It's a Bellingham diss to say "you would be a great fit for the Bagelry!" when your friend is looking for a job. They will make the best bagels of your life that's for sure so I love that place but man. I don't want to call them NPCs because people-watching there is pretty entertaining, but they function in the same way. Ah, I still love it. It's just a part of the place I'm used to. Fav bagels: rosemary, everything Fav spread: plain, feta garlic dill (do not attempt on a date. Solo is best. So good though) read more

Bagels are still great. How this place is run is nuts and puts stress on customers and the one lone cashier. When there are lines of customers waiting to order as well as pick up online purchases, perhaps filling napkin dispensers can wait? While there is likely a good reason why those making the food/filling orders can's multitask and help out the from of the house, watching 3 team members just stand around when it's busy in front sends a mixed message about customer care. read more

The bagels were good and the service was great but they are SO skimpy on the cream cheese, my bagel had bald spots.

Delicious food and fast service. Freshest bagels in town. Busy ambiance, but always a place to sit...

Ordered an egg and cheese on a bagel. It tasted delicious. The wait was a bit much but what matters is that the food was awesome as well as the staff. The inside of the restaurant is also nice. read more

The service has gone way down here unfortunately the only time I really come here is to get a Togo container of their Italian cream cheese as its seriously the best! The employees dress code is all over the place one employee cut the sides of her shirt and tied the sides and when she would lean down it exposed her chest unintentionally that was the end of summer when that happened another employee was dressed like a mouse or rat just a all around different vibe these days read more

I haven't tried the food but they make wonderful London Fogs with oat milk. The service is wonderful and the atmosphere is a warm, vibrant vibe. I love coming here when I'm in town. The food, btw, looks great. read more

I've never had a bad bagel from here in over 30 years. Yeah it's changed not the same owners and help turnover and skillset varies. Prices may seem high one month then you come in again and they don't seem so bad. They are not trying to gouge anyone, just run a business and that includes all the taxes, permits, licenses, insurance and properly paying their employees. They really do have a bend over backwards attitude towards just plain being kind, I've seen folks get rude and mean towards the employees and it's just wrong. Stop that be an adult. Order is messed up, they make it right I've seen and experienced that 100%. Buy a dozen bagels get a card punch. No, REALLY, get a punch card. Now that is said. I am a New Yorker. Don't try and tell me how my bagel is supposed to be. I know. There is a certain pull, and chew that is part of the experience while you savor the texture and seasoning involved. There should be a certain a la dente exterior texture from being boiled. THIS IS IT. There is no other. Pumpernickel bagels and an experience in themselves. I lean more towards the savory side with my bagels because a lot of time at home I make a lox sandwich. I can vouch for the lox spread, jalapeno spread and the highly under-rated cinnamon raisin walnut. The latter is definitely a treat and the former can apply to most bagels and bialys in a highly complementary fashion. The garlic bagel is made to only be toasted with butter, but sometimes I make a breakfast sandwich with them. I only like to go to establishments that have better food or convenience than what I can do at home. I still make my own bagels, because I can. If I could go to ONE place the rest of my life, this would be it. Bravo Bagelry for keeping up your time-honored traditions and being a cornerstone of what I know as Bellingham. read more

Came in at 7:16 and expected an online order I made for 7:15 to be ready, as I ordered it ahead of time so I could grab it and leave. I get to the front counter and I'm just standing there waiting for at least 1/5 of the people working in the front to come ask me what I need. I even made eye contact with 2 people just for me to stand there for another 5 mins and get ignored before I had to go up to someone on the other side of the room and ask if my order was ready. And then just for them to tell me it'll be ready in a few minutes...it took 10min. And when I get to finally open my food, I find the paper wrapping they used is in the middle of my sandwich. Food is mediocre and paper is an ingredient apparently now in bagel sandwiches. Had to throw away the bagel because of how hard and stale it was. Won't be coming here again. read more

The Bagelry - Tuna salad bagel sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

The bagels here are fresh and this place is a Bellingham institution. It's been here for over 40 years I think and it hasn't changed much and that's a good thing. Fast and friendly service and is the perfect size and seating for a bagel joint. Also has cool local art on the walls. Definitely a place to visit when you..... visit. read more

See all

The Bagelry has been in business since I was a child. I am 48 years old now. The service is still on point, friendly and efficient. The bagels and cream cheese are just as wonderful as I remember as a child. It still has the same cozy, nostalgic feel to it as it always has! The only thing I would recommend is they bring back their amazing split pea soup...keep up the good work! read more

Came here for decades. This place used to be super cool. Fresh, very tasty bagels in a nice old building downtown. Now it's a luxury bagel money squeezing shop. Quality not even close to where it was years ago. Questionable customer service. Absurd prices! Not a repeat! read more

The Bagelry - After taxes and tips, it's $15 for one sandwich bagel. Gotta take that in! - Bagels Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

See all

Bagels were 2 to 3 days old at best. Service was great but then I was here early on a Thursday morning. Won't be back.

Dad and I absolutely loved our breakfast here! Dad is a lifelong strawberry lover, and The Bagelry has the best house-made strawberry preserves ever. It was delicious, and they were generous with the smear. Any chance we could get them to sell their heavenly berry concoction by the jar? Either way, we'll definitely visit again when we're in town. read more

The Bagelry - Best strawberry jelly we've ever tasted. Bob couldn't wait! - Bagels Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

Everything here is amazing!!! I love it so much. Their bagels are soooo delicious and my mom introduced me to this place so it's extra special :) read more

I grew up in Bellingham and worked downtown Bellingham for many years and I always went to the bagelry. It was a nice morning meal to get my day started. The owners were great back in the day but not sure if they still own it. I don't live in Bellingham anymore so when I visit I always stop in. It's a delicious treat and brings back so many memories. Always puts a smile on my face! I always get the bialy bagel with Italian spread it's my go to! The Bialy bagels are a softer texture than bagels and have a thin, cracker like center rather than a hole. They are topped with poppy seed & Onions. Delish that is all I can say! There's usually a line inside cause they just do bagels right! read more

See all

Very popular bagel spot. We went on a Sunday and the line was out the door. Seating is somewhat limited for how busy it is; but luckily bagels are an On-The-Go type of food. They have a pretty wide selection of bagels and spreads. My wife tried their garlic fennel spread which was really good (unless you don't like the smell of garlic, then maybe try something else). I ended up getting eggs and a bagel; which I think was a mistake. Nothing wrong about this; but nothing really stood out either. My rosemary bagel was really aromatic; but without an accompanying spread, the flavors felt somewhat lacking. I'm sure we will be back, and I will have to try one of their many spreads instead. read more

Well, luckily I was able to get in to the store even though it had closed 15 minutes before. I did have an order so I slipped in behind another woman who was late and we both got our order just fine. As usual they are delicious . My dog thought so too, since she got into the bag twice during our travels to Spokane for Thanksgiving. read more

Terrible service, very slow workers, impolite, wasn't greeted or taken care of in a timely manner. I was the only customer with 5 people working and looking at me, not saying a word until I did. Then my bagel had no cream cheese on it. read more

The Bagelry - Bagel with very little cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

See all

Real bagels! Boiled first, not steamed like every other bagel you get... makes such a diiference! Delicous! Service was fast, atmosphere was very much an old school deli vibe. Right on point. read more

Fresh baked bagels on the ready Great music / Jazz Older diner with wood tables feel Fast service with a smile And the food is good that's a plus .. read more

Staff give you the feeling that you're lucky to be purchasing their bagels. They looked annoyed with being there and with MY being there. Online order of a variety of bagels came with all 13 bagels in one large bag. Onion, garlic, blueberry . . . . Paid to have them sliced but they weren't. read more

Once again convinced my wife to drive over an hour to get bagels, something she can't really eat since she has to have a low carb diet. "Totally worth it" -my wife Got the rosemary salt bagel, egg over hard with Munster cheese and chive cream cheese. It was a mess and we cleaned the plate. Also grabbed an assorted dozen. read more

got a lox bagel sandwich. I enjoyed the wild caught fish, as I'm not used to that where I'm from and coming to Bellingham the quality of the salmon everywhere I have ate has been a nice surprise. I also enjoyed the micro greens on a lox bagel, an interesting choice. However the bagel was extremely stale and not very impressive. I did enjoy the service and the atmosphere. Overall a pretty decent experience but nothing really special. read more

My favorite bagel place for as long as I can remember. I've lived in Phoenix, North Carolina and Houston and nothing comes close. Everything bagel with Italian spread is my all time favorite. The lox spread is also amazing. The restaurant itself also has such great character with art all over the walls. 10/10 recommend their lavender london fog as well. Also stop by mallard's next door for the best ice cream! read more

Personally, this place did not "wow" me. Don't get me wrong, the food was good but the line was really long and there was basically any seating. I think that if there's an option for another brunch place in town, I would pick somewhere else. It was just busy. The bagels are def unique and there isn't something similar I've seen in town. So if you're craving a bagel and something different this is a good place. I think the wait just wasn't for me. In addition the customer service could have been better, since they are so busy they really rush through your order and don't have much time to answer questions. In addition, they messed up my friends drink and claimed they didn't. His drink was supposed to be a white chocolate mocha, but the drink was really dark and tasted like dark chocolate and had chocolate flakes on the top. read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

See all

I like the ambiance of this place but this time when I went there, contraction work inside the shop made is so much harder to have a good time. Coffee was great and I bought the bagels from here. Some everything, some rosemary and a blueberry. Bagels that this place has are good. I won't say they are the best. I have had better bagels in Vancouver, but it's not too bad for a change. read more

The Bagelry - Cute bench inside the shop - Bagels Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

Food (4 stars) In terms of the quality of the food, there's no doubts that their bagels are the best in town. If fact, other "bagels" sold in town are more like bagel shaped bread. They just don't have the texture and flavor of a real bagel. Service (2stars) Their service is often painfully slow. It's not that there aren't enough people working. Many of them are often just walking around and not doing even when there's a long line. To make it worse, the same person who takes your order makes your bagel, extremely inefficient. There are two counters in the restaurant, and they they have designated one as an express lane. I have to say it's completely useless because you can only buy unsliced bagels. Today, there was a long line in the regular lane, but there was no customer in the express lane. There was one person staffing the express lane but was not doing anything! My final complaint is that their hours are extremely short. They close at 4:00pm (Mon -Sat) and 3:00pm (Sun). I give 3 stars because the food is good, but the service is less than mediocre. read more

The Bagelry is my hometown favorite! Beautiful bagel sandwiches with plenty of delicious cream cheese and toppings. I'm hungry now just thinking about it! read more

I've been to several different bagel establishments this past month and The Bagelry is the best. I must admit that I was skeptical at first and so I was really surprised and happy that they were so good. The flavor of the bagel was great but the texture was perfect. I also really enjoyed the orange spice cream cheese spread. read more

The best bagel place in Bellingham! Now that I moved away, any chance I'm home I make sure to get a dozen bagels!!

Wow! This place is incredible; from the food to the staff to the ambiance, I'm thrilled! As soon as you walk in the smell of coffee and fresh bagels surrounds you. I've had a hard time finding a bagel here on the west coast that even comes close to the ones I know and love from back on the east coast, but these are superb! Chewy and just dense enough, the flavors are perfectly balanced. I had the Lox Sandwich on a Garlic Bagel and added Cucumber, DELICIOUS! Eleanor made my order and she perfectly portioned the Lox, which was married beautifully with all the other flavors. I loved it so much, I came back the next day to get half a dozen more bagels to take home. 12/10, I'd get breakfast here everyday, so don't sleep on this place! read more

I have gone to the Bagelry since the 90s (or was it the 80s)? Their bagels really are the best. I am not a purist from Brooklyn nor am I a regular bagel eater, but these are prepared properly with a good crust, perfectly baked bread, and great toppings (sesame is my favorite, but cinnamon raisin is a close second). I hadn't been here in years but it seems The Bagelry is stepping into the modern age (credit cards accepted, wha, what?) and no more "To Go" and "Regular Bagel" side of the storefront...so confusing. I ordered a couple of bagel sandwiches, directly off the menu. I waited 10 minutes in line to place my order. Once I placed my order, it took 10 minutes to get my food. The bagels are alway fresh and well-prepared. The service is what is it, the employees seemed to be having a great time (happy employees are good) so I can't really fault them. read more

This is my favorite bagel shop in the world! I always come here when visiting Bellingham. The storefront is super cute and they have the most delicious bagels I've ever had. Super crispy exterior and soft chewy insides. They have awesome flavors (including pumpernickel) and tons of cream cheese flavors and toppings. I usually get something basic like a sesame or everything. My friend got a pumpernickel bagel, pictured here. We went back the following day for another round. I dare you to try to find a better bagel on the west coast. read more

I enjoyed a sundried tomato bagel and cream cheese here on a busy Sunday afternoon. For less than $5, you can get a scrumptious and filling breakfast. The 1 star deduction is because I thought the flavor could have come through a little stronger, but otherwise I plan to come back whenever I need my bagel fix in town. read more

Love the veggie sandwich with Italian cream cheese. Getting a baker's dozen, getting them sliced, and taking them home to store in the freezer for the week is the best! read more

Bagel was so good. Highly recommend the rosemary salt bagel. Good parking and the order comes out fast. read more

See all

I spend my days searching for a bagel better than at the Bagelry. It does not exist. The absolute best bagels I've ever had, I cannot recommend it enough. read more

Visited twice during a visit. The bagels are excellent. We ordered sourdough, rosemary salt, and the seasonal bagel - pumpkin. Yum! The service, however, seemed slow. For as many people bustling behind the counter it seemed silly to wait nearly 15 minutes for 3 unadorned/untoasted bagels to simply be put in a bag. read more

Rosemary and Salt Bagel is to die for! I got that one and the everything to try the next day! I wouldn't eat them any later then day two, they get super hard. Anyways I was a fan! When you walk in to the right is slicing, shmirring (cream cheese and fixings), to get bagels as a Breakfast meal and if you want coffee this is the right side. ! Ordering for a meeting, getting some bagels to go for the next day, or perhaps for an event, go to the left! It's not that hard ONCE I told you. ahhaha Cash registers at both! Most likely the long line where the restrooms are is where people age ordering for one or two, that's the next spot! Look to the FAR right by the bagels section of the spot and that is the variety of bagels (on the right side). It's HUGE here plenty of seating. Parking you do have to pay, it takes quarters and I didn't see white to pay cash but it might be on the back, not sure don't quote me! Took me 15 mins and I waited in line, didn't know what I was ordering and ordered bagels to go just to let people know! If you go to the wrong side you'll know it's no line and it has a SIGN!!! If your in the area and want grab and go and then head to CANADA like us get them, they are great! read more

See all