Went to Stumpy's today for a slice. The pizza was great! Not too much cheese or sauce. Just the right blend of ingredients. Place is great! I read Ed R. posted Dec 17, 2022. obviously this person has NO idea what it takes to own a pizzeria. My dad and cousin owned a pizza joint in Brooklyn for 35 years. I know good pizza. You just don't stop at closing time to start cleaning up so you don't have to do it for the next day because the next day you start making the dough and do all the other things to prepare for the days activities. This is a nice little place. Fort Edward is very fortunate to have a place like this. The place opens at 11:00 AM and we there at 11:05 AM and the lace was filled with people already. Most of the booths were already taken. Amy is outstanding and knows how to handle a pie. We will be back for dinner. Thank you Amy!!! Love this place! read more

Great pizza and staff. Stumpy's is elevating the street and giving us reason come out of our way to go to fort Edward

Very good pizza Friendly atmosphere.Will visit again next time I'm up that way.Says I need 85 characters so I'll post this

Incredibly disappointing. The pizza here is good, not great, certainly not bad, but good- (see my previous reviews) and that is unfortunate because Stumpy's is the only game in town- and it would appear that they take advantage of that fact- if you don't like our arbitrary hours, too bad and that's the message that they sent my family again tonight... It's now been not once, not twice, but 3 times that I have called after 8:30 on a Saturday to order a pizza to pick up- not deliver mind you, but to PICK UP and have been told, "Sorry we're closed." First time, I can understand: 8:55, and hoping I could sneak one in- I get it, a "no" at 8:55 a reasonable response if your posted closing time is 9. But call at 8:45 and 8:35 and they refuse to make a pie to pick up? I call BS!!! Are you freaking kidding me? Do the girls have some place to be? Is Saratoga calling that loud that you can't HONOR your contract with your customers? Seriously? It's just not right, by ANY stretch of the imagination. NOT COOL LADIES. BE PROFESSIONALS. Change your freaking closing hours to 8:30 or 8:45 but don't deny regular customers a frigging pizza at a REASONABLE time before your POSTED closing time. I WANT to support a female owned business I'm guessing because I see the same two women working hard behind the counter every time I have been in. And as much as I want to keep a good pizza joint in my town, at this point, I will no longer be patronizing this business. I'm done. There are a few places in Hudson Falls that make a good pie- I'll call them next time. Sigh..... read more

Solid Pizza. Great salad. Awesome music. Fast service. Great people. I am glad I came in for lunch after work and will definitely be back again. They had fresh brownies in the oven that unfortunately weren't ready when I was in but i'll be back for those too! read more

Stumpy's Pizza - Greek Salad - Pizza Near Me - Fort Edward, New York

See all

Great classic local pizza place with ample seating. If you go to Slickfin down the block make sure to order from here and they will deliver it to you. The ingredients are great. Gf ordered a wonky pizza with pineapple sausage and was way better than we would ever expect from a small uptown pizza place. read more

We had half a Buffalo chicken and half pepperoni pizza, quality was good, especially liked the Buffalo chicken. They are short on staff and the wait on a Thursday night was long read more

Stumpy's Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Fort Edward, New York

We placed an order for pickup for a large pepperoni pizza and a calzone with mushrooms & bacon during lunchtime on Friday. It was ready right around the 30 minute mark quoted to us over the phone & nice and hot when we picked it up. The calzone did not come in a box though; it was on a plate in a paper bag so the packaging was a bit peculiar. The pizza was quite large, but my grandparents weren't impressed with the flavor. My mom didn't mind it though. I thoroughly enjoyed my calzone, but it was smaller than any other calzone I have ever had. The portion size was great for one person, but in my experience calzones usually are good for at least two people. read more

I love that most restaurants will impress you the first time and let you down the next. Not so with Stumpy's Pizza. They delivered right away. Almost $20 for cold, overseasoned fries and I got Subwayed on the wings(only 11 in this "dozen"). It's all good though, you've saved me time knowing that I'll never eat there again! Kudos! read more

Stumpy's is a must go to spot. The food and service are 5 stars. You will not be disappointed.

Usually our go to spot for delivery we haven't ordered in a while and decided to for dinner but was very disappointed tonight! My dad really wanted wings half mild half garlic Parmesan was informed that was something they couldn't do..he was extremely bummed but not the end of the world ..we also ordered garlic bread asked them to lightly toast it they usually do but today it was kinda burnt we also asked for light sauce on the large pie we got and unfortunately we didn't get that either we got the pie but definitely not light sauce...the only saving grace was the Alfredo!! Absolutely delicious they make their sauces from scratch so they are the only place we order our Alfredo from so was very thankful that has not changed! Usually the food is great so it was a little disappointing but will still try again a different night because the Alfredo is that good!! read more

See all

We waited awhile before trying again and sure glad we did, it was DELICIOUS Previously I found the regular pizza disappointing but this time it was amazing!! Great crust, great flavor! read more

My family and I regularly order from this establishment. Throughout the pandemic they have been fantastic with their mask policy, being one of the few local places that felt normal to be inside of. Their flavor is unique to the area but similar to pizza shops in western NY. The pies are always good size and their menu is always affordable. Probably my favorite place to order wings from in the region! Very happy to see they setup shop in my home town! read more

I stopped in for a quick lunch. What an awesome surprise! Two HHUUUGGGEEE slices and a drink for $5. I think there was 9 or 10 pizza's to choose slices from. They had it all. Friendly people, clean & cool atmosphere and AWESOME PIZZA. I loved the crispy crust. Just go. read more

This place is the best pizza place I've had ever. Big serving sizes on everything, fairly priced, and friendly staff. The flavor on everything is amazing, definitely original, plus the interior of the shop has a nice ascetic read more

Stumpy's Pizza - two sub sandwiches on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Fort Edward, New York

Greatest pizza in Fort Edward. Authentic Italian food, authentic Italian experience. Great delivery range. Food is always hot and delicious.

First few times I ordered, it was better than par. This time not so much. Two hours past when finally delivered and the delivery boy says "sorry bro, we're busy ". Keep in mind we're 5.6 mi. Away so two hours and cold food is not acceptable. I wanted a small pizza and I was told all they had was large. read more

This. Place. Is. AWESOME! From garlic parm wings to garlic knots to their basic cheese slice, they have got it down. The owner is a great hostess and the employees there really seem to care about their customers. If you're in the area or even want a drive for good food and atmosphere, you need to go here! You wont regret it. read more

Stumpy's Pizza - If you get a chance to try this place, you won't be dissapointed! Garlic parm wings, chicken fingers, garlic knots and a cheese slice. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Edward, New York

Great pizza, the owner here is Wonder and always interested in hearing from the costomer. The decor is gorgeous and it makes the road / town look a bit nicer. read more

So far, this is the best pizzeria I've been to in the Fort Edward/Hudson Falls/Glens Falls area. The pizza is very good. Nice crust, good sauce and toppings. My favorite is sausage and peppers. The Lumberjack (I think it's called), with multiple meats, is also good. I've also gotten the baked ziti (with sausage), and cheesteak heros, and again, better than any I've had within a 20 minute drive of Hudson Falls. This is good, real, freshly-made pizza and Italian food, not chain store stuff. read more

After seeing this pizzeria win "Best in the Region" from The Post-Star (local paper), I had to stop in to try. My wife and I never heard the name before but after doing a search online, we figured out where this place was. I decided to try out a pizza last night as my late dinner choice. I ordered the large pepperoni and was told 20 minutes (not a bad wait time at all). The restaurant has a rustic look to it. To me, it looks like re-purposes barn wood, which is s nice touch. The staff is very friendly. The woman making the pizzas chatted with me and made me feel at home. I let her know I was a newbie to their place and she was happy to have me stop in to try out the place. I returned home to dig into the pizza. The crust is thin and chewy, just the way I like a New York style pizza. Cheese was plentiful as was the pepperoni topping. Sauce compliments well. I usually go to I Love NY Pizza in Hudson Falls for my pizza but Stumpy's will now be my "go-to" place. To the owners and staff, keep up the good work. You have a nice place to stop into and my first pizza from you was a great one. I will definitely be returning and letting others know about you. read more

Stumpy's has only been open for four weeks. They have done a lovely job of decorating the store front. The food is amazing and the service is quick and friendly! read more

Stumpy's Pizza - Stumpy's is a great little pizza and pasta restaurant! - Pizza Near Me - Fort Edward, New York

Left a bag with money for contactless delivery on our door. The delivery driver took out the money and counted it. Must've thought she deserved more so she blew her nose or wiped it on the bag, brought the bag back and then stuck it to the door. My mother then touched said bag. My mother called them and emailed the video and they brushed her off! God knows what these people are doing to your food! Be wary! read more

Stumpy's Pizza - a car in a garage - Pizza Near Me - Fort Edward, New York

See all

Not one out of the 6 people working on Thursday afternoon was wearing a mask!!! They were not keeping themselves safe or their customers wellbeing in mind. I was disgusted! Watching them touch their faces and touch the food they were making. This used to be my go to spot, never again! No excuse to run a business like this during this pandemic. They are not doing what all business are supposed to be doing right now. read more

Chicken tenders were so overcooked they weren't editable. Overall the other food was good. Service was lackluster at best.

The Puzza is good and the wings are better. Cheap prices. Pizza slices are enormous. Over all good time

Best NY style pizza around...house salad is fresh and portions are generous...my go to place for consistent excellent pizza delivery . Stumpy's doesn't disappoint. read more

Heard from a friend about this place, went with the family last night. Great pizza, good wings and apps. Courteous staff and fairly priced. I would recommend! read more

We placed an online order. We had a couple special requests, pertaining to our wings, and it was perfect, exactly what we asked for. The pizza and wings were awesome. Definitely will order from them again read more

My fav pizza place ever!!!!! Here weekly if not more! Not only is it some of the best pizza I have ever had, they have the friendliest down to earth staff too! Love the daily special, and when they have buffalo chicken pinwheels I suggest you try them!!! read more

Have tried this place twice; the first time the pizza was burnt, but they were a relatively new place when i first tried them so I figured they might still be working out the kinks. Unfortunately, I tried them again recently and AGAIN my pizza was burnt; the whole bottom of the pie was black and inedible. I was happy to have a new takeout option on my way home when I first heard about this place but we will not be ordering from here again. read more

By far, without a doubt, the BEST in the area. The pizza is amazing, the calzones are incredible, love the chicken fettuccine Alfredo! If I were to recommend, I'd say get a "Bear Trap" pizza, some fried raviolis, and an eggplant calzone. Call it a day! read more

Stumpy's is our new favorite place to order out! Our favorites are the garlic knots, calzones & homemade desserts! We've tried their dinners as well and the Alfredo is very good! Everything is so flavorful & delicious! Everyone is so friendly there and the service is great! read more

This is our go to pizza and salad place locally. Their pizza slices are huge and delicious. They offer other options from salads to mozzarella sticks that provide a great taste and overall yummyness. Would highly recommend the food and they have a awesome customer experience within their spaces. Thank you for the good eats!! read more

New favorite pizza place in town. After trying almost every pizza place in the area and being disappointed in the consistency of food and bad customer service we gave stumpy's a shot and you should too! The owner is so nice and so is the rest of the staff the food is always delicious. Best pizza around. Subs are fresh and tasty. Also try the fried ravioli yum!! read more