Unfortunately the original owner had closed this location new owners supposed to be opening shortly. My last visit before they closed was typical. Best Sicilian slice on Long Island in my opinion. Like no other. Hoping when the new owner opens they make it the same way. Many years of great pizza from this location read more

Gino's Pizza - The best Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Williston Park, New York

Good large pizza pie. I don't prefer extremely thin pizza, I prefer my slices to be a bit thicker crust and size which is how Gino's makes their pies, thank you. Service was quick & friendly on a slow Memorial Day. Inside ambiance is mirror walls & the establishment is very tidy and clean. Pizza was pretty good & $22.80 at the time of this review 05/2025. read more

See all

Best Sicilian pie I have ever had. I have had them all over and it is not even close. Better than L & B Spumante Gardens in Brooklyn

My husband called to ask about their pie sizes and whether they offered Hawaiian pizza. They said they only make one size (large), which is fine, but when he asked about the Hawaiian, the response was, "We don't make Hawaiian pies," followed by, "Pineapple doesn't go on pizza, buddy." First of all, my husband is not your "buddy," and no one called to get your personal opinion on pizza toppings. It was a simple question about menu options, not an invitation for sarcasm. The attitude was totally unnecessary and unprofessional. We'll gladly support Vincent's down the road, a pizzeria that knows how to treat customers with basic respect. read more

Food was uninspiring and overpriced. Staff member who served me was surly and sarcastic in a very unpleasant way (nicely bearded male). Portion size was good but unfortunately that only meant I had to eat more of the uninspiring pizza. Not a place I would recommend. read more

This is a quiet, cozy restaurant with plenty of room for a party or intimate dinners. The bonus to having delicious food, they have pasta night and chicken nights! The menu was pretty extensive. You select your entree with a salad. Dessert and coffee included on the price too! All for less than $20 a head. I had a great time with the company I was with and we enjoyed ourselves on the filling and yummy food - including linguine and clam, pasta with spinach, mushroom, tomatoes and vodka sauce, baked ziti read more

See all

great pizza, back in time pizza, oldtimers make the best pizza, hey carol c, this is not the place for a hawaiian pizza, that post of yours sucks, you shouldnt give a place 1 star, because they dont make a hawaiian pizza, unreal, read more

The pizza has nothing special, sauce is just okay plus the crust is too thick. The charge doesn't match the price on the menu which was odd. Don't have much to say and would not return. read more

Gino's Pizza - margherita pizza, menu says $24, credit card was charged for $26. - Pizza Near Me - Williston Park, New York

Ordered a slice of Sicilian at the counter. Lots of clean booths with partitions. Slices were delicious. They have table service and the salads & pastas were over flowing. read more

See all

I've been eating here for over 40 years whenever I am in the area I have to stop in Frank's Sicilian pie is the best anywhere

What can I say... I am a stickler for a proper greeting when I walk into any establishment. This was the first time I purchased at Gino's Pizza and will certainly not be the last. It was also easy to park here... While street parking was full, the side streets are close and had plenty of available spaces. I walked in to the "Pizzeria Side" of the business and there were at least five guys behind the counter, and I got five hellos when I came in. All friendly and outwardly happy to see me. When I told them I was a first timer and lived locally that all smiled and asked "why?" This side of the location is the classic Pizzeria, booths and a counter loaded with every pizza you can imagine. I pretty sure that if you can think of it, they have it or will definitely make it for you. everyone behind the counter was extremely friendly and enjoyed speaking with the crowd waiting for their take out order. They were busy, I mean, really busy. Lots and lots of people picking up and now I know why. There food is really good. Did I mentioned that Jerry gave me a slice of pizza to show me how good their food is. It was good... thin crispy crust with plenty of flavor from their delicious sauce. It is definitely a place for the locals, everyone seems to know everyone here, both guests and staff/ I brought home a Chicken Parm and Francaise. Both of these dishes were excellent. The part were delicious strips of breast meet and the Francaise were larger cutlets. They also give you a large portion that I finished the next day. I am really looking forward to a return trip(s). They have a beautiful menu and I plan on trying all of it. read more

See all

WOW,... I'm sure they were just having a bad night but I didn't actually think pizza on LI could be this bad. PLEASE save your money. So many great options in this neighborhood. We actually had to throw the 2 pies we ordered in the garbage. What a disappointment. You can cross this one off your "pizza list". read more

Really enjoyed myself at Gino's on Monday night, the owner Frank was very nice, then it was handed off to John. He was also very good, the pizza is one of the best in Long Island, food is very good. Service was excellent I love the veal Sorrentino the light marsala wine sauce was very good,, rigatoni Florentina is also very good the portobello mushrooms and cherry tomatoes., Desserts were fresh, overall a very pleasant experience read more

See all

Took my family here decided to try a local pizza around my house. My neighbors mentioned this place and we said why not? Ordered margarita pizza for myself and regular pizza for my kids. One look at the pizza and it looked nothing like a margarita. Tried it anyways and I probably had 2-3 bites until I literally couldn't eat anymore. Tasted horrible. Super thick cheese ruined it. My kids Were eating it until my wife noticed liquid on their shirt, we took a closer look and noticed that it was from the oil of the pizza. It dripped all over their clothes! 4 slices, and we probably ate 1 all together. We all took 3-4 bites each and threw the rest out. However, the staff was very friendly and showed lots of respect. Overall, I wouldn't rate this place over a 2 but the staff brought the number up. Sucks because we really did want to like this place. read more

Decided to finally order Gino's family take out meal ... glad I did. The whole meal was yum!!! I added an order of garlic knots to my order cuz I can't order anything from Gino's and NOT order their garlic knots. My favorite thing to eat in Williston Park is Gino's garlic knots. See ... love love LOVE the garlic knots. Ok, let me get back to Gino's family meal. It easily feeds a family of 4. The trays weren't deep but there was still enough food. Decided on the tossed salad, which we really enjoyed. The salad dressing .. delish!! I do wish there was more rigatoni alla vodka cuz that was the family fave. The chicken parm was flavorful and good, the pieces weren't big or anything. All in all, will definitely order the family meal again. Great price for the amount of food. read more

See all

Grew up in the city and this is the closest thing to NYC delicious pizza on long island. Not saying that much because Long Island pizza is pretty bad, but this would be near the top. read more

The pizza side rules (Sicilian is da best! ) but My husband and I Try to go to Gino's on the dining side every Thursday. We always feel so at home here like we're in one of our Italian relatives dining rooms. Cozy little place that we love. delicious food awesome service, reasonable prices. The meatball parm hero pasta Gino, pasta carbonara the best read more

See all

Came here, while going to another business near by & I am so glad I did The staff was friendly & fast in fulfilling my order I got a buffalo slice & omg !! It was so good!! Super spicy, like I like it !! & I got knots & they were perfect too!! So glad I came here & I plan on coming back !! read more

Gino's Pizza - Buffalo slice - Pizza Near Me - Williston Park, New York

I was heading home in terrible traffic, eventually needing to find a stopping point with a craving for Italian food. When I can across Gino's I knew they usually have good cooking. I opted for an old fave from Vincent's Clam bar, the calamari and pasta entree. This wasn't nearly the best I've had. The squid was tender enough but ringlets are extra large cone shaped, lots of tentacles (which is okay because I enjoy them) that were very large as well; and the sauce was tangy and tasty, but kind of watery. Penne was plain, but the sauce made it fine. Might've been better off sticking with deluxe pizza slices. read more

Gino's Pizza - Fried calamari entree with penne pasta beside. - Pizza Near Me - Williston Park, New York

My husband was craving pizza last Sunday night so I suggested that we give this place a try for dinner since we live close by. This was your typical neighborhood pizza store opened by a real old school Italian owner. It was located in a central location in the town of Williston Park and there was plenty of residential parking. Pricing was very cheap and service was great with a family feel. We were the only customers eating in so there was no need to fight for a table or wait to be seated. One negative part was that they did not have a full selection of pizza since it was late Sunday night so our choices were limited. I got a traditional chicken cutlet parmigiana hero while my husband got 1 regular pizza slice, 1 Sicilian slice and an order of garlic knots. Although we have had better chicken parm (theirs is really messy-I had to eat it with a fork and knife) and pizza elsewhere, everything still tasted good and we will be back again to try some of the other things on the menu. read more

Gino's Pizza - Chicken cutlet parmigiana hero, slice (regular & Sicilian) and garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Williston Park, New York

Haven't had take out in forever from here and my dad showed up with pizza one day, yum! Seriously such good pizza. Anyway then a week later I decided I needed alla vodka which was amazing too. Def have to order from here more often! Great place for take out in the area, also nice restaurant too. read more

Great pizza , great food. Good people. 20 years been eating here. Always very good. They even play the Italian soccer matches.

Gino's pizza is "fracka, lacka, lip smacking good!" I wish I had more adjectives to express my adoration for this place. I would give it 10 stars if the yelp folks gave me special dispensation. We all had great pizza in New York City. Gino's of Williston park is no different, other than being located in Nassau county. Great crust, sauce, fresh ingredients and a lotta love and pride in making those pies! No wonder they were voted 2012 best pizza by the Long Island Press. The restaurant is divided into 2 dining areas, typical pizza parlor ambiance, or nice sit down dinner affair. I have never been here for dinner, but my friends swear by the quality and taste of the main entrees like chicken cutlet parmigiana and Scungilli Marinara. Excuse me, while I wipe the drool off my keyboard. Like I said, Pizza is a must, dinner go and try it, I know I will. Can you find a better Pizzeria than Gino's within the Williston Park area? FUGGEDABOUTIT!!!!!!! read more

See all

So this is my go to pizza spot on Long Island. The place is divided into two sections, a fancier dining room option or a very quintessential pizzeria. The slices here are larger than normal and have a nice crusty bottom, the crunch from the bottom of the pies are great. The food: Handrolled meatball slice- The hand rolled meatballs are great. The cheese, sauce and crunchy bottom make this a slice worth getting. http://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=LEQM65CUGo2NlYHABTSz1g&userid=Y_iTTjKvV5hLy-880SZzlA Chicken Vodka slice- Going to a predominantly white Prep school for high school, all I remember hearing was penne a la vodka, these white kids knew what they were talking about lol So the chicken vodka slice here was great, but unfortunately it was really greasy. Grease oozed out when I cut into it and it felt greasy in the stomach after consumption. http://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=ZkNp1a2JZoYEw_joaPmA9w&userid=Y_iTTjKvV5hLy-880SZzlA Chicken Marsala slice- this was another good slice, the flavors of the Marsala are great, the chicken is nice and tender, and the mushroom are a nice complement. Penne a la Vodka slice- this is essentially a pasta on top of a slice. The penne has nice flavor but it's too much carb, it's carb on carb. The first couple of bites are nice but then it gets redundant. Grandma- I thought the flavor was nice and the bottom had a nice crunch. The grandma was a lot thinner than other grandma slices i have had, I enjoyed the grandma slice but it wasn't very filling. http://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?userid=Y_iTTjKvV5hLy-880SZzlA&select=qwXEhPnavQVG04vGjI_1Iw Broccoli Rabe and crumbled sausage- I don't normally like Broccoli Rabe but this worked on the slice, it was a tad bitter as expected but not too bad. The sausage had good flavor that paired well with the rabe. http://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?userid=Y_iTTjKvV5hLy-880SZzlA&select=QziFR-t17LJjWQVv12Shig Garlic knots- a little lacking on flavor but the crunch on the bottom was great. http://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=UXNzsBLAUBofTK4UZS_mqA&userid=Y_iTTjKvV5hLy-880SZzlA read more

See all

I don't understand why Gino's doesn't have garlic knots, been going to them for years and 80% of the time they don't have garlic knots and won't make them. So I just go to Vincent's now, which always has knots and they are huge. 2 of Vincent's knots = 6 of gino's. Plus Vincent's has gotten better and their portion sizes are huge. Plus gino's regular slices just suck now. Bye gino's!!! read more

Didn't love it but didn't hate it. Tried a regular slice and a vodka Sicilian. Did not like the vodka slice but the regular slice is good. I'm guessing I picked wrong slices. Will come back and try other things on a menu. read more

Overpriced. They don't inform you when they add on charges. Honestly charging money for an extra cup of marinara sauce is ridiculous when it's sitting in a giant vat that gets tossed at the end of the night/week. I've had their food other locations and by comparison is better. Also the staff at this location has a crappy attitude. I've encountered this crappy attitude for the last time, as I've also had issues with delivery from this location. There's a zillion other pizza places in the area and I'd advise people to go elsewhere! read more

Love love love love this place!! Pizza is like Brooklyn pizza...don't get better than that. Love their server Jess, what a sweet hard worker! The pizza is delicious! I highly recommend the Detroit slice, their pene vodka slice (omg amazing), chicken bacon ranch, Sicilian, and the regular. Thank you. And Frank the owner is such a wonderful person, bless him and his establishment! Thank you, Ginos! This is old school and it doesn't get better than this. Grateful for this place. I like to grab a slice once a week when it's my short day for work. It just makes my day so much better! read more

Terrible pizza. I don't usually leave reviews but I had to this time. Ordered a cheese pie and came undercooked. Not sure how it's possible to mess up a cheese pie but definitely upset. read more

There are a few pizza places around this area, this is a good one, their bread is doughy and taste is not bad

I was so hungry all that oil seeped right into bread and the sausage was dry because it was overcooked read more

Gino's Pizza - Oil from plate - Pizza Near Me - Williston Park, New York

See all

Very informal, extremely friendly and efficient wait staff...But let's not forget why we go there at least weekly! The food is like family prepared, is served in very generous portions and you get dessert and coffee included as a bonus. It reminds us of the old days when a restaurant was reasonably priced and the food was a delight. You must give this place a 'whirl'- Mar 'n Gar read more

Gino's keeps his place super clean place everything sparkles never seen such clean mirrors. Their pizza is the best Sicilian around. Garlic knots too next time I will try other things read more

Update 5/2020 So impressed with the set-up for takeout and curbside. Place was spotless and outrageously efficient! They even thought about one-way traffic with clear, concise signage. Way to go guys! Pizza is ok but the guys at the counter are always miserable and gruff. Just witnessed Frank yell at one of the younger guys in front of about 6 patrons. Nobody likes a bully, I'm not going back. Frantoni's is better anyway. read more

I'm not bashing it but I've had better pizza. We got a Sicilian pie, everyone seems to rave about it. It was nothing special, pretty average Sicilian. I did however like the pepperoni cups...that's different and I liked it. I see people say the regular pie is good. I'd like to see barstool go before I go back and try the regular. My pizza tastes seem to mimic his. Williston Park isn't far from Eddys if you like a bar pie....awesome spot. read more

My neighbor told me to try Ginos. The sicilian is phenomenal Absolutely loved it, best in the neighborhood. And I also got a chicken roll which I loved as well. Going to be going more often. read more

Let's be honest if you come here and don't get the Sicilian you are wasting everyone's time! Best Sicilian I have ever had. read more

Mixed bag. I don't know, I think you have to have grown up in WP to love this place. The pizza is okay when it's not burnt on the bottom, but it usually is. Their Sicilian is different but very good. If you're looking for a traditional Sicilian slice this might not do it for you though. I stay away from their meat dishes because I've gotten very chewy chicken more than once. We love their garlic bread and their rigatoni vodka. My hubs is a WP native and this is his go-to pizza place. I pretty much prefer any of the other local spots to this one. read more

Gino's Pizza - Home of the burnt-bottom pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Williston Park, New York

There are no words for how much we love Gino's, Sind ether opened years ago has been my families go to and it's now me and my sons ! Thank you for outstanding food every single time we order !! read more

The Best Pizza! Gino's is simply the best! It's the best pizza you'll have in the United States and has a great feel to the place, though I wish they never installed the TVs in the pizzeria. It has three rooms, the pizzeria, the dining room and a party room, so it can suit any need. I love this place more than words can say! read more