ice cream wasn't very good, 3 of us ended up throwing it away. i got two rice crispies that looked amazing but tasted like how the shop smelled if that makes any sense? the employees were very sweet though and provided great service so i was not mad at my experience here at all and would probably go back for some of the other cute things they had in there:) read more

Great place for sweets as well as unique gifts and toys. At night you will face a wait, but it is worth it! Good parking.

Yummy ice cream and nice place to stop for a break during the day. There's also an area where the kiddos can play board games and with a dollhouse. The chocolate peanut butter ice cream was delicious, as well as the mint chocolate chip. One of the kiddos had the guava cheesecake, which just tasted like cheesecake to me (I couldn't taste the guava), but they liked it still. Would definitely come back again! read more

The green Carmel apples are to die for . The gooey Carmel wit the tangy green apples are delicious. I wish I could say the same for the red candy apples . For the most part mine tasted burnt. Not sweet or cinnamony. Just burnt . It was a waste of 5$ for a burnt little bruised apple. I had saved it for my trip back home to miami and it failed me . Maybe next time savannah I'll just get your delicious green apples read more

Sweet Savanah's is a great place to get place to get great ice cream, key lime pie and even a great latte or espresso! When we were in Marathon we often dropped by for a special treat. Their ice cream is worth the trip! read more

So many delicious treats you can get here, milkshakes, malts, icecream, key lime pie, cake balls, cupcakes, etc.. I'm always looking for good places in the keys and found this when I was searching for key lime pie since the blonde giraffe was close due to COVID. Slightly pricy but not bad since you're paying for really good desserts. I went here like four times within a week with my family. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Family needed a key lime lie fix while we were staying on marathon key. SS provides. Pie was good and for the key lime pie nay sayers in the group I picked up a brownie. She enjoyed it thoroughly. read more

First - let me say the decor was sweet! Beautiful chandeliers! Second - I got the key lime ice cream and the key lime pie. The pie had the perfect balance of sweet and tart, with a perfect graham cracker crust. Whip cream not meringue, which is my preference. The ice cream was creamy and light. Excellent. read more

Such a cute shop. Very clean and inviting. Nice girls working the counter. I bought a whole key lime pie. It was my favorite we tried in the Keys. Tart, but not so much that it made your cheeks pucker. Awesome, homemade graham cracker crust. The crust was my fav part actually. Yum! My son tried a small scoop of ice cream also. Good price and he said it was tasty. read more

Finally a place with great tasting ice cream! Snickers flavor and salty caramel was delicious! Decor was very pretty and quaint! Great date place or with the kids! read more

I don't like food much but they have different cupcake flavors every day, and many different ice cream flavors. Extremely good.

So, when in the Keys you have to drive the 7 mile bridge and have key lime pie. SO, after driving said bridge back and forth, we stopped here for the pie. It was 930, and I thought they would be closing soon, but the two gals that helped us were friendly and didn't seem at all freaked out that we (party of 6) and two other families were coming in for pie and ice cream. Cute place. Games, free self service water, and a nice decor. Pie was good...the better of the two we had on the islands. read more

Very nice dessert place. Very few pastry locations have ample room or allow you to sit down... you can actually have a sit-down dessert meal with the family. Most importantly the cupcakes and ice cream are amazing. In fact you can combine the best of both worlds in one of their sundae creations. And if you are into key lime pie, this is the place. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Quaint ice cream parlor setting. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

We have been coming here for years. Their ice cream, cupcakes and cookies are so yummy! Try the key lime cupcake! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Cookies and cream ice cream in between two chocolate chip cookies! Perfection - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

This is a very cool little ice cream place we love to go to when we're in Marathon. They also have A little gift shop inside, it's worth checking out. read more

Delicious ice cream and key lime pie! My hubby enjoyed their top seller Oreo and heath bar - too sweet for me. I loved the coconut joy and we both liked the espresso chip! read more

My friends and I went here about 4 times during our trip! It was a nice thing for everyone to do together and their treats were so yummy! One time the girl working their made me a frappe speciality drink, so nice! Their ice cream was reasonably priced. Their malts (which I really wanted) cost almost $7 and couldn't suffice spending that much. Everyone is friendly, the atmosphere is clean and cool, a great place to hang out in! **My favorite flavors were Coconut Joy & Oreo Heath Crunch! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Coconut joy - recommend! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

We got married in Marathon and used Sweet Savannah's for our wedding cake! They did an amazing job! The cake was absolutely delicious and beautiful! We received so many compliments on the quality of the cake and how pretty it was! We were extremely happy with the final product and it was exactly as we had envisioned it! So, so happy and highly recommend! read more

Sweet Savannah's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Damn this place makes some really mean key lime pies! I so regret not getting a whole piece instead of just a slice! It's heavenly ! I finished the whole thing in just seconds :-/ I am already missing it! read more

We hired Sweet Savannah's for our wedding! The cupcakes were phenomenal all of our guest raves about them. Although, the look of our cake was a bit disappointing the photo of the cake I wanted and how it turned out was not that impressive. The taste was excellent though the design was not. The first photo is the one I sent the other with the C was ours read more

Sweet Savannah's - The cake we liked - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

This is a hidden gem in the keys! Just finished eating the BEST Oreo cupcake I have ever had. Apparently it was made the morning of my visit - and I could certainly tell by how fresh it was. The atmosphere is very chill -- they even have board games you can play while eating your dessert. read more

Very clean place with nice seating in the back. Not too friendly however. When I asked what kind of coffee they served the lady said regular and decaf .... hmmmm Also one of the sales folks asked how some teethmarks got into her display cupcake. Sort of strange. Also a "sliver" of key lime pie set me back close to four dollar$ ...... it was just OK read more

We were on our way back from keywest to Miami!!! Everyone just wanted a coffee... we randomly find the nearest coffee shop...we wer expecting a decent coffee shop... but these girls amazed us all by the beauty they put in cookies, cakes, coffees. This is not the "could be" place... this is "should be" place... you all should stop on you way to have coffee here... read more

Sweet Savannah's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Warm gooey brownie with coconut and ganache, blueberry cheesecake, coconut ice cream... FIVE stars all around. The owner was a warm and friendly lady. She told us about the fresh cupcakes she makes with two different flavors each day. They looked so good! The ice cream was really delicious. As we were leaving I was watching her package the brownie and she told us to take one home. It was outstanding service. Will definitely go back next time I'm in the keys. read more

Very family friendly, nice little toy shop in the front. Quaint dining area in the front and nice one in the back. Good service, very cute decor all around. The ice cream was very good and refreshing, also a wide selection of desserts and pastries. Definitely will be coming back here again. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

The place is lovely and the service is excellent. They have a variety of ice cream. I asked for birthday cake and it was delicious

Delicious cupcakes with out of the ordinary flavors. I tried eggnog keeping with the Christmas seasons. It was so light and fluffy. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Egg nog cupcake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Stopped by this place later in the evening about 30 minutes before they closed and they were as helpful as if they just opened. Didn't rush us to order or anything and let us try different samples until we decided what we wanted. The staff was very friendly and we would stop in again for a late night dessert. read more

This place is ADORABLE! & you definitely get your bang for your buck. Honestly, I inhaled my two-scoop ice cream sundae before I even thought about taking a picture. Service is very friendly. They have coffee, tea, cupcake, cookie, ice cream, etc. options and they have cute Knick-knacky stuff to buy. SO FULL & CONTENT!!! read more

Average quality, nothing special about the key lime pie as stated in the reviews. It was the only open coffee which was closest to us that's why we tried. We are not planning to visit this place again. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

My ice cream was ok at best. The milk shakes were milk. Horrible I recommend you taking them off your menu especially since the staff. And stand making them. That was made very clear read more

Really friendly staff and a lot of dessert/ice cream combo options. 3 stars for the ice cream. It was a little more icy than creamy. The Sweet and Salty cupcake was pretty good, though. If I go back, I would probably try a slice of their key lime pie with chocolate. That sounds amazing. read more

Lots of options for dessert! Ice cream, pies, cupcake as, cookies and more. Ice cream and key lime pie were delicious. A variety of sundaes are also available. Clean environment and friendly staff. read more

Keylime pie and the key lime bars so good they are to obsess over. The key lime pie is the best I've ever had. Extremely moist and tangy.

Service was horrible. Ended up walking out the door without ordering anything after waiting for 20 minutes as several individuals cut in front of me to order "coffee." The defining moment was when the teenager assisting people in the line rudely said to me that someone else would help me as he began helping the girls who cut in front of me. Too bad. The food items looked good, but the employees need training on some basic food service etiquette, especially if this business is going to charge $6.25 for an ice cream sandwich. read more

Cute family place with delicious Key-lime pie! A must visit when in Marathon! The ice cream is awesome and they have very low price! Don't miss it! read more

Kids loved their oreo cupcakes. I was disappointed with the serving size of the key lime pie. Maybe my expectations were too high after reading the prior reviews. Maybe I eat oversized servings of dessert. The key lime pie was good and tart. The crust was good and buttery. Apparently I am just a 2 pie slice kind of girl. read more

Sweet Savannah's - Key lime pie. Small serving? - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

The cupcakes are fantastic, got the Half Baked and Pina Colada flavors and they were full of flavor, light, and perfectly portioned

Staff was so sweet and the selection is amazing! We got shakes, waffle cones and cupcakes which were all great. Loved the whimsical atmosphere and cute Knick knacks! read more

Oh key lime how I've missed you! Got a special treat with the key lime fudge. It's mixed with white chocolate, a hint of key lime and a graham cracker crust. Looking forward to our key lime pie! read more