July 2024: Today we dined in to take advantage of the A/C, as ours is on the fritz. Our pizza was garlicky and delicious, although loaded down with too much cheese. (Fantastic if you like extra cheese, otherwise not so much.) Jesse was personable & lovely to chat with while we ordered and waited for our pizza. 4 stars! Feb. 2024: Today I ordered a thin crust mushroom pizza with red sauce and was very disappointed. The crust was a big letdown, not tasty at all. The red sauce tasted of too much tomato paste. Mushrooms were so scarce I could count only one or two slivers on each slice of the pizza. 2 stars. read more

It's a decent place - glad to have this option nearby. I'd give them an extra star if the sauce was just a little bit tastier.

This spot just opened up a few months ago and is still working out some details, yet is definitely worth using for a Friday Pizza Night pick up! Staff were friendly and helpful. It took about 20 minutes to get our food and we were there around 5 before the crowd began, yet the staff were attentive and apologetic. Our pizzas were delicious, soft pillowy crust, stretchy delicious cheese and quality toppings. Everything came in takeout boxes so this is more of a takeaway than eat at spot as of now, yet there are a few tables inside and a patio with tables and umbrellas outside as well. The place was clean and smelled deliciously like garlic bread. We will be back and next time will most likely get it to go. read more

See all

Pizza was really good: the crust, the sauce, and the toppings - they nailed all the basics. Most places have cracker crust or sourdough, but I have been looking for more traditional but really good pizza and this is now our go-to. Pizza came out FAST. Staff was attentive and fun. Keep up the great work! read more

REFUSING TO TAKE OUR ORDER ! First time going out with my wife in a few weeks as school started back and work life has been hectic. I recommended THAT PEETZA PLACE for dinner. We waited in line just one person ahead and picked up a menu. Walking up to the counter next after the person finished paying and Before I could even say hello the young person said "I WOULD NOT ORDER ANYTHING". Not exactly what we were expected as the greeting to such a well recommended place in our small kept secret of a town. I said I do not understand what you are saying. THE RESPONSE goes as follows (mind you the kitchen is spotless the floors clean, no pizza slices in the pizza warmer and no pizza's cooking) we just received a big Togo order so basically by the time we get to your pizza it will be past 8 pm which we close. 7:05pm was the exact time this conversation was occurring. I asked kindly for a business card with a response of you can take a menu. Overall we are disappointed with the outcome of refusing to take our order. read more

First time trying out a very good pizza. I got "the egg and I" which is got a lot of meat toppings to it. Definitely a great one if you were a carnivore service was quick and convenient not a lot of people in the restaurant but a lot of people getting takeout. read more

See all

Really nice and friendly local pizza joint at The Village in Port Ludlow. Good deal too. Best Pizza place within 20 miles guaranteed. read more

That Peetza Place - A Build You Own Pizza; Double Pepperoni, Sausage, Salami, Mushrooms and Onion. Crisped it up for a few minutes in the oven at home. - Pizza Near Me - Port Ludlow, Washington

See all

We'd been meaning to try this place for a while and finally made it there last week. The Pizza was quite good! Being from the East-coast/Mid-west pizza is different back there. While we love the wood-fired pizzas, and even some of the sourdough pizzas, of the Northwest sometimes we're craving just a good quality ooey-gooey cheesy pie. This place delivered. Dough was delicious, sauce was good, plenty of toppings. Not much else I can ask for. Oh! The garlic bread! Forgot to mention that. It was AMAZING! Got that instead of cheesy bread by accident and I did not regret it. Fresh garlic in just the right quantity. Even the kids gobbled it up. I'd give this a 5 star review for the food, and 4 stars for the ambience. It's not overly impressive, and sadly they no longer serve beer or hard ciders, etc. but they have board games and tables and we had a fun yummy meal there while playing connect 4. read more

Great new food option in Port Ludlow that makes a great pizza pie It was easy to pick-up, piping hot, where both white and vegetarian pizzas were great. read more

When this pizza place opened they had the most amazing and scrumptious wings, they were big and juicy. Now, you get the smallest wings they can find, they are tiny wings and they are dry. The pizza is still good. read more

Great pizza!! they definitely load it with more than enough cheese!! very hearty with ingredients that seem high quality. Wings also great, crispy on the outside, soft on the inside with a variety of flavors. Both workers were super friendly! The inside is modern minimalist while the outside is in what feels like an upscale strip mall. read more

That Peetza Place - wings and 12" Zaaaa - Pizza Near Me - Port Ludlow, Washington

See all

I stopped in and bought two slices to go for lunch. The pizza is very tasty. Generous toppings, good sauce, chewy crust. So happy to have them in the neighborhood! read more

First visit to this new business and had the chicken garlic and tomato thin crust pizza. It was excellent. Highly recommended.

Super friendly staff! Good pie and salads. Just opened this week and it was a busy Friday night when I arrived. Staff is still in training mode, but they are off to a good start. For now, it is take-out only. We have needed a decent pizza place here for a while and welcome them to the neighborhood. I wish them great success! read more

The quality of ingredients is amazing, the service is great and the location is convenient (if you live in port Ludlow). With that said, I am not an employee, but as a customer, I have a few notes. * I wish you guys had an actual website. * Please include a side of marinara dipping sauce for the cheesy bread and garlic bread * For the Swanson pizza, please add more barbecue sauce by default. The pizza is so good, but I taste more of all the other ingredients and not enough of the barbecue sauce. * Implement an online order option. Online ordering is so convenient for customers and will also help prevent any order mistakes. Love what you guys are doing! Keep up the great work! read more

Great pizza with ample toppings. Nice staff. Id give them 5 stars but they forgot the marinara for the bread sticks.

This is a brand new pizza place in Port Ludlow, and our first time there. So far, I understand they are take-out only. They have upgraded the interior from the previous owners, and the feel is much "lighter." The pizza was excellent. We asked for a thin-crust pizza, and it was, made perfectly and deliciously! Next time we will ask for double sausage, as we forgot to ask this time. We will definitely be trying them again. read more

I've traveled all over the world and the United States and I've eaten pizza on all those travels. Today, in Ludlow, WA I had a large "make your own pizza" with a thin crust and white sauce. I chose a variety of vegetables (red onions, black olives, dried tomatoes, mushrooms, garlic) and sausage. To my delight, I rate this pizza as one of the top contenders for "best pizza ever eaten"! Yes, the crust was flavorful and cooked perfectly crispy. Yes, the vegetables were fresh and delicious, Yes, the sausage was tasty, moist and generously provided. Yes, the cheese was just the right amount and delightful to taste! I can add that the wait staff provided immediate and friendly service and the ambience was inviting. The pizza was definitely built from scratch and cooked while we waited about 20 minutes for it to be served. The entire ordering process was smooth, professional and pleasant. I give this experience my highest rating and my strongest recommendation for anyone to stop by and try a pizza. I don't think you will be disappointed and yes, I will be back again and again! Ernie N. read more

This place is great. Good pizza. Solid specialty pizza menu with the option to build your own up to 6 toppings. Beer coming soon. Cool staff and convenient location. Good portions of tasty and delicious pizza. read more

12:15 Friday. No one there should have been a warning. By-The-Slice carousel had one half of a veggie pizza. We were hungry. Thought about 2 slices each but it looked questionable so we went for one. Neither of us could finish it. No one cared. Never saw the cashier after she delivered. Unless they have a long term lease they can't get out from under, I give them three months. It is so sad that this community cannot attract even an average business. There is some kind of curse on the restaurant businesses in this community. read more

Good pizzas with high quality toppings. We have tried several varieties and all have been very good.

Nice to have a pizza service is an underserved area (Port Ludlow) and I hope the owners hit a groove and keep improving their processes to keep costs under control so the prices can drop of pizza size grow. The pizza reminds me of pizza we have in Korea. We like the taste with some onion in the sauce. Our critique is the size of the pie is less than the previous pizza shop but prices are as high or higher. Also a loyalty program would likely help retain business. read more

Today was my third vist and its been amazing every time. We tried the Hawaiian with white sauce and this could be my most favorite pizza ever. The PNW with pesto sauce is also delicious! I'm excited to have such a great pizza place in Port Ludlow. read more

Great pizza (both thin crust and regular), service helpful, efficient, order ready as promised. We like this even better than the famous pizza in Port Townsend. So glad to have them close by. And I see they now have outdoor tables, umbrellas; looking forward to summer. read more

Food, service and ambiance - couldn't ask for better in this new Port Ludlow Pizza restaurant. Take out for now but looking forward to their expanded services. A wonderful addition to our community - thank you! read more

Have ordered pizza here a few times,always good. Order has been messed up a bit a couple of times, but it's a new place, and they are getting in figured out. I'm so glad to finally have a pizza place back around that is actually open.Delivery would be nice, so would Dine In. read more