Food took a really long time. But I knew that going in. The food was really good, they have that special Italian American touch so many Italian places lack these days. I'm converted. read more

My husband and I go to Taormina's a great deal and we are never disappointed. They have an appetizer of Spiral calamari and shrimp that is out of this world. The waitstaff is always very accommodating and friendly and we always look forward to coming. read more

Taormina Trattoria - Eggplant parm. - Italian Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Food was very good Eggplant parm and seafood dishes fresh shell fish Service very good waitresses are excellent Ambiance homey and friendly read more

The service was horrible! My order was wrong. The chicken and potato came out burnt. I sent it back and the pasta I had as a replacement was not better. I will never go back. Save yourself and your money. Go else where! read more

Location, kind wait staff, and warm bread are unfortunately the only highlights. The food is incredibly bland. Some may appreciate the big portions but it feels like a waste of money and food. read more

Taormina II is located in Peekskill right along the Hudson river, and I found myself here for an end of the year dinner with about 15 others. The entire experience and meal was definitely worth the hour drive north of Manhattan! Since it was a weeknight, we were offered the prix fixe menu in addition to their regular menu. Although the regular menu has a few selections that are missing from the other (lobster ravioli, one of my FAVORITES!) the prix fixe menu was a much better deal. For $16, you get a choice of appetizer, salad, entree, and a complimentary soda, beer, or wine. I started off with the baked Clams Oreganato (a bit "bready"), before we were all served our house salads. Their homemade vinaigrette was prepared with crushed almonds and was absolutely delicious! For my entree, I selected the Chicken Sabrina, two thin chicken cutlets topped with mozzarella cheese and drizzled in a scrumptious pesto sauce. On the same plate was a potato and green beans with a hint of garlic and butter. Service was friendly, and they made sure to get everyone's food out simultaneously, despite that some in our party arrived later than others. I highly recommend Taormina II if you're looking for great Italian in the Peekskill area! read more

Taormina Trattoria - Chicken Sabrina - Italian Near Me - Peekskill, New York

If you've never had real Italian food, you'll like this. The food is 1 star honestly, but the staff are so sweet and family oriented I feel bad saying that. The risotto is just white rice hahahhha. I had the eggplant parm and it was just ok. Nothing to write home about....salty sauce, heavily breaded thin eggplant. Hospitality was 5 stars read more

Covid sucks, but this place does not! 5 stars all the way around. We can't wait to come back! Old school Italian restaurant feel. Hospitality was beyond great. The owner made us feel at home. Carli made great recommendations. He definitely knew the menu. The food was to die for. The portions were huge. True to Italian potion size we started with the caprese salad and clams oreganatta. For dinner we shared the chicken martini, chicken francese, and a side of penne ale vodka. We boxed up more than half the food to go so we could enjoy dessert only because dinner was so good. The chocolate lava cake did not disappoint and the cappuccinos were the perfect ending to a great meal. Covid wise: we sat inside and felt very safe. Spacing seemed like tables exceeded 6 feet in distance. read more

Taormina Trattoria - Chicken martini, Chicken Francese, side of pasta with vodka sauce. Ohh and the potato croquettes - Italian Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Dirty old restaurant... Bathrooms filthy, floors and walls old and stained, staff overwhelmed and leaves you waiting and waiting... Grated cheese, silverware and condiments go on the table BEFORE the food comes. Staff needs training. Overpriced for small portions. Not a good experience at all. How do you ruin chicken parm? Well they figured it out. If you're going to overcharge then give some better service and better food read more

Incredible food and easy online ordering. Thank you Taromina for saving a Fourth of July baby from having to cook because the holiday fell on a Tuesday and everyone else is closed! We will definitely be back and can't wait to try eating in as well! Thank you! read more

Our plan had been to just have a drink and share the calamari and shrimp appetizer at the bar, but the $26.00 4-course menu called to us and we ended up ordering dinner. Incredible value! Large portions, delicious food, and great service. We had to box up the dessert because we were so full. (Great take-out packaging, by the way--no plastic!) We may make this a Tuesday night tradition! read more

I'm very curious how Yelp is positioning a 3.5 value to a crappy place like this? It has more 1s than 4s. Now that's a point I'm trying to make,maybe they are paying for that? Another thing is,owners never come and maybe apologize, yes! Because they are to busy shoving money in there pockets with no interest on there clients kind of I don't give a f&@ about them! read more

Taormina Trattoria - My lovely 83.00 for horrible food and RISOTTO that is RICE! - Italian Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

The food was terribly bland. Everything tasted like special diet. No salt etc. tried it once and won't ever go back. It's also doesn't appear to have changed anything in the decor for +25 years. read more

My first time here. Service was good. Everyone working there was friendly. Minestrone soup was quite good. Eggplant rollatine was not what I was expecting, though perhaps it was my own fault for not paying attention to the description in the menu? Either way it was more or less a plate full of ricotta cheese, along with some red sauce, and some thin slivers of eggplant rolled around the cheese. It was tasty, but .... I was not interested in eating a plate full of ricotta cheese, so I left most of that on the plate. The tiramasu was 'ok'. Didn't appear to be made in-house, as it came in a plastic dish container ....likely from another business that makes tiramisu in bulk for Italian restaurants. As for the decor, sure, it's dated and old-school, but that's part of the charm. ;-) read more

The best restaurant we always eat at. They beat all others in this area. Food, service. Never have a problem. If the food takes awhile to be served it's because it's fresh cooked. If you want fast food this is not a McDonalds. read more

Totes forgot I ate here a few months back with the ladies! Was going to buy the yelp 20 for 40 deal but instead on saw on their website, they do a pre-fixe dinner for $18.95 which includes..get this.. Appetizer, salad, entree, dessert & coffee AND a glass of house wine!! [Must pay in CASH ONLY tho to get this deal !!] If that is not the best deal then idk what is! I've seen dinner deals which include salad or soup, dinner and a soda for nearly the same price so this was ballin on a budget if you need to. The three of us shared three different apps of coconut shrimp, mozz-basil-tomato-eggplant, and mozzarella sticks. All very good and came out fairly fast. You get a handful of options for dinner like mushroom ravioli, chicken parm, eggplant parm, pastas.. the usual guid fare. Our food was also above decent quality and a nice portion for everyone. When dessert came only two of us could handle it, which is a choice of cheesecake or carrot cake (or i suppose whatever else they may offer that night.) The coolest part is, if you want to skip dessert & coffee or just coffee or dont drink, they deduct a few bucks from your dinner! Instead of paying the 18.95 you might end up only having to pay 15.95. Its a really good deal and you cant go wrong! It was rather quiet the night we went but I would gladly come back and try some other menu choices as well as recomment to others to check out. Close to the train too if you need to hop on it right after ! :) read more

Don't waste your time or money. We waited almost an hour and the food was mediocre at best. My dish tasted like it had been reheated.

No bueno. I'm not sure why it takes so long to serve the main course. Cook authentic food, for Christ sake ! It's not hard.

Everything! Melanie was friendly, polite, and very helpful with the menu. Suggesting different menu items. The food was phenomenal! The chef, Fernando outdid himself. The soup, the pizza, the wedges (sausage/peppers, chicken parm, and the chicken with broccolini) were all outstanding! It's a must visit!! We will definitely be back!! read more

This restaurant is absolutely fantastic!! We stumbled upon it after having seen a beautiful sunset on the Hudson which by the way can be seen the moment you step outside if this restaurant. We didn't know what to expect and we were so happy with our findings. They have a cash only four course meal for $20.95. The meal included house wine, choice of appetizers, a main dish which included salad and it a medley of sautéed veggies with a non pasta dish, desert, coffee or tea. We had burgundy and rose wine, a scrumptious stack of mozzarella, eggplant, basil and tomato as appetizers; my partner raved about the portobello mushroom ravioli drenched in cheese sauce, while I savored every forkful of blackened tilapia with sautéed garlic spinach and cannelloni beans and a medley of other sautéed mixed veggies. We finished the meal with tea for my English companion and hearty and flavorful brewed coffee. We had little room for deserts so bagged up slices of cheese cake and carrot cake. ( I did pinch a taste of both and OMG!!!! Very excellent deserts!) We were comfortable. The waitresses were lovely. The ambience was warm and pleasant framed by nice music , candles and the sounds of other diners enjoying their meals and cascading sounds of good cheer bellowing in from the bar area on the other side of the dining room wall. We will definitely eat at this venue again. What a great start to a holiday get away!! read more

Taormina Trattoria - Mezza mozzarella - Italian Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

The most basic and sad Italian food you could ask for. Underseasoned. Watery sauce. Ravioli and spinach that was clearly frozen. And way too expensive. If you want Italian you can definitely do better. At least the service was okay. And the decor is trapped in the 80s. read more

Fantastic food, service, lighting, customer service! Definitely a gem of a Resturant! read more

Taormina Trattoria - Salmon di Laura!! Amazing! - Italian Near Me - Peekskill, New York

The restaurant and staff are amazing. I had been here several times this year and have purchased several dishes. From what I've ordered, their rigatoni bolognese stands out the most in my opinion. The sauce is amazing and I always ask for extra to dip with their delicious bread! Just writing about it makes me want to go there! read more

It's really sad, I genuinely love the fettuccini Alfredo here, with the shrimp or chicken. Nice authentic Italian taste. But the sad part is it takes almost 30-45 mins just to get your food! The last time my family came on a Friday; we waited over an hour for our main entree! Maybe even longer!!! We left at 9pm when we got there at 6! They gave us bread and salads, but it didn't take away from the fact that it took that long to get our food. I decided to give it a second chance and my husband and I brought our niece here to celebrate me being cancer free after going through treatment, and I chose here because I was in the mood for Italian. We went on a random Wednesday and then was the only people there and they still messed up my order!!! I ordered fettuccini Alfredo with chicken and my niece ordered fettuccini Alfredo with shrimp. And they gave me a bowl of Alfredo with chicken and shrimp! What if u was Allergic? Ten minutes later I asked them where my nieces food was and the waitress said the cook messed it up and gave wrong order. So after 20 mins we took my nieces food to go and we ended up sharing my plate. And when the waitress came back, she said sorry I wrote it down wrong. So which is it, you or the cook? I was mad at the waitress. And her attitude is uncalled for. They did not give us a discount or anything and didn't even Acknowledge their mistake blaming one or the other. The main waitress and the cook time is why I will never return. Sad really. The waitress is an older woman who seems like she needs an attitude adjustment. Very rude. It's a shame. read more

Old school in terms of hospitality, service, and amazing dishes. If I were Italian, this is what I imagine eating with family would be like... Don't get me started on the hazelnut-stuffed zeppoles... read more

My brother lives in Peekskill and frequented this restaurant weekly for years and got to know everyone there. This past week my brother passed away unexpectedly so after the funeral mass this was the obvious choice for lunch. With no way of knowing how many people we would have attend we told the restaurant it could be up to 50 people at 1pm on a Wednesday. We had 32 people show up and they charged us for 42 stating they prepared food for 50, which in no way was there food for 50. This was not a wedding where you have an exact headcount. It was a family tragedy and we were taken advantage of this restaurants greed. These restaurant owners are disgusting people. read more

Just had their dinner take out special for four which included a salad; a combo of fried ravioli, Mac and cheese balls and mozzarella sticks; garlic bread; chicken parm over spaghetti; and choice of dessert (amazing cheers cake and a big fat canoli). Not only was dinner delicious, it was only $35!!! Highly recommend eating take out and supporting this local business, thank you! read more

Ordered the Taormina pizza on Friday night. Hands down the best pizza I ever tasted. Light and crispy with succulent shrimp and slivered, sautéed garlic on top. Perfect. Thank you Taormina for this delicious treat. read more

Old school Italian food for great prices. We ordered a family dinner of spaghetti and chicken francese, a large salad, bread, fried appetizer platter and two desserts - $35!! So tasty. Excited to have an easy Italian restaurant to add to our list of local joints. read more

Side note: I'd like to give Taormina a 2.5 out of 5 stars, however I am unable due to the archaic Yelp grading scale, to be conservative I will give them 2 stars. I came to Taormina yesterday after an exhilarating hike through Blue Mountain State Park. I was not well versed in the foodie scene of Peekskill, and have to admit this was not my first or second option. I feel like this is the root of the problem for the majority of the negative reviews on Yelp. So onto Taormina itself. Upon entering, my first thought was the decor. I doubt any upgrades have been made since before my birth year (1992). However, who really cares? It's Italian comfort food. A place should not be judged by the decor. It's spacious! There was a banquet hall in the back which was holding a Minnie mouse themed birthday party, and 2 other dining areas. The waitstaff was severely understaffed. One stressed out lady was taking care of all 3 areas of the restaurant plus the bar. She deserves a gold star, no one has time for that shit. We were traveling so we didn't want to fill up and feel gross for the trip home. But oh man we were famished! We placed an order for Penne Alla Vodka, a side of sausage, and at the last moment splurged for some garlic bread as well to split. As soon as our order was placed, a bus boy greeted us with an assortment of bread for the table. Usually this gesture causes feelings of extreme jubilance, however after placing an order for garlic bread I was indifferent. Bread was good though. Garlic bread arrived way before the main course. Or we might have just devoured it? I'm not sure, but what I am sure about was that the garlic bread was the definition of bland. I'm talking picture next to the word in the dictionary. Have no fear though fellow yelpers, this did not undermine my dinner. Thanks to my Italian roots ;), I knew to drench those bad boys in olive oil, salt, pepper and parmesan cheese. Hopefully, Taormina reads this and takes some tips. Finally we get to that coveted Penne Alla Vodka (my favorite Italian dish) with a side of sausage. i was full from the garlic bread, but I felt like a fat kid at a candy store when I started scooping a portion onto my plate, mmmhhmmm it looked good. I took that first bite and :( I was disappointed. It gave me some nostalgia to my younger years when I was microwaving Chef Boyardee's famous Beefaroni on the reg. Sigh, such disappointment. I looked over at my special someone and she confirmed my negativity. After getting acquired to the taste, we were able to enjoy it a little more. They need to add some fresh herbs and spice into that bad boy to really make the flavor pop though. By the time we put our forks down it looked like we didn't even make a dent! Overall, Taormina is a spot that needs to be planned out to go to. This is not a spur of the moment place. If you know what you're getting into then thats great. If not though, read my review and move on. Honorable mention: -They charged refills on club soda....What barbarians -Bus boy had some funny zingers when we told him we didn't want the food wrapped. read more

Was not impressed. They had the worst bread I've ever tasted!! I ordered the feed 4 for $40. The chicken Marcela was excellent, salad was ok, the fried appetizers were too over fried, and the carrot and cheesecake was excellent. The only thing feeding 4 though was the entree n bread. They only give u 2 slices of dessert to feed 4?? Small salad?? Was disappointed that they didn't feed 4 for the entire meal you ordered. read more

Waitress was overwhelmed. Knew I was in trouble when she asked me what I wanted to drink - I told her a Peroni - 2 minutes later she came back and asked me what I wanted to drink. My daughter ordered a wine and we had to ask 3 x before she received her glass. Ordered 2 Cesar salads 1 house salad - got 3 house salads. We waited nearly 1 hour after our appetizers before our main meal was served. Needless to say we had enough, wrapped our dinners up to go and left. Went home and we had 3 peanut butter and jelly sandwiches which were awesome. Don't even know if our order is correct. We'll find out when we have them for dinner tomorrow night. So I can't tell you if it was any good. Appetizers were ok as was the salad. Thanks for the wonderful experience Taormina. read more

Quite nice & traditional checkered red table cloth Italian. By surprise had a very tasty Lobster Thermidor! I think it was a one-off special, but succulent. Recommend whole-heartedly. Also love the hamburgers at the Peekskill Brewery if they are open. Thank you. read more

So I get dragged into this so called restaurant for another going away party, why this choice is beyond me. The food was pretty blah, the broccoli rabe greasy mushy and seasoned with garlic powder that left a weird after taste. The pasta dish could have come out of the freezer section of Stop & Shop. The real clincher,, charging the amount they do for wine, some of which is the cheapest hooch and pretty awful. I honestly don't know how this place has survived. If i ever have to go for another soirée, I'll make sure to eat at home first. I'm always hopeful for local business, I have none for this one. read more

We are still huge fans of their pre-fixe dinner at $19.95 per person Sunday-Thursday. The menu is extensive on the pre-fixe and you get bread, choice of an appetizer, salad, entrée, dessert, coffee/tea and a glass of wine or soda. If you choose not to get dessert, they take $3.00 off of the price. My husband and I paid (with tip) $52 AND both walked away with leftovers! Portions are not small (hence the leftovers). As a note the pre-fixe can ONLY be paid in cash, but it's so well worth it. read more

Food was average, nothing new or exciting to eat with a basic menu. Daughter had the Penne Vodka and it was basically light red tomato sauce, not very good. Left there spending $70 for three dinners, a personal pizza and waters.. yikes read more

Waitress said pizza would take 15mims I had 35 mins to catch a train and she kept saying it will be out in 1 minute. She kept looking at the clock. Since I had paid... They knew I was waiting on train, they never put pizza in oven, I had to run out. Paid for pizza got nothing! Good trick!! read more

Authentic Italian food in generous portions for a great price. The chicken Stacy or Taormina is highly recommended

I dined here last night with my boyfriend. The manager explained that there was a retirement party going on, so he seated us in a quieter, more intimate area. My boyfriend and I had printed out the Yelp $20 for $40 deal and it was well worth it; our $60 bill came out to be $20! The food was pretty good; I had veal parm (very heavy!) and my boyfriend had their chicken dish. It was advertised as something extravagant but when he got it, it was pretty much chicken francese with peas on top. He enjoyed it anyway. Our waitress had a table of her friends near us, which got to be pretty irritating with their cursing and her joining them between serving us, families, and working at the bar. It was as if the girl busing tables was more courteous than the actual waitress. I would return to this restaurant though, despite our waitress and the very loud retirement party going on in the next room. The food was good and management was accommodating and friendly. read more

We stopped in during the afternoon and things were a little slow. Calzone was good, a bit too much ricotta vs mozzarella. The food in general lacked a little bit extra. Olive oil for fresh, but lacked a little flavor. Good Food, but lacking. Outside the river area was great and we walked around a little. read more