A lovely local spot for freshly bbq meats. Owner is nice and proud of his food. Quality meats. read more

Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ - Barbeque Near Me - Locust Valley, New York

Delicious No frills Service is friendly/ the rest is self serve Ambiance is very casual I can't wait to go back. Order early, they sold out of the chicken. There's no dessert. Don't skip the sides. read more

See all

This cozy, small restaurant is nestled in the heart of a charming, quiet small town, making it easily accessible for locals and visitors alike. The menu features expertly prepared dishes, and the brisket, in particular, is a standout -- tender and flavorful, practically melting in your mouth. Outside, the garden offers a peaceful and lush retreat, perfect for a relaxing break. The staff is consistently friendly and attentive, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. I highly recommend this spot to anyone seeking delicious food in a serene setting -- it never disappoints. read more

Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ - Smoked Brisket, Smoked Baby Back Ribs - Barbeque Near Me - Locust Valley, New York

See all

I just took a short trip to North Carolina while eating at Stueys BBQ in Locust Valley. It's a small, mostly take out place with a few stools( and I think a back yard terrace) . They have smoked brisket, ribs, chicken and more. I had the brisket sandwich with corn bread and coleslaw. I have to say the best brisket I've ever had....hand carved by nice kindly lady , the best cornbread I've ever had by a long shot, and crispy light vinegar Cole slaw that was perfectly mated to the rich meat. For this area, this is exotic food! I'll be back to try the rest read more

Top quality food. We walked in and the lady behind the counter was slicing apart a tender chicken. The menu is simple and it's easy to choosse what you want. Most of it was sold out by the time we arrived. My boo and I ordered a pound of the brisket with a mini cornbread and two bottles of water. It would be great if they had more non-carbonated options. We sat in the back patio and the guy behind the counter brought out our tray of yum yums along with some bbq sauce for dipping. The bbq sauce was good but it doesn't go with the brisket. It takes away the smokiness of the meat. Th brisket is so tender and tasty and the burnt ends are really good too. The cornbread is the perfect consistency and the jalapenos are tasteful but don't issue any heat. You can also see the corn inside the cornbread too! My boo and I ate everything and it was the perfect amount of food between the two of us. So glad we got to try someplace new and we'll definitely be back for more in the future! Happy eats! read more

See all

While I love food, I'm also older which means it takes a lot to impress me. Stuey's is the rare place that consistently impresses me. The brisket (i go lean bc even lean isnt too lean), sweet potato and cornbread is one of the most perfect meals on Long Island. read more

Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ - Cutting delicious brisket - Barbeque Near Me - Locust Valley, New York

A treasure! An unplanned stop after strolling through the Arboretum put us into excellent ribs, brisket, beans, etc. The place is small, no, tiny, but the talent of the two 'do it all' staff is exceeded only by their enthusiasm and pride in their food. A smokehouse miracle! read more

I dream of Stuey's corn bread and ribs. Nothing like it. The lady that works there is very kind and welcoming. Don't walk. RUN!

Really the best BBQ I've ever had in the Northeast. The pulled pork and brisket were deliciously moist and barked. Slaw, beans and cornbread were spot on. Tiny place, only a few counter stools, but so authentic. Feels like you stepped off a street in Memphis or New Orleans. Staff if very welcoming. I'll be back, with BYOB! read more

Amazing! No need to say more! Ribs! Yum!! Don't forget the cornbread!!! I've driven past this place hundreds of times! So glad I was looking for ribs locally and found this place on Yelp!!!! read more

Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ - Ribs corn bread and string beans! - Barbeque Near Me - Locust Valley, New York

See all

Great little bbq spot. Brisket and ribs were amazing. Sides are very good and fit character of the restaurant very well. I hope the back eating area is open in winter. I like to cruise all year round and would love to stop by in winter as well. read more

Probably the best barbecue spot in Long Island the ribs are perfect. The brisket is perfect and oh my God the chorizo is addictive, friendly service, easy parking. All the sides are made from scratch, which seems like it should be obvious but (local place here in Seacliff where I live get their salads and sides out of a Cisco 5 gallon tub which drives me up the wall! when you spend 12 hours on cooking brisket or more and can't take -1hr to make a large thing of coleslaw or potato salad. Stueys makes everything from scratch and it shows. Always a treat to sit at the counter for good food friendly convo and smiles read more

We visited Stuey's on an unusually beautiful day in December after a hike through a local park. We were very excited about some good barbeque after our exercise. To say that Stuey's underwhelmed us would be an understatement. I'll start with the negatives. The staff was not very friendly. It seemed like we disturbed them during an off time of the day. Several of the menu items were unavailable and this "smokehouse" doesn't even smoke their chicken. In addition, the only place to sit was at the counter staring at the staff who were sitting on the other side of the counter staring at their phones. That meant that we had to take our BBQ to go, over a 30-minute drive. As for the food, the sausage was very good and would be the only reason I would stop back in at all - but only if I were in the neighborhood. The ribs were good, but nothing fantastic. All in all, I would probably not go back to Stuey's unless I was near by and wanted to pick up some sausage. Otherwise, I can get as good, if not better barbeque closer to home. read more

Really legit bbq. Not a place to go sit down and eat at but the food amazing. Very surprising to find amazing bbq in locust valley of all places read more

Can't really give it any stars because we never got to eat anything...called last night and they didn't have most things on the menu, Like baby back ribs, sausage and out of most sides. How does a rib place NOT have ribs...? Can't blame it on supply chain issues any more...I guess just bad management.. Too bad according to most reviews it should have been good... read more

Great find! Saw some good reviews on Yelp so my daughter and I took a ride into locust valley. Very little place with the smell of bbq wafting outside luring you in. Parking is plentiful behind the joint and it has a small, covered back area to dine in. The pulled pork was delicious, moist and just enough fat for texture and flavor. The brisket was great as well, moist and pulled apart easily. We ordered corn bread which my daughter loved s as were the sweet potatoes which were like dessert . Definitely will return read more

Very good bbq. Came for the food. Though the seating area can use some work, some simple fixes would make this place better. In regards to the food, it was delicious. Me and my wife ate all our food. I would come back again. I had the pulled pork sandwich and my wife had the brisket sandwich. Sides were also delicious. Very filling. You can also BYOB. 4 stars ! read more

Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ - Food was great!!!! BYOB too - Barbeque Near Me - Locust Valley, New York

I have enjoyed smoking baby pork ribs today. Thank you! .. read more

Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ - smoking baby pork ribs - Barbeque Near Me - Locust Valley, New York

What a great find. BBQ meats were fantastic. Tasty tender and delicious. Cornbread was so fresh and delicious. Highly recommended.

Not the most flattering picture but I sped home to eat it. Honestly best bbq I had in NYS and that's saying much considering most of my family is still down south. The only con is the string beans are a little undercooked but still has great flavor. Absolutely plan on going back and getting two helpings of the sage sausage. read more

Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ - Sweet potatoes , beans , 1 lb. Smoked Brisket - Barbeque Near Me - Locust Valley, New York

Stuey's is in an unassuming building that resembles a home but once you climb out of your car in the parking lot, the smell engulfs you. BBQS in NYC have always disappointed me so I honestly was not expecting much, especially since we had just returned from a trip to Texas a mere few months ago. There were sold out of brisket and all the sandwiches (ran out of bread) so we opted for a full rack of ribs and the cornbread. I have never had cornbread like this. Extremely moist and packed with tiny bits of corn and jalapeño, I would've purchased this by the loaf to enjoy it slowly over the week. Their ribs were pretty epic, just the right amount of seasoning and juiciness, the top crust of the meat was a bit stringy and overdone but that sauce made up for it. That sauce is the best bbq sauce I've ever had. They need to sell it in stores. It's that good. We sat in the outside patio and there was ample room but beware of ants and bees. can't wait to come back to try their other options read more

Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ - Puppy approved - Barbeque Near Me - Locust Valley, New York

This is literally the best brisket I've ever had in my entire life and I've been to Texas! The bark/ crust had just the right amount of pepper, I want to go back there and just ask "How did you do that?" Ribs were very good too. My only regret is I didn't buy more. This place is a gem a real find. Good BBQ is not easy to make and takes a LONG time to make. It's much more difficult than people realize. That's why it's so rare to find a place like this. I am so happy I found it! Great job! read more

Food was amazing. We ordered the brisket sandwich, half chicken, corn bread, and sweet potatoes. Even my kid, who can be a picky eater, loved the food. Ambiance is cozy. We sat by the counter inside the restaurant. I believe there's outdoor seating, but we didn't have a chance to check it out. The service was also quick and the woman who took our order was super friendly. read more

Didn't think exceptional BBQ existed on Long Island. Stuey's exceeded expectations. Brisket Sandwich, Ribs and sides were all cooked to perfection. Melted in our mouths. Highly recommend. read more

Update - cornbread is savory, with peppers and corn in it (see pic) Salmon only on Fridays and Saturdays read more

Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ - Corn Bread - Barbeque Near Me - Locust Valley, New York

Stueys isn't much to look at but the bbq menu was outstanding. We enjoyed dining outdoors. You don't want to go if it's raining or cold unless you're taking it to go. The friendliest service I ever had. Also, the brisket was so delicious that I wanted to go back the next day too. I will be going back soon though. No booze here, btw. read more

Their brisket is the best I ever had, so tender and juicy. I tried a few other places and no one can beat Stuey's. They have a little yard area where u can enjoy your food there, it's very nice to sit in the summer time. read more

Going south? Texas? Louisiana? Don't bother. Go to locust valley New York. Some of the best smoked meat I have ever had. The owner was super knowledgeable and took the time to teach me to use my smoker better. read more

Stuey's Smokehouse BBQ - Best on either side of the Mississippi - Barbeque Near Me - Locust Valley, New York

As Far as the NY BBQ scene goes ... Stueys is 1 of the best Bbq joints in the state . They absolutely have the Best Brisket in Long island NY and prolly top 5 Brisket in all of NYC , The owners are friendly and welcoming, The restaurant has an intimate homely feel , The 1st thing I notice was the flavorful smell of smoke and the screen door . The pricing is reasonable for the location and what goes into cooking legitimate BBQ slow and steady . A simple menu . I highly recommend you go there and Try the Brisket ...No sauce needed that's how good ! read more

See all

They do not answer the phone when you call. I called for hours on Sunday to order a rack of ribs. They finally answered when I called again at 4:30pm, but they "were out of ribs, because they were busy". The man who answered the phone said he was "too busy making ribs to answer". He also was not friendly about it. This was my 1st and last experience. read more

The food here is so good, the staff is so kind (even telling me when they thought I should get the small instead of the large and when getting a combo meal was less expensive) and the outdoor dining area is so cute. read more

Amazing pulled pork & brisket. Sold by the pound or 1/2 lb. . Chicken & Sausage as well. Sides are fresh and tasty. Lunch Specials are filling and with a savings. Highly recommend when you have to have your bbq fix. read more

I ride my bicycle past here all the time and the smell drives me crazy! I was in LV with my wife one afternoon and we stopped in for lunch. Sat at the counter because a bit chilly for us in the garden, loved speaking with the folks behind the counter. The brisket is great, a little better than the pulled pork. Will return. Give this place a try if you're anywhere nearby! read more

Wow! This is the real deal folks. Authentic and amazing BBQ hand crafted by gifted angels who came down from BBQ heaven to make our lives better here on the North Shore. Brisket amazing Pulled pork awesome Jalapeno cornbread - Bam! The team there is friendly and clearly experienced and passionate about what they are doing there. Now here is my challenge folks I was there yesterday for the first time and am still reeling from my smoked out of body experience. I want to call again today. Is it too soon ? Should I wait a few days. Maybe play the part ? Geez I feel like I'm dating again. Maybe I'll just stop by and say I was in the neighborhood! read more

See all

Our usual rib place wasn't available. We tried Stuey's. We were not disappointed. The ribs were perfect. The coleslaw got good reviews from people who like the vinegary type of slaw. The baked beans were excellent! The brisket was a little fatty but very good tasting. The chicken was done just right. The cold garlicy green beans were a surprise and a delight. We ordered a lot and had leftovers that we promptly fought over who was taking them home. We will be back! read more

Competition quality bbq. The brisket was literally unwrapped from the warmer in front of me. Tender and soft, great peppery flavor gives me little beads of sweat. Perfect amount of heat. The bbq sauce I could drink from a cup, peppery like the brisket but with a red or Cheyenne pepper heat to it also. Thick viscosity as if it were almost chucky. Subtle Apricot or apple sweetness to it for balance. The chorizo was a great size, had a nice snap to it. Fatty (as it should be, it is chorizo) but not chewy/good consistancy with really good flavor. This place has got something going, doing smokehouse bbq right. Cant wait to go back. Cheers! read more

See all

We love this place! The ribs were huge, not a bit of fat and bursting with favor. We never had such flavorful food. The brisket was amazing. The sweet potatoes were sweet and tender. But not overpoweringly sweet like other places. The were perfect!! read more

Best brisket and ribs I've ever had. Its so nice to know this place is here whenever I'm in a smoky southern mood. Their meat is like butter. Crispy on the outside, soft and juice in the inside. You can really taste the flavor as well. Service is impeccable too. Will be back :) read more

See all

I enjoyed my lunch special. I got the brisket, pit beans and corn bread. The sodas here are extra small. Total was $17 and change. Pretty pricey for a lunch special. I was nervous at 1st, guy pulls out a loaf of white bread, small piece of brisket. And that's it. But the sandwich, the white bread and brisket just melt down in your mouth. Brisket on it's own was good, but i drizzled alittle bbq sauce on the side and perfect. Down side is locust valley is just very quiet, if this place was close to hemp turnpike, it would be 10x as busy . Food is better when it's not sitting and there is a steady flow of customers . read more

The best ribs, I love the BBQ sauce. The corn bread. I want to try other things but my mouth drools for those ribs..