Terrible customer service. We have ordered delivery from this location several times. Then the next time we called they said they don't deliver in our area. We are 3.9 miles away.They suggested Eat Street but the prices were way higher..... So the next time we called the Neenah location and they were more than happy to deliver here. Today at lunch time I tried again the Appleton location for delivery...the gal said they were short one person so they couldn't deliver and then suggested EatStreet again and when I said they were too high she hung up on us. Needless to say that is the end of us doing any business with the Appleton Location. You should be happy that people want to support you during Covid. I have heard other bad comments about how rude this location is. On the brighter side Neenah was very friendly and more than happy to take and deliver our $43 lunch order. read more

The closest thing to Chicago Pizza in Appleton. Sweet sauce, amazing crust, and a great price. To add on to it they have an amazing staff and team back there making it one amazing experience. read more

Great service and awesome calzones! The large calzone is massive and very delicious, it can easily feed two. This is my go-to place when I'm out in Appleton for I-car training. read more

Stuc's Pizza and calzones are very good. We've eaten in the restaurant a few times and have had appetizers before dinner, which were also very good. But OMG, the desserts are amazing! Sometimes I skip the pizza and just get a variety of desserts delivered! read more

I have yet to try the thin crust pizza, so I cannot speak for that. However, Stucs has the BEST deep dish pizza I have ever had...and I am from Chicago! I recommend the pepperoni with onion cooked extra well-done...Mmmmm. We relocated to the Appleton area a little over a year ago and I am so glad we found this gem to get our deep-dish fix! ohhh... and you cannot go wrong with their chocolate mocha cake either. delicious! read more

I loved this pizza and the service was fast and friendly. I just wish I had ordered a larger pie to have later when I got home that evening. Wish we had a place like this close to home in Utah. read more

I am not from WI but from MI. My family went out on a whim and got your guys deep dish pizza and antipasto and none of us were disappointed. So delicious! read more

Had a meeting in Appleton and afterwards yelped for a good pizza restaurant I was not disappointed. Stucs hit a home run as far as I am concerned. Salad was fresh and crisp Pizza was over the top. Met the owner Dustin. Very personable and really cared that we were please with the service and quality of our meal Stop and in support this fine establishment. read more

Great pizza! Calzones, deep dish, hand tossed or thin crust - all delicious. Lots of beer choices including craft beers. Take out or dine in available. You can also get "unbaked" pizza for takeout and bake at home. Service is good and restaurant is very clean. read more

Stucs always provides good service AND appreciated of our business. Well run business. Great staff.

To continue on the quest of finding the most enjoyable pizza in Appleton my friend and I went to Stuc's Pizza. We ordered our standard pizza and it was well made and had lots of cheese. The ambience is nice but would be nice if there was a lower ceiling to reduce echo. I really don't like that in a dining experience. Very Delicious. I am also impressed with their menu. Some of my family members do not eat gluten and they offer a gluten free crust and beer. And they make it in a separate kitchen area. Which actually needs to be done when dealing with food allergies. I found that to be very impressive. read more

Best pizza in the city if not the state. The cheese has a good texture and makes me think about childhood memories. The sauce is made to perfection and would satisfy god himself. Incredible customer service. The waitress is very nice, gives mother teresa a run for her money. 10/10. 5 stars love stucs read more

Best pizza and Spinach and Artichoke dip in the Valley. Love their sauce, crust and sausage on the pizza and the Spinach and Artichoke dip is so cheesy and delicious and for only $4 can not go wrong. Absolutely scrumptious every time. Reasonably priced and always good service!! I would highly recommend this place to anyone looking for some reasonably priced yummy food in the Appleton area. read more

If you are looking for deep dish in Appleton, this is the only place I have found. Good service and a nice variety on the menu. They do a lot of take out as well. read more

Stucs Pizza - Our favorite place for deep dish! - Pizza Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

I am trying to agree with other travelers on this one...it's hard for me. I could not get past the sauce and crust.

If you like deep dish pizza and live near Appleton, WI you have to try Stuc's Pizza. Wonderful crust and tasty sauce. You will keep coming back :) The College, Ave. restaurant is small, but the food is good. read more

Ordered delivery via yelp/eatstreet. Was our first time trying Stucs. The pizza was cold upon arrival. We ate a cold slice and decided to warm up in the oven. Pizza was dry-no visible sauce. Not the worst pizza I've ever eaten (dominos and Pizza Hut would be worse choices.) But absolutely no redeeming qualities to make us want to ever try again in person or via delivery. Cardboard like crust. Cheese garlic bread was all bread with minimal cheese. read more

Cute place! Just like the comfy vibe in here. Review said - like Chicago pizza, so I had to try that deep dish. Have to say not as good as Malnati's (impossible!) but darn good. Nice crust. Next time I might try sausage or mushroom. I should have ordered thin SLICE. I did take the rest home. How much pizza can a gal eat and keep this girlish figure. The server was warm and friendly. read more

OMG! There food is amazing!! Even Salads!! And save room for desert, Have to try the chocolate cream cheese muffins! You won't be disappointed. I give the a must must try!!!!!! Way to go stuc's!!!! read more

I have been going to stucs for years (back when they were just a husband and wife team back on corner of badger and Wisconsin Ave). They recently have made some updates to the interior that I personally am not a fan of. It is a darker atmosphere. It is also a loud atmosphere during busy hours, so I would not recommend it for first dates. The food is delicious. I saw in a previous review they were confused on the layout of the building. When you walk in there is 9/10 a sign up saying to seat yourself. To the left is the register that you can place to go orders. Unsure their experience but this is how it usually is out of the many times I have been there. I order a calzone or deep dish pizza whenever I come to this place. I love their garlic bread because they have actual bits of garlic on it (unlike some places that just use garlic powder). read more

Unique pizza. After first piece of deep dish pizza, I thought it was ok, but something in the sauce made me craving more. If you eat two pieces, you'll be stuffed. Excellent desserts! read more

Ok I have to say, I stop here whenever I'm in the area and bring a pizza and spinach garlic bread home 1.5hours away. There is one in appleton and neenah. I've been to both, don't know that I have a preference yet. I'm in my box and always order a spinach pizza with mushrooms. The sauce is great the spinach is spicy and the crust is thin and perfect. The regular garlic bread is made with good bread and toasted nicely the spinach and cheese bread is phenomenal. They have many choices for pizzas, ingredients are fresh for the most part. I don't like canned anything on my pizzas. The many times I have ordered, the staff is so nice and really take pride in what they do. Very customer oriented and it shows. My orders have always been ready and correct. I have no complaints. I hope they never go out of business. I've eaten in the dining area as well. Family or friends place. Acceptable selection of beers, better than most small pizza places. Would suggest more New Belgium and New Glarus selections or just more micro brews available. Maybe they should package their pizzas so I don't have to drive so far. read more

Excellent! First time here with the family and we loved it. Deep dish za was great, server was very helpful and polite and we loved the atmosphere. Great for the parents and the kids. read more

I ordered the Ham & Swiss on white to go. It was delicious. Generous amounts of ham on an artisan hoagie, not overloaded with lettuce or tomatoes. It had just the perfect balance of meats, cheeses, and other stuff. So why four stars? They didn't have chips or fries to go with the sandwich. Though they do have a half sandwich & salad combo (I think soup was an option). read more

Our second time dining here. Lunch was simply tasty. We ordered Spotted Cow to wash down a yummy Stucs Specialty pizza. I can never eat more than 2 pieces of pizza, today I topped out at 3 pieces, lucky me. Kelly waited on us and she has a dynamite personality. For a bonus the GM, cute as all get out, told silly stories making us laugh. A good time, and look forward to our next visit. read more

Love this place! They are always pleasant and the pizza, calzones, and sandwiches are always incredible!

Here a few weeks ago for the first time & loved it! Had the cheese bread which was awesome, great bread and quality cheese. Ordered a large, think it was like 16"?, and split the toppings half and half. Hubby was happy he could get green olives and thought the quality of the sausage was very good. I had mushrooms, onions and pineapple which were all bet good as well. The sauce and cheese on the pizza were also great! You can tell they use good ingredients in every bite. We loved the deep dish!!! Spent about $30 total and were able to bring enough home for supper that night! Two meals for $30! And when reheated, the crust and toppings held up and tasted as great as the first time! Four thumbs up, we'll be back! read more

This pizza was some of the worst I've ever had. I think little Caesar's is better than this place. Garlic cheesy bread was dry and lacking flavor. Didn't even have a garlic taste. The pizza must have a lot of sugar or something cause that was way too sweet! Wish I would have read the prior reviews before going. read more

This is my favorite place ever to get calzones from... I moved out of state 12 years ago, stopped in to get one and it was still as amazing as I always remembered. I'd recommend the Stuc's special or the meat lovers Ultra. Make sure you order ahead, they do typically take 30 minutes to make. read more

This is absolutely the best pizza ever and the garlic bread is to die for. I go often with my friend and it is a real treat. Would recommend highly read more

From out of town and ordered this based on a recommendation from a local. I acknowledge that I am from New York and maybe a bit of a pizza snob but this pizza was seriously average on a good day. The sauce was way too thick and almost like a can of tomato paste and seriously what self-respecting pizza place cuts a round pizza into multiple square pieces? Sacrilegious. read more

YUMMMMM! I've been here ONCE and now I'm questioning myself why! My pizza (deep dish) was fantastic!! I will be returning very soon!

stopped in for the first time, and was surprised at how roomy this place is. plenty of seating, and there's a long countertop where you can see into the kitchen. their sign says "baked or unbaked or half baked" so I'm assuming you can order unbaked like Papa Murphy's. the pizza was good, but not my favorite. however my husband loved it. he used to work in the area and they would come here often on their lunch breaks. so it's definitely a crowd pleaser! I just wasn't a huge fan of the sauce. but that's me. we received excellent service which makes me want to come back and try one of their calzones instead read more

Great pizza and great service! Only complaint is a little too much sauce, but if you like that, this would be a great place for you!

Great pizza. The pizza is amazing. Many option. The staff are absolutely friendly. Found this place by chance. Would definitely come back to this place when I'm in town. read more

Both pizzas burnt black on edges. 1 Wrong pizza. Ordered specialty spinach and got something with sausage and pepperoni.

Order off eat street the one thing I asked for in the whole order was no mushrooms on my calzone I wait a hour for the food to get to me then find out it's loaded with mushrooms now I have to wait another 30 minutes I'm fucking pissed read more

The red velvet cake tasted like it sat out too long at room temperature. Everything else was wayyyyy too salty (even the calzone). Noodles in the spaghetti was overcooked. The spaghetti sauce tasted off. Meatballs and sausage definitely seemed like it was frozen and not homemade. We will never eat/order from here ever again. read more

Really, the only reason this gets three stars was the service. The waitress was very nice and had a good sense of humor. But the pizza was disappointing. The sauce was too sweet and there was way too much of it. read more

Stucs Pizza is the best pizza I have ever had!!!!! The deep dish is amazing. The red velvet cake is also amazing. We will be eating here a lot! read more