First off, why would Yelp say that Sully's is closed today? On St. Patricks Day? Come on. So, I've been to Sully's at least ten times but never written a review, I don't believe (it's been a while). On this occasion I didn't have any food, I was here to pick up my Irish dancing daughter who was arriving via party bus (is it bad that I made her drive me home because she has her temp license and I had too much to drink?). Any ways, the times I have had food here, the quality has always been good. Great sandwiches, Reuben's, appetizers, etc. Also, the ambiance is always fun and the people nice. Lastly - and I kid you not - Jack Black is one of the bartenders! read more

Sully's Irish Pub - This might be the only area of a little open space here. Nothing like St. Patrick's Day. - Irish Near Me - Medina, Ohio

went here for date night with my wife... and it was meh at best. The waiter had no personalit, whatsoever although he was attentive and polite. The dining area was Very hot and uncomfortable. I got the corned beef sandwich cause I figured why not, it's an Irish pub. The wife got a cheeseburger..... regrets all around. My corned beef was already $15, plus another $2.50 to add fries... I could only stomach half the sandwich. it's basically lunch meat... slimy and cheese more like a chip-chop ham Arby's has better corned beef.... And that's not saying much. I've read reviews on this place and either the people commenting are Bots or have absolutely no taste And no standards. They're saying stuff like "best corned beef I've ever had" I seriously laughed out loud, pretty terrible food.... like it's an Irish pub... it's beer and corned beef... that's why you go! If you can't do at least those two things, then don't serve food at all. Wife's burger was wayyyyyy over cooked and was maybe beef.... It some kind of was meat... but I've never seen beef crumble like that. the Best thing I had was the beer. Silly's sin. Half Irish red and half cider. Pretty good. Food not so much. read more

We ordered fried pickles, the potato leek soup and corned beef and cabbage. The soup was good (it tasted a lot like clam chowder). Everything was salty. The cabbage seems like it is fried with onions and it is great. I would pass on the fried pickles next time. The bathrooms were not great but okay. One of the staff yelled "Dammit" REALLY loud while we were there and we were all wondering if someone lost a finger in the kitchen or something (we were peeking in the window to the kitchen to see if something was wrong, but we didn't see anything). Nobody refilled my iced tea, which was a disappointment and there are only two high chairs (not enough)! read more

Good place for a drink and meal after work. Love the laid back vibes and service is usually good. Food can be heavy but has consistently been tasty. They do rotate some seasonal beers here so it's a good place to stop in for a new brew or a tried and true regular on tap. read more

I was in Medina last weekend for my best friend's wedding. The night before, a bunch of us went to Sully's and it really captures the essence of the Akron area. When we were walking in, there was a biker festival across the street and a bunch of gruff looking guys in a band singing the national anthem. Classic! Once I walked in, I found more bikers and a sweet irish live band. A decent sized bar with awesome Great Lakes Brew Co craft beers on tap, Sully's offers a comfortable spot with a VERY diverse group. We saw everyone from kids in their early 20's to senior citizen couples all boozing it up. What else do you expect in Akron? The best part of the night was getting my tab. I bought a round for the group earlier in the night. For 14 drinks my tab was something like $55. If I ever (and I don't expect to) return to Medina, I'll be spending another Friday night with friends at Sully's. Awesome spot. read more

Went back and the waitress and food were wonderful. The guinness battered haddock was delicious. My friend said her coleslaw tasted fishy, but I didn't eat mine cause I remembered I didn't like their slaw to begin with. My mother had the soup and she enjoyed it, I thought it was bland. The cake for two was wonderful. My friend did not like the frosting on it or on the peanut butter cake, but overall she loved her cake (it was the same frosting). I had the bailey's cheesecake, I loved it. The waitress was friendly and personable. read more

Had a burger with side salad and Sully's own red ale. All were pretty good but not great. What was great were the corned beef egg rolls! Recommended. My wife also had the similar corned beef sammich and said it was very good. Sully's is pretty busy. You have to seat yourself but I can't imagine how that will go when they are really busy. read more

Decided to try something new and i'm glad I picked Sully's. Received both excellent service and food. Our waitress kept checking to see if we needed anything and was very attentive. Would highly recommend coming to Sully's if you're in the area! read more

The entire experience was an excersise in mediocrity. Servers were apathetic. The iceberg lettuce was warm in what could have and should have been a good Buffalo chicken salad. read more

Always heard nice things of Sully's, never been. Wife and I had a free afternoon without the kids so we went to check it out for ourselves. Sure am glad we did. Ordered the Sully fries with kraut and cheese on them. They come with a mayo horshradish sauce that you use as a dip. Trust me,you'll want 2.. Amazing. I ordered the fish sandwich, comes on a keiser roll, tomato onion, lettuce and tarter sauce. I don't know if our was the beer batter or the tarter that made this sandwich but the combo of them both made it a great choice! Highly recommended. My wife ordered the pulled chicken sandwich. A good sandwich but could have used a bit more of their home made bbq to sauce it up a bit. Home made chips for or side were tasty and a good option since we already stuffed ourselves on the fries. Wait staff were friendly and attentive. Going to go back for some live music some Friday evening soon. Should be fun. read more

Not a good fish dinner for Lent. Ordered the Perch Platter which only comes with 2 very small pieces of fish and 4 perogies which were definitely frozen out of a box (Mrs T's type quality) . For $17 it was very disappointing and I would not recommend it. Don't get me wrong, Sully's everyday food is great but we went there for the fish dinner and not impressed at all . read more

Nice place and a very warm friendly atmosphere. The wine and food selections were amazing. The staff was very friendly and let us try some mixed drinks which were amazing. Live music most definately compliments this place on fridays and saturdays. Special thanks to Neil for making it a very nice experience. Would definately come back. Highly recommend this place. Thx DR MD read more

Had a great dinner. My husband and I both had the pork barbecue sandwich. It was messy, but so delicious. We were very pleased with the meal. My daughter had the bacon cheeseburger. She did not enjoy the spices they put in the handmade burger, but my husband and I both tried it and loved it. Our server was so friendly and very accommodating. We were very happy with this restaurant during our trip. read more

We hadn't been to Sully's in quite some time and were in the area so we decided to stop and grab a bite. Im so glad we did! The Irish stew was amazing and the Pot Roast melt was incredible! read more

Excellent Atmosphere, nice wood work in the restaurant. The Reuben egg rolls, Mussels and Ocean Cakes as appetizers were superb. The Angry Leprechaun Hamburger was Hot and Spicy, with several kinds of Heat. They have 2 different kinds of Fries. Waffle and regular fries which were both tasty. Overall a fine establishment for excellent comfort food. read more

The music is excellent, and the beer is excellent. But I haven't had any food yet because the kitchen closes super early for a pub. So it's not the place to go after the second shift. read more

When people suggest I go to my "happy place" I jump in the car and head to Medina's Public Square! ;-) Sully's Irish Pub has the whole package: wonderful decor, great ambiance, a talented kitchen (the Chef's specials prove this place goes way beyond the joke about the Irish seven course meal --that'd be a potato and 6 pack, for those who didn't know), the friendliest, most attentive waitstaff around, and a great variety of liquor and beers, featuring Sully's Irish Red on tap! All this and live entertainment that will make any lass or laddie yearn to travel to the Emerald Isle. Yep..."happy place" is an understatement! read more

I was here the other week visiting friends in the area and we had an awesome time. We arrived earlier when it was pretty quiet and stayed into the night as the place got busier. I really liked that even when the performer came on the music wasn't deafening. I hate having to shout across a table and being drowned out by music. That definitely didn't happen here. The noise level was just right. Our server (Katie, I think?) was awesome and quick to bring refills even when it was busy. The food was alright and arrived fairly quickly. If you're here, try Sully's Irish Red! It's strong and tasty. read more

We have gone their for the last 2 years for New Year's Eve and had a great time. The food is really good! Thanks, Ed read more

Love that Sully's is dog friendly and allows dogs on their patio. The service here is great! Love all the OU Bobcats they hire. The food on the other hand leaves much to be desired. Not a whole lot of flavor. Come here for the drinks! read more

So my husband and I had a date night and decided to go here. We both ordered the Shepherd's Pie. It was really good, we both enjoyed it. I wanted the pierogi Rueben but the we're out of pierogi's. That was a bummer. We also had a specialty shot that was so good. It tasted like a Girl Scout cookie. Live music was enjoyable and even though it was a crowded Saturday night, the way things are laid out, it didn't feel that crowded. read more

The worst Rueben ever ... waitress was still half asleep when we ordered at 1130 ! Manager was just as interested as the waitress when I complained ! Never again !! read more

What an awesome place. My second time there with my older brother for lunch, and again we really enjoyed it. Right off the square with easy parking, a great place for a quick pint or an evening out. Live music, great beer on tap and awesome food! The fried pickle (spears no less) are frickin' Amazing! The loaded bacon burger was good, and a loaded grilled cheese that is out of this world! Def worth the drive to, or a stop by if you are in town! read more

Stopped here for lunch on a Tuesday. Lots of great choices. GET THE REUBEN EGG ROLLS! they were scrumptious!! Chicken cordon bleu sandwich was good. Good service and friendly waitresses. read more

The place was really nice, came here on a Sunday. It was slow, but the place is extremely nice. Good food, and just a good atmosphere. The only part that I had a hang up was with our waitress. She seemed like she just didn't want anything to do with us. Which I can recognize it was a Sunday and it was probably close to closing time, but hey at least fake being friendly. read more

Came for the Good Friday fish fry. Waited for over an hour only to be told they were out of Perch. Really??!! First Lent Friday and you're out. Same thing last year. Now I remember why we haven't been here since last year Lent. Hello!!! Who's in charge of ordering food??!! read more

Good food, cold beer, smiling faces

Clean and nicely detailed accommodations, very good service and menu selection. Nicely prepared and nicely presented food.

Hadn't been in to Sully's in a few months, and am sorry to say, things have gone downhill. While the service was good and the waitress attentive, the food isn't being prepared with the care it once was. The corned beef sandwiches have been reduced in size, and were dry and lukewarm. The meat, while tender didn't have very good flavor and looked like something they bought from a food service instead of making in house. Our waffle fries were barely cooked and cold by the time they arrived. This was on a Friday afternoon, and there were only a handful of people in the place, so they were not rushed to make our order. The one bright spot was the beer....Sully's Red was served nice and cold. The menu has been pared down, and I wonder if the ownership changed hands? It's too bad because I looked forward to a good sandwich, and it just wasn't there. read more

A Medina resident, we often spend time at Sully's. Although careful to stick with sandwiches and burgers, which are usually safe, one of my all time favorites was the beef stew. Generous portion, with big chunks of tender beef and potatoes with carrots in a thick rich gravy. Hugely disappointed when I ordered yesterday and found they now add peas, rutabaga and corn. Corn in Irish beef stew !? in fact there were more peas and corn than meat and potatoes. What pieces of beef where in there were meager and only a few small pieces of potatoe. The gravy was also pretty bland. NEVER order this dish. read more

The cheese dip is the bomb diggity! This location gets pretty busy sometimes and the staff tends to forget to attend to you sometimes. The Boxty is great. Their appetizers are usually the best thing there for me. I also feel like their lunch menu (different from dinner menu) is the better choices and values. There are things on it that you can't get later in the evening for some reason. read more

Food is good, entertainment is fun but usually to loud. If you sit in the back so you can communicate with your friends, you no longer feel like you are at an Irish pub. Patio addition has been a nice touch. Staff has always been fabulous and fun. read more

Great burgers and ruben egg rolls. Service and drinks are also good. Thanks for being in Medina.

I love a good Irish pub, and was sorely disappointed by Sully's. First of all, $6 for a pint of Harp's? In Medina? That's more than I pay for comparable beer in LA or NY. I also found the fish and chips -- classic pub food -- to be weak. The fish was merely okay -- breaded, not battered -- and the fries weren't fresh. Worst of all was the side vegetable: over-steamed, limp, watery brocolli with a fake cheese sauce on top. My husband didn't fare much better with the "sheperd's pie", which turned out to be stew with a scoop of mashed potatoes on top. No! Sheperd's pie is supposed to have a layer of mashed potatoes on top, and the whole thing should be baked so that the potatoes are browned on top. read more

This place has an amazing fish fry and awesome Reuben egg rolls! The food is classic Irish deliciousness. On the weekends they have live Irish music but get there early.....the seating fills up fast!!!! read more

Having grown up in Medina my whole life I am glad there is finally a place I can spend time at that isn't a dive bar. The people seem to always be having fun when they are at Sully's. They have a great selection of beers especially all of my favorite Irish beers like Guinness, Harp and others. I enjoy the live music but the volume of the music can get kind of loud. My favorite Irish band ever played there during the summer of 2009 and it was amazing! My friend Kieron from County Kildare, Ireland came to visit Medina that same summer of 2009. He used to own a pub in Naas in County Kildare. He loved Sully's. It is his favorite Irish pub in the United States. read more

The atmosphere is nice and they often bring in acts that put on a good show. The grub is a small step up from your standard bar and grill. They have great bar tenders and everything that is something is on tap. read more

my mom and aunts seem to like this place and i was always intrigued. of course, my aunts also like the browns and they've been a hopeless cause since i was 11 years old. the good: the restaurant looks nice pretzel bites service was ok everything else was completely "meh". why do restaurants put a long filet of fried fish onto a round hamburger bun? the sandwich tasted ok but was a complete mess. it fell apart in my hands, turned into a lump of mush and was near impossible to even pick up by stabbing with a fork. also, battered fries, ugh.i should have stuck with the chips that come with the sandwich. Danielle said her BBQ pork sandwich was also just barely ok. $45 (after tip) for 2 sandwiches, sodas and an appetizer is way too expensive. so, i've got that out of the way. i should have had a shot or two. they were priced pretty good at $3 dollars. read more

For an Irish pub, this place has some great food offerings such as steamed mussels and some wonderful wings. I was surprised by the level of quality put into these culinary creations. They have a large selection of brews on tap that are often rotated with seasonal offerings. Many of NE Ohio's better Irish themed bands have played here at one time or another which makes this a fun place to be on any given weekend. read more

I love the food here, but it doesn't come cheap. The live entertainment is good but a little loud. This place gets crazy busy so be ready to wait, it's worth it though. read more