Unassuming & dark with dated decor but damn do they make a decent meal. In this town full of chain restaurants this place is refreshing! The locals know. The tourists, probably not. I often order the fish entrees, they know how to season & cook it so it's just yummy. The menu is extensive with many Italian dishes that I'm told are equally tasty. The salad entrees are huge and fresh. The sandwiches are large and equally good. The servers are friendly and quick. There is a separate bar area, a downstairs room for events and a large parking lot. read more

Perch Dinner is a longtime classic! The restaurant has been around since the 60's and it still is a go to restaurant in Millcreek. Come as you are to the out of town summer Presque Isle vacationers or the usual casual dress is appropriate. Enjoy!!! read more

Awesome local spot with great service and good food. Nice local fish options and Amber was great with service and very willing to make substitutions. Homemade desserts were also very yummy. More of a family restaurant vibe instead of the touristy chain vibe of a lot of other places. read more

Good food, loved the Lake Erie Perch and Walleye fish. Will return again when next in the area

M- tired is the theme here over the years it has been better but now just worn out. It's become a locals haunt and I believe more of a habit than an adventure to be enjoyed. No new updates to seating or menu. Destined to roll up the sidewalks and drift away. Throw out a life preserver before it drowns. read more

I really enjoyed the pan seared walleye. It came with 2 sides. I got a fresh veg. medley and swapped my side for a bowl of homemade clam chowder! It was amazing! They had a very friendly staff and my waitress was nice! My food came out hot and my meal was terrific! John H. read more

Great dinner tonight. Wonderful server, perfect walleye and perch and fries. Able to sit outside with our dog, also very happy. Just sorry we had no room for dessert. Highly recommend. read more

Great place . Great food and really good cocktails! Always see families celebrating. Our service has always been excellent.

We don't live in Erie but when we camp there, we always eat at Syd's. They have anything you'd like to eat!

Syd's place is a hidden gem. Great menu and delicious food. Highly recommend. Their staff is very nice and the interior is cozy. I would recommend the pasta dish with Alfredo, scallops and shrimp- 10/10 read more

Syd's Place - a plate of pasta with chicken and mushrooms - Seafood Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Terrible food dated decor poor service extremely unsatisfactory was excited to go there last year for my Birthday as we had eaten there in the past and was good but not this time never again read more

Such a lovely home-style seafood restaurant in Erie! Good place to grab a big meal if you are visiting Erie. It had a large menu to choose from, both seafood and non seafood. Service is nice especially when the whole industry is understaffed after COVID. The fisherman's platter and the walleye special we ordered were nicely cooked and delicious. Also, the clam chowder was loaded with clam meat. Portion size is big! You won't leave hungry from Syd's place. read more

See all

Prime Rib on Friday night was best we have had since moving to Erie! Bravo Syd's. Service excellent as well!

Syd's is a great neighborhood bar/restaurant!! John and his staff do a great job of working to satisfy their customers! If you go there be prepared to enjoy the local food fare but even better the friendly people! read more

We were a party of 7 who enjoyed our dinners at Syd's on Wednesday. 3 of us chose the y-bone grilled pork chop. Tasty, well-prepared, and everything that came with it was good. Soup, salads, homemade salad dressings, great rolls, and sides were all very good. Our server was very attentive to some special needs. read more

Made a special trip from Lake City on a Friday for their special prime rib. Absolutely the worst prime rib we ever had anywhere. No exaggeration. It was so tough I couldn't even swallow it. Very disappointing. read more

This is a really nice group oriented restaurant. There were a lot of groups when we were there. We both got sandwiches and they were excellent, everything tasted very fresh. Our server was so nice and checked on us frequently. No complaints! Everything was enjoyable. read more

This is a very nice and comfy spot for dinner. Service is great and friendly, though there were plenty of guests on the Friday evening. I had the Lake Erie perch, which was quite tasty. Prices are reasonable, though perhaps the portion size should be a bit more. On the whole, good experience, would recommend for anyone visiting Erie and looking for seafood. read more

Ordered perch dinner and it was so small that I doubt it was legallly caught. To top it off it was overcooked and chewy. I've heard great things about their perch so this may have been an off night. read more

First time here and we should have turned around when we walked in and smelled the lurking odor of years of cheap cigars leaking out of the walls. The only reason I can imagine that this place is still in business is that the regulars don't know that better food exists. We ordered bacon jam Brussels sprouts as an appetizer for $13. We were served an unappetizing plate of once frozen, recently boiled sprouts with some jam and bacon on top. What year is it when people are still boiling Brussels sprouts? I ordered the broiled Atlantic cod which came with what appeared to be frozen vegetables and had to send it back. The fish had such a fishy smell when it came out the entire table could smell it. I gave it a try anyway and immediately regretted it, realizing it had turned. The server took it back and I ordered a well done burger. My husband ordered the veal which was dry and rubbery, my father ordered blackened chicken Alfredo that was dry and bland, and my daughter ordered meatloaf that she described as tightly packed sloppy joes. I was embarrassed that I brought my parents to this place, but we'd had high hopes based on the history and reviews. read more

We came to Syd's after our second day on a 5 day bicycle tour. We wanted to have a solid meal. Boy was it. The tossed salad was fresh and salad dressings are all home made and so delicious I wanted to dip my finger in the remaining dressing while waiting on my meatloaf I had the meatloaf Marsala which was rich and flavorful. The rice pilaf was also delicious...my buddy got Baked Cod and mashed potatoes... He said it was exquisite! read more

This place was a lot of fun. It is a very old school like town sea food spot. We were by far the youngest diners in the place, but the food and service were worth it. read more

See all

Ok I have to say this place surprised me. I thought when we walked in it was going to be disgusting. As soon as you walk in, the place is very old and reeks of mold and stagnant water. But dispite all that we sat out side and ordered anyway. I was soooo surprised. The food was fresh and very tasty. The only thing I would say is on their seafood platter I wish they were not so sparse on the portion size. But other then that it was very good. read more

See all

I love the restaurant Chris the bartender is fantastic I recommend the restaurant to everyone Richie

After a day of sightseeing we asked the captain of our tour for a restaurant recommendation. He steered us to Syd's place. The staff asked if we had a reservation. No problem it's busy but you can sit outside. That was fine with us. The hostess sitting us had a very cranky bad attitude. She said she had no time to be nice as some people expected to be waited on who didn't have reservations. It was rude and inappropriate. I shrugged it off. Our waitress was courteous and did her best. It took a very long time to get our food. It was delicious and portions were plentiful. Not sure I would rush back there in the future. read more

Been going here forever and first swing in - in some time tonight. Best big pretzels and salad. Great seafood. Nice complete menu and more than adequate beer selection. Genuine, friendly owner. Beachie vibe with good tunes read more

Not sure WHERE ON EARTH the bad reviews are coming from, but this place is fantastic! Really nice decor, super friendly staff and the food?! FANTASTIC! Definitely unassuming and a wonderful find! Hubby had cajun scallops and almost cried! I had a fantastic walleye that was on special. Definitely be back... SOON! read more

Syd's Place - Cajun Scallops - Seafood Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

We have been going to Syd's place for years. It is our go to place when we go to Erie on weekends. Food is excellent and the service is great. Although this past weekend we decide to use our Visa gift card we receive as a gift from our children. When we presented to our server, she advised they do not accept these as their system does not support them. We were very disappointed as we were not prepared to use our own credit card. We will continue to support Syd's but wish they would update their system as these gift cards are very much way of life. read more

Highly recommend this place for dinner. We went on a Saturday afternoon around 4 with a group of 8. Staff were very friendly and very helpful. We had about 4 or 5 different meals and they were all very good. I had the Chicken Commodore and it was excellent. Parking was easy. We left around 5:15 and it was starting to get very busy. read more

The service was very quick and the waiters are very nice and helpful. The walleye fish was excellent and the menu was very easy to navigate. The price was very good and very low for a delicious night out. The outdoor patio was very nice and quiet with soft music in the background. Overall there was a very nice atmosphere. Great desserts! read more

Syd's Place - French Silk Chocolate Pie - Seafood Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Loved this place seafood is really good nice size portions price is right. Tell lots of people about this place

Delicious!! My daughter found this gem when spending the day at Presque Isle. We don't like butter and the chef was able to make all of our entrees with oil instead. Excellent food and excellent service. We'll definitely be back!! read more

I took my disabled 90 yo mom and another elderly aunt out to dinner. Neither of them are able to "get out much" so this was a girls night out. My mom suggested Syd's since she heard they had the best perch in town. I was skeptical since Syd's has been around forever. Some of the other (older) reviews mentioned the old, dirty dank smelling decor. BUT let me tell you, we're we're so pleased we went. Stephanie, our server, was kind, helpful, and took excellent care of us. The food was hot, delicious, and exceeded expectations. The older women proudly left with well stocked doggie bags! Mom was also happy that our booth was sturdy and had a ledge for her to use to stand (she needs to pull herself up). Anyway, don't overlook Syd's as a place to grab a meal. Prices are well worth the value. Thanks again for helping me spend quality time with my lovely mother and auntie. read more

This quaint little slice of America, serves up the best seafood in town. The atmosphere is delightful and calming, especially the young lady Heather at the bar. We started with a tasty appetizer of fried cauliflower with a creamy buffalo dipping sauce, which was very great. The pan seared walleye was very delicious with it's citrus beurre Blanc. My wife had the seafood Florentine with the shrimp and scallops pan seared and in a delicious sauce which had tomatoes and spinach. My server Amanda was a very knowledgeable woman and did everything we asked for and more. This restaurant will always be a stop of mine in the beautiful town of Erie. read more

Syd's Place - Beautiful Philly cheese steak sandwich, this was very delicious, thank you Syd's. - Seafood Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Wanted to try something more "local" than an Applebee's or thousands of other chain restaurants in Erie. Kids meals were standard - no complaints from them. Mussels appetizer was very good. Now it gets a little downhill from here. Chicken salad was good sized, served on Iceberg lettuce, and wife disappointed in meal. I had fried fisherman platter- haddock, shrimp and scallops. Was decent, batter and oil were not overdone and it came with a nice cup of very hearty clam chowder( very good). Our server was very nice... just slow. Casual dress is definitely ok here. I'd also say that it looks like an older crowd. There is a patio out back but was starting to rain so we stayed inside. I was told that they do a nice job w perch but I did not try any. For the money, it was just ok....maybe Applebee's next time. read more

Honestly one of the best restaurants in Erie. I have to rank pineapple eddies in front of Syd; but Syd is pretty good. I really enjoy the seafood and the burgers. Though the price is on the higher end than regular restaurants, it's still an enjoyable dining experience every time I come here. read more

A really nice spot with great service and delicious local seafood. Loved the fried perch.

Great food Friendly service Good value for price Overall well done ! We are visiting Erie for the weekend with the kids and wanted to get something local and for a casual feel. This was definitely a great find for seafood read more

We had perch that had a really fishy taste and the beer batter cod was too greasy to eat.

Nice place. Needs more vegetarian/vegan options. There was not one vegetarian option in the specials. There was a veggie stir fry on the menu, which was very good for my husband. I had just had stir fry the night before, so I ended up getting a side salad and fries. No veggie burger. Would be easy to add one to the menu or have it available on request. read more