I really wanted to like this place, but unfortunately, the service was incredibly frustrating. I ordered a BLT, and the woman taking my order specifically asked if I wanted mayo. I said yes, but when the sandwich arrived, it was dry. When I pointed this out to the gentleman in the back, he snapped, 'Well, you didn't order mayo, so I didn't put it.' I then went to the woman at the front to clarify, and she just pointed at some packets and said, 'We have mayo right there. I didn't take your order, so...' Honestly, the whole experience was super embarrassing for the establishment. It's one thing to miss a condiment, but it's another to have the entire staff treat a simple request like it's a personal confrontation. If I wanted to assemble my own sandwich with room-temperature packets while being talked down to, I would've stayed home. I won't be back. read more

First time trying this bagel shop and we were pleasantly pleased. Our Bagel Thumann's Roasted Turkey and Provolone LT was delicious. Bagel was fresh and tasty. Service 5 stars and the restaurant I side was modern and clean. read more

The Bagel Club - Delis Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

First time trying this bagel place. It was ok, nothing special. Place could use some updating to make it more inviting.

Enjoyed the bagels, super fresh! Great fresh coffee and the service was fast and friendly. Glad to hit this place as I passed by... if I lived here still, I would go here often. read more

See all

The bagel club is my go to spot! The bagels are really fresh and delicious - and they're a nice NYC texture The seating area is also nice with places to sit and enjoy a cup of coffee along with these fresh bagels. Overall this is a solid bagel spot - really delicious! read more

My wife and I recently moved into the area. As part of our new homeowner welcome package, we received a coupon for a free half dozen bagels and a small tub of cream cheese. We had tried the Manhattan Bagel that's closer to our house and was not that impressed. We figured we would try Bagel Club even though it's 15 minutes from our house. We got plain, egg, everything and poppyseed. They were all very good, good crust on the outside, soft on the inside. Whenever we're in the mood for bagels, we always come here now Ava pick up a dozen. They'll usually last a few days, especially with a quick nuke in the microwave to soften them up. read more

my absolute favorite bagel place for at least 20 years & i'm 26 lol! my review is strictly for bagels with butter / cream cheese etc. I always get a bagel with butter bc they've have the best bagel butter. I don't really get anything else bc it's so good haha bagels are always the same size, plump and round. i'm sitting outside eating my bagel thinking they should have more than one location & then i was like lemme hit them with a review after 20 years haha! coffee is great too! & everything is well priced. read more

the bagels are excellent and price is fair. My only reason i am rating this a 3 is because of the help / cashier, a tall young gentleman who is not very friendly. . read more

Partial egg sandwich, that was supposed to be 2 eggs & cheese. Received a bread sandwich with little egg & little cheese. $7.80 for this. Never again. read more

The Bagel Club - Egg sandwich with extra egg. Can't find 1st egg, let alone 2nd egg. Bread with partial egg & partial cheese. $7.80 for this. Never again! - Delis Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

The holy grail of Flemington bagels. Will forever be my favorite bagel shop. Marble bagel with veggie cc is a must. Honestly everything is great and the staff is friendly and fast. read more

See all

Tried couple other places in town . Although other places are good this place is consistent and best for me to get great pork roll egg and cheese on marble rye in Flemington . read more

A friend recommended this place and I have to say it was a very solid NJ bagel. Came on a Saturday morning and this place was hoppin, so always a good sign. Very fast, good service. Plenty of employees working and the bagels were stocked! We got everything, French toast, and jalapeño. My husband really enjoyed the kick of the jalapeño and my kids were thrilled with French toast. You know an everything bagel is a good one when every single inch of it is covered in seasoning. The bagels are not only good, they are huge! We will be back! read more

The Bagel Club - Delis Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Updating my previous review to 5 stars after having tried a few more of their bagels and cream cheeses. Their marble bagel is one of the best bagels I've ever had! I also loved the seasonal pumpkin bagel and pumpkin cream cheese that was available seasonally. read more

See all

These bagels are more like bread . The different flavors all taste alike . It's like they are filled with air . Way too much interior and the exterior doesn't have a crack . Ive tasted better grocery store bagels than these . read more

Food fast and really good and the people are super nice!! It's a decent size with inside and outside seating

I left a review last week about the denial of gift card. Dominick reached out to me and the issue has been resolved satisfactorily. Thank you read more

Decent bagels out of a bagel shop deli off Route 202, Flemington, NJ. Perhaps, a little denser than I prefer, but still a worthwhile bite and chew. My only complaint was that I ordered an onion rounder, but got a garlic substitute. Anyone knowing bagels can tell the difference between roasted onion flakes and garlic granules, but apparently, the crew there. Detracted from my enjoyment, and left that unpleasant aftertaste. Too, their self service coffee setup wasn't checked too often, because their's lacked covers for the 12 oz. cups, and I left deftly carrying the cardboard container to avoid spillage to my car, and in it as well. Didn't spill a drop, but was annoyed nonetheless. Hard to score higher then average with those shortcomings. read more

See all

Moved to Ohio from Flemington. Missed this place. Recent visit slightly disappointed. PEC was weak at best. 2 thin slices of pork roll barely cooked enough to be considered done. read more

The Bagel Club - Pork roll egg and cheese. - Delis Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Best bagels in town!! They also make a great sandwich. The place always has a crowd. Must be a good reason.

Best bagels in Flemington!!!! I have tried three different places the past few days and the bagel club is AMAZING! My sausage, egg and cheese was $7. Great price. Don't waste your money anywhere else. Bagel club is the goat! read more

So I've lived in the area for over 25 years and was back in town and figured I'd get a bagel with veggie cream cheese and this is what you get for $3.50!!!! This place has always taken to long to get a bagel but at least you got what you paid for! read more

The Bagel Club - Delis Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

The best bagel place ever! They have a great variety and are always so fresh. The owners are friendly and care about their customers. A great place to meet friends. Jean read more

Good customer service and good quick service! You can call ahead with your order which is so awesome! They have a good selection and don't quickly run out of popular selections. My go to for bagels for a long time now! read more

A small shop and yet well organized order-paid-pickup flow. I personally like the texture of the bagel, chewy and soft to my satisfaction. read more

See all

Best fresh bagels I've ever had in the area!! Delicious breakfast sandwiches and flavorful chicken soup! It's not salty but not bland! Get there early or order early to enjoy a fuller selection of their specialty flavored bagels. If not early, all the bagels are worth a try and may get you hooked either way. And the handmade cream cheeses are yummy too if your into that. I typically grab 1 or 2 loose bagels. The French toast, sunflower, egg, Maple walnut are my favorites but I'm not disappointed if these are not available bc the other bagels are just so good. read more

Not a fan of the ordering system, but it was good. I liked it and it deserves a five. Ordered two bagel breakfast sandwiches. Both were pretty very good. read more

Quality and service has dropped recently. There are much better options out there that are worth the drive. Although its back, they were not giving a bakers dozen for some type of reason read more

worse service ever cannot communicate with customer or door dash that they ran out of bagel and didn't put salmon locks on Nova Scotia bagel. I call and they say there is nothing they can do about it read more

Yummy toasted pork roll egg and cheese coffee. Plenty of seating for dine in and lots of people picking up. Fast service Clean restroom.

Decent bagel but very stingy on cream cheese ( you are not going to get a NYC bagel here). Also if you like an iced te with your bagel they never have Snapple or other iced teas available : go the other joint if you need iced tea as they never have it gere read more

love the place!!! Been here many times over the years to pick up delicious bagels or hsng outweigh friends on a Sunday morning.

if you want to see people that are rude to their own stuff this is the place to go. Not willing to teach and be patient with them is unreal.

Some of the freshest bagels, yummy breakfast sandwiches, and great selection of salads!

Now they charge 3% to use your credit card. What a ripoff! This is how you show gratitude to your customers.

Normally this would rate much higher but today I am currently waiting 20 minutes and I still haven't received my four bagel order. While the picture in the receipt says Martha is the server, it's obvious that Martha is not here today. There were also about seven orders with meat and toasted bagels that were delivered after mine. read more

The Bagel Club - Delis Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Great food, friendly and professional staff. Lots of great food and drink options. The staff does a great job getting you out fast when it's busy. read more

Best Bagels around!!! Friendly and fast service. I've been enjoying these bagels for 25 years, quality and freshness always! So nice to have this staple in Flemington!! read more

Wonder staff, service, food, and prices - can't beat it! I would highly recommend to anyone looking for a top notch quality family-run business! read more

Delicious food, beautiful atmosphere and warm and friendly staff. Two thumbs up! They make great platters too.

Excellent, courteous service and delicious food! Staff is attentive and makes customers feel welcome.