I'm not sure if people in this town have ever eaten in a good restaurant, because all the positive reviews had me thinking this was a hidden gem. I was even more excited when I saw the old mill and serene pond with swimming ducks. Wow. What view. But then the food came. The water tasted like chlorine. The sodas were flat. The caesar salad was wet cheese with croutons. The pasta was bland. The steak tips were cooked to shoe leather. The calamari was doughy and gross. People are actually eating this stuff and raving about it? I'm glad to be back in Boston. read more

Left hungry on mothers day, so disappointed! The grounds are beautiful but unfortunately had the worst meal I can remember today. It was inedible. Didn't see the waiter again so I couldn't order something different. Then he had the nerve to not take the uneated food off the bill. Not 1 person out of 4 at my table liked their food but i was the only one who literally couldn't eat it, it was that bad. We'll be back to feed the ducks, not to eat! read more

Truthfully, we came for the view and the unique dining experience and we weren't disappointed! The view is great- beautiful flowing water and trees, with covered bridges, the Old Mill and plenty of ducks and geese! Tip: come in the spring to see a lot of ducklings swimming around. Service was good, but they definitely needed more servers and the dining room was loud! The food was decent. My husband's steak was over cooked and my chicken was a little dry but not terrible. The peacan rolls and bread with corn fritters (and maple syrup) were the main event. They're free and come with your meal. A very New England experience! read more

See all

Having been here numerous times, I can only say one thing. Feels like home, tastes like home. The food is as if I make it myself and the service is always very friendly. Price is always reasonable and the pecan rolls are a wonderful takeaway for breakfast the next morning. Definitely recommend The Old Mill to anyone who prefers a more cozy environment. read more

This is our local "go to". Always have a good experience there. I really like the Old Mill burger. And you always get their famous fritters and pecan rolls. read more

Beautiful place with big portions I come here every time I go to the water slides, only a few minute drive!! read more

We attended a baby shower for a family member here and the event was outstanding! This restaurant has such charm to it. They are clearly working on ups dating some more of the function rooms, which will be great for their already booming business! The staff was friendly from start to finish and so helpful to our family who was hosting the event. They kept on top of theests who needed coffee refills and were very quick to replace foods at the buffet. The room we had was a perfect size for our parrot, fitting about 6-7 round tables and a buffet. We loved the food as well and hope to come back for dinner in the future. There was salad, hush puppies (friend pancakes), scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, chicken Alfredo, homemade cinnamon buns and delicious juices and mimosas. We had a great time and hope to go back in the future on our own! read more

I usually only go to the pub downstairs. It's a great place to relax and enjoy the view and fireplace. Jared makes the experience even better as do the other bartenders ans waitstaff. I've gone here for Thanksgiving before as well and was very pleased. The food is great! read more

This place has it all: The decor is rustic - like an old mill (go figure) The setting is on a pretty duck pond There are lots of windows looking out The servers are very solicitous and helpful They overload you with good food The warm pecan rolls (that come instead of bread to start) are fantastic!!!! - we took home a dozen Our vegetables were NOT overdone and NOT pre-salted !!! (Yay!) My spouses sirloin was tasty and cooked correctly My chicken breast was moist and (again) NOT salted ... it had it OWN flavor and I could add salt The desserts were great - I had Indian pudding, which does not appear on many menus The place is a wonderful hodge-podge of little and big rooms all at odd angles with warped floors. It is just as it should be!!! It's fun to get lost in ... and then happen upon a gift shop! We took our menus over to sit in front of the fire and warm up while we perused the menu ... Yup - this place does what it advertises AND does it well read more

The 1761 Old Mill - Stuffed chicken breast with broccoli - American Near Me - Westminster, Massachusetts

HORRIBLE, HORRIBLE, HORRIBLE dining experience! Service was way beyond slow: sat for thirty minutes before addressed and recognized (in a reputable establishment the hostess [of which there were apparently two this evening in the "Old Mill"] would step up and help out. Not to be; Hostess seemed above such mundane tasks. The wait might not have been so egregious if we were able to have a civil conversation but the din was so loud in the 'barn-of-a-room' one had to yell across the little tables just to be heard, as it seemed the rest of the herd were doing. Hence the elevated noise level. When asked to have our table changed to another more quiet room our "hostess" while picking around her nose, states: "I have nothing." Looking around I can't help but notice empty tables in other smaller quieter areas. Again she exclaims: "I have nothing!" We should have left then but decided to stay the 'course' for the review. Drinks? The martini with a twist looked good but the 'twist' was: little to NO GIN! The gin must have evaporated during our long suspenseful waiting. Ah ha. The Chardonnay was bitter, however that could just be me projecting at this point. The food is nothing to write home about, so I'll stop right here. To be fair, our waitress, Danielle, was running her 'mass' off and must have dropped the 'm' along the way somewhere. She was actually incredible to watch. She had a party of at least 16, another table of 4, who were seated just before us (and waited just as long) and our table of 3, and WHO KNOWS how many other tables she had in other areas. I'll tell you who knows (or should know): MANAGEMENT! This, in our opinion, is where the breakdown lies: SQUARELY with POOR MANAGEMENT. It is not wise to run solely on past reputations in the eatery business. And with Yelpers like us out there it is only a matter of a little time before word gets around. NEVER WILL WE RETURN TO THIS "old mill!" read more

The 1761 Old Mill - Nothing to write home about! - American Near Me - Westminster, Massachusetts

It's nice to see that the Old Mill came up with a much smaller, more manageable menu. It's too bad they're still sending it out at room temp! read more

The food here is really poor, but the location is really cool. It's a fun spot to take kids as the river and waterfall are super fun and ducks are there to feed. But the food is definitely not good. So just be ready for not a great meal. read more

Grounds are pretty. We arrived at 3pm. Hostess (tall young gal) barely looked at us asked "do you have reservations"? We didn't. She seated us. I asked for a window seat and she said "we save those for people with reservations". The place was empty!! I didn't bother to explain today is our 28th wedding anniversary. She wouldn't have cared. Heard her complaining about someone who called earlier too. Our waitress was much more courteous thankfully. Now about the food- The roll basket was superb. Hot corn fritters were tasty. I ordered haddock casserole and it was awful, not hot and mushy and watery. Clearly frozen and reheated. My husband ordered a ham and cheese panini it was average at best. Prices are good and the grounds are beautiful. You need someone better than that hostess making your first impression. We won't be back because of the food and those seats I wanted remained empty. read more

This place went from a 5 star to being just awful! Such a shame to see a once great place fall apart. The food, service and waitstaff were horrible. read more

Good corn fritters, mundane service, very bad meal. Ordered prime rib, 30 minutes after ordering the waitress returns with menus in hands and said they're now all out of Prime Rib (ok whatever, stuff happens). My wife, my dementia ridden grandmother, and I all order a different steak. It comes out cold and very much on the rare side. Seems as though they tried to rush cook it. Waitress doesn't return to our table to check on us for another 20 minutes so at this point we just want out. When we get to the car, my grandmother says to me "George (that is not my name) that was one of the worst meal experiences I can remember in a long time". I have to agree Grandma. 2 stars for the fritters and the cozy rustic setting. Get a better kitchen staff. read more

The atmosphere was absolutely stunning. However, the food was atrocious. The scallops were definitely not real and seemed to be imitation and the shrimp was frozen in the shrimp and scallop Alfredo. The Alfredo sauce was from a jar with no flavor. The broccoli was frozen and frozen tenders for the chicken Broccoli Alfredo. Irish nachos were alright even though they came out cold and ZERO sour cream was given despite asking for it. Waitress was pleasant and very apologetic for the disgusting food and seemed very overwhelmed. $80 for food that I would never suggest to anyone. The duck pond was worth viewing (best part of the whole thing). read more

Waited 40 minutes and watched several tables get their drinks and orders after us. Not one waitress said hello and the hostess could care less we walked out after we told her why. Aweful! Will never even try to go back. read more

We ordered take out bc we have twin toddlers and didn't want to disrupt other diners. We spent around 75$ including tip. I should of checked everything when I picked it up. I got a baked potato instead of mashed. The surf n turf was incredibly under seasoned. It was cooked correctly (rare). The scallops had a chunk of shell in it but taste was good. They also forgot two orders of the corn fritters and pecan rolls that came with the entrees. I've never review a restaurant on here but I felt compelled since we are new to Westminster and really wanted to like this place. All my patients talk highly of the unique restaurant with the ducks/geese. We will try them again sometime but not anytime soon. And I did double check the receipt to make sure the order was phoned in correctly. Hopefully this was just an off night. read more

Love this spot. The mill with its classic design makes it a unique and beautiful dining location, for date night or family meal, great spot. The menu is very reasonably priced for the quantity of the meal. The staff has always been friendly. Favorite date night restaurant in the West Fitchburg / Westminster area. read more

Wonderful old school restaurant. We have gone here many many times as we live about 5 minutes down the road. The staff has always been amazing and attentive. The food has been top notch at every visit. The atmosphere is amazing. I can't think of a bad thing to say about this place. read more

Great food. Great drinks. Great service. The setting is stunning and very picturesque. They have a gift shop that is moderately priced and full of little knickknacks and memorabilia. The Cracker Barrel lounge is full of colorful characters and excellent drinks! Try the old mill's famous fritters and homemade pecan rolls. For a main course the old mill sizzler is an excellent choice. Enjoy it with a side salad and their homemade buttermilk ranch dressing. As I hear the sweet song of the sizzler passing by me I always become full of regret for choosing another dish but never let down when mine arrives. The surf and turf, wild mushrooms ravioli, scallops and filet mignon are also favorites. Thanks for the great experience! read more

A river, beautiful ducks, and a picturesque restaurant. Definitely worth visiting, but not for the food. The only thing good to eat are their rolls, which usually come free with your meal. I'm not a picky eater, but I've been here 4 times and ordered something different each time, yet, I've never enjoyed the meal. read more

We came to the Old Mill for an early dinner for my mom's birthday. It's absolutely beautiful and we were all blown away by the food!! So much so, I forgot to take any photos of it! If the review was based on atmosphere and food alone, it would be a 5++++++++. We had 8 people in our party and we each ordered something different ranging from steak, chicken parm, haddock, burgers, etc. EVERYONE loved their meal and the pecan rolls and corn fritters are excellent. The only reason for the 4 instead of 5 star rating was due to the service. Our waitress was fine, but overall service was not great. We had a reservation and the resturant was not busy at all. We arrived 20 mins early, 5 waitresses were sitting around talking and did not acknowledge us for a couple mins. The hostess was not friendly, said we would have to wait a few minutes and then they continued to talk keeping us waiting the full 20 minutes and then sat us in a room where there was only one other table occupied. When we left, the resturant was still slow and the waitresses were not only all standing at the hostess booth talking but giving eachother back massages and did not say anything as we were leaving either. When it's slow I absolutely think it's important to have fun, talk and joke... I value customer service in retail and in the food industry and think it's imperative for a successful business so it was just somewhat disappointed. read more

The 1761 Old Mill - Outside area of Old Mill - American Near Me - Westminster, Massachusetts

This restaurant in a historic mill building is really cool. There's a duck pond and covered bridges as you enter. The food is not great, but the service was good, and the complimentary pecan rolls and hush puppies are delicious. Next time I come here I will likely stick to drinks and appetizers which seemed fine. My kids loved feeding the ducks and geese pecan rolls. Bottom line is that I would come back but I would order different food. read more

We go for the bread basket. The food is so-so. But THAT BREAD BASKET! it makes me hungry just thinking about it. We have been multiple times since moving to the area. The restaurant itself has a wonderful ambiance outside. Think Duck pond, cascading water falling from a pond under rustic wooden bridges, ducks, geese, and swans resting in the waters of the pond, and the pond surrounded by a serine wooded setting. It's beautiful. Upon entering you are treated to an old fashioned stone faced fireplace with rocking chairs surrounding it, historic bare beams and planked flooring. You feel transported to the past. It truly is a treat. However, once being led to a table it quickly turns cramped and tired. The different dining areas all have an outdated feel that is trying to feel antique. Tables and chairs are cramped together and look like they haven't been updated since 1980. There is a huge difference between antique and just old. These are seriously just old. The menu is large enough that everyone will find something they want to try. We tried the prime rib, which was delicious once you cut away the ample gristle. However, we also tried a chicken dish that we had to purchase sides separately for. The chicken ended up being more expensive than the steak. We also ordered a seafood casserole which came floating in water with the sauce thrown on top. It looked like throw up in a dish. Very unappetizing. Food was presented in cloches that resembled hospital food covers, that gave us a good giggle. Service was okay. We were there on a busy night and it seemed that there could have been at least 2 more servers on the floor. Glasses went empty for long periods of time and it took a very long time to receive food. Food came out hot, but not all at once. We were a party of 4 and 2 of us received food while 2 others had to wait another 7 minutes for their meals. This made it awkward as social niceties would say to wait to eat until all the food was there. Once the missing dishes arrived, the original food was cold. If you choose to give the Mill a try, reservations are recommended. They also have a Sunday brunch that we might give a try in the future. read more

The service, food, and price was all fantastic. My family and I stopped in while staying at the Great Wolf Lodge since it was a only 5 minute drive, every meal they start you with their homemade pecan rolls and corn fritters. The portions were all big and we were able to bring home half our meal which worked perfect. Any time we're in the area we will be sure to stop in for a meal read more

See all

Wedding reception at the 1761 Old Mill, an early test "For Better or For Worse"... It's challenging times for restaurants and diners alike. Space is limited and revenues are down. Some restaurants are pulling out all the stops for their clientele, others have decided to go the other way. My visit to the 1761 Old Mill in Westminster this past weekend was, unfortunately, on the "we just don't give a (fill in your favorite word)" The worst part of the whole experience is that it was a wedding reception. With all the new rules, attendance was limited to 50, and those 50 guests were separated into two outside dining tents. Not necessarily a bad thing unless you are wearing high heels and dressed to the nines. In that event, it is bark mulch hell. But happy celebrants can get over that kind of thing so let us divide this review into 2 parts food and service. Starting with service. C- The restaurant was not ready for the guests. We were early by almost 30 minutes so some of that was excusable. What was not was the curt and rude reception by the "hostess" team whose primary job seemed to be to tell everyone in the line waiting to see them that they were sold out until much later that evening. Being a reception guest, I was told to gather people and wait outside and come back later. When we did just that some guests were shown through the restaurant to the upper area where the tents were set up. Others, including my party, we're told to just walk in that direction (outside and uphill) until "you can't miss it" Finally we can sit down for some cocktails and appetizers, that is if you can corner the ONE server assigned to the entire event that delivered drinks. She delivered to her credit, a heroic level of service, but one person for a party of fifty??? The food was served sporadically. The best word I can use to describe the staff was confused. I would be really surprised if they were dedicated to the function and not just pulled from their sections in the restaurant. Let's talk about food. Presentation A, quality C. The typical wedding cocktail hors d'oeuvres. In true Covid style, a selection was placed on each table rather than passed by serving staff. Nice approach. The fruit plate was ok, it is hard to mess up grapes and melons. There was a selection of cheeses on another plate, and hot hors d'oeuvres on a third. The first problem is that not all the tables received all the plates. As the waitstaff brought them in they cast about looking for an empty spot to drop their load, again confused. The second issue was the taste. The hot appetizers were indeed hot but overcooked beyond belief. Given the level of dryness, I expect they spent an extended amount of time under a heating lamp. The "teriyaki" (I had to ask) steak tips had a metallic liver-like flavor that was noticed by several guests. At first, I thought it was me so I asked around. The bacon-wrapped scallops had just started degrading into the "jerky" stage. The stuffed mushrooms were uninspired but tasted like a button mushroom stuffed with instant stuffing. The main courses were not much better. The portions were generous, and the food came out reasonably warm, but the salmon wrapped in filo dough was overcooked and dry. The filet mignon was medium well leaning towards well and the accompanying shrimp was as dried out as the salmon. The stuffed chicken seemed to be the shining star in the culinary darkness. Dessert: A for effort F for execution. Dessert was a 50% good 50% horror show. The house-made apple crisp was a pleasant surprise, piping hot and tasty. The wedding cake was also a surprise, attested to by the look of horror on the bride's face when she saw it. The Bride and Groom bought into a "package" sold by the restaurant which included a wedding cake provided by the Old Mills "partner" The Dutch Kitchen in Fitchburg Massachusetts. The cake was two tiers of navy-blue rounds with a cheap bride and groom wedding topper. That is it. No decoration, no flowers, no pipping, no nothing. Soon the cake was whisked away and returned decorated with fresh flowers. Someone was trying to think quickly. So, you may ask, did it taste good? It tasted ten times better than it looked and got a "not bad" from my Le Cordon Bleu-trained pastry chef daughter who happened to be sitting at my table. In summary, if you want to have dinner at a place where you can sit by a millpond and listen to the ducks and geese, or watch the beautiful ice formations of the pond's waterfall, and you don't; have super high expectations for the food, the Old Mill is your spot. I have hosted several business dinners there with a high success rate. My wife and I also enjoy having a drink and a light dinner in the Pub where the atmosphere is king, and the menu is low risk. On the other hand, if you are looking for a place to celebrate your once in a lifetime wedding, look someplace else. read more

The food was so good, and the service was great. I had the Maryland Crab Ravioli and the clam chowder. I'd highly recommend this place!

This is a very scenic restaurant on the lake. The food is good. Not outstanding, but delicious and generous portions. The pecan rolls and the corn fritters are a nice complimentary touch. The wine list is not long, but good selections and fair pricing. read more

We loved the setting in the history of the restaurant. The food was pretty good I would give it four stars but it could be a little better. Service was excellent our waitress was very nice and attentive. We live far but will come back!! read more

See all

We arrived at 4:45 PM for dinner. The white couple in front of us checked in without a reservation and were told they'd have a 5-10 minute wait. The white couple after us were told the same. My husband and I are a mixed race couple and we were told we would have a 3 hour wait. We left. The woman at the front desk was very rude. read more

Good, classic comfort food in a terrific, rustic setting. Quirky gift shop. All the elements for a great meal and a charming, old-school Colonial atmosphere. Easily a hidden gem in central Mass. read more

Sadly the Old Mill is not what it used to be. Today's lunch started with a nice wine $24.00 btl,but then came the under cooked pecan rolls and over cooked hush puppy type item. My wife had a "yummy" chicken vegetable pie with burnt crust edges ( I guess they haven't heard of using foil to protect the edges). I ordered chicken with broccoli and alfredo sauce. The first order came thru with a burnt ,dry chicken breast that should never been allowed out of the kitchen. The replacement WAS good but the sauce lacked the signature alfredo taste.( not awful,but not flavorful). P.S. our waitress was VERY good and that helped keep the review at three stars. read more

This is a unique spot, great for diner. The complementary pecan rolls are very good and a nice pre dinner treat. I had the scallops which were large and very well cooked with a perfect texture and flavor. This place is very large with sectioned off in rooms that creates a smaller ambiance. Waitress was good and attentive. I would recommend checking this place out for dinner. read more

See all

This place has a soft spot for me, because I had my first job there (as a laundry person, i was only 14), AND it is the token place where any huge family dinners are held, after Baptisms, Weddings, Mothers Day, etc. Everything is so old an incredibly authentic, I love it. The man and lady (I forget their names now) that run the place do a great job at keeping everything together. They are extremely nice and supportive to their staff and they run a very admirable kitchen, I might say... aka people actually wear gloves and make food because they love it not because it's their job! But to cut to the chase, the food is really really good. If it's easter or some occassion, you'll get a nice big basket of unlimited corn fritters and maple syrup with are SO SO GOOD. They're also famous for they sticky buns, which I don't love as much as the corn fritters, but they sure are tasty. They also have a really good brunch on Sundays I think that's big and very good. Don't forget to bring your extra rolls when you leave to feed the ducks and geese! read more

See all

We were visiting the near by Great Wolf Lodge and wanted a better quality restaurant experience than what was offered at the lodge. We were short on time and needed a quick lunch so we could get back to the lodge by 1pm to start swimming. The 1761 Old Mll is definitely a great place to bring the family for lunch. Old timey feel with a better than expected menu. My wife and I both had wraps (buffalo chicken and the lunch wrap special) which were great. My oldest had a cheeseburger that was amazing. Fresh made bun, quality meat and all the sides you need. My youngest had a hot dog which she enjoyed. The fresh made cinnamon rolls, buns and corn fritters were a nice treat. Was not expecting them. The servers were quick and courteous. After our meal we were able to feed the ducks with day old bread. If you are need of a good local place while in town this is the place. read more

The 1761 Old Mill - Girls in front of the fire in the main entry way. - American Near Me - Westminster, Massachusetts

See all

Beautiful location! Be sure to feed the ducks with the leftover bread they have available for you to feed them with. I'm not a local and we ate here while visiting relatives that live in the area. We were not disappointed. Yes, the service is a bit on the slow side, but the food definately makes up for it. I highly recommend the "Famous Old Mill Sizzler" All I can say, is that I've never had a thick sliced prime rib slice served up this way! It wasn't overly dry or overcooked as I would expect it. Still tender and full of the teriyaki flavor as it sizzles in front of your face. I can still smell the smoke in my nostrils. HEAVEN! I found it rather amusing that my mother ordered the Roast Country Duck after just feeding the ducks in front of the Mill. The duck was great....tender and juicy! Pecan rolls and corn fritters! Cannot afford not to mention them. Best pecan rolls I've ever eaten! They didn't last that long with our table of 12 guests. Warm, sticky, melt in your mouth goodness! Yes, the decor is a bit old and the mens bathroom looked as it if it wasn't remodeled since 1920. That's ok. It makes this place vintage! Good food....I would fly from CA to MA to eat here again. read more

The 1761 Old Mill - The Famous Old Mill Sizzler - American Near Me - Westminster, Massachusetts

I must say, their breakfast food menu is delicious! I love the hush puppies and crepes! The food always tastes amazing and I frequently recommend the old mill to others! read more

Come for the atmosphere, stay for the corn fritters!! My mom was visiting from out of town and we were looking for a place close by (I live in Ashburnham) that wasn't too fancy and that had decent reviews. We made a reservation, which turned out to be key, and waited about 10 minutes before we were seated because they were running a bit behind. Once we were seated, we ordered our drinks and food and everything was great! The corn fritters were AMAZING; you must use the syrup they give you!! We'd go back, for sure, maybe earlier in the day so we could really enjoy the pond/waterfall ambience. read more

This venue is lovely as you approach the front door. There are two covered bridges to walk through, a babbling brook, and ducks/geese to greet you. On a wintery, snowy day/night, it is a perfect setting for a romance and a wedding. We held both our wedding ceremony and dinner here. It was an intimate event with just family. Priscilla was able to give us the Garden room after a cancellation. This is a spectacular room with a view of the grounds (with the snow, I swear Bambi could have come walking thru any moment and completed the ambiance) and a fireplace going. The original room we had booked didn't have a fireplace and I don't recall mentioning wanting one but, oh how I really did want to get married in front of a fireplace. To have her make it happen was magical. The room was decorated nicely with just the right touches of greenery and lights for the Christmas season. The ceremony and dinner were perfect in this room. Chris was our server for the event and he performed his function with grace and ease. The dinners were all very good. The only reason this is a 4 star vs. a 5 star rating is the quality of the dinners here. After eating here a couple times, the food is good, just not quite stellar enough for 5 stars. read more