Decided to split a bagel with my daughter. One bagel with chicken salad and cheddar. One small vitamin water. Are you ready? $18.15 Am I out of touch? I figured 11 or 12 dollars at the most. Insane. The price put me off but then we ate it. Tasted like they added simple syrup to it. There was nothing but celery and chic. No cranberries. Horrible! On the plus side,they were friendly. read more

Best bagels in town!! friendly owner and staff bacon egg and cheese sandwiches were amazing also!! read more

Always a friendly face to greet you and everything you need. They also have delicious food and good selection of drinks.

The coffee was great! We got bagels with cream cheese and just enjoyed the peaceful atmosphere.

Average bagel place. Salads in the display case didn't look fresh. They had nice big pastries wrapped in plastic which looked fresh. They write your order on a piece of paper to make sure they get it right. Seems to be a local neighborhood place. We just happened to be nearby and needed a place for breakfast. Not a place we would go out of the way to go again. Some small tables inside and outside. read more

See all

Two. Stars because the lady behind the counter was very kind. However, one thing that will absolutely turn my stomach is when I see the person whom is making my food wearing the same gloves for everything. She was at the register when I first walked in giving another customer their change back. She then starts to work on my food order with the same gloves she just touched money with and the same gloves I just saw her crack eggs with. I used to work in the deli business I know how to work with food in a sanitary Way. This is absolutely disgusting. I don't know if they can't afford to buy gloves but I won't be going back read more

Way overpriced, skimpy sandwiches, tried the place twice to give them a chance...was even worse the second time

Excellent, fresh delicious, big Long Island New York bagels. Beautiful, clean store. Vanessa & Cynthia and the owner Craig are fantastic, really friendly and professional. Terrific music. Definitely would recommend. PS my eggs on bagel sandwich tasted great. read more

See all

Good, decent bagel place. Service is friendly and quick; the place is clean and neat. One line eliminates any potential chaos that some other places in the neighborhood have. I'll be returning! read more

This was the best toasted bagel I've had in a long time. It came out actually really nice and toasty hot. Coffee did, too. Perfect amount of cream cheese. Hit the spot. Would definitely recommend! read more

Used to be great. Under new management and every one in there is now nasty. They fight behind the counter. And can't get any order right. Just go to bagel boss down the road. They will be packed but pre order before you get there. read more

Just got a bagel here. Cashier had gloves on. Handled my money. And then didn't change his gloves to make my bagel. I threw my bagel out. Disgusting. read more

Omg love love love. Their homemade cream cheese is amazing. I got 6 bagels and 3 different flavor cream cheeses and it was like $22. I don't know if that's the going rate but I'm in love with bagels for real now. read more

This was the best bagel I've ever had and the egg was cooked perfectly! I loved how much avocado was put on it too read more

Sunrise Bagel - Egg everything with bacon egg and avocado (SOO DELICIOUS) - Bagels Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

My go to bagel spot when I come to visit my mom. I love the everything flagel, it's so thin and just jam packed with flavor. My only complaint is that I get the same sandwich practically everyday and the price keeps changing...I don't like that at all. Consistency is key people!!! Still love this place though. read more

On my way back home to Florida, I stopped by to pick up some bagels to bring back. I called ahead to ask if they could hold 6 everything bagels for me and the gentleman on the phone was very helpful and accommodating. When I arrived, I was welcomed and my bagels were in a bag for me. I explained how I wanted to bring them home and asked to get a full dozen. I selected the bagels I wanted and the owner said give him some free ones, too. The customer service was absolutely the best! All 3 of the people working this day were friendly, engaging and helpful. They asked about my trip and sliced the bagels for me as I wanted to freeze some when I returned home. We talked and shared stories and I felt like I lived nearby. If I move back to Long Island, I will definitely make my way often. When I return, I will also stop by for more bagels. The bagels were tasty, fresh and they don't skimp on the cream cheese. Overall, this is a great place and one I will return to for sure. read more

Stopped in for something quick for lunch. The girl was friendly. The guy yelling behind the counter was more than annoying. The bagels tasted bland. I'm not happy. I bought 6 bagels, a small tub of veggie cream cheese, & a breakfast bagel $18! Way overpriced & like I said the bagels were tasteless. Come on this is Long Island. We are supposed to have the best bagels. Needless to say, I won't be returning. read more

I would give it zero stars if I could. I went here multiple times and the only thing they can seem to get right is a bagel with butter or cream cheese. Everytime I order something else, it is DISGUSTING AND NOT WHAT I ORDERED. read more

Been coming here for years. Delicious bagels and always fresh cold cuts. Today we ordered some egg sandwiches one over easy, one over medium and they were perfect!! I just had to post this. Service always friendly and fast. Prices are good too. read more

I always come back to this bagel shop. Their bagels are soft with good chew. I seldom toast my bagels. So if the bagel is hard it's not due to toasting. Recently I started getting their mini bagels. I feared that the smaller bagel might be tougher, so I ordered a regular one too. That wasn't the case. Both were delicious, pillowy goodness. The place could use a remodel, but I don't go there for the decor. read more

Never again will I return. You should take my advice...buy your bagels less than a mile away from this place at bagel boss. Sunrise bagels will disappoint. They have no regard for what you order, and the product you do get is chewy and dry. Buyer beware. read more

I just want to know why the cost is different every time I go there. I always get 3or 4 bagels with nothing on them. Sometimes it's $1.00/bagel. Sometimes it's $1.50/bagel. Today it was $1.35/bagel. Great bagels, but some consistency in pricing would be nice. read more

Went in on a Tuesday morning, two people ahead of me, one was allready being helped then the other guy was asked what he wanted. I waited my turn, was never greeted or acknowledged. Someone else comes after me being there for 5 min and the guy whose working at the bagel store starts asking him for his order. Total disregard for me. I was so upset I didn't say anything and just left. First and last time I'll ever set foot in that place. I'll keep giving my business to Bagel Boss in Bay Shore even if it's farther. read more

Make sure to check their math. They like to charge you for a drink after they tell you it comes with the sandwich. Happened two days in a row. And when i confronted them that a sandwich and bagel shouldn't come to $20 and change they tried to argue until I presented them with their own prices +tax and my order was a good $3 cheaper than they charged me. Watch out for snakes like this. Customers shouldn't have to ring themselves up and worry about being robbed. read more

This was personally not my favorite bagel store. The butter was horrible and the cream cheese according to my brother was even worse. I couldn't even eat the bagel it was ridiculous. Gross read more

We catered with Sunrise Bagel for a luncheon we threw for a client. The food was AMAZING and Craig and the crew went out of there way for us as we had people RSVP last minuet. Job well done. Thanks again. read more

Meh. Bagels are alright but never, ever, warm. And they always seem to be out of something. My guess is they make the bagels the night before and don't replenish when something runs out. read more

There's no reason to come here. Prices are high, bagels and egg sandwiches aren't ver good, and the place is very dirty. The bathroom in particular was terrifying with stuff all over the mirror, corroded faucet, stained and dirty walls. Turned my stomach thinking how dirty the kitchen must be. Cashier also kept gloves on when handling money. read more

This is my favorite bagel spot. No bells and wistles or anything fancy, just a great spot fir a bagel, breakfast or a sandwich. The chicken salad is great, give it a shot for lunch. Also ordered a couple of hero platters from here for a holiday party at my house. The price was right and the heroes were perfect. read more

Not impressed. The prices are more expensive than other bagel places in the area, and the staff is anything but friendly. WAY too much butter on the buttered bagel to the point where my bagel could've made like Mark Spitz and swam multiple laps. The egg sandwich ($2.49 + tax) was mediocre. The bagel itself wasn't bad but the egg was not cooked properly and was way too soggy to be a solid fried egg. To focus on some positives: The place is clean and spacious with plenty of seating. You can get Boars Head meat and cheeses instead of going into a supermarket. A bagel to go is anywhere from 75 cents to $1.10. I recommend not getting your bagels in a strip mall to begin with, so this is further evidence. read more

Stopped in here because it was the closest place I thought I might be able to get a salad while driving on Sunrise Highway on my way to visit my dad in the hospital. When I walked in I noticed that there were no salads displayed or on the menu but when I asked if they could make me one, the cashier cut up all the veggies and made me a fresh, beautiful salad. It was very reasonably priced and my dad loved it!! read more

best service i've had in a while. very friendly and welcoming. bagels and egg sandwiches are so so good and very reasonably priced. i will definitely be returning! read more