Great pizza. He not only makes great pizza but he is great guy to talk to. His cheese pizza and Alfredo are my favorite.

Was in town yesterday for another venue but just for curiosity I drove over to Teddy's... It was 1230 on a Wednesday. And sure enough the sign said open at 11 on Wednesday and not a person in sight. Lights off closed sign in the window. I don't know how this place stays in business. I'm done trying to go read more

Still going strong! Teddy's hasn't lost a step! Their pizza is NY Pizza all the way, been to too many pizza places that "Say" NY Style Pizza and have been disappointed, but not Teddy's. I don't mind the 30 minute drive, well worth it. Got my pizza fix, and topped it off with a Chicken parm sandwich. Awesome, just Awesome; from the Amoroso Roll to the tender chicken cutlet covered in their great sauce, not acidic like other places, topped with grated cheese and mozzarella. I love this place from the Owner to the Food, give it a try! It's great Fughettaboutit read more

Teddy's Brooklyn Style Pizza - Chicken Parm sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Virginia

I love the place but they are NEVER OPEN! If you are lucky enough to find them open, they have great steaks. But they are rarely there.

We drove out there to try Teddy's after reading great reviews via FB. My son loves. NY style pizza and we had just tried Andy's Pizza last week and thought we'd continue the hunt for good pizza. Well, despite the open sign on a Wednesday early afternoon and their website indicated it is open... we arrived just before 2pm. It was NOT open. We called again and again while standing outside looking in and not a single person was inside, just a TON of flies zooming around the insides of the window. Gross. Big disappointment. This was a special trip for mom/son lunch before he heads back to college. We had a nice lunch at Oyster Bar near by instead. The waitress there told us it is a normal occurrence with Teddy's as he is inconsistent. Oh my, I don't mind they chose to close whenever they choose since it is a mom/pop type place but maybe updating their website and leave a message on their phone would be helpful for their customers and not unreasonable to ask. Oh well.... Not sure we will drive the distance to try them again. read more

Teddy's Brooklyn Style Pizza - Doors are shut yet the website and their sign says open. - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Virginia

See all

An institution. Teddy's is as legit as it gets. Pepperoni, garlic, cooked well done is a damn near perfect pizza.

After hearing so many positive things and reading the reviews on social media, as well as seeing Teddy's making the top 10 list in the Northern VA area I was finally able to give this small pizza joint in historic Middleburg a try on a weekday for lunch. Teddy is clearly passionate about the pies he makes and it's evident in watching and tasting his food. He's got the typical Italian "pizza joint" menu including pies subs, and other Italian entrée items. We opted for a white pizza, a cheese only pizza, and a pepperoni pizza and all three were INCREDIBLE!!! Easily the best pizza we've had in the area. The sauce was outstanding! The cheese was incredible!! The crust was perfect!!! But the way it all came together, the perfect amount of cook on the pizza and the flavors were OUTSTANDING! We truly understand why he's been getting the amazing reviews and recognition he's gotten and it' well-deserved! If you're in the mood for amazing NY style pizza, this is the place! read more

See all

Really happy to have found this place! Moved about 7 months ago and had been looking for good pizza. Stumbled over Teddy's and stopped in. Not much seating so I took a couple slices to go, perfect crust and the perfect amount of grease. Loved it! read more

We got the cheese pizza. It was delicious. A large pizza was a great portion. The cheese and sauce were great. It was a true NY style. Take a bite and all the cheese comes off. We really enjoyed it. We also got the Philly cheesesteak super, also very good. A very large portion, and easily shareable. Great meat to topping ratio. Overall, a great spot in Middleburg. A few tables to sit and eat. But I think they do a lot of take out. read more

See all

If you don't like Teddy's pizza then pizza isn't for you. I've never been to a pizza place -- actually any restaurant for that matter -- that makes their food with more love than Teddy's. Not only did I get to try some of the best homemade pizza ever, the conversations I had with Teddy and his brother definitely made this an experience to remember. read more

See all

This is all I could ask for out of a small pizza shop. Origina recipe brooklyn owner fresh ingredients. The owner was so much fun to talk to and created such a fun little spot.definitely will be back read more

What is up my foodie peeps. I'm very excited to share with you my experience at a superbly amazing restaurant making some righteously and highly addicting pizza! Enter Teddy's Pizza and Subs located in Middleburg, Virginia. I was lucky enough to chance upon this on a Facebook group post, Northern Virgina Foodies, and the images were just mesmerizing. I had to visit here! As I entered the place, I am greeted with an amazing olfactory whiff of heavenly pizza smells among other yummy delectables. I'm also greeted by the owner, Teddy, as he banters with familiar customers and his staff. It was awesome ! I proceeded to order a slice of thin New York Brooklyn style cheese pizza and a small Sicilian pizza. OM-freakinzy-Goodness!!! The cheese slice was packed full of flavor! The tomato sauce is a perfect blend of savory, tangy, and a dash of sweetness. The cheese adds to the savory salty goodness. The bottom of the crust is perfectly crunchy and holds the pizza shape in all its glory. The Sicilian is absolute royalty! The slightly thicker crust absorbs the special tomato oregano sauce, making each bite a layer of happiness. The fresh cheese stretches with each pull as if reaching for your heart ! This was made with love! I absolutely recommend coming here to grab the goodness and treasure. I can't stress enough how delicious this place is paired with super friendly staff. You won't regret it! Until next time, stay safe and healthy. SUPER NOMZ!!! read more

See all

lifelong NYer here who can attest that Teddy's is indeed authentically NY pizza - as in pizza you'd buy in the bowels of Penn Station and accompanied by about the same levels of sanitation (low) and stress (high.) read more

Wow - The Northern Virginia Foodies page was right! This pizza is so very much like the fab NY pizza I have to travel up north to NYC to get. Light, airy with that great crispy crust that's the best. We ordered the meat lovers with extra Italian sausage and it was amazing. Seems Teddy is from Brooklyn and he knows his stuff. His wife, Susan, took my order over the phone and was so sweet. When I picked it up she gave me a roadie of a mozzarella stick just out of the oven as I told her I had to drive to Leesburg before we could dig into the pizza. It was soooo good. She's from Philadelphia and said next time we should try their cheesesteak. Game on Susan..... read more

Teddy's Brooklyn Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Virginia

Amazing NY style pizza from a family owned little shop right off the Main Street in middleburg. The pizza had a great crust and you can tell the dough was fresh. The cheesesteak was average as the bread got soggy by the time I got home to eat. Overall the customer service was great and the owner has a great sense of humor. read more

Teddy's Brooklyn Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Virginia

See all

Ammmmmmazing pizza. Best in the area by far, great service and prices. Definitely recommend

We are so incredibly fortunate to have a business like this within our tiny little community. I couldn't keep on two hands the number of New York and Brooklyn style pizza places I've seen in northern Virginia, but Teddys is the only one actually living up to that brand. There's two, maybe three guys that you will ALWAYS be dealing with here, and if charisma and charm were treated like toppings, they'd be able to charge a whole lot more. Doesn't matter who you are, they make it feel like you've been loyal customer for years on just your first visit. Anyway, about the actual pizza: Theres one thing that all these New York style pizza places get wrong, and that's the crust. In my humble opinion, a true New York pie shouldn't have the idea of doughiness anywhere near it. The slice should support itself, and the bottom should be crisp, but not that disgusting, powdery, bone dry crispness we see from boutique brick oven pizzas. I don't know how they do it, but every pie is truly a work of art (if you like good pizza) and they can get it to you, usually, pretty quick. The menu is simple, the kitchen and dining room are not any bigger than they need to be. The thing is, Teddy's could make the same amount of money making standard calibre, or even bad pizza, but they choose to do things the right way. That shows me that they care, and is going to make it difficult to choose anywhere else. read more

Closest to the real deal Long Island pizza I grew up eating in Virginia. Go for the food but stay to get your balls busted by Teddy, Anthony and Then Suzanne will be there to help you not get beat up too bad! Wonderful group of people really very nice to be around reminds me of home. Amazing hidden gem in Middleburg that most of you just won't understand but that's cool more for me! "Mums the word!" read more

Best NY Pizza in NOVA.....Great service and price. Cant go wrong with Teddy's and nice quaint location.

A dump. Epitome of a dirt bag operation, Angry dull boss, soup nazi service, below common pie, cheap ingredients, open 1 hour every other day. exists to fill hole in food options for small town.. read more

Ridiculously good pizza. Cheese slice - phenomenal. White pizza - unbelievably good. This is one of if not the top pizza spot in the DMV. read more

Teddy's Brooklyn Style Pizza - Outdoor sitting. - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Virginia

Didn't get a chance to try the food, the person who answered the phone I placed to make an order is very RUDE, will never try and/or recommend this business. read more

Good authentic new York style pizza. Gets pretty busy at lunch. Plenty of parking, not a lot of tables. read more

Teddy's Brooklyn Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Virginia

Heard a lot about this place, so had to try it. Well, let you tell it is worth the trip!!! The pizza was fresh, and awesome!! The service was great, Teddy the owner is fantastic!! The pizza shop reminds me of the ones your see on tv. Love it !!! Will come again !!! read more

I went on a motorcycle ride with a friend and ended up stopping at Teddy's Brooklyn Style Pizza because I had heard some great things, like the pizza is authentic NY pizza, and some not so good things- the hours are unpredictable. This was actually the second time I stopped there and the first time they were closed. We waited and nobody showed up...oh well, stuff happens. This time we found them open and as it turned out, I'm really happy they were. First off, if you read my reviews, you know I'm an Italian guy from NY and I pretty much have given up on pizza in VA because it just sucks. So I was anxious to see if Teddy's is the real deal. IT IS! One thing for sure is, Teddy and his brother are the real deal! I love these guys and Teddy's wife- great people who really care about what they're doing and the quality of the food they are putting out. To the people who are giving them one star because you showed up and they weren't open, how about actually calling and, here's a concept, ASK THEM what happened before bashing them online. Teddy and his family are from NY, and they immediately made me and my friend feel at home. I was immediately comfortable with my new friends, so I asked why they weren't open the last time we stopped. Teddy explained that he will not take shortcuts or put out food that isn't fresh and, due to COVID and supply chain issues, some of his fresh ingredients aren't showing up, so he can't open. He is at home when he gets a call telling him the truck isn't showing up so he doesn't go to work. Frankly, I'm not mad at that, sure it would be nice if he could remotely post a sign, but life is too short to get upset about this. Well, let's get to the pizza. We ordered a medium pizza, with the intention of eating two slices each and getting back on our bikes and heading home, where our wives would want to go to dinner shortly after. Well, the pizza came out, super fresh and hot- my half had sausage, my friend's had pepperoni, and we were both stuffing our faces so much we killed the whole pie in 10 minutes! Teddy wouldn't take our money until he got our opinion on the pizza and we were happy to pay the man his well earned money. Teddy is a throwback type of guy- he is passionate about his food and his business. I felt like I was standing in my hometown of NY when I was in his place, and even though Middleburg isn't exactly around the corner from me, I'm going to be a regular. I'm happy that I can finally eat pizza again! Thank you for your hospitality, Teddy- you are one of a kind. Ciao! read more

I came here after reading about it in Facebook groups and heard several people declaring it the best pizza in NoVa. It's good although the best...I'm not sure. It's well above average at minimum with very good house-made crust and not-too-sweet sauce. Interior is quite spartan. Worth it if you are in the area but probably NOT worth a special trip. read more

Such good pizza!! Everyone was so nice and everyone was friendly and welcoming! I loved the seats outside perfect for a nice day to have pizza. read more

Great pizza! Stromboli is fantastic too. Friendly staff, family atmosphere, quick service and reasonable prices.

This place is the bomb! The staff is friendly and they take the time to get to know their guests. The pizza was the best I've had in the area. The steak and cheese was delicious. No complaints other than I wish you were closer to my house, but it won't stop me from coming. Must try! read more

Great pizza and the best Cheesesteak in Northern Virginia. And I'm picky...rolls imported from Philly!

Place is great. Owners are great. If you posted and said the owner are "rough with words" you need to grow thicker skin. The pizza was great and the spaghetti was amazing. read more

Love love love this place. Dough is fantastic. Ingredients are fresh. Get the cheese or sausage.

Amazingly good Pizza and very nice owners. Recommend strongly, and more words to get to minimum.

Nowhere near the hype. If you're local, great. If not, don't make the drive. The pizza is fair. The 14" medium cheese arrived undercooked and soupy. However, the true colors of this place were revealed when I went up to pay for my meal. Paying with a credit card, I was rung up. I pointed out to the youngman behind the counter that the $16.95 that was appearing on the payment screen for a 14" medium cheese pizza was more than the $15.95 price that was on the menu board hanging above the counter. The owner then stepped in and I pointed out my concern. He said, "it's only a dollar more". I said, " Yes, but it's more than your advertised price." He then said some words to his employee, erased and re-entered the items. Again, the medium pizza was showing as $16.95 and I pointed that out. "Do you think I'm trying to rip you off?" The owner said. He then said it was showing as more because of the tax. I pointed out that tax is not added before the sub total. He didn't like that. I believe the information I was giving him was beyond his mental capacity to comprehend. I wanted to leave, so I was paying and he started walking away, mumbling and saying that he doesn't need this and something about customers giving him a hard time. I told him we didn't need to drive a 1/2 hour for this circus. He told me that my problem is that I'm rude. What?? Side note, my son told me that the customer who paid before me had raised concern about what he was being charged for his meatball sub and had words about that customer once he walked out of the shop. Never again. Check that your payment system is working properly or, yes, you are ripping your customers off. read more

I visited and brought friends since people said that it's the best pizza around. I know NY Pizza and it was not bad; however, the owner/cook may treat his regulars fine but he certainly was mouthy and unkind to our group which consisted of some very nice ladies. I was quite honestly horrified at the comments that were made towards our group. Please note that this is a local carryout in an old shack building on the backstreet of Middleburg. If you want to get Pizza from there, call in your order, pick it up and eat at home or your car. Hopefully, that will help you have minimal contact with the owner who has something to say about everything. I'll stick with Solo Pizza in Leesburg since they treat their customers with welcoming kindness and respect. read more

Best. Pizza. Period. High quality. Salad was also very fresh with homemade Italian dressing. Incredibly friendly family business.

Confirmed New Yorker here. This is the real deal for New York pizza. Of all places, it's in Middleburg! Glad to have them hear though. The folks in there are a funny bunch too! read more

The best pizza in Virginia. Period. Moved to Va from NJ last year and have been searching for good pizza around here. Needless to say, the search has ended now that we found Teddy's. read more

I'm not much of a yelper but I had to write about this pizza shop. I come from the New York City area and I know pizza. Teddy is from Brooklyn and he carried that pizza tradition all the way to Northern Virginia. I've lived in NoVA for 7 years and finally found pizza that matches what I had in New York. I drove almost an hour to get here and it was worth every minute in the car. If you want to experience New York Pizza or if you're from NYC and want to have authentic pizza come here! They'll even indulge in New York banter with you also. read more

Great food! Subs are amazing! This is a must visit if looking for fantastic pizza in Middleburg!