Edit: To answer the owner's comments, we gave some the cake away to a relative, hoping they would…read moreenjoy it more than we did. They ended up not enjoying it, so that's why there's some missing and none of us wanted to eat it anymore! Spoke to Suzi when picking up the cake and explained to her that the cake would not be eaten on the day of, but instead two days later. The cake was for September 1st and that happened to be Labor Day so I had to pick it up earlier! She said, "That's fine," and it can be stored in the fridge for up to a week and in the freezer for up to three months. So, not sure why there's a sense of judgement, cakes should be able to be stored for longer periods of time! And we wanted to order from a bakery specifically, since it was a special occasion. Not sure what your reference to a "squished" cake has to do with it food will accumulate residue in containers overtime! 9/12/25 From seeing professional pictures online of the beautiful cakes on Google Reviews of Suzi Cakes and good reviews on Yelp, I genuinely thought that the red velvet cake I ordered over the phone with Suzi would be amazing. Boy, was I wrong. I had to throw out the cake after 6 days because no one wanted to eat it anymore. We gave some part of the cake away to a relative, so we didn't consume much...not sure if they enjoyed it either. There were 'red' flags that I noticed when placing an order with Suzi. I chose to ignore them because I needed a nicely catered cake for my sister's birthday. Suzi sounded very direct over the phone and sometimes dismissive, so I felt that I needed to truly know and prepare for how I wanted my cake each time I called. I could not go in person to explain or show pictures due to the distance from her business in East Hanover. Suzi gave me the listed price of $90, and I personally thought it was overpriced for a 7-inch, single-tiered cake. I originally did not want to place with Suzi, but I could not find a place around me that would do a red velvet cake legitimately, besides Coco Luxe Cakes in Peapack and Gladstone. Coco Luxe discontinued their red velvet cakes, unfortunately, which is the cake I truly needed, hence why I ordered here. Next, trying to find the suite number and building for this place was a nightmare, another red flag. It's very tight behind some train tracks and very easy to miss. Thank goodness for advanced technology and Google Maps/Street View for helping me navigate. I called Suzi on the phone so she could service me at the front desk to get the cake. I picked up the cake and truly believed that I would make my sister's birthday special, and I planned everything perfectly. I stored the cake in the fridge for 2 days before eating and followed all of Suzi's storage directions. We tried the cake and it was awful. It had a fermented-like taste, and we could not eat it. I saw a similar review on Yelp of someone having Suzi make their cake for their wedding, and their wedding guests could not eat it; it was that bad. I was hoping that would not happen to me, but it did, surely. The icing was hard, dry, and chunky; the cake itself lacked flavor. I got a red velvet cake from ShopRite in July for $16.99, and it tasted way better; just the cake was a little dry. I called Suzi to give her some feedback so she knows. She informed me to come back so she could examine the taste, but at that point, we threw the cake out. $90 truly wasted. Can't really ask for a refund, I guess, because I never came back to her about it, because her location is almost an hour from my house...not sustainable for me. Despite the good reviews, I will never go to Suzi Cakes again. I will stick with another recommendation I got from a relative for Coco Luxe in Peapack if I want a professionally made cake from a bakery. My sister's birthday was ruined, and no one in my family liked the cake. The price for the cake was outrageous, and compared to other local bakeries in the area, the price does not justify the taste. The presentation of the cake is good, but the taste is abysmal. Save yourself, your palate, and your wallet by looking elsewhere!

I stumbled onto Suzi Cakes after having to pivot unexpectedly from a bad experience trying to order…read morefrom a local (new) bakery. Suzi Cakes could not have been nicer or more accommodating with just 2 weeks notice. The communication was so simple, professional, and pleasant. They delivered the cake exactly when they said (in the pouring rain) and even placed the topper and flowers on it before leaving! And then the cake itself...oh my yum! We did Vanilla with Oreo Mousse filling and it was DELICIOUS. The cake was so soft, fluffy, and flavorful. And the filling was awesome! I know I've found my new bakery for future events!!! Thank you Suzi Cakes!

I had a cake done for my future. Daughter-in-law's wedding shower, Colleen was fabulous, I was not…read moresure exactly what I wanted, I gave her the invitation & told her to add a little bling...wow, she did an amazing job. The cake was beautiful and delicious the bride was so amazed!

They made the prefect cake for my baby shower. Loved it. Many compliments on it. Tasted very good.read more

If there's one thing to get from here, get their mint frosted brownie. It's divine and let me tell…read moreyou why. It's chocolately but not in an overwhelming way, fudgey but also slightly cakey, making it an irresistible texture. The frosting is light, airy and minty but not to the point of tasting like an overpowering breath mint. Bonus point is this place is located on Lake Mohawk, which is stunning and transports you to what feels like a little Swiss town. The interior of the bakery is cozy and has an almost Hallmark movie ambience. The staff is friendly. They have 1-2 outdoor tables and I think serve coffees too.

Cute place and their Easter selection had me going overboard. It's a smaller place but there are so…read moremany goodies inside. Their cookies are a work of art. I took two little kids with me and the staff were very patient with us!

I've tried getting cakes from bakeries closer to where I live but none even come close to Sweet…read moreSisters! Their cakes are absolutely delicious, moist, and not overly sweet. Beth from Sweet Sisters made cakes for two important events that I had. Both cakes were visually stunning and truly works of art. You won't believe how good they taste until you try it! Thank you Sweet Sisters for making the BEST cake I've ever had!!

I contacted Sweet Sisters to see if they could help me create two cakes for my child's first…read morebirthday party. One would be a smash cake and the other for our 30+ guests. Beth, the owner, was so lovely to work with. I show her a picture of what I was looking for, and she helped me come up with the best cake and cream combination. Both cakes turned out exactly how I envisioned it, and the best part is they were both equally delicious. They are on the expensive side because each cake is freshly made and tailor just for you. What she will create for you is something you can't just walk into a bakery to purchase. If you are looking for a cake for a special occasions, Sweet Sisters should be your first stop.

The cake was fantastic, it was everything I expected. I only had a few things that I wanted , tye…read moredyed, chocolate cake , and 70 and all of those things he were meant and went above expectations. I picked my cake up which I don't suggest to anyone. I had a panic attack driving with cake in the car, Have it delivered always. Kaela was fabulous as expected.

Kaela was so easy to work with and organized. She was willing to do whatever I wanted and gave her…read moreadvice when it was needed. She was on time and showed up with a beautiful smile on her face. The cake was perfect and guests at our shower thought it was the best cake they had ever had. It was worth every penny. I am so grateful I found her. I will definitely use her again.

Completed an easy and fast transaction in purchasing a macaron tree over the weekend, while in…read morelabor, over email. I haven't tried anything personally, but their ability to take care of this expediently and beautifully will bring me back for more!

Lot's of different things to critique so I'll try to categorize…read more Pro's: Friendly Staff, Accommodating (Depending upon the staff) and some decent offerings. Some of the pound cakes and brownies are tasty, pies, some cake and cupcakes. Cons: Not consistent with lunch menu items and what sides are supposed to come with meals - all depends upon the staff or if they are running low on sides. Breads are sometimes under-cooked and just plain doughy. "Fresh baked" cookies are too heavy on the sugar and sadly not made with butter. Andover location is in serious need of paint, a new window sill outside and a cleaning! No clue if they use preservatives or fillers. To start with, Café Pierrot has a lunch menu which states what sides, toppings, or ingredients are included on a salad, sandwich, soup or wrap. Depending upon whom is making your lunch it will vary each time and many times NOT include what it is supposed to on their menu. All wraps are supposed to have potato salad, pasta salad and greens. Sometimes you may get an average portion of these sides, sometimes just a heaping spoonful, other times you may only be given one or two of the sides. One of the wraps states "with EXTRA potato salad". Uh, no. Never happens - why have a menu then? If you order one of their salads, good luck getting what is supposed to be part of that dish. And they are very skimpy on the greens. I've stopped ordering salads, because its just not worth it when you DON'T get everything that you are supposed to! Some days you order soup to go and they will include several slices of their bread, with another young lady you get nothing. Or, if they are running low on the sides, someone may skimp, but to be quite honest, why cheat the customer? Mind you, you are still paying FULL price for these dishes. Maybe the staff needs a refresher on what it states on their menus and to stay consistent! Walnut Coconut Bars - twice now we've tried these, which COULD be delicious - first time the walnuts in this bar were stale. I thought, well, maybe it's just this one time and I questioned to myself whether any of the staff tastes the walnuts to insure freshness or are there expiration dates on these things? We tried again almost 2 months later - yep - same thing. Entire bar is riddled with stale walnuts. WHY??? That's unacceptable. Moving on to the condition of this establishment. Not trying to be mean, but you walk up to the little building where they have the Café (they own several buildings on this property) and you cannot miss the completely rotted window sills in front - why would you let this go for so long? And you just celebrated your 30th Anniversary? Also, there is some sort of antique mill sitting in front - rusted to high Heaven - again, it can't be there for any kind of décor because at this point its an eyesore. On the latest visit - since we were waiting for so long for an order to be done (which we called ahead and gave it MORE than ample time to finish) I happened to look towards the corner that leads into back area where they prep and bake and maybe 20 large bags of flour were stacked against the wall - next to them some lawn and leaf type trash bag dangling over something and I looked above and there were dark cobwebs dangling from the ceiling over the bags of flour and trash bag. Not appealing at all. Not to mention, the walls looked dirty and all around it's in need of cleaning and fresh paint. Just makes me wonder what else is lurking in the back where they prepare the food when the entrance to the place is rotting and the place needs to be painted and cleaned? Does the owner ever take a look or care? They offer so called fresh baked cookies if you call at least 30 minutes ahead (their policy, not mine). OK, we tried this and when I called I was told it will be about 30-45 minutes. Fine, no problem. We arrived an hour later, figuring it gave them plenty of time to prepare the cookies. When we got there I was told, oh, they are just going in the oven, so it should be about 5 minutes. NO. Try 30-40 minutes later of waiting. Gee, thanks. To top this all off, after waiting so long for something that should have been ready - they dumped all these large (warm) cookies on top of each other with NO wax paper in between! If you even attempted to dislodge one, it would crumble. Geeze, after all that and you end it with sloppy packaging? And it's not like they were all the same cookie type. Lastly, I'm not adverse to sugar, but when the flavor is overpowered by just sugar, it's no good. And we tasted no butter, which homemade cookies should be made with real butter and these had none that could be detected. HUGE disappointment and would never order these cookies again. We keep going back, hoping for better quality and service, but it's hit or miss.

From start to finish this was just a wonderful experience…read more I needed custom logo cookies for a special event, and Delicious Delivered SERIOUSLY delivered. I sent in requests to at least five different businesses. Hope was by far the easiest to communicate with. She was very responsive to all of my emails, answered all of my questions and helped me figure out the right order. Hope delivers cookies locally which is a huge time saver. She also packaged the cookies in cute individually sealed bags. Also a huge time saver. As for the cookies? They look fantastic and came out exactly as I hoped they would (pics coming soon). Fair prices, professional and most importantly -- the cookies are truly deeelish. I will surely be ordering again when I have custom cookie / dessert needs.

Was looking to get something special for a good friend of mine and her kids for Halloween. Found…read moreDelicous Delivered Desserts on YELP, read the reviews and decided to give Hope a call. Needless to say, she did not disappoint!! A platter with cake balls (decorated like mummy's), black and orange cookies, blondies with spider web decorations and orange "velvet" fudge was delivered this afternoon and my friend said they were AMAZING. Coming from her, that says a lot since she is a real "foodie" and knows a great dessert from the moment she sees it! My entire experience from my first call through today's delivery was great. When you need high quality and creative desserts for whatever occasion, your first and only call should be to Hope!!

OMG what an amazing gluten free bakery. Let me start off by saying they were so easy to with with…read more I ordered a cake for my nephew's engagement party. His fiance and some family members are strictly gluten free. Not only did the cake look beautiful but the taste was amazing. They got engaged in a sunflower field and the decorator did the most beautiful design on the cake. I also ordered an apple pie, chocolate mousse pie, a tray of brookies (brownie and chocolate chip cookie combined) and these adorable almond cranberry heart cookies. My husband said the cookies were amazing and I had a piece of the brookie which was also amazing. Everyone that tried the pies was raving about them. Almost all of the sheet cake was gone and that doesn't usually happen but people were eating more then one piece. Kudos to the staff and owner of this incredible bakery.

First time there, best tasting gluten free bagels, donuts, bread, shortcake I have tasted!!…read more Can't wait to go back!