Bad experience all around: 1st) Don't order from their website. Showed up at the pick up time and was told it would be another 20min (ok fine it was busy) 35min later told it would be +6min. 15min later had to practically go into the kitchen to get it. 2) Mid pizza at best, by the time i got home realized the undercarriage wasn't fully cooked. Ranch was above average though read more

Love the variety of pizzas and dessert! Delish and Harvest Pizza are my favorite veggie pizzas. Salads are fresh! Great open space for gatherings. read more

I try them out bc of the too good to go app. And they did not disappoint. Their pizza is amazing it's light and food of flavors I had the meat and the veggies, all were good. I will drive from Chula Vista to get pizza for my kids here anytime!! read more

Tried this place for the first time for lunch yesterday and it was great! We love pizza by the slice because we love pizza but don't like any of the same toppings. This spot gave us the ability to each order a couple of slices we were really exited about. They have great beers on draft, awesome decor and it had tons of seating (in and out doors). We will definitely be back. read more

Went on 10/5 ordered a beer $13, I asked $13 for a beer. I was told it's Octoberfest and everyone is charging more. I went to several other restaurants and no one was charging more! To bad the restaurant and Cohn group needed a quick money grab from their patrons! read more

Pizza lacks flavor and identity. Crust is uninspiring. NY pizza??? I don't think anyone that calls this NY pizza has been to NYC. I tried one slice and threw most of it away. read more

Pretty good slices. They have a pretty good deal for 2 slices and a drink and you can mix and match your slices. A great hang out spot, plenty of room inside and outside if you want to watch the game read more

I work on La Mesa Blvd, and this is literally my favorite place to go for food and beers! The pizza by the slice is always super good and crispy, but where it's at is the DIRTY CHEESESTEAK Sandwich. It's so damn good, fresh, and spicy. This, a beer, and some pizza with some friends is a great time. Also I have become pretty cool with a bunch of the workers here, so the service is always great. I love how they always have the game on too (no matter Padres/NFL/CFB), overall good atmosphere. read more

See all

Very cool looking spot with tons of curb appeal! Great menu as well - lots of variety. The pie was massive and reasonably priced. We ordered a pie for delivery to Coin Haus. The delivery process was super smooth. The spicy vegetarian had awesome toppings and flavor. However, it was incredibly greasy...both on the slices themselves and residually on the pan. Not sure if it was the special "dirty sauce" topping or if this was a one-off. We both had to stop eating after the second slice. But I would be willing to try a slice or different pie. read more

The food left a pleasant taste in my mouth but the prices didn't. Woof, this place can be pricey! The reason I'm a little turned off by the high prices is because they're not disclosed. The menus when you walk up to place your order don't display prices, only the food items, so your final total is, well, a surprise! I ordered the "Godfather" slice and also the meatball sub, which seemed excessive when I was ordering but was the perfect amount of food when I was done eating. Both items were delicious and my only critique would be that the meatball sub could have been a bit more hefty, but that's grasping for something to pick apart. I'd certainly order both items again. To get back to the pricing of this place, my total after a 20% tip was $30.00. I should add that I also ordered a soda, but $25.00 before tip for a slice, a sub and a soda is a bit steep. I still don't know what each individual item cost me but I'm guessing $17.00 for the sub, $4.00 for the slice, and $3.00 for the soda? I dunno, but $30.00 total after tip. Be prepared for a delicious meal that will make your wallet weep a little bit, friends! read more

My family and I explored La Mesa today, we stopped in for lunch at Surfrider Pizza. It's part of the Kohn restaurant group and a location we haven't tried before today. The restaurant was busy but plenty of room to eat either inside or on two patios. We had a family meal option for a pizza with 2 toppings and a large salad. We also ordered garlic knots which we never received but were given a refund for. The food tasted good, pizza slices are huge and salad was fresh. The staff was nice and the only reason it's not 5 stars is the experience with the garlic knots which was a little weird. Overall, we enjoyed our meal and I would give them another shot. read more

I can only give details on the food because we got delivery but wow! This pizza was so delicious!! to be honest I was browsing the menu and remembered seeing this on the news when I saw the mention of dirty sauce on their menu. We had the SoCal Heat pizza and dirty sauce wings. I love spicy and this pizza was it! So much flavor and well balanced portion of toppings but man it made me sweat! Next time I might do half not so spicy maybe they can do less jalapeños because it was good flavor, but my mouth was on fire and I wanted to enjoy it a little more. The wings were great as well something in that dirty sauce has my husband and I hooked. I can't wait to go into the place and try out some more because flavor seems to be a priority read more

Surf Rider Pizza - Wings sauce on side - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

See all

Tasty thin sliced pizza. They have a deal for two slices of pizza and a draft beer for $14. Have both indoor and outdoor seating plus heaters. Bathroom is clean along with the common areas. Nice pizzeria and kid friendly. read more

The Surf Rider Pizza class was a blast with my 4 year old daughter. It was incredibly organized and we learned a lot about the history of pizza and pizza making. I recommend this class to anyone looking to do a fun activity with their child. The pizza here is amazingly delicious! read more

Surf Rider Pizza - Pizza making class pizza at Surf Rider - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

I was excited to try this place out, when i was looking into ordering there was a fly all over the pizzas. It was in the pizza case it was so gross. The service was so weird, he just stared at us and didn't say anything. Ended up going next door and eating there. read more

Steve is the best!! Pizza and cookies are to die for and the customer service is out of this world, thank you for making are first time so amazing Steve! read more

Surf Rider Pizza - Reese's cookie - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

They changed the Padres game in the middle of us all watching it and wouldn't change it back, on top of being extremely rude about it. In particular, Carlos and Allie, and she left the bar unattended for over 10 minutes. Literally threw our pizza away and left. This place used to be good but if you're reading this, avoid it at all costs it's gone DOWNHILL read more

Our favorite place to get slices in La Mesa! There are lots of tables indoors and outdoors that are great for families and groups. The beer selection isn't extensive, but there are solid local beers to choose from like Societe, Stone and Alesmith. The pizza is NY style thin crust with and there is a gluten free option that's one of the best I've had. They also sell the most incredible cookies that are made in house. Our faves are blonde rocky road and s'mores. The restaurant is located in the heart of downtown La Mesa and perfect for an after dinner stroll. read more

My husband and I came to this spot to check out down town La Mesa. We were not disappointed! Located in the heart of the main street, surf rider has a charm that is unbeatable. The ambiance is laid back and casual. There is north indoor and outdoor options. Great for kids. The pizza has so many different options to choose from and the put it in the wood fire so it's nice and crispy. Great beer selection as well. The service was great. We came on a busy night and they were quick to get our food to us. Overall great experience! read more

Surf Rider Pizza - Cookies - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

See all

Pizza is good. We love the variety. Can get a little expensive with a group. Staff seems a little impatient.

We happened to walk by when we were walking around the car show. I wanted something sweet, and I saw they had desserts. So we went in and they had cakes, cannolis and cookies. I'm a sucker to cookies, and let me tell you, this place has some pretty good cookies. They are huge, soft and most. If you are looking for a cookie spot, please come check them out, you won't be disappointed. Thank you Surf Rider for your delicious cookies I will definitely be back. read more

See all

Great pizza I just subtracted 2 stars for the forgotten ingredient I originally bought this pizza for. I love artichoke! And this didn't have a single piece of artichoke on it. read more

Surf Rider Pizza - Proof I wanted all ingredients and didn't ask for any off yet they still forgot the artichokes! - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

See all

I, obviously, always get a pizza whenever I go to Surf Riders - but today I also got a Philly Cheesesteak and it was phenomenal! The bread was crunchy, the meat tender, and the peppers and onion perfectly caramelized. I ordered online and the order was ready and waiting for me. I also got the cheese pizza and it was great! Can't wait to go back. read more

Surf Rider Pizza - Philly Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

It was my first time going and I saw the ad from IG. I'll definitely come back! We went right as they opened on a Sunday. They had plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. You know the place is great when it got busy a little after we got there! The staff there was very friendly and helpful. The pizzas were delicious and the crust was perfect! read more

This might be a matter of preference but I wish they would cook the crusts just a bit longer. The crust can't hold all of the toppings so it falls apart easily. That might just be me though. Otherwise, the toppings are great and fresh, the staff is always nice. The chicken wings are bomb and they have ample seating in the restaurant so it's good for groups. read more

I love the sliced pizza here! They have a special for 2 slices and a soda for like $12. So worth it because the spices are huge. I've like everything I've tried there, especially the spicy meatball, the surf rider, the GOAT.. read more

This is my second time eating here. I love the two slice pizza special & a drink for $10.50. They have a great selection of pies. You order at the counter & they bring it to the table. It is casual atmosphere with outdoor seating so you can bring your dog. They also have delivery. read more

The pizzas were very good! I ordered a large pick up order and it did not disappoint the family. We tried a half dozen of their set menu 18" pizzas. The crust was thin and crispy and the toppings were generous. Upon pick up the atmosphere is laid back casual surf theme with sports on the multiple flat screens. This pizza joint should be on your radar if on the la mesa area. read more

These people are awesome, take care of your every need, they will even get your own hair out of you face

Disappointing experience. We placed a pick up order for ONE pizza at 6:25p and didn't receive it until 7:58pm. At 7:00 PM, staff told us to come back in 30 minutes, and when we returned, they said it would be another 10 minutes. In the end, it took over an hour and a half to get our order. they didn't offer any compensation or discount for the wait. Just a lot of unclear communication. Super disappointing experience for a simple order. read more

Placed a pick up order and the pick up time said 30 minutes. Got to the store 30 minutes later and the order wasn't even rung in according to the staff upfront. Returned another 30 minutes later and still had to wait an additional 20 minutes before the single pizza I ordered came out. Wasn't even offered anything while waiting for a pizza that took an hour 30 minutes to get. Terrible service read more

Good pizza, and fast survive!! Recomend this place a lot if you are in the area. Pizza was also crucnchy and good!! read more

Surf Rider Pizza - Cheese pizza pesto pizza ranch and Diet Pepsi - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

Came here during covid some time in July to pick up a pizza for my boyfriends nephew birthday and support business during this time. Apparently this place is his 8 year old nephew favorite place. We got half cheese and half sausage. I only had half a cheese slice because pizza and gooey cheeses don't go well in my digestive system (or do anything for my figure). However everyone else in the groups enjoyed it, although everyone agreed it is quite greasy. To me it was just ok, but nothing I would crave or order again but I also only ate the cheese option. Note: I am not a big pizza fan or Italian food lover. Overall it's basic pizza, no frills and no real depth of flavor for me, however gave three stars for the group I was with who enjoyed it more than I. Pros: - ambience - menu selection - size of pizza - service Cons: - very greasy and burnt/ very crispy crusts -parking can be an issue read more

Surf Rider Pizza - Front - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

We came in pretty late on a Monday and we had the pleasure of being helped out by Steven, the kitchen manager. Very cool spot with neat decor, great service, delicious food, and creative pizzas. Don't forget to get a cookie. read more

Wife likes the coconut tea so that is why we stopped here on our little venture up and down the boulevard. Nice selection of sliced pizza. I had the spicy meatball and she had the basil pesto slice-the 2 piece combo with a drink. I guess any time you reheat a slice it's gonna come out a harder crust so that's why I wasn't ecstatic about my piece. Lots of open windows which makes you constantly shooing the flies away which are always around. Nice place to start or end a walk visiting the stores. read more

Surf Rider Pizza - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

Super excited to finally eat here! Staff is very friendly and the selection looked amazing. We ended up getting a few different slices of pizza: The Godfather, Surf rider, and classic pepperoni. It's a beautiful day out so we sat out in the patio while we enjoyed our deal of two slices & beer for $13.95! read more

See all

Thin New York-style crust pizza served either by-the-slice (after freshly reheating in the pizza oven) or by 'One NY size = 18".' That said about the crust, what Surf Rider really offers is a great slice of California-style pizza: creative use of local toppings, and lots of it! Fellow garlic-lovers rejoice: I loved eating both the signature Surf Rider Pizza and its Bacon Rider sister pizza (same, but with bacon!). My other favorite is the Pesto Spinach Delish, which was amazingly green with huge slices of lightly-marinated artichoke hearts. Only small critique is the marinara sauce served with the pesto bread, which seemed straight out of the fridge. This could be refreshing on a warm SoCal day (especially in their spacious outdoor patio), but I would've preferred warm marinara sauce with my toasty bread -- or even room temp. Otherwise, the pesto bread itself boasted great features -- vibrant springy dough, garlic-forward pesto (was a great match with the signature pizza's roasted garlic), and the texture stayed interesting between the mozzarella & ricotta cheeses. Excellent quality as expected from the Cohn Restaurant Group: customer service was a lovely part of my experience, with counter service moving smoothly in spite of frequently busy dinner nights. Plentiful TVs playing a variety of sports, and good varied tap menu -- overall, there's something on the menu for everyone and it's a great place to meet with friends/family. read more

See all

Pizza can never be bad, right? Wrong! This was terrible. I hate to leave a bad review, but it was just horrible. So rubbery I could barely cut it with a butcher knife! Omg! I had been craving pizza for a week! This was the worst! read more

Love the idea of pizza by the slice, that way you can try different combinations and if one person doesn't like veggies, the other person doesn't have to suffer, if only ordering one pizza. We tried three different slices, Mt Helix, Spicy Meatball, and one that had pepperoncinis. They all tasted delicious. Even though it is previously made pizza, they way they heat up the slices make them yummy. I didn't feel I was eating reheated pizza, though there is absolutely nothing wrong with that! They have a nice variety of beers on tap. The servers could have a little more clue on not mixing orders up, but they were very friendly and accommodating. read more

I was in the area and decided to order some pizzas to take home. I ordered the signature Surf Rider Pizza and the L. M. Deluxe. The restaurant is in the middle of downtown La Mesa and it was about 5pm when I arrived. Inside was very modern designed with surfing decorations. I was greeted by staff at the register who was very welcoming. I immediately noticed a case filled with random cookies that I decided to order on the spot. I ordered 2 chocolate chip, a Reece's crunch, a s'mores mountain, and blond rocky road. The cookies were a good size and later informed they were made daily. They also came in this cool rectangular box. As I arrived home, the pizzas were fresh and delicious. I wasn't able to take any pics due to the hunger but everything including the cookies were great. I'll definitely return to take out again or dine in. read more