Stopped in with clients that had never been to Stefanina's before. Food was what I expected but having to listen to the young am who was in the kitchen cooking F this and F that and complain about customers having lunch and their orders was completely unnecessary. If he doesn't like his job he shouldn't be there. Needless to say it also didn't help that I had my CLIENTS there either and they had to listen to it. read more

I have to start this off by saying this was a whim of a stop for me tonight. I was really looking forward to pizza, and had a place picked out using our Yelp app, but it doesn't seem to exist. So, on our way to a second spot, we passed Stafanina's and decided to turn it around and try it out. Walking in, this place is small. I mean, little. I counted 8 tables in the entire place, with a patio of about 4-5 more tables. Small isn't a big deal, it's just, well, small! We were waited on relatively quickly, but it was apparent that the service would be an issue from the get-go. I ordered a beer, my wife a soda, and the waitress returned with my beer and a water. When asked if the soda was on its way, our waitress gave us that "what was I thinking" look and apologized, and immediately fixed the error. No big deal. We ordered the potato skins to start, and an extra large pepperoni pizza. The potato skins were edible, but nothing special. Again, I asked for some ketchup when they were brought out, and the young lady smiled and said she'd be back with the ketchup. As she walked away, my wife noticed we didn't have any napkins on the table, and commented that we needed them. The waitress returned with napkins and utensils, no ketchup. It is important to note this was a different person than the one that took our order. We never did get our ketchup. The pizza was, in a word, excellent! Absolutely some of the best pizza I've ever had. The crust was perfect, the cheese was fantastic, everything about the pizza was delicious. As we sat and waited, and waited for a to-go box, we watched as our server, Allie, ran her behind off taking drinks, food, napkins, etc to tables. Of the six or seven employees we observed in the restaurant, Allie was the only one truly working to take care of customers. We observed two employees standing at the counter, just watching and not really doing much of anything. One of them was, in fact, the same girl that had promised to bring us the ketchup. (still waiting!) Maybe three stars is a bit harsh, but given that the entire place had a total of 12 tables, and the speed at which the service took place, I would call it highly disappointing. The pizza is excellent, and the next time I'm in the mood for a good thin crust pizza, I will keep this place in mind, but I most likely won't dine in again. I do want to thank Allie for her efforts, she did her best given the amount of support she was receiving, but in the end, the customers shouldn't have to wait for their server to "remember" them. For that, three stars. read more

I've lived in St. Charles over a year now and had no idea that Stefanina's delivered. This was definitely a pleasant surprise!!! Ordered a large house salad with grilled chicken and a 1 topping pizza for my boys. For just being lettuce, cheese, and chicken it was absolutely fabulous. Probably the best Italian dressing I've ever had and the pizza was great as well. My online order estimated an hour for delivery, but really only took 20-30 minutes. This will definitely be our go to delivery from now on. read more

This place is lackluster to say the least. 1. The pizza was bland. I ordered the bbq chicken pizza and the chicken tasted like the fully cooked Tyson chicken you get in the freezer section. The crust was a typical St. Louis style cracker crust and was flavorless to say the least. I decided against the provel cheese (as it is weird and gross) and I'm glad I didThe service was subpar. The atmosphere was off. I will not go there again. read more

Great pizza, but their order on line app is extremely difficult to use. Took me at least 5 tries to order, so next time I'll just phone it in read more

We have no complaints! We are regulars and eat here about twice a month. We always get 2 topping pizzas, toasted raviolis, house salad, grilled chicken sandwich. Pizza is always very good. We don't recommend more than 2-3 toppings. Simple is better here. We did like the taco pizza too if you are having a few pizzas for a crowd. It is something different for a 2-3 pizza order. Always very cheesy and loaded with toppings. Salad is always fresh. We get house dressing and ranch. Never disappoints. We also get the big dinner salad- it is cheaper and good for a larger crowd with pickier eaters. Toasted ravioli- the best in town!! Got them with butter sauce. Always a win!! Grilled chicken sandwich- flame grilled with all of the fixings. Very delicious. Ample amount of chicken on my sandwich every time, never a disappointment! Quick delivery and always the right order! read more

Received a recommendation to go here from the front desk of the embassy suites. It did not disappoint. The young server was so nice when we came in. Gave us a great recommendation of what to order and it happen to be on special. The prices were so reasonable considering how big they are. We had the house special and BBQ chicken. Thin crispy crust that was amazing if that is how you like. If I am ever here again and craving pizza it will be a destination. The young lady also gave us a recommendation for BBQ, so that is what is for dinner tomorrow. Thanks for the great experience stefanias! Give them a try if you are in the area. read more

It's a go to place for pizza. I love their Steph salad & pizza. The only thing I don't like is the provell cheese, which 99% of the time I remember to request mozzarella cheese. read more

This is our favorite pizza place to eat. We LOVE their chef salad wo much. They are always so nice even though they are always so so busy.

Great lunch specials, delicious pizza. Server was attentive and refilled drinks often.

The pizza, appetizers & salads are all sooo good! The staff is always friendly. The food is priced right and it's a good place for families!

Tonight's pizza was much below standards. There was almost no cheese, the pepperoni was way too salty and the whole thing was dry. I was very disappointed. read more

The only thing better than bringing home a Stefanina's pizza is eating one there. The best St. Louis style pizza anywhere. The new location on Jungermann with a nice sized seating area is a winner. As always, tons of toppings, crispy, thin crust, and oh that gooey provel cheese. Fast service also! read more

I haven't written a Yelp review in quite some time, but my negative experience with lunch today at Stefanina's calls for a special occasion. My wife and I walked in around 3:30. We were quickly greeted by an upbeat and personable server who showed us to our booth. The pleasant interaction with her was the only positive aspect of the meal. I ordered a meatball sandwich, fries, and a salad. My wife ordered the fettuccine and a salad, which also came with a half-loaf of bread. The salads arrived within minutes. They consisted of a pile of iceberg lettuce, literally two halved- cherry tomatoes, and a mountain of provel cheese (although my wife requested mozzarella replace the plasticky provel that pervades the St. Louis area). Hardly appetizing, but we were hungry, so we ate it. The sandwich and pasta came out a moment later, which probably should have been a warning sign. The meatball sandwich was composed of exactly 2 tiny meatballs sandwiched on a small half-loaf of italian bread. It didn't look like much, but I took a bite. The meatballs were burnt and consequently very dry. Even the bland sauce couldn't help to offset the taste reminiscent of a microwaved school lunch. It was bad. My wife took one bite of her pasta and immediately added salt and pepper in an attempt to salvage any pleasure from our meal. It didn't work. The fettuccine tasted and looked as if the sauce was a packaged powder, to which the "chef" added a cup of water and a slab of butter. Zero taste. She gave up, so I doused it in red pepper. I took one forkful and realized the problems were beyond spice. We paid our bill and escaped to the seemingly-five-star treats that are Costco samples. Thank you to the very nice server. You deserve better. As a sidenote, it's almost impossible to believe one of the reviews here is not written from an owner or employee. I'm not even going to single it out. A quick scan of the limited reviews will reveal a bit of writing that sounds a bit too much like a radio commercial that would air in the middle of the night on an AM station. Never again. read more

Honestly I was extremely disappointed. Paper thin crust with cheddar cheese on it. Really didn't like it but we were having a diet cheat day and they were close to the hotel we were staying. Delivery was quick, pizza was expensive and we threw leftovers in the trash. I just don't get this St. Louis style pizza love. It was like a graham cracker dough with non pizza cheese. read more

We went on Mothers day, the pizza and pasta con broccoli was excellent. The food was hot, delicious just the right amount. The place is starting to need some work, chairs are torn, bathroom walls are chipped and stained, trash full. The service was excellent but they could have used the time cleaning versus the staff sitting in the table by the kitchen door. The 4 stars is for the food & service, not the location. read more

Literally BEST PIZZA EVER. Sorry Imo's, the Hill, etc., but Stefanina's wins by a long shot on St. Louis style pizza. It's all in the cheese, provel I think. My personal favorite toppings are bacon, pepperoni and green pepper, but to each his own. I also recommend the salad with house dressing! read more

Excellent pizza, had the thin crust and was very impressed. In from out of town so had delivered to my hotel and arrived very hot, will order again. read more

I was turned on to Stefanina's pizza when I moved into the area. From the Stef salad to the pizzas loaded with toppings, you cannot pass this up. The price is comparable to other chains, but this pizza stands out from all the others. Give it a try and it will become your new favorite. read more

The wife and I were pretty disappointed with this place tonight after trying it for the first time. We had a simple order consisting of one pizza and one appetizer that I picked up. I wish I would have looked at the food before I left. Our pizza was burnt and the appetizer was cold. The pizza was also missing toppings and had little flavor. Needless to say, we will continue to drive past this place to a different establishment when we order out. read more

Their pizza is very good, but their cannelloni bites were my favorite. They were a great app to start the meal off right! Its reasonably priced, and there are many locations around the area to enjoy. This place is a good bet! read more

Some of the best pizza in town. Period. They have stepped their game up over the years, making great improvements.

This place has delicious St. Louis style pizza. The delivery guy is always expedient and courteous. My recent order was a large mear lovers, potato skins, and chicken strips for a group of folks. So good! It's a little more expensive than a chain but I thinks it's definitely worth it! read more

Great food, can be a little pricey but it's yummy. Really like this location, so close to the house. The fried mushrooms are amazing!

Whoa....super cold food with decent service. Very disappointing. My lasagna came out of the fridge and right into the microwave. Not fresh at all. read more

Nice little neighborhood place. Good house salad and St Louis style pizza - much better than Imo's, in our opinion. A real favorite with our teenagers. Service is always fast and friendly. Great for a quick bite. read more

If you love st louis style pizza then you have to go there. They have the best st louis style pizza and they make their thin crust there so it's fresher tasting. Compared to other offering similar items they have a larger menu and better bag for you buck plus they just taste the best. They are family owned like most st louis style reaturants you get the family feel or have it delivered to your home in 30 mins. They are by far my #1 choice in st peters and st louis. read more

Seriously the best pizza in St. Louis! We love their house salad. And we love their extra large sausage mushroom pizza. They give you the option of pro Val or mozzarella cheese. They deliver in a timely fashion with hot pizza every time. They are always the first place we call when we have friends from out of town over. Pick up the phone and call and ask for their special! read more

This restaurant is good one day, horrible the next, I guess it depends on the staff of that particular day. I visited Thursday, Dec. 13 as I was in the mood for some chicken parm. The server, Katie, was pleasant, but in a distant kind of way. I think she had other priorities that night. I wanted a nice cold beer to go with dinner, but amazingly the beer prices aren't published on the menu, so you have to ask. Prices were a little high for just a simple Bud Light, but OK, I let that one go. I got my chicken parm, and dinner salad, that's when the trouble started. Wilted and almost rotted lettuce UNDER the fresh lettuce- covered with cheese, well hidden. The chicken fillets were way overcooked, I think they were left over from lunch, again smothered in cheese, and sauce, then right to the microwave. It's not a good sign when you have to use a steak knife on a chicken filet. I looked around for an adult staff member to speak to, and of course Katie didn't offer any solutions here either, just a sheepish giggle, so I guess that meant that there were no personnel over 18 running the place. Maybe someday, I'll try it again, I always give a second and sometimes third chance, everyone has bad days, I know. But I certainly won't order the chicken parm again. Maybe it was just too complicated for them to prepare. read more

I was encouraged by the reviews I saw on this site so we ordered two large 2-topping pizzas and a large dinner salad for carry out. The salad with house dressing was terrific but the pizza just didn't live up to the expectation I had after reading other posts on this site. The cheese was fantastic, and they put enough pepperoni on it, but they really skimped on the mushrooms. Also, the crust was not really in the St. Louis thin crust realm...I mean it was thin, but more like Pizza Hut thin, not Imo's or Cecil W's. The crust also had a disturbing layer of flour still on it, so much that when my wife placed a piece on her plate, a "whoof" of flour blew into the air nearby. Out pizzas also had very little sauce and that dissappointed me as well. Since this was our first try with Stef's, we may give it one more shot; eating there this time and include a pasta dish or two to see how those work out. Perhaps we caught them on a bad day, or bringing it home caused some degeneration, but I was hoping for a better experience overall. I'll write another review once we try the place again..... Hoping for the best this time! St. Peters, MO read more

My family loves their pizza and wings! Pretty sure the pizza sizes are big, bigger and huge ass pizza! I really can't comment on anything else on the menu because we are yet to try it. If it is half as delicious as the pizza though, it will surely be top notch. They have the option to dine in or carry out so no matter your mood this is the place for you. Oh and you provel haters can rest easy. They offer mozzarella only options for you lame ducks. read more

I get the meat lovers every time and it's just amazing. I love my bacon crispy and my cheese is always perfect. They use the classic St. Louis cheese: Provel, which I recommend to anyone who hasn't tried it as it was designed to go on pizza! read more

Only locals like this place because they grew up with it. It is NOT authentic Italian food by any means. They use canned/jar sauces from Costco or Sam's club and don't do much with it. It's just cheap... cheap quick food. read more

If you are looking for St Louis style pizza this is the place. Thin crust and provo cheese. Nice size pizza and good toppings.

Some of the best pizza I've ever had this place is incredible. Some of the best pizza in the country.

Great Pizza and Italian. I cringe when I rate pizza joints. Saint Louis style, thin crust is my favorite. Steph's does pizza very good. They offer good variety and great pastas. In my opinion, they are among the top three pizza joints in St. Charles County. read more

CATERING: Went to a casual wedding reception where they had Stefanina's do the catering. It was SOOO delicious. The salad, red and white pastas and pizzas sat on the counter all afternoon but there were delicious and fresh all day long!! Highly recommend their catering for your next event! read more

Excellent pizza and quick service with carry-out orders!! Not a bad price for pizza either. One of my favorite thin crust restaurants!