Beautiful, calm, and special. It's the place you go for the one really nice meal for the week of vacation. One thing: there's no mention of this anywhere and it's important to note -- the kids menu rocks! Seafood, steak, Caesar salad. And yes, chicken fingers, mack & cheese. But there are real options. I got the recommended scallops. Excellent. The calamari (which I think I've become a bit of a connoisseur lately) were mid. There was a lot of sauce on them which made them slightly goey. The oysters Rockefeller were ok. A lot of breadcrumbs with the tiniest oysters ever! Is that a Florida thing? Because I have not had ones so tiny before. The shrimp - for the kids meal were huge! The pasta with seafood was great (has a kick). I wish I ordered the salmon because it looked great. Bacon wrapped Grouper was very good as well. Would I go back? 100% Next time - Caesar salad, salmon, Shirley temple! read more

See all

Really delicious seafood. We had snapper diablo and lemon Parmesan crusted salmon. Both dishes were very good. Service was nice too. read more

See all

I can't say enough about Tarpon! First and foremost Mark!!! Mark was amazing, read the room, got our personalities and made our dinner spectacular. He is a definite asset to your restaurant and hope you recognize him accordingly. Now to the food.... The olive tapenade was so deep in flavor. Bread was fresh. We had the lobster ravioli for our appetizer, so good! I ordered the scallops they were good, maybe a second or two over cooked but still stood out as a great meal with the risotto. My husband ordered the steak, he had no complaints. Mark then brought us each a dessert drink... Carmel espresso martini, couldn't have been made any better, fantastic! This was definitely a stand out experience. Well done. Beautiful separate eating experience over the pond. read more

Tarpon Bay Restaurant - Scallops with spinach risotto, fillet with asparagus - Seafood Near Me - Bonita, Florida

See all

Great atmosphere and service with really good food. I had the Frutti Di Mare, which is seafood cavatelli pasta. Not really sure why it was named that. See attached pic. Made with what seemed like house made pasta and plenty of shrimp, calamari, scallops, and even a little fish of the day. First and foremost this dish was HOT temperature. I appreciate having a good hot fresh meal. Now it was also spicy to a comfortable level for me, similar to a jalapeño level. Over all very good but pricy and could have had a slightly lower ratio of pasta. I suppose that should be expected for a hotel restaurant. Really that was the only reason i didn't give the food 5 stars, however the other three friends would say theirs was 5 stars, but of course I picked up the tab lol. Also want to add we all had some of the speciality drinks that were delicious. The Grinning Tarpon was great. read more

Tarpon Bay Restaurant - Frutti Di Mare - Seafood Near Me - Bonita, Florida

See all

Beautiful restaurant hidden inside the Hyatt! Every experience here always delivers from kind staff to high quality food. Food notes: Smoked old fashioned: love a drink that comes with a show! Smoke adds extra layer to this classic drink Snapper diablo: warning...this one is spicy! I LOVED the flavor the spice added. Fish cooked to perfection. Slaw on top adds a nice freshness and break from spice Triple chocolate cake: YUM! Super light layers that all add to this treat. Perfect bite to split read more

See all

At the Hyatt for a conference and we came here for dinner. Nice ambiance, very farmhouse/waterfront porch vibe. Our server was phenomenal. The bread was amazing - we got two baskets, and comes with a wonderful olive tapenade and butter. My colleagues got the catch of the day for the second night in a row, so I know kit was delicious. I got two tapas plates, with smoked grouper cheek bao buns and another with squash ravioli. The bao buns were amazing. The ravioli had such amazing seasoning. read more

When we were here 2 years ago food was OK. We came back last night for New Year's Eve. Everything was bland and lacking flavor. From my cocktail which I had to return to the burrata that was missing balsamic to balance it and the overcooked risotto. We were very disappointed with the meal overall. read more

The service was incredible. Upon informing that I had a gluten allergy, I was given gluten-free bread as a starter to enjoy with their delicious olive tapenade. For my meal, I chose the catch of the day: grilled halibut with jasmine rice and broccolini. You get to choose how you like your fish prepared, as well as your side starch and vegetable. Our entire table was impressed by freshness of the fish. read more

Tarpon Bay Restaurant - Grilled halibut - Seafood Near Me - Bonita, Florida

We wanted to have a special dinner with friends who were heading back north and decided to meet them at Tarpon Bay. What a great choice! The service and food were both excellent. Even though seafood is the specialty, I ordered the pork chop and was not disappointed. It was tender and served with some deliciously prepared gnocchi and Brussels sprouts. I would definitely recommend the dish. My wife and one of our friends ordered the Asian tuna. They both raved about it. His wife ordered the scallops and they were cooked to perfection. Reservations are highly recommended. If you want a memorable evening out, you can't go wrong with Tarpon Bay. We will be making this one of our top three restaurant choices in the Bonita area. Give it a try and thank me later. read more

This place is amazing! I've been here twice and both times have been great. This time I was with my coworkers and we all had a great experience. For appetizers, we got the ceviche: scallops, shrimp, and tuna. It was very flavorful. It comes with plantain chips which is a nice touch. We also got the berry burrata which was delicious. I ordered the Chilean sea bass, which was nicely sautéed in butter and melted in my mouth! The service is always amazing. This is a must visit if you are in Ft. Myers! read more

This was a great hotel restaurant! Nicely done. Pretty baby blue and ocean vibes! The staff was super attentive and very knowledgeable of this menu. The ceviche was very fresh and well dressed! Unique! That lobster mac n cheese is competing! read more

Tarpon Bay Restaurant - tarpon bay logo - Seafood Near Me - Bonita, Florida

It was one of those restaurants that is pricy, but worth every penny. I can't say that often when I review My wife went here for our vacation and inside the place has dim lighting and it was quiet. The tables have a beautiful set up. The server was also great. She was very knowledgeable and everything she suggested was delicious. Now the food was fantastic. We got the Chilean Sea-bass with this citrus lemon butter sauce. I felt like I could drink it. The sea bass was seared and it was cooked perfectly. It did not have the "fishy" flavor and it was lighter than expected. With it being seared, it has a perfect crisp on the outside. It sat over rice and asparagus. The flavor was exceptional in the dish. We also had the calamari which was probably the best calamari I have ever had. It had arugula and a hint of citrus. It I was definitely a place worth checking out. read more

Tarpon Bay Restaurant - Chilean Sea Bass - Seafood Near Me - Bonita, Florida

See all

This is one of my favorite restaurants. A staple point for our date nights and important business dinners , I have made my way through the entire menu and absolutely love everything about this establishment. I always get a jar of diablo sauce to take home , and it is kisses to the chef Everytime. The red snapper is one of my favorite dishes here , eclectic and yummy you can never go wrong with the red snapper. The environment itself is classy and yet relaxing , and I absolutely recommend the service. One of our favorites indeed ! read more

We go there every year to celebrate 3 birthdays, they give us the captain's table (we were 8). Fantastic food!!! Very good service. A bit on the expensive side but well with it. The validate the valet as well. A real hidden gem in Bonita. Located at the Hyatt Regency. read more

Restaurant is located at the Hyatt hotel. Place was busy but not packed. The food was excellent. I had a lobster Mac n Cheese and wow it had so much lobster I was surprised but happy. I felt like the staff was friendly but it took a long time to get out meals read more

Food was out of this world. The staff were great. They even brought us a desert on the house for our anniversary. read more

Tarpon Bay Restaurant - Maine Lobster Tail - Seafood Near Me - Bonita, Florida

See all

We had a great dinner at Tarpon Bay, part of the Hyatt resort complex. I had the frutti di mare, which was rich and chock full of seafood. It came with cavatelli pasta and contained mussels, shrimp, calamari and fresh fish. Excellent. My wife had the Parmesan crusted salmon, also quite good. Nicole, our server, was a gem. She made great recommendations and provided very attentive service. She knew the menu and our options backward and forward. read more

The third star is earned by the hard working staff who are handicapped by Covid, poor management and choices that miss the little things. Yes , all restaurants are challenged nowadays. Yes, staffing is a challenge. But... A wine list with no vintages, and many bottlings missing. Cold food sitting wayyyy too long on the warming bar. Inedible. No wet-naps for King Crab legs. Shrimp stored at too low a temp. Decor that was imagined by who knows, adding East Village to Coastal Carolina. Seriously? Embarrassing...and a huge waste of $. Eat burgers and nuggets next door. read more

SeaFood was delicious service was fantastic but no outside tables which we really wanted to eat outside

You cannot trust a reservation made through OpenTable. Weeks in advance, I made a dinner reservation for a special family dinner in the Captains Room on December 30th. I committed to spend at least $708.40 for the seven of us. On December 29th, I received the normal notice from OpenTable asking me to confirm our reservation, which I did. OpenTable replied that the reservation was all set. We all got dressed up and arrived on time only to find out that the Captains Room had been given to another party. The manager, Jonathan, refused to honor our reservation and said it was out of his hands. He ruined my night and embarrassed me in front of my family. I will never return here to this restaurant which has no regard for basic customer service. read more

Tarpon Bay Restaurant - OpenTable reservation - Seafood Near Me - Bonita, Florida

Delicious food, amazing service, and beautiful ambience! Jason did an excellent job. Unsure of some of these reviews as we are foodies and absolutely loved all of our meals. So delicious. I had the lemon crusted salmon and my husband had the snapper. My kids both ate the catch of the day (grouper and snapper). Their plate was cleaned, which is rare. Thank you! read more

The service was great but the food was subpar for price. Crab legs great but the other food was served cold and the potatoes with the steak were not great. It was not a very welcoming ambiance. read more

I normally don't leave reviews but I think they made some changes after the renovation because omg the service was one of the best we've ever experienced! Especially Nicole-- she was just the sweetest and most caring server ever. My mom absolutely loved her attentiveness and quality of service and she kept asking to come back to eat here just for her! The food was surprisingly great honestly!! Really fresh seafood and great flavor. Cocktails were strong and good. Vibes were great. Highly recommend!! Our favorites were the calamari and salmon. They even went out of their way to split the salmon dish for us as they knew we were sharing:) read more

See all

Lovely shiplap walls, costal interior, painted concrete floors, rattan hanging lamp shades and white wicker chairs create a casual ambiance. Food is not inexpensive and is really great. Service by Candice was wonderful. I loved our busser Jean. He brought us warm bread and when we thanked him he said " we deserved it". Such a lovely man. I know this is a resort so service is over the top but you really feel valued as as a customer. This is fancy dining family style. Lots of kids so if you want intimate this is not it. I enjoyed the casual ambiance because that's more my speed .I thought the fish was fresh and the sauce was delicious and the staff genuinely cared about my dining experience. And you can't ask for more than that. I appreciate the hard work and great service I witnessed last night in making sure each patron had a great dining experience. I would add they did have a special for 55.00 per person that had an appetizer, entree , wine and dessert and last night only choice was filet. We ate at 6 on a Friday so not sure if it would be more couples later on in the evening but it seemed to be mainly people staying at the resort as they asked for a room number when we paid and seemed surprised we were just dining there. We just like checking out places we have not been and we dine out often. Definitely something nice to check out for a nice staycation as the resort and restaurants are really lovely. Also if you like live music they did offer that as well. We really liked it. read more

See all

The Complimentary bread basket could have been better. The Tarpon Bay salad was too sweet and too many different flavors. The Burrata w/fruit and berries appetizer was very good. Enjoyed only that. The four of us were disappointed with our entrees. The Lemon Parmesan Salmon had not a lemon taste or a lemon anywhere on the plate. And waay too fishy tasting. Had only half. The bacon wrapped grouper was the better of the two entrees but dry not moist and half the bacon uncooked. Too much with the cream sauce. My two friends also not enthusiastic either. The brie and jam appetizer they was good. Not crazy about the 12 oz. Kurobuta pork chop entree or the Artichoke & Ricotta ravioli entree. The coffees weren't temperature hot but good tasting. I guess hotel food. Would like to stay there for two nights, but definitely have meals outside the hotel as we do live in Naples and great restaurants are within a few miles from the hotel in either direction. For $132 (excluding tip) I expected better. I read reviews on different outlets and cannot believe them anymore. The service and ambience were very nice, no complaints there. Our server Reggie L. was very professional and personable. read more

See all

Been going for years. Juan John musician is great. Food seriously took a down hill. Calamari's was soggy. Shrimp and chorizo was wet and limp. Short rib ravioli tasted dry and bland. Drinks and bartenders were horrendous. Wait 30 minutes to get a drink while SITTING AT THE BAR. Asked for a Tito's and a lime and got a lime drink. Asked to correct it and got the same thing. I'm not a picky person but this was really bad service. People next to me said the same thing. Bring back Drew! read more

As far as hotel restaurants go, this was great! We saw some bad reviews but decided to give it a try anyway way. If you take a closer look they mostly complain about ridiculous things. The food and service were both fantastic. I would def recommend and go back. Little pricey but not too bad. We had the ceviche sampler, rock shrimp, and ban mi smoked cheeks. Everything was super flavorful. My fav was the grouper smoked cheeks. Delicious! My only suggestion would be to put a warning on them bc they were pretty spicy. Thankfully I like spices but I could see how others may be a bit shocked. read more

If I had to be honest I'd say this is one of the best places ever! The waiter was the best and so kind and funny. Treated us like real customers. The special room we were in was absolutely beautiful. You can see the sunset from the windows and the inside is so nice! The food was delicious and I had crispy Brussel sprouts, lobster Mac and cheese and a quarter of king crab and an 18oz steak with some sides. We also saw an alligator in the little section of water outside! I love this place so much and I HIGHLY recommend it if you're visiting Hyatt regency coconut point Bonita springs!I also had steak and crab legs and dessert which was cheesecake and the vanilla homemade Ice cream tasted like heaven! The service was absolutely unbelievable and it was the best place ever!!! The waiters name Jason and had the best humor and personality ever! 100% visits this place if u are visiting here!!!!!!! read more

See all

We had the best experience at this restaurant! All the food was so incredible. I love the style and decor, very beachy! I wish we had asked to sit outside but I didn't think about it at the time. We started with the shrimp cocktail which had large delicious shrimp. I got the scallops over black mango rice (this was my favorite dish of my entire trip!) it was soooo good! The scallops were huge and perfectly cooked! My husband had the snapper which was also excellent. My oldest got the shrimp off the kids menu and I love that they offer something other than mac n cheese and pizza. It's nice to have a healthier option! The shrimp were giant!! We had the key lime pie for dessert and it was incredible! I highly recommend this restaurant. It is pricey but the food and service was amazing! read more

See all

Atmosphere,Staff, and Food were totally amazing and we're going back again tonight! The SNAPPER DIABLO is a blackened snapper fillet, with coconut rice, mango slaw, & the pineapple diablo sauce has a sweet and spicy kick but not overpowering. If you like great food , people & ambiance, this place is for you! read more

This place must have gone thru some recent changes because based on the reviews my expectations were not too high, luckily, I was pleasantly surprised ! Service was on point, ambiance was delightful and food was really good. We tried the lobster Mac and cheese and it was amazing and enough for two people. My boyfriend asked for the Parmesan crusted salmon and although the side risotto was a little bland the salmon itself was amazing . Overall we were satisfied and had a very nice date ! It is safe to say this is the best place to eat inside the Hyatt ! read more

Decent food, good drinks, pretty pricey. Could be a 4 with a better menu and a few more salads - only 2 on the menu. Heavy on the seafood if that's your thing. The scallops were very, very good, the lobster rubbery and overcooked, the blackened snapper quite good. For desserts we had a key lime pie which I expect will be intensely flavored and it just was more like lime cheesecake. a little better service and more consistency in the cooking would bring a 4. read more

Food was average/good Service was great. Main drawback, lots of young families with young children who were screaming, yelling. I've been there....had young children and took them to restaurants. But I walked outside with mine if they were screaming. Not fair to the many other tables of people trying to enjoy their meals. People around us had same opinion. That is...the people without the screamers. lol. Side note: it's not the fault of the restaurant. read more

Sunday brunch is what I have been hearing about so I stopped in to try it out. They have a buffet with a lot of seafood choices. Pretty much everything on the buffet line was some form of seafood. In addition to that you get your choice of an entrée and bottomless mimosas and champagne. Crab claws were the star of the buffet. Pre cracked and ready to suck out the meat, they were great. They also had mussels, oysters, smoked fish, ceviche, and a few other choices. I just stuck with the claws. If you don't like seafood this is not a good buffet for you. I got a crawfish benedict for my entrée. This was good but not amazing. It was missing that flavor that pops to make it top notch. I just kept drinking the champagne and went back for more claws. Next up dessert. They had a small dessert table. These were all good but nothing amazing. I tried pretty much everything. The macaroons were my favorite. Very light and good flavor. They had a few different kinds but they went fast. As soon as they put them out they were gone and then were not replaced very fast. read more

See all

This was a splurge gone wrong. The first hint of what was to come was the olive tapenade which was served with the bread. It's complimentary but something so simple missed the mark. The lobster bisque was a big disappointment. I've been lucky enough to have enjoyed some excellent lobster bisque over the years and this was one at the bottom of the list. The bowl was presented at the table with a chunk of lobster and the creamy soup was poured over it. If it hadn't been for the piece of lobster I would never have guessed it was a lobster bisque just from the taste! I thought all was not lost since the bacon wrapped grouper was coming next. Boy was I wrong. It looked nice but there were so many things wrong with this entree starting with a lack of basic seasoning on the fish itself. I enjoy cream sauces but not when they overwhelm something like fish. I really struggled to try to eat this bland fish. I added salt and pepper but there was no way to improve it. I gave up and decided it wasn't worth the risk to try a dessert. I'm thankful that it was just me and not a couple out for a romantic dinner or a special celebration. The restaurant staff was super nice though. read more

Tarpon Bay Restaurant - Lobster bisque - Seafood Near Me - Bonita, Florida

See all

We celebrated our Parents 32nd wedding anniversary here and everything was excellent! Clement was our server and he was wonderful in explaining the menu and suggesting items. It's slightly overpriced, even for a resort-style restaurant. However, the taste and quality of our dishes were good. Coffee had a slight stale/bitter taste to it as if it was coming to its expiration date or was sitting to long. Overall, I think we would come back again for another family celebration! read more

The food was overpriced, over spiced specifically the boa buns, the eggplant was watery and mush. The service was excellent and the ambience was a delight, great views from any seat. The idea of the food is on point but the execution is off. read more

This restaurant is great! I came here with family for a celebratory dinner and it was an awesome experience! Ambiance/setting: (5/5) This restaurant is one of my favorites when it comes to ambiance. It was relaxing, upscale, and perfect for any special occasion. Service: (5/5) We were served by Peggy who absolutely crushed it! Her pacing was perfect and she was one step ahead all night. Additionally, she was very kind and warm, which added to the experience. Apps: (5/5) We got a dozen and a half oysters (west coast) and they were amazing. The were the biggest oysters I've ever had and they were fresh. Cocktails: (3/5) I got a Gin and Tonic and a Captain Cocktail. Both of them were good, but they tasted a bit watered down. Entree: (5/5) I got the Alaskan King Crab and the 14oz. New York Strip. The steak was cooked to perfection and in the top 3 best steaks I've had (and I eat a lot of streak). It came with a side of mashed potatoes and asparagus. Both were good. The crab was good, but it was a smaller portion than I expected. Dessert: (5/5) We ordered the No Bake Cheesecake (Snickers Version) and it was heavenly! Overall: (5/5) Peggy turned a great experience into an amazing one. She also comped our dessert in honor of our celebration. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone and I hope to be back one day! read more

See all

It has been almost 8 years since I ate here, memories fade like the names of the restaurant but will never fade and what has yet to be topped in the last 8 years, is the best lobster mac & cheese I have EVER had. In fact it was so delicious that I ordered 3. The first one was shared, the next 2 were just for me. So many disappointing attempts since then. All I remembered was that in Bonita Springs. I then came across the name of the hotel and also my old receipt for Tarpon Bay. I'll be within a few hours of Bonita Springs come March, and I know that I will be making the drive to get this again after far too long of me being without it read more

Was staying at the Hyatt coconut for training so decided to try this restaurant! Great seafood and attentive service. However she was a little slow. Not sure if it's because we had a party of 12 but I had to ask for our water cups to be refilled. Anyways had to try their fresh made ceviche! They have 8 different ones. I tried the shrimp and grouper! Very good! For the main course I had the scallops with blackened kale! The kale was very salty so I didn't like it that much but I needed my greens! It's kind of expensive so I wouldn't go back but good food. read more

Tarpon Bay Restaurant - They come with 5 scallops but I traded some for the ahi tuna! - Seafood Near Me - Bonita, Florida