Justin was professional Place is SUPER CLEAN brightly lit,…read morewelcoming, friendly, Accessible. Ample parking. Fresh piping hot traditional Italian choices. A must try on way to #bayport #beach They affordable and speedy. A must try

This place was recommended to me. Was it the best pizza I've had on Long Island? No. It was ok at…read morebest. Let's talk about the shop and not the food: The layout of the shop is terrible. Whoever designed the space, I hope they quit right after. When you walk it the door the counter is to the right. It leaves no space to create a line so your line is either out the door or wrapped inside the restaurant. I ordered a Sicilian pie to go and I almost walked in to walk out because the waiting part was miserable. If you wanted to order something else or see what was in the case on the counter good luck. What is the purpose of the counter when you walk in straight? Besides being home to pizza boxes. With over 700 pizzerias on Long Island, I don't think I would come back here again.

Pizzas are outstanding. So is service. A+. My husband and I are there at least 2x a weekread more

Good food, great service, and a classic pizza shop ambiance is how I describe Donatina's. I had the…read moreAla Vodka Spicy Pepperoni slice and the Detroit style pepperoni cup slice. Both were very good, especially the Detroit Style Pepperoni cup slice. The cheese crust, the sauce, and pepperoni was delicious. The Ala Vodka slice was really good too. The crust was decent. Great service, and great selection of pizza. Looking forward to trying the Jonny Gravone Detroit style pizza next time!

The food is traditional the service is fast yet not hurried. Parking is something there is plenty…read moreof just around back.

I ordered Pasta Bolognese, which is supposed to be pasta with meat sauce…read more There was no meat just pasta and ricotta. Also the garlic bread didn't have melted butter just herbs tossed on some bread. Very disappointed. Worst Italian food in Patchogue!

If you're looking for the kind of pizza spot that leaves a lasting impression, this spot was one of…read morethem. We made a quick pit stop here before heading out to Long Beach to catch the sunset and some live music on a Friday night. Let me just say, this place absolutely hits the mark, whether you're grabbing a pie to go or taking your time and soaking in the lively, authentic pizzeria vibe. The ambiance is effortlessly inviting. When you step in, you're greeted by the smell of fresh baked dough, gooey cheese, and a friendly crew behind the counter. Even though we were in a rush, you could tell Saint James is the kind of place where locals gather, families grab an easy dinner, and pizza lovers unite over a hot, cheesy slice. The walls are filled with classic memorabilia, and there's just something homey and vibrant about the space. Now to the star of the show: the pizza! We ordered a classic cheese pie right from their Yelp page (super easy process, by the way! All the menu options are laid out with prices and descriptions, and online ordering was a breeze). The crust was that perfect balance of thin, crisp on the bottom, with just enough chew to make each bite satisfying. The cheese was plentiful, gooey, and rich, with a tangy tomato sauce that tasted homemade. We enjoyed our pie oceanside at the beach, and even after the drive it held up perfectly. No sogginess or limp crust! I can only imagine how fantastic their pies are fresh from the oven in-house. Next time, I'm grabbing a seat and trying the pasta, too.

The pizza was good, and so fresh made to order! The only down fall was the grandma was really oily-…read morebut still tasty! The staff was incredibly friendly I will definitely return just because of the service!

Stopped here for a quick slice of pizza and it was 10/10. Had to come back later in the week for…read moreanother. Friendly staff, the perfect pizzeria in my opinion.

Sorry to say. This place is now terrible. Sal is a great guy but seems to be overwhelmed now and…read morethe food is suffering. I have gotten a burned pizza from there twice now and had to return it. I don't mean properly charred, I mean, burnt. Why is he microwaving heroes ?? This destroys the bread and render it in edible within 10 minutes. The young guy who sometimes answers the phone there has zero personality and is almost sub-verbal. Everything in the place is old, worn out and filthy. Sad.

Easily my new favorite pizzeria!…read more The regular pie w/ pepperoni is everything I could ever want in a slice, just perfection. The sauce is the best I've had. I try to grab a specialty slice when I'm there to pickup because those are also fire! There was a pesto, pepperoni and (hot?) honey slice, wow, that was a treat. Really looking forward to that tri-color sauce I saw once as well. Can't go wrong here, definitely my new go to spot! These folks are clearly passionate about making great pizza. We ordered a salad once as well and that was easily the best salad I've gotten in a while. I'm sure their other food is equally awesome and we're excited to explore more of their menu! 10/10!!

What an amazingly delicious pizzeria serving some incredibly mind blowing pizzas. Their upside down…read morevodka is a show stopper, I would drive an hour just to eat this slice but when every other slice looking equally as incredible, this drive would be a no brainer. One of my favorite pizzeria's period. Such friendly customer service and large dining area to enjoy these great creations. Highly highly recommend if you love Pizza. FYI regular slice is amazing as well as all the other flavor options.

I can't believe I haven't written a review about one of my favorite local No Frills spots…read more The Food speaks for itself for its delicious, sauce/cheese/topping- they don't cheap out here! They're cheese slices good but they're real hidden jam is the upside down slice and I'm not a "sauce person" but give me that square pie upside down all day long... garlic, knots or flavorful and stink up your car so that's a good sign that there's actually garlic on there. The our zones are incredible. They make a really damn good calzone. I picked up a rice bowl for my husband and he's never had one from here and all is yours so I will post about that in an updated review. They recently did renovations, but still kept that pizzeria feel where everybody tries to get all bougie and stuff. They did the upgrades necessary, but still kept it quintessential to what a pizza place should be. Now down to the service and yes, the food matters primarily, but the service does matter if you get bad service! You will never get bad service here! The staff are so friendly they know everybody by name and what they essentially order! It's a family run business and the father is amazing but these two kids really shine above anybody I've ever seen in customer service with a restaurant! Nick and Lucas are incredible kids/man that know how to make a dining experience feel like you're at home! These incredible guys have managed to know their customer base learn everything about their customers and provide you with an instant experience asking about how your day at work is that whatever job you work and it's not just for me I see they do it with everybody and that's really what makes you feel like you're at home when you go to Albert's I'm super proud to support this business because the food is great, the service is great and unlike Olive Garden when you're here, you're actually family If I got the worst slice of pizza of my life, which I never have, I would still give a 4/5 stars just for the experience, but the pizza is a 10 out of 10!! They know what it is to run a restaurant and I'm glad to see the future generations taking hold of that :) such a beautiful thing to witness

This is a good little pizza place. The inside is nice, it's clean and they have a few small tables…read moreif you want to sit to eat. Service was quick and friendly. Pricing was fair Definitely mom & pop pizzeria vibe in here, which is nice. I got a chicken bacon ranch slice and a sweet chili chicken. Both were good and I enjoyed how they were a little crispy on the bottom. The chili chicken was a particular treat because I haven't seen this speciality slice elsewhere. My wife got a plain slice. She said it was fine (not her favorite plain slice around, but solid for the quick lunch we were grabbing). I'd grab slices from here again!

Hands down our favorite pizza place in the area. We've been customers for decades…read more No one comes close to their crisp crust that has FLAVOR. Their sauce has the fruitiness of good quality EVOO, and fresh, not jarred garlic. My favorite is the baby eggplant. Unlike most places that do a clunky breaded and friend eggplant, here it is sweet and tender baby eggplant sliced paper thin and sautéed in garlic and EVOO. Heavenly Others we've tried including white pies are equally magnificent. It you want real-deal, tasty from first bite to last pie--this is your place!

Been going to Rocco's when Rocco and family owned and operated. Sadly it's slowly deteriorated to…read morethe point where it's unrecognizable. My meatball marinara had undercooked meatball and overcooked pasta. Pizza has been bad and service stinks. RIP Roccos