First of all, how can you not go to a place that serves both New York and Chicago style pizza??? We ordered the spinach dip appetizer and out came this decadent cheesy bread (aka gooey cheese pizza) and rich spinach dip. It was massive, so we packed it up and shared it with friends. We had two, good sized side salads and then...the pizza! We chose Chicago (which takes 45 minutes to make) and it was AMAZING!!! The sauce‼ you will love the food but love the service even more. They were personal, attentive, and kind. Darren was a pleasure to visit with. It felt like I had lived here all my life. The decor is fun with nods to both NY and Chicago. Overall, this is a must visit place if you haven't been!!! read more

Ordered 2 pizzas paid $56 one was correct the specialty pizza ordered ended up being a pepperoni pizza like the first and was supposed to be the meats. Disappointed I didn't get what I paid for. Taste wise, was a decent pizza. Felt like the first time I had it was amazing and the 2nd time was sub par. read more

I had food here once before as a To Go meal. My friend and I had split the deep dish pizza and the beignets! I was in the area and feeling reminiscent of the Pizza Beignets and I decided to place a To Go Order through Yelp. Unfortunately Yelp didn't go through by the time I got there, so I opted to wait for the food and eat in instead of taking it to go. I also ordered Spaghetti and Meatballs from the lunch menu. The food was very satisfying and the lunch portion of the Spaghetti and Meatballs was perfect! I probably could have finished it all, but I was also enjoying the Pizza Beignets. The servers were super nice and directed me to choose any table and brought over water right away. They also anticipated my needs and brought my a To Go container without me asking. Service: Very good! Drinks: There's a full bar Outdoor Seating: No Parking: Parking lot outside read more

See all

I came for dinner with friends on a Sunday after our having adventures elsewhere. Service was prompt and friendly. I got the small pepperoni pizza. Refills were frequent. The food was good, reasonable prices. Kind of dimly lit, but pretty cool place. read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

See all

Authentic flavors and traditional dishes that warm your heart (and tummy). From their robust sauces and fresh ingredients to presentation and flavors, That's Amore Pizzeria has me wanting to come back for more asap! My family and I have been twice now. We've tried an array of entrees and pizzas, not to mention soup and appetizers. Everything is very delicious, so much so you don't want to leave leftovers. We were looking specifically for a Muffuletta Pizza and boy did theirs exceed every craving and expectation! If you're looking for traditional, comfort food that reminds you of a home cooked meal and more, you'll definitely want to try That's Amore Pizzeria! Their staff and services are superb! Immediately greeted and seated at an available table. The restaurant filled up quickly after we were seated, around 6pm. It's a cozy and not very loud environment. Freshly made pizzas require time to make, but it doesn't take forever! Depending on what you order is how long it will take. We've haven't waited more than 20 mins. They also have dessert, so make room for it. We haven't been able to partake but it sure looks and sounds amazing! Our most recent visit they brought a chocolate chip cookie with our check! Bonus points from me and my littlest. Thank you for such a wonderful and delectable experience! read more

See all

Delicious beyond words. The deep dish pizza tastes just like Lou Malnati's in Chicago. I've always had a great experience here. Excellent service and inviting atmosphere. Even during COVID, they were open but only delivered food to your vehicle, which was very nice. The pizza and chicken parmigiana were great and the food is always hot and fresh. We will definitely be returning here again. read more

See all

Everything is amazing, the food the atmosphere the people. Everything is always fresh and tastes great. All of the people that are there are super friendly and always so helpful also!!! read more

4 stars for chicken wings alone!!! Super meaty chicken wings, the buffalo and the butter herb is our go to, the sweet chili isn't bad just didn't hit like the others did. Spinach and artichoke dip w Cheese pizza sticks are delicious. The pizza lacks. First we tried the Chicago style. For me, too much cheese not enough of the other ingredients we had ordered and I'm not really a fan of there pizza sauce. I don't see us ever ordering it again. It's not terrible, it's just not my bag. We tried the regular hand tossed, it was good, I would order it again. We got pretty much a meat lovers add mushrooms. Lots of toppings not too much cheese. The wings tho!!! I know lots of ppl who love the Chicago style deep dish, it's just not something I enjoy. Overall this place is delicious and I can't wait to work my way around there menu. Those wings tho!!!! read more

We used to order thin crust pizza delivered and it was good. But I went there the other day with my daughter and her friends and ordered calzone with meatballs. I asked for less marinara sauce and they did add less. But they also added very little meatballs. Literally there was maybe 2 meatballs cut in pieces and spread over giant calzone. I have never seen that size calzone and I have to say, it wasn good at all! Dough was too thick and tasteless. Few small pieces of meatballs. Marinara had some bitter taste that I didn't appreciate and even large amount of melted cheese couldn't save this monstrous food. Sometimes less is more. Ambiance was good, people who worked were polite to the level of this establishment. Lady who worked the bar and brought my food was sweet and very personable. Other waitresses were...strange. Not sure if it is because they were overwhelmed by 5 kids we had with us, or something by else. Conclusion, if I have to go there again I will get NY pizza slice, which btw was the size of 3 normal pizza slices. But I don't think I will go there again. read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - Giant calzone. - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

Get the deep dish pizza! Absolutely delicious! Customer service was amazing! Very impressive staff who are so polite!

So so so good! Such a unique place food wise. We got the deep dish meat lovers, it was soooo good and so so filling! It does like 45 min to make so if you go in hangry get an appetizer. We got the caesar salad (3/5), cheese bread with spinach dip (2/5) and the chicken wings (5/5). The marinara sauce is good. Service was great! Good sweet tea. You will leave FULL! read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - Meat Lover's Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

See all

The Chicago Deep Dish Pizza is amazing. I have ordered this pizza from this establishment a number of times over the last couple years and they do a great job every time. If you are need for a pizza that will knock your socks off and also leave you satisfied; I recommend you get the Chicago Deep Dish meat lovers pizza from here. read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - 14" Chicago Style Meat Lover's Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

The service was really good here. The staff was friendly. We started with pizza beignets and the wings. The pizza beignets were my favorite. They were soooo good. They were pillowy soft, buttery, and cheesy on the outside and so flavorful on the inside. The wings were also a hit. They were my niece's favorite. She said she would come back everyday just for the wings lol. We got the deep dish pepperoni pizza. When you get a deep dish they tell you ahead of time that it's going to be like a 50 minute wait. The wait time flew by. It was worth the wait. The sauce is so good, the crust is so soft yet crunchy, and it's super cheesy. If you don't like a lot of cheese the deep dish pizza isn't for you but if you're a cheese lover then this might be your jam. read more

See all

Went in and sat down. Waited 15 minutes before we got anyone to our table... it was the busboy, he was polite and friendly. He wanted to help but couldn't take our order. Another 15 minutes passed I stood up and went to the bar to ask for a server. 10 minutes later we got a server. Our pizza was made wrong, the pizza was almost as good as Sam's club pizza... almost. The server was very apologetic and polite. Still, the experience bad. I will not be returning to this restaurant. I hope they get their act together. read more

I went here on a whim one day. I ordered a mushroom calzone. It was huge and I got excited because it looked so good. Then I took my first bite and it was just baked dough. It was so disappointing! There was hardly any filling and it was very bland. The service was nice and the atmosphere was nice. I will definitely try it again maybe a pizza next time! read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - Mushroom 1-Topping Calzone - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

This place brings me back to my roots in an old style vintage restaurant. A customer service here is beyond great I would say fantastic.. the food grade A and I mean it for awesome. I have nothing to say here I can tell they treat every customer with respect and a timely manner. I will highly recommend this place. This is my first time here and I will be coming here biweekly at a minimum. read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - I gotta tell you this is a great Chicago style pizza. Fantastic ingredients. You can tell that the sauce is homemade 100 out of 100. - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

Great service and good food. It's pretty spacious in there and great for large parties. The chicken also is really good. Enjoyed the calamari as well. read more

I had a taste for pizza so I decided to try this place out. A group of lovely older ladies were playing bingo, but I was able to find an empty table and the bingo did not bother me. I came here for the Chicago style pizza. I ordered a 7' pepperoni. My server informed me that I would have to wait 45 minutes for this so I decided to order some wings. The wings were fried to perfection; crispy, crispy. My server kept me informed on how many minutes I had until the pizza was ready. When my pizza came out, it was gooey and crunchy; one really only needs a slice of it to be full. They gave us two cookies to-go. Their service was ok. A taste of Chi-town in NOLA! read more

See all

Everything I ate at That's Amore was delicious! From the mozzarella sticks to the spinach dip to the Chicago style to the New York style, there was not one bite I did not enjoy! And the service was great! I will definitely be back to explore the menu! read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - Spinach and Artichoke Dip with Flatbread - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

See all

Goddamn Chicago Deep Dish is good. Only wish they did delivery but my fat ass needed to get up anyways for the monstrosity that is a large deep dish pizza. Fed me and my fiance for like 3 days. Absolutely mouthwatering. Never dined in but servers look nice and so does the ambiance. Your basic Italian vibes read more

Updating my previous review. We got a NY pizza to go and it was completely different from the first one we had at the restaurant. The crust was much thicker and it didn't taste the same or as good. Taking off some stars for consistency. The pizza has to be the same every time! read more

I love this place. Their pizza is so good! The Chicago style really is delicious but be prepared to order it ahead of time. Their appetizers and salads are tasty and they have a good ambiance inside if you decide to sit. Everyone working here was very nice. read more

Surprisingly good! Upped my standard for pizza and oysters now. We both will return soon.

We always get the cauliflower crust pizza and meatballs. 10 out of 10 every time. We crave it once a week.

Some of the best pizza we've had anywhere! We were in New Orleans for a long weekend and wanted something other than Cajun food. Chicago, deep dish style pizza was exactly what we needed! This neighborhood, Italian pizza joint served up delicious, thick, gooey, meaty, crispy perfection! read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - Chicago deep dish perfection! - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

See all

We ordered pizza from here a couple of years ago, and it was descent pizza. We recently ordered (june, 2024) two 16'' specialty pizzas, and OMG! they should not be called pizzas! They were horrible, the dough was so hard cardboard like. the toppings were good, but with such awful dough, the pizza is ruined. It was so sad, we threw away 90% of the pizza, and we never waste food like this! Not sure if it was change in ownership but you need to do better. You cannot sell a pizza with a dough that is like cardboard. The texture looked like the already made dough from the store. read more

We really went for the deep dish but didn't give ourselves enough time and decided to just get NY style. I'm not sure where in NY this is supposed to be based on but it wasn't what I expected. Crust wasn't very thin and was very crispy, not pliable like the NY style I expected. Flavor was fine but didn't blow my mind. Enjoyed the fried ravioli. Staff was good, maybe a little too eager to clear our plates but I expect they have a high turnover for tables. read more

See all

Not impressed with the pizza at all. NY thin only tasted like the toppings. Sauce had no flavor and crust seemed pre made, perhaps bought pre made. Had high hopes. Appetizers were Sysco brand. One guest had the thick pie and liked it. Service was really good though. Not sure if we will try again. read more

Absolutely delicious! The food was amazing, will definitely be returning! The deep dish was worth the wait!

I feel they have gone down hill. The fried ravioli was good, not delicious. My son's pizza was good. But mine was completely raw in the center. The waitress did offer to recook it, but I wasn't feeling it. Then they charge $4!!! Four Dollars for ONE scoop of ice cream. Really??? read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - Raw pizza. No thanks. - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

Amore Closed the one on the north shore, so had to make a must stop to eat here when across the pond. Didn't disappoint at all, the place was very busy for lunch, I had the lasagna, and left very satisfied. Food was quick and delicious. Getting the check took time though. Again will be back for sure read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - Served hot and pretty quick.. very filling. Lasagna. Loved it - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

We love That's Amore! For an appetizer, we always get the Fried Ravioli. Everyone loves it. It's fried cheese ravioli with a marinara sauce. This time we also got the Caesar Salad (large) and Pepperoni Pizza (10 inch). Both were very good. Additional things to note: 1. You can get Creole Creamery Ice Cream here for dessert 2. You can get Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza (rather than the thin crust we got) Go and support Darren and the entire team at That's Amore, you won't regret it! read more

See all

I just don't get the hype. Ordered a deep dish supreme pizza and it was just ok. The bottom of the crust was soggy and the dough was tough. I ended up scraping the toppings out and just eating it that way. Very disappointing. My SIL got a calzone which he said was good and my daughter and granddaughter each had a small pizza. They were ok but nothing to write home about. Honestly, the pan pizza at Dominoes is better. read more

Really good salad and excellent pizza. Everything I've had here has been tasty and well prepared. I look forward to going back. The servers are courteous, attentive and helpful. The ambulance is cozy and laid-back. read more

We had a good time here. Great beer deals served in fish bowls. Also a fish bowl of Dr Pepper for my son. Pizzas are well priced. Lots of cheese and toppings. Taste is good not great. Enjoyed the fried cheese ravioli. Nice people. Lots of locals. read more

My wife and I dined here tonight. Had Amy as our server who was a very nice lady and gave perfect service. It's a cozy type of place so you feel like you're in your neighborhood spot. We are from Michigan and know pizza. Being so close to Chicago we were craving the deep dish style. Man did they deliver. Tons of cheese, light bakery fresh dough and the perfect tomato sauce. I would run, not walk to get here if this is what you're craving. Prices are very fair and the menu has great selections. Thank y'all for a delicious meal. read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - Two meat with mushroom 7" Chicago Style Deep Dish Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

The last time I had deep dish pizza in Chicago was 2016. I've been craving it since then. About 2 years ago, my girlfriend had a work trip and spent a few days in Chicago. She was supposed to bring back three pieces of deep dish pizza for me but got drunk with her coworkers and decided to gobble up my pizza as a midnight snack...like Hungry Hungry Hippos. About 6 weeks ago, I stumbled upon this restaurant one day for lunch while renovating a house nearby. I noticed they had Chicago style deep dish pizza on the menu. I waited until I had an open Friday and took my girlfriend for date night. We knew that we had to wait 45 minutes for the pizza but in that span, the owner came up and talked to us for about 15 minutes. The owner couldn't have been friendlier. This Is the best Chicago style deep dish pizza in the New Orleans metro area. In comparison, Midway Pizza on Freret Street is basically "Pizza Hut pan pizza on steroids". If you're looking for Chicago style deep dish pizza, this is your spot. read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

I think this was the best pizza in Louisiana hands down. It's worth a long drive to go here. The service was amazing, the food, OH MAH GOD THE FOOD. Be ready to take a nap afterwards in pure bliss because the bread, will fill you up. We got a deep dish meat lovers, the garlic bread, AND when our server learned we drove from far away she even gave us some free cookies to go. *muah* 5/5 The restaurant itself is very clean. Which is rare for pizza places. I cannot wait to go back and I'm currently drooling thinking about my next visit. read more

Chicago style deep dish pizza one of the best styles of pizza I've ever hade. Full of flavor. Service was pretty good. Overall atmosphere was decent as well. read more

Amazing deep dish pizza, every time. Five stars! Online ordering was easy. My favorite is the deep dish chicken Alfredo, which I think is their best. read more

That's Amore Pizzeria - 14" Chicago Style Deep Dish Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Metairie, Louisiana

See all