The salad was so fresh and balsamic vinaigrette was sweet and tangy. The bolognese sauce had the perfect consistency and meaty with the fresh pasta. My daughter had the drunken chicken alla vodka had the creamy and buttery sauce and the chicken was so good and so fresh! The appetizers: shrimp cocktail, Mozzarella & tomatoes and fried calamari were oh so fresh! We truly enjoyed our dinner and meeting Wendy and Angela made our dinner more special. Angela also gave us a coupon for next time! We're definitely coming back and will prepare for karaoke! I can't wait! read more

See all

Spaghettini Pizza Trattoria is a wonderful gem that truly delivers on quality, comfort, and hospitality. The menu offers a great variety of Italian favorites at very reasonable prices with generous portions. I ordered the baked chicken with spinach and mashed potatoes, and the portion size was excellent--fresh, flavorful, and very satisfying. For dessert, I had the homemade tiramisu, and it was absolutely delicious. It was the most generous portion of tiramisu I've ever been served anywhere, and as someone who orders tiramisu whenever it's available, that says a lot. The atmosphere was cozy and relaxing, making it the perfect place to unwind. My friend and I spent four hours catching up after 16 years apart, and we never once felt rushed. The staff were kind, attentive, and welcoming throughout our visit. Thank you to everyone at Spaghettini for creating such a warm and comfortable experience. There are not many places that make customers feel genuinely welcomed, relaxed, and free to enjoy meaningful time with the people they're with without feeling hurried or overlooked. That kind of atmosphere is rare, and it made our visit even more special. I highly recommend this restaurant for a casual meal, family dining, or simply a place to enjoy great food and conversation. read more

I feel like I've been living under a rock !! My first time trying this place and I love it!! Like the food is amazing!! The food is fresh and tasty!! This place is my new to go spot!! read more

See all

I went for their Lobster dinner, service was great, they go out of their way to make sure everything is perfect! I had wanted a beer they happen to be out of and the owner went out and brought me back one! read more

Spaghettini Pizza Trattoria - Dining area - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

This might be my favorite restaurant in Mineola. Not just because the food is absolutely delicious (the beef Bolognese with rigatoni is out of this world) but the staff and owners are all great. We are always welcomed with a smile. The owner is so sweet and stops by the table to say hello and personally ask how the food is. I chose to have dinner there with some friends on my birthday and when the owner found out it was my birthday she ran out and got me balloons and flowers read more

Had a birthday party here. The pizza itself was good and the kids had fun. As for the party itself, as the hosting parent, it was a little embarrassing and I had to ask the person working the party to basically do anything. It took a while to get it going. They gave out the dough and apparently the kids were supposed to wait for someone to show them how to make the pizza. It took a while for someone to come so the kids had already started doing their own thing. I had to ask for more drinks, plates, napkins, and for the table to be cleaned up. I cleaned up a majority of it myself multiple times. I was given probably 6 dessert plates for cupcakes when we had 12 kids plus parents. I went and grabbed some myself because the person was gone. He then came over and goes oh we were really busy last night some of the plates might not be that clean. I looked and went ewww can I have paper ones then. How is that a thing? How did they go to the clean pile then? Some of the parents felt the same about the server when they made comments to me about me having to do stuff. I found out after the fact that the gratuity was already included for him, which totally made me feel like oh, he was getting 18% no matter if he did anything or not, so it all made sense why he put in almost no effort. Unfortunately I wouldn't recommend having a party here for that reason. read more

We went there today for my son's girlfriend's graduation lunch. The food was delicious. Joshua our waiter was amazing! And the owner Wendy is so sweet and thoughtful. She gave the graduate a beautiful orchid. I would highly recommend this restaurant. Thank you for a great celebration! read more

Spaghettini is a wonderful place to eat. The restaurant offers indoor dining and an outdoor dining option, weather permitting, which is in a beautiful tent. All of the food is delicious and the menu is extensive. Joshua G., our waiter, provided excellent customer service. Joshua was also very conscientious about dietary restrictions and he made sure my order was prepared correctly. Thank you so much, Joshua, the chefs, and the entire staff at Spaghettini for such a great experience. read more

Went to Spaghettini in Mineola NY today for Sunday Brunch. Got in just before the St. Patrick's Day parade around noon. The place upon entering has a pizza setup and then inside benches and tables for diners and a bar on the right side. Outside was a set up in a tent for diners, decorated with the Irish St. Patricks day theme, for what I'm sure was a busy time after what I found to be a very nice parade. ( see pix) We ate inside at a table. Elizabeth was what can I say , adorable and a good waitress. We ordered chocolate chip pancakes, waffles with strawberries, coffee, and pineapple juice off of the Sunday Brunch menu 11-4pm. The pancakes and waffle small yet light and tasty. 2 dishes just the right amount for 2 people. They did not have the chocolate croissant that day for dessert. NOTE: 15% OFF Dine-In/Take-Out Use Code- which we were able to validate and redeem per the phone. I'd stop in again when in the area. read more

I recently visited Spaghettini for the first time and had a decent experience. Located in Mineola, this restaurant offers a blend of fine dining Italian cuisine and classic pizza by the slice. The interior is spacious, featuring both table and booth seating, along with an outdoor patio where they host events and live music, reminiscent of a classic Long Island pizzeria. The staff seemed friendly, though my interaction with them was brief--mainly taking orders and delivering food promptly. Spaghettini offers a modest selection of slices. I opted for a regular cheese slice and an eggplant parm slice, while my brother tried the vodka sicilian slice. The restaurant is clean, and there's paid street parking nearby. -- PLEASE READ: I am creating a new Pizza Review Series in which I will be rating slices from over 30 different pizzerias in my local area in Nassau County, Long Island. I will use a regular cheese slice as a baseline and a specialty slice as added depth to the review. These rating are solely based on my opinion and taste preference so please do not be offended if one of my ratings does not align with your opinion on the pizza. I am excited to have Spaghettini as my fourth review in this series! #4 Spaghettini Pizza Trattoria Cheese slice: Thin and crispy with no flop, perfect for folding. It had just the right amount of cheese and sauce, although there was a bit more oil than I prefer. Overall, I rate this slice a 9/10. Specialty slice (Eggplant Parm): The slice was thin and crispy, but unfortunately, the eggplant slices were too thick, causing toppings to fall off when lifted. Inconsistent heating left some parts piping hot and others cold. The flavor leaned heavily towards raw eggplant rather than a well-composed eggplant parm. I doubt I would order this slice again. Overall, I rate it a 5.2/10. For more ratings please see my Pizza Ratings Collection on my profile. read more

See all

Wonderful lunch! We were visiting loved ones at the NYU hospital and came here for lunch. As west cost Italians, Jeremy was a wonderful guide, we asked him "whats the best" and boy did he give us good recommendations and excellent service. Ordered family style- salad(with a Delious Italian vinaigrette and roasted bell peppers) , garlic knots, amazing margarita pizza slice, with bolognese, and penne Al la vodka(a little sweet but with some red pepper flakes was delicious). Ended with espresso, cannolis and a cannoli crème tiramisu. Jeremy did not disappoint! It was a great spread! So good that I took home some cannolis (filling on the side) and some slices of the drunken Sicilian pizza home to my husband in California. It was a welcomed break from the hospital, and Jeremy really made it a wonderful lunch to remember. read more

See all

I stumbled upon Spaghettini when attempting Taglio across the street and decided to give it a try. I'm glad we did. My daughters got plain slices (I know they're boring) but the sizes of the slices were nice and big which is hard to come by these days and the taste was delicious. I especially liked the sauce. I got myself a drunken grandma slice which I imagine I'll be dreaming of. Crispy pieces of breaded chicken cutlets topped with vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella on a thin square slice. I will definitely be back to try more! read more

See all

The hubby brought home a personal buffalo chicken pizzetta and it was fantastic! With a paper thin, cracker-like crust topped with generous amounts of buffalo and a tasty buffalo sauce. Not the spiciest but had great flavor. When in the area I'll stop back in to grab another one. The Italian cookies were among the best as well. read more

Thank you to the owners of Spaghettini Restaurant (Mineola) for making me feel so special on my birthday. Service was great and the lobsters were fabulous read more

Spaghettini Pizza Trattoria - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

I work across the street at the hospital so this place is very convenient. The food is good but the only complaint I have is they stop making fresh pizza in the early evening and you have to pick from pizza that's been there all day read more

Came to see some music but the food was excellent!! We had spaghetti and meatballs and pasta primavera in garlic and oil. I'm very particular on my meatballs- and these were perfect! Very hard to do for me. Red sauce was outstanding. With the primavera, I asked for linguine al dente, and despite the fact that the restaurant was packed to the gills, my pasta was cooked as I asked (something that's hit or miss in other places). We shared the mint chocolate chip tartufo-type thing...Heaven- nice center of fudge. The entertainment was stellar (John of the Hambones) and our table was singing, dancing and smiling the whole time. Thank you, we will be back. read more

For a small place it was packed was lively and food n service were great. Cheerful ppl n a great Friday night out. Old Italian signs on the walls, reminds me of the old days I lived in Brooklyn. Ask for Angela, the best waitress there. read more

Spaghettini Pizza Trattoria - Live music - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

I've been to this restaurant before about 7/8 years ago and the pizza was much better. The food is not as good as it used to be. The one reason I'm leaving a 1 star is that I saw a mouse where they cook pizza. read more

Mineola is very lucky to have a place like Spaghettini as a local restaurant. I have been here a few times and always enjoyed myself. Joe, the owner, took great initiative when the pandemic hit and once outdoor dining was allowed set up a beautiful outdoor setting with a large tent. 10 of us came here for a Kiwanis dinner meeting (held outdoors) and we all really enjoyed ourselves. I had a wonderful sole franchise with rigatoni. There were many different dishes that night including a huge salad that got rave revues and a few orders of chicken cutlet parm which also received huge reviews along with the fact that the portions are ample size. We sat outside the tent which was holding a big retirement party. There was plenty of music and singing so we also had entertainment. Our servers did a nice job making sure that everything was good and we did not need any drink refills. Joe and his brother are seasoned restauranteurs and do a nice job making everyone feel comfortable and enjoy their meals. On a side note... During the height of the pandemic, they were collecting money to purchase meals that they brought to the hospital [located down the block] on a regular basis.... KUDOs to you gentlemen! read more

See all

4.5 stars overall: A wonderfully delicious surprise find. I happened to be in this neck of the woods late in the evening so I was looking for a dinner spot for my family at 8:45pm. Saw the lights on and called to confirm they were still open as many places were closing between 9pm and 10pm. Lucky for us, they had plenty of space -- indoor and outdoor options available. They have a lovely well lit outdoor seating area situated in the back of the building that stretches to around the corner. Menu ranged from pizza slices to full on entrees like seafood fra diablo, eggplant parmesan, and baked ziti. Or smaller bites like the jumbo rice ball and stuffed calzones. Great dining spot for both small or large groups. Service was friendly and the recommended entrees were spot on. Must try: the penne a la vodka, the seafood fra diablo and the clams with white wine sauce. I picked angel hair pasta as my choice of pasta but you have plenty others to choose from. We were so full between eating the complimentary bread and our entrees, we had no room for dessert. I spotted a delectable and freshly made Cannoli dessert plate. I'll return for that!! Note: the jumbo rice ball was indeed jumbo. Great sauce and size if you're feeling peckish but not entirely hungry. I wished it had a little more seasoning and texture, needed a little more crisp on the exterior. read more

See all

Good pizza always fresh and hot love the food here never had a issue with any of my food

My boyfriend and I went to Spaghettini a few weeks ago. We sat outside because their outdoor patio area was all lit up and it was a great ambiance to eat. I started with a nice glass of sav blanc and my boyfriend got a beer nothing crazy. We shared the mussels they were absolutely amazing and great way to start the meal. Then for entrees we wanted to just split more things to get the different tastes of everything. We split a special app, the Farmstand peach with burrata arugula salad which was so fresh and delicious. We also split their Supreme Pizza and this was by far one of the best pizzas I have ever eaten! We also decided to split the Porterhouse Steak which is on their special menu. This steak was absolutely incredible, cooked to perfection and priced very reasonably. Even though we were incredibly full we ended with espresso martinis and some cannolis and they did not disappoint. I will be returning to Spaghettini in the near future. The food was amazing, the service was great and the vibe was on point. We had a great experience. Highly recommend! read more

I ordered a chicken bacon ranch hero the guy asked me what "bacon ranch" was then proceed to ask me if I want tomatoes on my sandwich 10 times each time I said no. My hero ended up having tomatoes on it and the ranch was blue cheese read more

Delicious food and always friendly service! Happy to patronize this business every week!

Quaint little pizzeria & trattoria that serves very large portions of very delicious food. (Appetizers are very much share sized or could be the entirety of the meal). Staff were friendly and helpful with clarifying the menu so we could choose our meal. And all areas of the restaurant were clean, with a lovely window to see into the kitchen. Definitely worth repeat visits if you're in the Mineola area read more

Spaghettini Pizza Trattoria - Calamari Fritti - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

This place is always on point! The food, drinks, atmosphere and staff are above and beyond. And the owners are the sweetest people you'll ever meet... A must try! read more

We came upon Spaghettini by chance one night and I am so happy we did. The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming. The owners, Wendy & Rob, go above and beyond to accommodate all their patrons and make sure everyone is satisfied and happy. The staff is also amazing and friendly. Food is great and the sauce is fresh with that home made taste. They also have live music on weekends and events during the week. It is my favorite place to go for fun and a warm friendly atmosphere. read more

Unfortunately was at emergency room and needed a quick bite. Spaghettini came through with a delicious break from our wait in emergency room. Large salad and eggplant & meatball parm hero's was a nice hearty meal we needed. Nice to see they take foodie card also. read more

Spaghettini Pizza Trattoria - Meatball & Eggplant parm hero's - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

Such a great experience. My wife discovered a new drink she loves: Espresso Martini! We had brunch and the choices were plentiful and delicious. I had Eggs Benedict and my wife had Chocolate Chip Pancakes. Such great staff too! read more

Spaghettini Pizza Trattoria - My wife and I enjoying brunch. Her's is an Espresso Martini. Plain Ice Tea for me. - Pizza Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

Hey, it's solid. Am I gushing about it? Nah, not at all- but their vodka sicilian slices are good, the prices don't shred me to bits, and that's good enough for me! read more