The food there is so fresh, the service also was excellent and very friendly. Beautiful family that runs it! Price point is affordable, especially for lunch, comes with a complementary miso or soda! Eel tasted delicious, it's my favorite! I love that it's very near to where i live, also lots of parking in the area, it is free meters after 6pm. Must visit you won't regret! read more

Sushi Kaiyo - Eel Roll Shrimp Tempura Roll, Spicy Salmon Roll and Edamame - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

Great sushi. My sister and I came here and we both enjoyed our sushi. I had one of the specials- the sunset roll. I can't remember which one my sister had but she enjoyed it. We both loved the crispy rice! We also enjoyed the plum wine. We will be back! read more

See all

Went last month with a friend and the food is phenomenal. As a vegetarian, happy to find good food. I had the age tofu and vegetarian ramen and fried green tea ice cream for dessert. Definitely going back! Service was quick and friendly and the ambience is comfortable. read more

We visited Sushi Kaiyo for a late evening dinner, and ordered: - Sushi Sashimi Combo for 1: $30 ($32.59 with tax). This dish had a lot of food; fortunately, there were two of us. The fish was fresh and presented at the right temperature. The included miso soup was over-salted. - Crystal Roll: $15 ($16.29 with tax). Aside from the sushi rice being slightly too hard, we liked everything else about the roll. The Crystal Roll was colorful and flavorful. The wasabi here is very strong. Suggested tips are calculated on post-tax subtotals and start at 20%, which is a bit high since there isn't complementary tea. read more

Sushi Kaiyo - Crystal Roll: $15 ($16.29 with tax) - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

Little hole in the wall sushi spot with awesome lunch specials. I work out in Mineola from time to time and this one of my favorite spots for lunch. They have a few tables inside and it seems they do a lot of take out business. I always eat there and it never disappoints. Everyone working there is so kind and friendly. read more

Sushi Kaiyo - Spicy Tuna Roll, Yellowtail Scallion Roll, Salmon Nigiri, Hamachi Nigiri, Fluke Nigiri - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

I ordered a two roll lunch special. I got two hand rolls. Yellowtail scallion and a tuna. I also got a crystal roll. The crystal roll was very tasty. The hand rolls were tasty too. My only complaint is I don't like mushy fish. i ordered tuna. not spicy tuna. i did not expect it to be all chopped up. The same thing for the yellowtail. The lady that took my order was super nice. I told her I'd wait outside by my car until the order was ready. The order was ready pretty quickly and she came out and gave it to me. I would definitely go back there if I'm in that neighborhood again read more

Sushi Kaiyo - two roll lunch special with tuna & Yellowtail - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

Quality: very good Prices: reasonable Service: fantastic Delivery: always on time I love Kaiyo! read more

My friends and I were in the Mineola area and wanted to pick up some sushi take out for lunch. We stumbled upon Kaiyo and decided to order 2 orders of crispy rice and the sushi lunch special, which was 3 rolls for $18. We got a spicy tuna, spicy salmon, and spicy yellowtail roll- all with spicy mayo, eel sauce and crunchies on top. Everything was SUPER good. Def going back. read more

Sushi Kaiyo - Spicy Salmon Roll, Spicy Tuna Roll, Spicy Yellowtail Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

Very nice owner and staff. Really enjoy the bento boxes, the California rolls and shumai. Lunch prices are a great deal for the generous servings. read more

This spot is so good! Feeling in a sushi mood...we walked in on a Fri. evening to have dinner at 7:30 PM, and we were able to get a table immediately. Our order was the sushi sashimi boat for 2, and also a couple of appetizers (pan fried shrimp dumplings and also the takoyaki--squid potato balls pretty good). The thing that blew my mind was the quality and freshness of the fish. I thoroughly enjoyed my meal here. I thought our waiter was helpful and accommodating. We had many requests, and he was patient as we ordered even more honey plum wine, raw oysters and more dumplings. I love the presentation of our sushi and sashimi. It was so beautiful, and I can tell you it was worth it! I would definitely return and recommend it to my friends. read more

See all

Can I tell you that I really love this place. Family owned business with indoor seating, can be good for groups. The fish is super fresh and the food presentation is up to par. There's so much selection in their menu. I especially loved the ikayaki which is a grilled squid with sweet sauce. The squid was cook just right, it was delicious and chewy. Besides sushi they also have ramen, udon, and bento boxes in their menu. I can't wait to try the rest. If you're really hungry I would recommend ordering the sushi and sashimi for two which also includes two special rolls order and your choice of miso soup or salad. They have a variety of special rolls to choose from. The customer service was excellent. I noticed that they do get a lot of take out orders. We didn't have to wait long for the food to arrive to our table. The service was very attentive. read more

Sushi Kaiyo - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

This sushi spot is definitely up there on my list within this area! It's a small mom and pop shop but there are several tables inside, mainly for smaller parties. I can tell that they get a lot of take out orders and they fulfill these orders pretty quickly too. I've gotten take out but also dined in and the quality doesn't differ when you do take out! The prices are very comparable to other sushi spots but I think the quality here is much better than most spots in Queens/Long Island. I love raw fish so rolls and sashimi are always my go-to items to order. There's a huge selection of special rolls and if you look at their online menu, there are pictures associated with each of them. I like to see what my food would look like and plus, it actually comes out looking like the picture, if not better! I think all their rolls are great. The filling to rice ratio is perfect and as I mentioned, the quality has always been great with every order. The shrimp tempura are actually meaty pieces of shrimp compared to other spots that are mostly just batter and they put generous amounts of raw fish as well. The sashimi is also in even, thick cuts and just delicious! A hidden gem but definitely deserves more traction! I know I'll be back here for sure. read more

See all

Came for lunch with colleagues during work. We jumped in so fast couldn't take a pick. We were seated quickly and the serve was polite. She was the only one working so service was moderate but not bad. We all had ne of lunch specials. The sushi was fresh and tasty very filling. I would go again. read more

Been ordering takeout sushi from Sushi Kaiyo, since the quality of sushi from our go-to spot has declined. They are pretty generous with the cuts and I haven't encountered any foul smelling fish. Everything has been fresh and presented nicely and hygienically. I've ordered the chirashi, rolls and sushi and have been very pleased. Excited to try out other items on their menu! read more

Sushi Kaiyo - Ate the tuna before taking pic - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

Phenom sushi in the Mineola area. Always the same folk staffing tables. Space is small so get there early to snag a table. They do a ton of take out- door is constantly opening and closing (prepare for cold burst of air in winter). Love their sushi- fresh and generous portions, and we usually get a noodle entree too. We tried the crispy rice and it was good but very filling- cost me stomach space that was reserved for sushi! Would 100% recommend and we have already been a bunch! read more

Who knew about this hidden gem? Tucked away next to NYU Langone in Mineola, this place might have the best sushi in Nassau. It's a small family run restaurant but the food here is really just top notch. We got the sushi sahimi for 3 (which really is enough to feed 4-5) and we really enjoyed it. The fish was fresh and they were generous with the amounts of food. What makes this combo great is that you can pick 3 of their specialty rolls to boot on top of the sushi and sashimi and their rolls are just simply delicious. The nami roll, spicy king crab and volcano roll were all beyond my expectations. We also tried their spicy tuna crispy rice which was really surprisingly good as well - on par with much higher priced restaurants. Hamachi kama was also fresh and cooked to perfection. Staff here is very welcoming and prices IMO are pretty cheap for the quality and quantity. Hard to say there's a better value in the area. Thumbs up. read more

See all

Great spot that has a mom + pop feel. We've been a few times now because quality of the fish is great, and the platters are good value. For the sushi for 3, you get enough for 4+ (but just sushi pieces accommodating for 3, so okay if you don't want each piece). The toro roll is actually full of toro so that's a good one and the sushi is fresh. The appetizers are also big portions so def plan accordingly. The white fish tempura is super tasty - there's a lot of pieces. Really friendly staff and accommodating chef. small spot so if you want to guarantee, just call ahead but doesn't seem to be a problem. read more

I wish I could give more stars. Best sushi in the area by a longgggg shot!!! Place is small but feels homey. Servers and owners are supernice and, again, i'm still daydreaming of our dinner. The combo with sushi, sashimi and 2 special rolls for 2 is totally worth it. read more

Sushi Kaiyo - Sushi, sashimi and 2 special rolls for 2. 85 usd - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

Food was decent. Not the best nor worse. The reason for a review and the rating is for the dishonesty and warning to future customers. My credit card charge was rounded up despite the clear writing on the merchant receipt. Keep your copy of receipt for evidence to dispute!!!! read more

I absolutely LOVE, SUSHI KAIYO! Not only do they have the BEST sushi on LONG ISLAND (I've tried all the big names) but truly this family owned business is why I come back each and every week. I am a consistent regular at sushi KAIYO for the last 2-3 years. They have the freshest sushi nigiri I've ever tasted at an unbeatable price. I usually order the sushi deluxe which comes with 10 sushi nigiri (omakase style - which is always an amazing selection) and a delicious fresh tuna roll and a soup! My personal favorite is their mushroom soup which has an amazing umami flavor. Some must try rolls are the genji roll, shiro roll, and tiger roll. I love their seared rolls! Our favorites are also the Salmon Bento Box Dinner which brings shumai, California roll, soup, salad and tempura appetizer. Also, their spicy rolls have big chunks of fresh fish so you will not get disappointed unlike other places that serve tempura filled spicy rolls. The online ordering system is great and has never failed. It is always ready at the time I've selected. This is a small yet MIGHTY restaurant. It feels homey and authentic like a great restaurant should feel! You will love the food and will fall in love with the family! read more

See all

Ordered take out that was fresh and delicious with huge portions. The price for value was terrific. Definitely will be back. We got Tomago, Shrimp tempura, and Chicken Teriyaki all delicious and we couldn't finish it. Highly recommended. It's a family business and their son is so terrific. read more

Food was great!!! Loved the crispy rice service was amazing ambiance was good!!!!!!! Yayayay

This place is amazing. I absolutely would recommend this place to anyone and everyone. They get a lot of take out foot traction and the dining place is quite small so big parties are not possible for dining in. But the food, the sushi in particular, was amazing. The quality of fish is some of the best I've had around Queens/Nassau area and for such a convenient price. The Ikayaki is definitely the best one I've ever had. I usually don't order it anymore since it's a disappointment usually. This one though, was perfectly cooked with a wonderful sear flavor from the grill. The sauce heightened the squid without it being overbearing. The chirashi was a lot bigger than expected for a lunch special. $17.5 for 13 pieces of sashimi and some sides. Rice was sweet and fluffy. The quality of the fish was fresh and tasteful. The rolls are a generous portion. The only thing is I wouldn't recommend oyster tempura roll. There wasn't much oyster and the flavor was not there. The other rolls were great though! I can out recommend this place enough, surely my go to place for sushi lunch. read more

See all

Literally the best sushi I had in Long Island . We had 2 special rolls. The ocean roll and the New York. Soooo good! Also had the Philadelphia roll. Service was great. Will definitely be going back read more

Awesome spot! The first place ive ever seen has crispy rice just like TOKU... and theirs is actually BETTER! Its hotter and a little crispier. major win. loved it. The sushi roll was also great, neatly made and fresh. you can tell the quality of the fish is high. Will come back! read more

Wow, what a nice surprise here. Middle of nowhere sushi joint that delivered some fresh, tasty and good quality sushi for a pickup order. Ordered Platter A which was 15 pieces of sushi, 30 sashimi, 3 regular rolls and 3 specialty rolls for $100. It does not come with soup and/or salad. I was pleasantly surprised by the types of fish they included e.g. otoro and other types of fatty tuna. They didn't skimp out on the rolls and appreciated the high fish to low rice ratio. Sashimi pieces were also a good portion. Pretty solid and reasonably priced. Plenty of food for 2 couples without anything else to eat. I will be ordering from here again for sure. read more

Our favorite sushi spot in the area! The sushi Rolls are always fresh and the family run business is always quick and attentive to our orders. We especially enjoy the Kai roll, kubo roll, and the crispy rice appetizer. Their lunch specials are also great during the week especially their bento box. Always looking forward to another sushi night with Kaiyo. read more

Maybe had on an off night but sushi was very mediocre and I felt expensive. Ordered the sushi for two and it had very little variety. For some reason there was a lot of salmon on the platter and few other choices. Usually at other places when i order a platter for 2, I get shrimp, octopus, eel etc. not here. Also this cost with tax about $90. read more

Sushi Kaiyo is such a hidden gem. I wish I had found it earlier! It is my new go to sushi place -- like I need it on a weekly basis. The fish is fresh and the sashimi is cut thick. My faves were the salmon belly and fatty tuna -- melt in your mouth delicious! Definitely recommend checking it out when you get that sushi craving. read more

Great quality sushi at a good price. No dine in, just pick up currently with COVID. read more

Sushi Kaiyo - Sushi Sashimi Combo For 2 - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

See all

Ordered sushi here for lunch. The prices are really fair ($15 for 3 rolls) during lunch. The sushi was pretty good and fresh. But the tonkotsu bowl was a little strange, it had a bunch of other veggies like carrots and snap peas. Definitely not bad though. Would repeat visit considering the price and quality for what you pay. read more

Sushi Kaiyo - katsudon, Philadelphia Roll, Spicy Salmon Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

Wow, the attention to detail in the delivery is insane. My jaw dropped when I saw they poked a hole into the top lid of my tempura order so that it wouldn't get soggy by the time it got to my house. I am so happy this sushi spot exists because my original go to spot just closed for business. Will definitely be ordering from here again. read more

See all

This review is for take-out/delivery during covid-19 closures. Kaiyo Sushi has been a staple during this time and I'm so happy I found it. It has easily become my go-to sushi spot. They offer online ordering on their website which is incredibly convenient. They allow ordering in advance, which allows me to put my order in even before they open so I don't have to worry about forgetting to put my lunch order at a specific time. The food is always neatly packaged and arrives in a timely manner. Their sushi is fresh and tasty. No excessive rice like other sushi places. I usually get the 2 or 3 roll lunch special, which comes with miso soup. I have tried the paradise roll, genji roll, and mikado roll. Loved them all. Also - their crispy rice appetizer is amazing. It has crispy rice on the bottom, topped with spicy tuna and a jalapeno slice. If you are a fan of spicy tuna, would definitely recommend. read more

Loved the presentation of the sushi. They served it in a boat. Waiter was attentive. Sushi was pretty good. Enjoyed the roll with the oyster in it (right). We also got the genji roll (left). Liked the steamed shrimp dumplings with their special sauce. The crispy rice wasn't my favorite unfortunately. read more

Sushi Kaiyo - Genji Roll, Kaiyo roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

Terrific little sushi spot near Winthrop hospital in Mineola. I was greeted by a cheerful woman who offered me my choice of seats. I choose to sit by the large front window to watch the rain soak Main street on a cold November afternoon. My server poured me a cup of hot tea while I waited for my lunch to arrive. The miso soup was very good but the star of the meal was the sashimi and vinegared rice in my Chirashi bowl. Everything was fresh and delicious! The size, presentation, and flavors earn Sushi Kaiyo 4 stars! Yay! I'm a fan! read more

Sushi Kaiyo - Chirashi Lunch - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

Ordered take out from here on New Years Eve and I have to say I loved the food here. They actually had Uni on the menu, it's hard to find Uni on the menu in a lot of Japanese restaurants in the area. The Uni was fresh on my Chirashi. The fatty tuna was melt in your mouth. My husband had the sashimi sampler which he loved and my sister had the special of the day the oyster roll and the dragon roll. And then you can customize your own roll which is great. This will definitely be one of my regular sushi spots! read more

Kaiyo delivered what the Dr. ordered on Uber eats ordered the hand roll combo that came with California, eel, yellow tail, salmon & tuna It was sufficiently tasty would love to return and eat at the actual restaurant read more

Sushi Kaiyo - Sushi Bars Near Me - Mineola, New York

Excellent food, excellent service! A nice, family owned business that is in a cozy and personal area of Mineola. I suggest asking for the omakase or chefs choices of sushi (not on menu) read more

Oh my DELICIOUS. The sushi was amazing. The noodles were sooooo good too. Get the steamed dumplings!

We visited Sushi Kaiyo recently and thoroughly enjoyed our meal. We both had the handroll dinner entree and found the fish to be both fresh and delicious. The rolls did not include cucumber or avocado but the restaurant was happy to accommodate our request. We will definitely go back for another meal. read more