The pizza is consistently delicious, with some of the best cheese around, perfectly melted, flavorful, and generous on every slice. You can tell Ryan puts a lot of love and care into the food he serves, and that dedication comes through in every bite. Great food, great people, and a place the community has been enjoying for years. Highly recommend! read more

0 - Star Review - Absolutely Terrible Service I rarely leave negative reviews (2nd time this happens), but my experience with Steve's Pizza was beyond frustrating. When I placed my order, I was told delivery would take about an hour and a half. That seemed reasonable, so I went ahead. Two hours passed with no sign of the pizza, so I called to check in. They told me the pizza was still sitting there but the delivery driver was "leaving shortly." Another hour went by--still nothing. I called again for a third time, and unbelievably, the pizza was still sitting there, not even out for delivery. At that point, I canceled the order altogether. Not only did they ruin our family dinner, but now I'm being told the refund will take 5-7 business days to show up in my account. The staff didn't seem to care in the slightest, offering no apology or real effort to make it right. Completely unprofessional and unacceptable. I won't be ordering from Steve's Pizza again, and I'd recommend others think twice before doing so. read more

Long time customer. Ordered 2 medium pizzas for delivery. waited 1 1-2 hours for delivery and they looked like day old, dried up, and cold. i actually drove to return them it attitude from the manager. never again, they lost me as a customer. i had to leave 1 star to post the review. this should be a no star read more

Best pizza in Cutler Bay. Taste just like pizza from NYC. Delivery was fast and friendly.

Great Pizza and service! We ordered take out and were very happy with the quality and the amount of toppings. Delicious!

I don't understand why this pizza place has such low ratings. I must admit, my husband was a bit turned off and automatically assumed the pizza wouldn't be good because of the reviews. I was also a bit skeptical but one of my daughter's was the one who convinced us to order and I am soooo glad we did! The pizza was delicious!!! The garlic rolls were also very good. Very soft rolls slathered with minced garlic and olive oil. We also ordered the ones that comes with cheese and they were even better. Perfect topping for an already perfect garlic roll! Ok so let's discuss the pizzas we ordered. We decided on one cheese and the other was veggie with mushrooms, onions, black olives, peppers and fresh tomatoes. They were thin pizza's. My favorite. Just the right amount of tomato sauce. So moral of this story, don't guide yourself by the negative reviews. I was pleasantly surprised! This place is good and prices are pretty decent. Will definitely be ordering from here again! read more

See all

After living in NYC for the last 7 years, I can confidently say Steve's Pizza is absolutely delicious! Flavorful, perfect amount of cheese, and baked to perfection. Yup ordered 3x in 2.5 weeks. This place deserves 5 stars! read more

Steve's Pizza Express - Perfection XL Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Cutler Bay, Florida

See all

amazing ny style pizza. lunch special is cheap and the service is great. Staff was super nice and the owner is also a great guy. if u want some good pizza u should give it a try. I recommend the pepperoni. read more

I just grab takeout here and it's been great. Pizza like my childhood in Philly. Bang for the buck is awesome. read more

We love Steve's Pizza. It never lets us down when we order it. We recently ordered the extra cheese pizza and it was delicious. The closest to NY style pizza we've had in Miami. We also love the garlic cheesy bread. Highly recommend! read more

Steve's Pizza Express - Extra cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Cutler Bay, Florida

The Pizza was amazing! Right out of the oven, melted cheese, and it tasted as good as it looked! Friendly staff. They have different specials (just ask about what specials they have). It is only for pickup or delivery. Plenty of parking in the shopping center. Great price, great food, great service. We will definitely get more pizza from here read more

See all

Absolute worst pizza and customer service ever. The pizza is often greasy, the crust is so soggy you can't even pick it up and eat it like a regular piece of pizza. The sauce is too sweet. On top of all of that, the employees are rude and incompetent. Placed an order online (this was pre-covid), and showed up and they hadn't even taken the ticket out of the printer so it hadn't even been started yet. I heard from friends who went in during covid that cooks were not wearing masks. Go somewhere else. read more

Steve's Pizza Express - Garbage floppy pizza. Can't even eat it like regular pizza bc it's so soggy and greasy. - Italian Near Me - Cutler Bay, Florida

Ordered an XL Supreme Pizza no bell pepper, no ground beef, and half anchovies for delivery. Received an XL Supreme with ground beef, bell peppers, half anchovies and no olives. They put a mountain of bell peppers on the pizza. I called, the young lady reads my order correctly, she states I can give you a credit for the mistakes. I could not accept because my father is allergic to bell peppers. So I drove to the place and it's filled with kids working in there not paying attention to what they're doing. I asked for a new pizza. They proceeded to give me a smaller pizza. This time just pepperoni, sausage, and onions and no anchovies. Which is not a supreme pizza. I asked for the anchovies then they put it on the entire pie. They also gave me back the original pie. They've wasted so much time and money to the business with their immaturity. It's honestly a waste of payroll to have 5 to 6 people in there not doing their jobs correctly. The one time I don't go to the US1 location It's about the principal not the money. read more

See all

Recently made a purchase of the chocolate cake an recieved it all broken up. I love the pizza but and I get that you have to raise your prices but you should let people know if youre going change your portion sizes and give them significantly less than usual at the sams rate they have paid in the past. Normally I do not write complaints but I have had too many incidents with them that I brush off to not say anything. Also dont order their jumbo wings they are no longer jumbo, they are the equivalent to chilis wing and way over priced, better off getting them at the sports grill. read more

Steve's Pizza Express - Chocolate cake Chocolate Cake - Italian Near Me - Cutler Bay, Florida

Always want to build up neighborhood establishments and I know this Steves is part of the larger Steve's. I stopped by today to get the two slices lunch special and the pizza was horrible. The slices were small. The crust was very hard and there wasn't nearly enough sauce on it it's not like I remember Steve's being And they charge me 995 no drink just two slices. Just moved back to the Miami area after being in Fort Lauderdale and this is not the way that I remember Steve's being before I say I'm never going there again. I'll give the one on US1 a try. These were dry and very unpleasant. Wont be back to Steve's pizza express ever... read more

Ordered a singular cheese pizza over the phone. Was told I could pick up in 40 minutes. I show up 40 minutes later. They gave my pizza away. I have to wait another 20 minutes for another pizza to be made. An hour for 1 pizza with no toppings on weekday is absolutely ridiculous. Train your staff better. read more

As a true pizza connoisseur, I was initially hesitant to try Steve's Pizza Express in Cutler Bay. However, after two visits, I can confidently say that their New York-style thin crust is truly amazing. The crust itself has a perfect taste, and the generous amount of cheese makes it even better. Being conveniently close to my house, I appreciate the savings on delivery fees. The pricing is also fair. While I've enjoyed the extra-large half cheese, half pepperoni pizza here, I must note that the Palmetto Bay location didn't quite match up. Still, I'm willing to give them another chance. My overall impression? Unmemorable (referring to the Palmetto Bay location), but promising. To be Clear, the Steve's Pizza express in Cutler Bay is my new favorite. You can find Steve's Pizza Express at 20216 Old Cutler Rd, Cutler Bay, FL 33189. For orders, call (305) 252-9054. . read more

Pizza is simply not very good. I can't explain why the Steve's Pizza in Palmetto Bay is so much better. Probably better ingredients.

Family special is a must, you will not be disappointed with their pizza! New York style and delicious.

I got a margarita. It wasn't bad. They charged me for a large and gave me a medium though. It wasn't worth the $20something I paid after tax. read more

Great local pizza!! Staff was super nice and pizzas were perfect! Buy and support local businesses!

Ordered from here before; however, pizza was extremely greasy and fell apart. I love thin pizza but this could not be folded or ever picked up because it falls apart read more

Steve's Pizza Express - Fell apart - Italian Near Me - Cutler Bay, Florida

See all

I am a loyal fan. Closest pizza in the area to NY pizza but not sure what happened today. I usually pick up and when I order for delivery its to school where I work. I ordered today and put delivery address - well pizza waas never delivered. I called and apparently went to wrong address. I got pizza an hour later with wrong drink and no sauce. Disappointed because I love Steve's Pizza. read more

We are in the middle of a GLOBAL PANDEMIC. If your handling food please use gloves and a mask. I went by to pick up my pizza the only people wearing gloves and mask are the delivery guys. I just drove away. You don't want to be responsible for spreading the virus due to lack of prudence. Also as the economy crashes if people are patronizing your establishment with there hard earned money be respectful. read more

Not great. Our pizza was so soaked with grease that it was literally dripping off. Not much else to say since the amount of oil ruined the whole pizza. read more

Steve's Pizza Express - So much grease - Italian Near Me - Cutler Bay, Florida

I used to order from steves ALL THE TIME a couple years back..... I decided to order this weekend from the new steves express since it's right next to my house. Not sure if it's my taste buds that changed or experience.... but the pizza wasn't how i remembered it in my head. the dough felt thicker than usual and overall I wasn't as wowed by it like i used to be. Overall, it was a decent pizza... average in quality. read more

We ordered the calamari and it was so tough and salty you could barely eat it Very disappointing. I heard this Steves was better in pizza than the one on US1. Pizza was ok The onions were in Chunks and not sliced thin Taste was the same. The difference is if you do not order extra cheese at the US1 location they barely put cheese on it. read more

Steve's Pizza Express - Pepperoni onion and mushroom Where's the cheese!! - Italian Near Me - Cutler Bay, Florida

1st time here, I ordered a cheese pizza, brownie and a slice of carrot cake, all pretty yummy. All yummy enough for me to attempt a delivery order (even though my address, very sadly, does not come up as a delivery option. This would have made me skip over this establishment quite rapidly. Even though it seems that that my address is not a delivery option, I called for delivery. According to Yelp, this establishment will not deliver to me. I called and was not denied delivery. It would be greatly appreciated if the true delivery options/possibilities were displayed consistently. I believe this place is a great pizza and brownie option, give it a try. More people might give it a try if Yelp delivery and processing was an obvious option! Yippeee!!!!!! Steve's Pizza Express just delivered my yummy garlic pizza and yummy brownie to me!!!! I know they are yummy because I am eating them right NOW!!!! For the benefit of your business, update delivery areas accordingly! Do not deny delivery of your yummy pizza to those willing to give you a try! They will help you grow your business!! read more

Been a loyal customer to the original Steve's pizza on us1 however will never order from Steve's express! Horrible customer service. Woman taking orders had a major attitude issue waited over an hour only to go to establishment and get a refund because they "claimed" I gave them wrong address! WTH, really? I know where I live and they've delivered before! Come on! Really pissed off f$&@'ing with my dinner! Never again and then asked me if I want pizza OH HELLZ NO! Don't even deserve a rating! Just letting ya'll know! read more

Ordered a medium pepperoni, sausage, onion and mushroom pizza for delivery. Delivery was as promised and the pizza was really fresh and tasty. read more

If you were looking for an above average pizza place, a step above Pizza Hut or Papa John's but don't want to spend a arm and a leg or travel far this is the place to go. They have quick delivery or quick pick up and their pizza is great. read more

Moving to Miami has been a difficult thing when it comes to food . I have lived in Rhode Island all my life . Steve's Pizza has been the closest to the Great food I'm used to . Thank you Steve! read more

I've been ordering from Steve's for over 10 years. Usually we order from the one on South Dixie highway but the last time we picked up our pie we noticed the box had a second address closer to home which delivered. We were very excited to say the least. We ordered last night for the first time. Nothing difficult just a large pie and an antipasto salad. They said it would take 1.5 for delivery but we didn't care BC the taste is well worth the wait. After a while we receive a call saying they don't have an ingredient for the salad and won't be able to make it. We thought that was unfortunate but oh well things happen. 1.5 later we receive another call asking for the address. After we confirmed they said the driver had went to a different house but will be to us shortly. After waiting another 45 minutes the driver finally got there. My teenage daughters opened the door and the driver gave them a total of 31$. This was the original price with the salad. My daughter handed him 30$ and the driver quickly left. Once my daughter told me that the driver didn't offer change or give the correct total i called the store. I explained what happen and the person on the phone gave me the correct total of 20$ and said she didn't understand why the driver had the wrong amount. I was very upset that a delivery driver would take advantage of a young person opening the door and asked her to please send the driver back. I usually tip delivery drivers generously but this one left a sour taste in my mouth. She said the driver would be back but it would take 1-2 hours. Long story short he never showed up and we never received a call from the store. You'd think that's the worse part but nope!! When we opened the box we found a cold stiff sloppy pizza. Seems like the driver went back to the store after going to the wrong house and no one bothered to even heat up the pizza that had been sliding around in his car for over 1.5 hours. So if you order here and your order gets changed last minute make sure you ask for the new total and check your receipt upon delivery. Also check Your pizza before the driver speeds off. read more

I ordered this pizza to try and switch it up from main stream pizza places and get a good mom and pops pizza. Sadly I was super disappointed. You literally can't see the crust it's so thin. So all you're getting is some firm cheese. The texture of the cheese is equivalent to a fried mozzarella sticks that has been sitting out for a few hours and cooled to room temperature. I gave it two stars because it's edible but not worth the calories. To be fair my husband doesn't think it's too bad and is eating it. So if you like more cheese than crust on your pizza than this is for you. read more

Steve's Pizza Express - three slices of cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Cutler Bay, Florida

Pizza was soft and limp. Definitely not the same management. Needed more flavor. Not the best pizza

Person who took phone order was not very nice, she was rude. (Misty) Not very pleasant. Lacks customer service training. When picking-up and after paying, had to wait 20 minutes to be notice by one of the employees (person making pizza), asking what was I was waiting for. Only then that they realized my order has been sitting there for awhile. Totally ignored. Never coming back to this pizza place - Steve's Pizza Express 20216 Old Cutler Road, Cutler Bay. read more

This is our 4th time ordering from here, and unfortunately every single time that we've ordered there is an issue. If you try ordering something else chances are YOU WILL NOT RECEIVE it. Why have wings on your menu if you don't have them in stock? And when you do they don't get delivered? even after charging us. Simply disappointed that we had to order side items for our family from a different restaurant. When we called because the wings were not delivered along the items in our order, the answer we received was "were busy right now, don't have time to call driver or have the item delivered"... well... thanks for the customer service. Only reason this is not a one star is because The pizza actually taste good. read more

Terrible customer relations, and extremely rude. Kitchen is very unappealing looks dirty Along with the employees.

I have been going to the Palmetto Bay Steve's Pizza location since before I could walk. However, the last few times I have gone there, they were clearly overwhelmed. They completely forgot our pizza once (waited over an hour before they noticed), or the delivery took 3 hours. That's why I was happy to see that they opened the Steve's Pizza Express, which is located just down the road from my house. I hoped that this would relieve some of the business from the Palmetto Bay location. Tonight, I called at 5:15 pm and placed a takeout order for an extra large pizza with half cheese, the other half mushroom and pepperoni. The man on the phone repeated it back to me correctly. He then told me the total and quoted me 30 minutes. I arrived around 5:40, knowing I was a few minutes early. I paid for my order, which the young man behind the counter again repeated to me (correctly). I then proceeded to stand and wait. I could see the manager (owner?) sitting at a nearby table. I recognize him from the other location. So I waited. Maybe 10 minutes later, the young man behind the counter asked me what my order was (after he just repeated it back to me 10 minutes ago). I told him again, and kept waiting. Not once did the manager/owner try to get involved. At this point it's 5:50 and I can still see around 4 pizzas (in boxes) that have been sitting on top of the oven for some time now. Finally, I overhear another staff member, a female, ask the young man what I am waiting on. Next thing I know, she walks over to the oven, and pulls down my pizza. Unless they very stealthily placed it up there while I was looking out the window, I believe it was there the whole time. Now it's 6:00, and I'm ready to get home. I was going to open the box to make sure it was correct, but I was distracted, trying to figure out how I was going to make a left onto Old Cutler. Big mistake. Once I got home, i opened the box and realized that the ENTIRE pizza was pepperoni and mushroom, not the half like I requested. And, it was fairly cold, so I know it was most likely ready by the time I got there, and was just sitting on top of the oven. I still gave two stars because the pizza was still good (albeit cold). I wouldn't have waited for a new pizza anyway, had I realized the error, but I don't know if I'll be back. It's always a mistake with them the past year or so, and I'm over it. There's nowhere to email them on their website, so I plan on placing a call. I'll just leave the picture if my pizza and receipt, in case someone with some from Steve's actually reads this. read more

Steve's Pizza Express - The pizza that was supposed to be half cheese, and the other half mushroom and pepperoni. - Italian Near Me - Cutler Bay, Florida

So I have ordered 3 times from this place. The first time they actually made a mistake and after the 30-40min I showed up And the order was "lost". I understand that things happen and they handled it very well and provided awesome customer service. They took ownership of the issue and got it fixed! Second time was also great! Both times We have ordered pizza and calamari and it's been great so far. 3rd time today! read more