Yet another great trip to the Bait Shop! I try not to write multiple reviews of the same restaurant unless the quality varies. That's not the case here but I saw it had been a while since some wrote a review here. This is the best food in the region, and everything is always so unique and large portion. It's an experience, very worth it! read more

See all

This place rocks for catering! I was pleasantly surprised by how well put together the dishes were. Quality- the fresh seafood and pork belly is amazing here. The smoked sturgeon, seasoned jumbo shrimp, and minced pork belly were the top dishes here. Sturgeon isn't as common around here and stood out because of the smoky taste and freshness. The shrimp cook and seasoning was delicious. Pork belly was the perfect combo of fattyness and lean meat. Quantity- you get a ton of quality food for the price. Atmosphere- N/A Service- excellent and friendly folks read more

See all

Very homey atmosphere with a delectable, ever-changing menu. The server is always attentive and cheerful.

In my opinion this place is the Schwa of NW Indiana. Think about it. All the same elements and dare I say even better execution? (Oh yeah, unlike it's soul twin in Chicago, Bait Shop has a liquor license.) read more

I didn't eat at the bait shop but I did eat at D's Meats next door and I unfortunately can't find their page to leave a review. I think the bait shop and D's are affiliated so im going to leave my review here. I don't say this about a lot of places I eat, but these people KNOW what they're doing and they do it WELL!! we ordered 2 sandwiches the egg salad and chicken salad and at first found them a little pricey, but when we received our food it was 4 croissants each PACKED FULL. The picture speaks for itself. They let us sit outside on the bait shop patio because they don't have any space for dine in and we didn't mind at all! They even turned music on for us while we were out there. The girl who helped us was so pleasant and nice. The sandwiches were delicious and sooo full of unique flavor, and the sweet potato salad was absolutely incredible! I can't wait to come back. Soon I'll have to try the bait shop as well! Loved everything 10/10 read more

The Bait Shop - Lakeshore Linda on the left, Yoshi's island on the right - Bars Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

The Bait Shop has become our restaurant standard over the past few years. Every restaurant gets compared - but truly there is no comparison. The drink recommendations are always spot on. The food is amazing every time with no exception. The team treats us like family every time we stop, even if it's been 6 months. I recommend to everyone! read more

Just plain and simply the best dinning experience in the area! From start to finish, every meal has been spectacular. Chef Scott and the crew know how to put on a meal!!! Have made several trips with the high quality level combined with superb execution has made this my favorite place for a night out! Well done. read more

Funky little dinner spot with great drinks. Does NOT sell minnows, night crawlers or bee moths. Don't ask. read more

See all

There a few places in Valparaiso to get a fantastic, creative meal. We went to celebrate our anniversary and we were not disappointed. The name and the looks of the place from the outside are deceiving. However, the vibe and the food are wonderful! First off, make reservations. The place is small and I'm not sure if there were any walk-ins because all the tables were full. I had the ono and my wife had the filet. The ono was fantastic - served on a bed of pureed carrots and then cauliflower and Serrano peppers, it was fantastic! The creativity in the ingredients and presentation were noticeable. My wife's filet was outstanding! Cooked to medium rare perfection, you really could have cut it with just a fork. Then to top it off we had the carrot cake for dessert. Keep in mind, it's not inexpensive. However, for a fun or nice evening out it's probably one of three places in the city that serves a trendy, gourmet meal. Enjoy! read more

Service was fantastic. People were fantastic. Food was horrible. Just too many flavors rolled into one item, no matter what you order. Ingredients that I would never out together, this place does. It doesn't end well. read more

So we stopped here on a fluke. My nubs had heard good things. The menu was a bit odd for my taste!! We decided to stay and were pleasantly surprised! We started with a dinner salad large enough for the two of us! My pork chop with sweet potatoes was fabulous and cooked to perfection. My hubby tried the shrimp and gnocchi and the sauce was incredible. I ordered the bartender special where I pick a liquor and yet create a drink. Vodka and kitties raspberry was too notch. Servers were super friendly!! read more

See all

Menu (which is tiny but mighty) changes weekly, and always fresh. They post what they're serving on their socials. Top notch, a gem. If you see the mushroom tacos or the ramen, GET THEM!! read more

I can't really say enough about this place. The food and drink are not only of very high quality but are prepared in creative ways. The portion size is very nice as well so you won't leave hungry. They add new dishes from time to time as well so id suggest following their instagram. The staff is friendly and attentive and make you feel welcome. Its a smaller place so call ahead to make a reservation if you can. Try the bannanas foster if you have room for dessert. read more

My mouth waters thinking about my meal at the bait shop. I should back up, the cocktails are delicious. They always have something I haven't tried before or with a twist to an old favorite and I've never been disappointed. The food is excellent and service is spot on. Go there you won't be disappointed. read more

I like the small atmosphere of this place. It's kind of hidden and you wonder if you're in the right place when you pull up. Just up my alley. The food is fantastic. Small menu, but you can tell it's because so much work is put into each dish. Interesting cocktail specials. This place is not for picky eaters and can be pretty pricey. read more

This small place off calumet, or old 49, depending on how you remember Valpo, is a gem. It's really small, so make reservations. The size also means it gets a little loud when it fills up, which it will. The menu is limited, changes weekly, and is delicious. I had a tasty salad and my wife kicked off with a soup she really liked (I can't remember what she had). Then the main course came. I should point out that they have a butcher shop where you can Wagyu steak by the ounce, but it was $24 an ounce. Unless I could actually speak to the Wagyu cow and discuss Japanese Bovine American relations, it was just too steep for that evening. I did get the non-Wagyu filet, and it was cooked to perfection. The potatoes were good too. My bride got the Mahi Mahi, not usually a fish person, and she loved it. We will be going back. I should mention that the service was great. There is Joi Di Vie amongst the staff and it makes The Bait Shop a fun place to go. read more

What a totally fantastic place to eat! A small team (3 people) in a small out of the way location putting out some incredible food. The word is getting out there so no longer possible to "pop" in and snag a table so get a reservation (not online so need to call) and enjoy. I had the monkfish, and the wife has the porchetta - both absolutely great. Cocktails were also on point. Killer Banana Foster for dessert. Menu is dynamic and based on what's available. 100% recommend. read more

Best food and drinks in Valpo hands down. Also one of the few remaining restaurants not owned by a larger corporation.

Excellent menu - everything we had was fantastic, service was great - strongly recommend

Really great place. The duck and beef poke was amazing, the salmon was perfectly cooked, and the creme brûlée was really good. Portions were good, cocktails were excellent, and it's a great atmosphere. Order everything and share it. read more

See all

One of NWI 's best kept secrets! These meals could only be found in world class cities around the world (this is not an exaggeration). Chef Scott (owner/operator) meals are highly inventive, yet approachable and will generate conversation for hours. Who puts homemade ice cream in the middle of Panko Shrimp (Chef Scott does, and it works). Don't be shy. Each meal is individually thought out, has a story to it, and taste damn good! I grew up in Gary, live in Chicago & have been blessed to have traveled about 1 million miles. I've enjoyed world class dining. Believe me "this Chef is likely the best Chef in the region." Don't take my word for it, check it out! It's worth the trip (again, not an exaggeration or publicity stunt). He's the real deal. Here is one warning: make a reservation. It's a small (yet comfortable) dining room. Don't expect snooty servers wearing bow-ties. You can expect friendly folks who "deservingly" serve proudly. BTE: if you liked Bistro 54 (Hobart) then you'll understand what I mean (there's a strong connection). Also, the menu changes often. Finally, there are the two TVs playing classic old movies. On this night "The creature from the black lagoon!" Who does this? Chef SCOTT does. It's brilliant! PS: pardon any grammatical errors; English was my worst high school class (ala Andrea) lol read more

If you are a foodie and love a chef's exploration of taste and scent this is the place to go in Valpo. I truly compare their flavors to Stephanie Izard and the Girl & The Goat in Chicago. The cocktails are also worthy of accolades, and the staff are beautiful! Kudos to everyone. read more

I travel for work and am always on the lookout for a gem like this. I can only imagine how many people drive by this place and don't give it a second thought. I first visited The Bait Shop two months ago when I arrived to the area and have visited many times since. The menu changes almost daily. The owner uses fresh ingredients from local farmers and growers and seasonal pairings. The inside is small but refined. From Foie Gras stuffed French toast to filet mignon to huitlacoche; every creation is a festival in your mouth. I always let the bartender choose my evening cocktail and have never been disappointed. They have high-end spirits and micro brews you cannot find at most places. If you are looking for the perfect place to bring a date or a place to relax and have a great meal I highly recommend not passing this place by. They are open for brunch on Sunday from 10:00 to 2:00 p.m. Go check it out! read more

See all

This place is very small and wants to be hip, but it is a BIG miss. The food is mediocre and if you are looking for something special don't waste your time. It only stays open because it is in the middle of nowhere and there are not many other places nearby to eat. read more

Our food was great but unfortunately the service was terrible! No refills on our waters or beers due to only two waitresses that it seems you have to know to get good service. The place definitely needs a bartender. Would come back but not on the weekend. read more

The Bait Shop - Wagyu Elvis Burger - Bars Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

See all

Fantastic brunch. We both really enjoyed our meals. I had a wonton fried rice dish and my husband had the filet. We will be going back. read more

The Bait Shop - Bars Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

See all

After having had carry out a few times, we finally got to stop in and have dinner in the restaurant and we were so happy we did. Husband and I got two different dinners, both which were delicious. I had the fried chicken which came with greens, mashed potatoes and a waffle and it was some of the best fried chicken I've ever had- and definitely the best waffle I've ever had. The portion was huge so I couldn't finish, but I definitely wanted to! The service was also wonderful, friendly and quick and the kitchen sent us out an amazing surprise fried rice! We will define back! read more

Impeccable service. Very friendly staff. The food has a more savory flavor to it. Loved that and the presentation on the plate was superb.

Alright. This place maybe one of best spots in the state of Indiana to eat. The chef/owner changes his menu almost daily. Serving anything from incredible ramen, short rib, fried chicken. But the flavors and style is really incredible. It's a small spot with a righteous vibe. Vinyl on the music side. Lettie the bartender and hostess with edgy vibe will have you relaxed and ready for your meal read more

The Bait Shop - Ramen - Bars Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

Stopped by for a bite to eat because the signage said they should be open. Was disappointed that they were closed. Ended up being rudely greeted by an employee that indicated we should check their Facebook next time even though the signboard clearly said they should be open. read more

Just read the reviews! Please don't listen to Ann Z.....OMG....she had to be at a different place or on something when she went here. Lol Ok, the food is AMAZING!!!! Has to be the best food in the region. Small menu and everything on it is unbelievable. We have been here several times and every single time the food has amazed us. The bartender and drinks are wonderful. Drinks are a bit salty. I think my vodka and soda was $11. Love the atmosphere. All the staff is extremely friendly and the service is always on point. I highly recommend this place to anyone. read more

I LOVE BAIT SHOP! The menu offers a lot of variety each day and their brunch is da bomb! You can tell that the chef loves what he does and he puts a super creative and delicious spin on every dish. I'm sharing pictures from a couple of different visits and basically any time you see a variation of chicken and waffles on the menu... you get it. Yum! read more

See all

I wasn't sure what to expect my first time at The Bait Shop, mostly because I couldn't quite figure out how the name fit in. I found out that the building used to be an actual bait shop. My girlfriends and I met up there for dinner and I immediately loved then look and feel of the place. The space is warm, modern, cozy, and intimate. The restaurant is not very big, probably seats around 30 total. We started our evening off with cocktails at the bar. The bartender Josh was a pleasure, fun to speak with and knowledgeable about recommendations. They have a great selection of beer from local breweries as well as a wine list of around 5 whites and 5 reds; all from sustainable vineyards. The menu offerings change every week with selections like duck wings, duck heart tartar, veal brains, and escargot; you don't find offerings like this in the area frequently. We ordered the cheese plate and mussels for starters. Both were exceptional! As a matter of fact the sauce the mussels were served in was so good, after we ran out of bread to soak it up we pulled out our spoons to just scoop it out. My finger may or may not have been used to get the last bit . Yep, I did that at a fine dining establishment, it was that good. For dinner we order braised pork shoulder with gnocchi made in house, Italian antipasto salad, classic burger, duck wings, and lobster bisque. My favorites among those were: 1. Duck wings: they had the perfect crisp and the chipotle buffalo sauce and blueberry blue cheese were on point! 2. Braised Pork shoulder: the pork was tender and had a nice crisp on the outside without being dry. The gnocchi texture was just the way I like. Cooked just right. 3. Italian Antipasto salad: let me just say that I killed this salad. The flavor explosion in my mouth was delightful! I don't like beets and they were throughout the salad. They were delicious and memorable. I've never had beets this good. I'd eat them everyday. The burger was also tasty. The lobster bisque was my least favorite. It just didn't taste like lobster bisque to me. When you order cocktails, beer, and half the menu and only one thing doesn't agree with your taste, the place is tops! Add to that elegant and cozy atmosphere and incredible service! 5 Will definitely be returning. read more

See all

Went here the other weekend and had an incredible experience. The food and service were both five stars. It's smaller on the inside which helps it feel cozy and inviting, but still safe. I can't wait to go back! read more

This place is the bomb! Great food, great drinks, great service, great music, great atmosphere!! Check, check and check !!! Fantastic food and choice for Valentine's Day!! This girl right here is a snob and I can now add this to the list of excellent NWI places to eat at read more

Such a good restaurant! Menu changes frequently; bringing you what's in season to your plate! The vibe is really cool but the food is the high light. read more

My wife and I went here and got the filet mignon. Most definitely the best steak I've had in the region. We loved the quaint atmosphere and the service was phenomenal. Such a hidden treasure, this one. Well worth your attention. read more

This place is hit or miss on the menu and what drinks are available. I have had some great meals here and unique drinks that are outstanding. Wishing for a little consistency! read more

Food was really good!!! Server a little out there but was nice!!! Small menu but worth the trip.

Stopped in for drinks, not only were the drinks amazing, the food was phenomenal. The atmosphere was chill and laid back , but the food and drinks send it over the top to easily being an underrated hidden gem in Valpo. Will certainly be back! read more

The Bait Shop - Bars Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana