This place fu**ing sucks. You will watch your egg sandwich sit on the counter for 30 minutes before any employee even realizes it's ready. The service is completely disorganized, and the whole experience is frustrating from start to finish. To make matters worse, from what I witnessed, the owner treats the employees terribly, which creates an awful atmosphere all around. Would not recommend. WORST BAGEL PLACE IN THE AREA!! read more

Absolutely the best breakfast sandwich's in a 20 mile radius. Delicious BEC (I'm a native New Yorker) so I know bagels, and they are perfect and consistent. From seasonings to texture. Many drink options also and they are included! You're welcome in advance my fellow Americans! read more

Unfortunately the food was not great. the bagels themselves are big and fluffy, but the bec sandwiches were horrible. they looked like they would taste delicious but both my husband and i agreed they had an extremely peculiar taste to them. We tried to pinpoint where that flavor was coming from but couldnt. I couldn't even eat it, it was just terrible. the pink lemonade was great, muffin was delicious also. home fries were good! hashbrowns and iced tea were a skip. read more

Great spot for gluten free bagels. The gf bagels are packed separately and a separate toasted is used for them. I got the everything gf bagel with cream cheese and it was so tasty, great texture, not heavy. Classic Long Island bagel joint with gluten free options!! read more

Strathmore Bagels - Gluten free everything bagel with cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

See all

I'm a New York native through and through and one thing I know is bagels. Let's be honest, NYC bagels VS Long Island bagels (with some exceptions) is superior! Now, with that being said and the reason I bring that up is cause this Long Island bagel spot not only doesn't hold a candle to NYC bagels, but I think would barely compete with other local LI spots. First bite you know. Soft (too soft) under baked and DRY as heck SMOTHERED in cream cheese. Who doesn't like cream cheese but there is a limit. That's really not that big a deal. It's the bagel itself. Just not on par. I've had better store bought bagels. Staff was no help. Saw two interesting cream choices I wanted to know what it was. The kid, and the kid he was training (LOL) didn't know what seemed liked any of the cream cheeses were, and was told "umm I'd have to ask". Oh brother, I'll just get scallion.. atmosphere looked clean, I'll give them that. Listen at almost 20 bucks for two bagels w/CC and two coffees... I'll pass on bagels not worth the bite. Sorry for review, just my opinion. read more

Strathmore Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

These are the best bagels in town. They are always crispy and soft and fresh. My request please come up with a few more Modern flavors!! You guys can do it. Maybe a sun dried tomato bagel or a zatar bagel. Love these bagels. read more

Some of best bagels on the planet. I have tried so many and that includes all over Long Island. The bagels may have gotten smaller over the years but they run an awesome business and ordering online and swinging by to collect couldn't be easier. Don't believe the haters. This is the spot. 2 words - Egg Everything read more

I have been going to strathmore since I was a kid. Obviously when looking for bagels this would be my first choice. Strathmore has delicious bagels, sandwiches, and baked goods. The bagels are soft and always fresh and they give you the perfect amount of cream cheese on the bagels. The staff is usually very friendly and efficient but there are many inconsistencies that I've found that have lead to this review. On a number of occasions my order has not been correct. Now listen the orders are not as difficult as you would imagine that errors might be understood. The first was when ordering a lunch sandwich, it was ordered with no pickle with the sandwich. This had been ordered in the past and there was still a pickle put in the container which led to pickle juice all over everything. Second time, different employee, please no pickle, not even on the side. The order still came with a pickle. The most recent time an egg sandwich can was ordered. The eggs were ordered fully cooked. Unfortunately when opening the sandwich the yolk was not fully cooked but yet dripping in some spots and gooey in others. It's frustrating that the order can never be right. I understand price increases and everything, and I don't mind paying for an order if it's correct. All in all, the place is clean the food is good quality but your order may not be correct. read more

Strathmore Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

See all

Worst service ever -- I'd rather go hungry than come back to this rude place. They will let people cut you in line, they will charge you way too much, they will make you wait a long time and not greet you nicely, and they won't let you switch out home fries even though most 4 years olds don't eat them. But they were sure to let me know I can buy them lol disgraceful customer service read more

I'm always on the lookout for a good bagel place and hadn't been here in years, so I figured I'd give it a try today. Very busy, so my hopes were high. The staff looked like mostly teenagers to early 20's. Basic customer interactions with the staff, and customers. I ordered a dozen bagels and the prices are close to most places. Unfortunately even with multiple types of bagels in my bag, the texture of them is almost like white bread. Way too soft of a texture on the plain, salt, everything, French toast, and the flaggel. I'll stick with the Miller Place Bagel and Deli. A bagel is supposed to have at least a mild crunch or crispness to the outside. This was way too soft. The Strathmore name used to be a reliable one but this seemed like they are just cruising on their old reputation. read more

This was my first time trying Strathmore Bagel and it did not disappoint. I ordered through door dash and I ordered an egg sandwich on a everything bagel. The bagels are jumbo. I definitely want to try some other selections they have to offer. My order: bacon, egg, pepper Jack cheese, bacon, hot sauce and ketchup on an everything bagel. read more

Strathmore Bagels - Bacon, egg and pepper Jack cheese on everything bagel with hot sauce and ketchup. - Bagels Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

Great as usual. Hi quality food, friendly staff! Today I had a SANTE Fe wrap. Earlier in the week I had a bagel and Lox sandwich. read more

Not worth the long wait for breakfast sandwiches. And of course they got my order wrong!

very yummy bagels and nice people. great atmosphere very much enjoyed and would come again

Ordered a side of bacon got burnt bacon in container that a hole. Almost every time I order a ham egg cheese to go they give me bacon instead of ham . Very frustrating but today really was unbelievable. read more

Strathmore Bagels - the contents of a strathmore bagel in a styrofoam container - Bagels Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

I come here often enough because it's close by but honestly I don't understand why the counter servers can't butter a bagel correctly or give you what you asked for. I have to always ask for extra butter on my bagel because it'll come naked but this time I asked for extra butter and he repeated it back to me but still gave me the tiniest amount. read more

Strathmore Bagels - a hand holding a bagel of bagels - Bagels Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

This must have how Indiana Jones felt when he first laid eyes on the chest containing the Ark of the Covenant in Steven Spielberg's 'Raiders of the Lost Ark.' After my wife, safely back from a Long Island work trip, opened up a bag that contained a shimmering, succulent, strawberry bagel from Strathmore that was more crimson than I imagine the rarest ruby would be, I hoped, née anticipated, the toasting of said bagel to a crisp, golden brown would unleash the flavor of Long Island bagels for this Red Sox fan for the first and not final time. After I devoured the strawberry bagel, I reached for a blueberry bagel, tinged a slight shade of navy, and dropped it into the toaster before lathering it with strawberry cream cheese. I cannot attest that all Long Island bagels are this scrumptious. I can only attest that Strathmore Bagels' bagels are. read more

Strathmore Bagels - Strawberry Bagel with Strawberry Cream Cheese! - Bagels Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

See all

Sucks... ordered a salad with breaded chicken cutlet, not only was my chicken cold out of the fridge and not fresh or warmed which is extremely weird and nothing I've ever experienced before but it was gross and quite frankly a complete waste of my money and I literally feel like I need another lunch. Minus the cold weirdness of my chicken, as you can see in the pictures are also absolutely disgusting and looks like who knows what don't know why they would serve this. Also ordered a regular coffee with French vanilla creamer and even that's gross... don't get it. read more

Strathmore Bagels - a close up of a salad - Bagels Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

Breakfast, one of the easiest things to put together. Usually 2-3 ingredients that consist of breakfast. Most popular is bacon, egg, and cheese. I don't understand how hard it is to put those three things together. If I repeat my order3 times to the teenager behind the counter, you'd think it would be correct? Nope. Eggs - CHECK, cheese - SOMETIMES, bacon - NOPE. My breakfast is usually wrong most of the time. I give this place the benefit of the doubt thinking "maybe this time my order will be right". Nope. Shame on me. Yelp, if you offered a zero star rating, this place would be worthy of it. read more

We recently moved to Bohemia and heard good things about Strathmore. We went today and were confused about the way you order due to covid. The way you order are by calling a number or waking to the front and placing the order in person but you can't go inside. They have a couple of tables outside to eat which is nice but you can't use their bathroom. The tables don't have hand sanitizer on them as well. I ordered a whole wheat everything bagel with assorted veggies and yellow mustard. I wish they offered a dairy free cream cheese. I also inquired about their horseradish mustard if it was vegan and they didn't know the answer. Overall really good bagels but give yourself extra time when you go there it is very busy. Also we saw a customer go to pick up their order and they had to place it again while their family was waiting in their car. read more

Strathmore Bagels - Whole wheat everything bagel with lettuce, tomato, onion, roasted peppers, and yellow mustard. - Bagels Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

For me the issues is not the wait or the food, They typically have plenty of staff and i have never complained about the food with the exception that they don't seem to knwo how to melt cheese on egg sandwiches. The staff for the most part are fine, but a few especially the guy with tattoos on his neck makes you feel like you are bothering him, he has ZERO personality and never has a smile. He must be a family member to keep his job. Also why is staff eating in the small dining area? They don't have tables in the back? Customer was sitting at small table near outlet & staff member (lady that has trouble walking) says i was going to sit there to charge my phone and then walked away not happy. read more

Gluten free bagels are hard to find at a bagel shop, and even harder to find one willing to make a meal out of it and not give you just the cold, prepackaged gluten free bagel. Strathmore hit it out of the park with their gluten free bagel. I got a plain one with butter to give just the bagel a fair shot and a BEC on an everything bagel. Both were absolutely delicious. I've missed bagel store BECs so much. Best part was no gluten reaction afterwards, so they followed good cross contamination prevention policies too. Only part I don't love is not being able to go inside to order- you have to call it in or go online. It is very COVID friendly though so I understand. read more

I usually like this place because the food is good but they are CONSTANTLY forgetting items in my orders. On MULTIPLE occassions i paid extra (around $2.50) to have an extra sausage on my sandwich and everytime I dont recieve it. Then today I order an corn muffin and dont recieve it as well... a $3.50 muffin that i didnt get. Im not the type to complain like honestly but its always something from this place. I just dont understand why its so hard to read nowadays. Ridiculous. read more

I used to come here often prior to COVID, food was good, we enjoy the BLT's. We are a year, OVER a year into the pandemic, vaccinations have been administered etc. They are continuing to FORCE their customers to wear masks but the owner was allowed to go in the back of their kitchen with her mask down? I'm no mask police, HOWEVER these people are the MASK POLICE. Right when we walked in she demanded "YOU MUST WEAR A MASK. If you don't have one there's a box full of them there" and she pointed to the mask box above the garbage pail. Real nice. Not a pleasant greeting to your customers. The lady who had helped us when we had gone was sweet, but this will be the last time we go there. BLT's can be made anywhere. Will definitely be bringing my business else where. read more

My favorite bagel store when coming to LI. As soon as you walk in the fragrance of the bagels makes your mouth water. They have everything you can think of for breakfast and lunch. Variety of cream cheeses, bagels, and a whole lot more including black and white cookies and rainbow cookies. Definitely not diet friendly lol although they do have gluten free bagels and low fat cream cheeses. read more

Strathmore Bagels - Happy St. Patrick's Day. #greenbagels - Bagels Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

I usually only get breakfast sandwiches on rolls, however my husband and ordered me One from here on a bagel. It was delicious!!!! The scrambled egg bacon and cheddar on a sesame bagel was amazing , one of the best breakfast sandwiches I've had read more

This place fell off, the boss ignores the blatant disrespect his employees give customers. I returned my food cause there was hair in my sandwich and they were like "besides that everything's correct, why would we remake the 2 sandwiches??" And the guy w angel wings on his neck was so rude to my Spanish friend, who is hard of hearing because it took a moment to say what side he wanted. And on top of that, they threw unpackaged pickles in the bag and that was before I went back to return the order. So unsanitary, disrespectful, I'm so disappointed because this used to be a great place I'd come to every Sunday w my family. This place needs to be humbled and get a nice reality check. Never again. read more

AND HERE WE GO!! My job orders from Strathmore every morning. Well today they finally got a feel for why I say NEVER order from this place. See photo below of their so called Bacon Egg and Cheese. As you can see the cheese is thrown on the sandwich. When we called them to complain about how the block of American Cheese wasn't even melted, they had the never to tell us that we have to ASK for the cheese to be melted!! HAHA Jokes on them, they are over priced, have the worst customer service. The lady who takes the orders who has a accent had the never when we called to complain say that WE are getting the girls in the front in trouble!!! Save yourself the headache and order from Pond Deli, or even Locust if you need breakfast and working!!! read more

Strathmore Bagels - Don't you love my BEC with a block of American ... $12 BEC - what shit - Bagels Near Me - Ronkonkoma, New York

Great bagels !!!!New York bagels like they used to be. Staff was great. Walked in and one of the guys behind the counter asked me how I was doing and what I wanted right away. Took my order and got it right. Made some small talk and I paid and was on my way in less than 10 minutes. Had an everything bagel and poppy seed bagels with cream cheese. Not stingy with the cream cheese but not just slathered on either. Cut in half and wrapped to go. Can't get a good bagel from where I am from o am an original New Yorker and can appreciate a good product. I would definitely recommend this place. You won't be sorry read more

Been going there for a while, it's not close to home but I stop on my way home sometimes. The service is very slow, management is rude and if you just want a Bagel with Lox and Cream Cheese they force you to get a watered down drink and a tiny mac or potato salad, all for an overpriced $9.00 Today they forgot to put one of my items in the bag and the manager was rude when I called about it. Enough, I'm done read more

BESTTTT bagels on Long Island, I've been going here my whole life and I definitely recommend Strathmore for your breakfast. Service is always fast and efficient and is a very homey environment. read more

If you want a perfect breakfast in bed, this is your Door Dash go to....here's why!!! Since COVID, many restaurants and delis etc have started food delivery services so we can have delicious and now very various at home dining experiences. Hence, creating a new arena for food critiques...best food by delivery. Sometimes things don't translate well in transit. But when you order from Strathmore Bagels, there is no need to worry!! Time and time again I have ordered breakfast from here. Each time the order is perfect. They never forget anything. They have never messed up anything. The food is delicious. The eggs are so fresh, always cooked to order perfectly. Really great crunchy fresh veggies for a scramble and yummy gooey cheese. Sometime I'll order a breakfast burrito with some hot sauce, peppers and onions, so good! Don't forget the avocado! And the bagels (drool) are one of the best on the island. My go to order is a toasted egg everything with butter. I like the Strathmore bagels because it's so soft inside, crusty outside and generous seeds. I hate when a bagel is too soggy, or chewy and no seeds. Like that's not how we do it on Long Island! I can also highly recommend their muffins, I love a nice warmed muffin and coffee in bed. Find them on Door Dash, order your fave to be dropped at the door. Then race back under the blankets to treat yourself to a perfectly delivered breakfast in bed!!!! read more

This place used to be amazing. The last two times I ordered from them the bagels we're not really bagels at all. It was more like a role. If you live on Long Island you know what a bagel is like. You know that a bagel is a bit tougher than bread and harder to bite. The last two times I got sesame bagels there it was just like eating a piece of white bread. I called them up and they said nothings changed but it has and the bagels aren't good anymore. At least the sesame bagels aren't good anymore. I won't be going back. read more

TERRIBLE service and unprofessional. This was my first time trying this place with my coworkers, and the last time. We had our food delivered and all of our orders were completely wrong. This happens, nobody's perfect.. it was the reaction from the staff that caught me off guard. I was was really looking forward to my order: The chicken caprese on a WRAP.. instead I received grilled chicken with peppers and tomatoes on a ciabatta ROLL. I also ordered an iced tea and got pink lemonade instead. When calling to let them know about their mess up .. a lady answered and instead of rectifying the issue, she was so quick to point the blame at us. The lady was EXTREMELY rude she showed no remorse, defended the employee who placed our order. At one point we heard them arguing over us. We were going to give the staff a chance to redeem themselves and order again but that attitude left such a bad taste that we requested a refund. 0 stars read more

Filthy place only could take two bites of my egg sandwich without wanting to throw up, I'll never come back here

I love this place! The people that work here are amazing , especially during this COVID! They have an excellent system down. They also deliver and they're so friendly. The bagels are the best anywhere, as far as I am concerned , it's true! All the food is excellent and nice portions! Sorry I didn't have a picture, next post I will. read more

To think... this place used to be where it's at for Bagels & Bialys. Now.. meh not so much. Yesterday went and got a flagel and brought home a couple of bialys. I have to say my love for Strathmore has came and gone. I used to love when my mom said to me when I was a kid "let's take a ride to Strathmore..." I knew I was always in for a treat because I used to love their egg bagels and their bialys. Put it this way.. my aunt from Nassau used to come out here and want Bialys from Strathmore! Now ughhhghhg.. WHY?! What the heck happened Strathmore?! Flagel was an everything that just lacked the punch of all the flavors of an everything flagel. Bialy tasted like an enlarged bialy with bagel consistency and just chewy and overall doughy. I know I love a good bagel once in a while with the doughy but when I want a bialy... I WANT A BIALY! You know the light fluffy disk thing? Yeah.. not some enlarged disk that I felt like I was a cow chewing on this morning. I don't know man.. I just don't know... maybe I'll be back but for now I think I'll stick to Nesconset Bagel Café. Besides.. its 5 minutes from my house and much better than Strathmore at the present time. read more

We placed a breakfast order for delivery at work and I ordered a mushroom omelet platter because I saw it came with home fries. When it was delivered there were no home fries. So when I called Strathmore to ask about them with my platter she said "home fries only come with the platter when it's eat in only, not when it's take out". WHAT?? A platter should be a platter whether you're eating in or taking out. So do customers get charged extra for the home fries if taking out but not while eating there? What kind of service is this? So then platters aren't available if taking out? Maybe that shouldn't be offered on their website if taking out. I didn't just order an omelet, I ordered an omelet platter so it shouldn't make a difference if I eat the platter there or take it out. Plus customers should be told, at the time of ordering, that take out orders are different then in-house orders. Makes no sense. read more

Fast service, fresh food. The line is usually long but moves quickly. There are not many tables, so if you plan to sit, you might need to wait. A very popular bagel destination in the area with lots of flavor options. read more

Best Bagels ever. Live in Florida now but when I fly into Long Island....Bagels for me it is. Head right over.