This was my first time trying The Dirty Cheesecake but my order was Uber Eats delivered as my family and I are recovering from COVID! We are extremely lucky we did not lose any loss of taste because we would be missing out big time of these outrageously delicious treats we enjoyed immensely tonight!! The orders tonight were the S'mores Lava Cookie, Midnight Cookie and Cream Milkshake and the Strawberry Cheesecake Cup. The milkshake was devoured by my daughters BF. He said it was a perfect consistency, the Cookie and Cream were tasted in every sip but he said there was just a little too much chocolate syrup! He will absolutely order it again but with a little less syrup next time! The cookie was ordered by my daughter but she said it was gooey and a little too rich for her taste but still enjoyed some with a big glass of mik! My 5 stars goes to the Cheesecake that I ordered! It was literally perfection in every bite! The cheesecake was so creamy, decadent and layered with deliciousness! There was enough fresh strawberries in that little cup that it was present throughout! The graham cracker crumbs made up the last layer that completed this cheesecake masterpiece! The serving is big enough for 2 people so lucky me I have dessert for tomorrow night too! I am thrilled I found you Dirty Cheesecake! Next time I visit you in person as there are so many different types of desserts and variations of each kind, I need to see everything vs reading them off of a menu! I just know I will most probably have the same reaction as when a child walks into a candy store....intense excitement, awe, sensory overload, jumping up and down, shouting wow or look at this but the adult version of it all!! read more

See all

Decided to try The Dirty Cheesecake last night as I was looking for a sweet after dinner treat. This is such a cute dessert place that i thought only served cheesecake but had so many more options! The brookie bar dessert that i got was absolutely delicious and satisfied my craving beyond what I could have imagined! The counter person Lyn was nothing short of amazing as well with her kindness to help me especially since it was my first time. I love that it is open till midnight daily! Definitely recommend and I will definitely be back. read more

See all

Ordered here for the first time. The rainbow cookie cheesecake was 7/10 but everything else was just ok. The flavors all started to taste the same. read more

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis - Rainbow cookie cupcake, giant cake, cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - North Babylon, New York

Fantastic service, great banana pudding and PHENOMENAL CHEESECAKE! 10/10 will return and recommend to all with a sweet tooth!

OMG... this place is so damn good. If you're looking to get into a little delicious trouble, this is absolutely the spot . The Dirty Cheesecake is rich, indulgent, and made to satisfy every sweet craving. The cheesecake is creamy, decadent, and loaded with flavor, topped with just the right amount of crunch and drizzle to take it over the top. You can tell it's made with care and quality ingredients -- every bite is pure indulgence. If you love desserts that are bold, messy, and unforgettable, Made by Lili's will not disappoint. Consider this your warning... once you try it, you'll be back for more ‍ read more

Update! Amazing as ever! We are regulars, and basically neighbors. We ordered the Reese's shake and cake in a jar tonight. I highly recommend the cake in a jar. It comes in a full size mason jar that you get to keep and it is so satisfying! The boyfriend loves the milkshakes and they are packed with flavor...ps. He really enjoyed that Reese's shake tonight! The owners and workers are excellent and always so friendly and helpful. Exceptional service! By the way, they have a really cute Instagram wall inside, so you better be ready to show off your delicious treats! read more

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis - Reese's PB Cake in a Jar - Bakeries Near Me - North Babylon, New York

From the moment you walk in, you're met with a colorful array of options. Their rotating menu features so many amazing flavors like Fruity Pebbles, Triple Chocolate, Cotton Candy, S'mores, Nutella, and more! Each one more tempting than the last We were blown away by the quality of the cheesecake, it's rich, creamy, and indulgent without being too heavy. There's truly a flavor for everyone, and the variety keeps things exciting! We had the honor of being one of the first people to try their newest seasonal flavor: Peanut Butter Fluff-a-Nutter, and it was incredible! A peanut butter lover's dream: cheesecake dipped in peanut butter, coated in marshmallow fluff, and topped with pieces of Nutter Butters! It was a delicious, nostalgic treat that lived up to every expectation One of the standout elements of The Dirty Cheesecake is their commitment to inclusivity and dietary restrictions! We tried the gluten-free cheesecake, Nutella Hazelnut Style. It was dipped in milk chocolate and covered in hazelnut pieces and Nutella drizzle, who wouldn't love this! The Gluten Free cheesecake was just as delicious as the traditional options and a great reminder that no one should have to miss out on dessert! We were also lucky enough to be the second group ever to try their brand new Iced Rainbow Cookie Latte A mocha raspberry latte topped with pink raspberry cold foam and crushed rainbow cookies! It was as fun and flavorful as it sounds, and a perfect companion to the cheesecake read more

See all

Cute little dessert spot in a large shopping center - it smells delicious as soon as you walk in the door. There's a cute grass wall for pictures - there are a ton of options. The young lady behind the counter was amazing - she explained the concept, the menu and helped me in deciding what to order. I ordered the Dubai Chocolate Cheesecake, Dulce De Leche, Rainbow Cookie ($35) it's a bit pricey - but the portions are large and very rich read more

See all

Went for the first time on may 19, 2026 to buy something for my husband's birthday . The young lady who helped me was so nice , helpful and patient. I choose the strawberry shortcake and Wow after he blew out the candle the cake was Delicious smooth and not sweet I will definitely be back for my treat as i did not want to take away or confuse his special day read more

I've never had a cupcake this good before!!! The frosting is top tier! Deff coming again with my bffs read more

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis - Bakeries Near Me - North Babylon, New York

See all

I am a frequent customer at Made By Lilis and I am sad to say that our most recent visit did not live up to our expectations. Going in, I figured why not try the new items! I noticed them right away and staff were very pleasant in describing each of the offerings. Unfortunately, the cookie butter blondie bar completely lacked flavor - and that is coming from someone who loves cookie butter and blondies. The cake overpowered the bar, with the cookie butter ratio being offputting, causing it to taste dry and with lackluster flavor. Moving onto the cookie monster, visually, so pleasing, which is ultimately what drew me to the dessert- and on top of that, I'm a cookies and cream lover. With that said, this dessert MESSED UP my stomach and tasted hard/stale despite heating it as directed. It was to the point that I did not even near finishing the dessert, in the trash it went. To top it off, the bottom of the dessert was burnt. As I mentioned before, this is very upsetting to us as we've always happily made the hour, round trip drive to visit and typically have a wonderful experience, but, this time, it just did not deliver. read more

See all

Had desserts from this cute shop near my house! The cupcakes were delicious & the service was awesome. The staff was friendly & offered suggestions for any of the multitude of items shown. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious and couldn't wait to come back and get another gluten free cheesecake!!! Always great service and the ambiance is beautiful read more

Do not use this place charged me 80 dollars delivered half the order. First the desserts were so small looked like they should be used for my 5 year old daughters tea party , they were do small. When asked to refund he said no I'd your problem call whoever you order through grub hub. I was like what I am calling you this is your store right refused to correct the issue and by the way I found his in the good read more

Was ok. Items look nicer than they taste. It's good just not exceptional. Definitely not worth going out of your way for. A little pricey.

Wife got me the banana pudding and she had a cookie butter cheesecake. Wow. I am a huge banana fan and this was the best banana pudding I've had. I don't like cheesecake really but this one was good. Worth a try if you are in the area. read more

I always forget to post a review because I order, eat, put my phone down and enjoyyy every morsel! But I'm on it tonight! If you've order delivery from this place and have never been inside, do yourself a favor and come on by! It is absolutely gorgeous! The staff is always pleasant! I had the pleasure of meeting the owner and he gave me the whole backstory of how he and his daughter came up with the cheesecake flavors and uh it's just wonderful My top 2 cheesecakes would def be LILIS cheesecake and the snickers cheesecake!!! The ice creams are delicious. The cupcakes are devine! Carrot cake! Snickers and cinnamon toast are theeeee best! I did try the red velvet and eehhh I have to say I wasn't tooo impressed. I've had it twice and it hasn't made my top 5. I feel like true red velvet lovers have their go tooooo spot to get their fix . This place isn't it for me which is perfectly okay because they make up for it with all the other flavors that I cannot find anywhere else. Hands down all around fav local cheesecake and cupcake spot . And they initially got me from Uber eats now I make sure to come with my daughter to watch as they layer all the toppings on the cheesecake read more

See all

Everything in this store is amazing and so delicious and the customer service is excellent. Whenever I bring any type of the dirty cheesecake it's always a big hit, read more

As someone who LOVES trying different types of dessert Dirty Cheesecake is a MUST try. I thoroughly enjoy making and eating cheesecake during the holiday season so finding this place was A GIFT. The Deer Park location has beautiful scenery with lots of different options. The item that caught my attention the most was the cheesecake covered in chocolate on a stick. This was to die for. The service was super fast and the employees were patient while waiting for me to make my decision. I will definitely be coming back again, especially with the variety of options. This is the perfect place for a cute date night or just a late night snack since it is open till 12!! read more

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis - Bakeries Near Me - North Babylon, New York

See all

Lemme tell ya... Their Banana pudding tastes amazing. A little different from what you're used to from Magnolias but the flavor is there! I ordered a custom cake and cupcakes for my son's 6th birthday. Tha cake was supposed to be vanilla cake with strawberry filling and fresh Strawberries but they made a mistake. They were apologetic and threw in that banana pudding and I'm so glad that they did! Cupcakes were delicious even after 3 days Would order here but I definitely want to try their dirty Cheesecake. Very hassle-free ordering and quick responses. Would recommend even if you're not in the area! read more

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis - Custom cake and cupcakes $189.00 and change - Bakeries Near Me - North Babylon, New York

Everything is so good ! Lots of options to choose from. If you're a cheesecake lover , this is the spot ! read more

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis - Everything is so good ! - Bakeries Near Me - North Babylon, New York

I've been here several times, usually at night. The dessert is great, the ambiance is great, the staff is generally great. My experience on a sunny Sunday afternoon was not great. There is a large sign behind the counter advertising the Samoa coconut cheesecake of the month. I order that and 4 premade things from the display- not too difficult right? Cuz the employee was alone and there were other patrons. She advised me she didn't know how to make it. It would be a while , she had to call her boss. Then it would take a while because no one crushed the nuts. Eventually I gave up and added another display item. The employee may have been having a bad day but the experience left a bad taste in my mouth and I'd be hesitant to return, or engage with this employee again. read more

Amazing desserts and great people!!! My go to late night treat :) The place is super clean too.

Love this little shop in Sunset city feel bad that they have to compete with uncle G's but it's worth a stop if you want some great desserts. I've had the cake in a cup and it was awesome. I've tried the lollipop dipped cake and it was so good the macaroons are, very tasty and well-made. The staff are knowledgeable about product and give great recommendations. So if you're willing to throw your calorie, count out the window indulge your palate at this place. read more

Cute desert and coffee place open in smithtown , cozy place nice decor . We had couple things that was really good will be back to try other things ! Glad they open this place near me !!They have a couple tables so u can enjoy and relax . read more

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis - Bakeries Near Me - North Babylon, New York

See all

This Is scam the Lil bullshit cheesecake in the stick it's just a plain fucking New York style cheesecake with bullshit on top of it literally the biggest fucking waste of fucking 15 minutes I ever had to drive to get something that looks so good but it's not true feels like I ran out of money with a hooker on GTA read more

This is a fun place for desert. It's not very big, although there are about 4 seats by the door, it is mostly a place you would go to take your deserts with you. They deliver and have a store front you can visit. It was clean and well kept. There were plenty of options including gluten free options which was nice to see. There were two women working behind the counter and they were friendly knowledgeable and helped 5 groups of people quickly and efficiently. The s'mores cheese cake was delicious. They're also open late which is really nice since there are limited desert options after 8pm. read more

See all

This place had so many different options and it was open late! Slightly difficult to find in the back corner of the parking lot but definitely worth it if you were in the mood for a sweet treat and it is late at night! The employee working was busy making milkshakes but so fast and efficient at helping us out! Prices were reasonable. Got a cheesecake with oreos & chocolate chip cookies! Also had a cool photo wall. Parking lot is huge and free, we were there late at night but there were a lot of people still shopping at different businesses in the strip mall. read more

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis - Bakeries Near Me - North Babylon, New York

So many desserts to choose from. The dipped cheesecakes are a must! I was very happy with my pecan pie cheesecake. The campfire cheesecake was my least favorite. The peanut butter explosion is good; it's like having a Reese's. The banana pudding is okay. It's not what I'd bother getting from here. The cheesecake and the stuffed cookies are where it's at! It's a cute shop with a few tables where you can sit and enjoy your dessert. The employee working helped us with making our selections and told me to avoid one of the gluten free desserts. I was thankful for that! read more

See all

Made By Lily is hands down one of the best dessert spots I've ever visited! The variety of desserts they offer is incredible--there's something for everyone, whether you're craving Macaroons (so many options), exotic chocolate dipped cheesecakes, pastries, ice cream... I can go on The shop itself is cozy and welcoming, making it a great place to sit and enjoy your treats. Lili is also super friendly and eager to help you find the perfect dessert. If you're in the area and have a sweet tooth, Made By Lili is a must-visit. I can't wait to go back and try more of their delicious offerings! read more

Best vanilla macaron I've ever tasted. 1st time went & everything looked so good. Friendly counter representative who was very helpful and patient while my friend & I asked about many of the yummy looking confections we were gazing at. Also tried a cinnamon toast cupcake & raspberry swirl cheesecake, both of which were good. The cotton candy milkshake was amazing. It's also really nice they are open til midnight for us night owls as it seems a lot of places that used to be open later, close much earlier now, especially on weeknights. It is a very clean & well kept space. There are 2 (2 seater) tables very close to each other in the front corner since the space itself is not that large & the large amount & different varieties of goodies are arranged very pleasingly to the eye in a big wraparound case. There is no coffee but it gives you a reason to splurge on a milkshake. I cannot wait to go back and try the banana pudding. read more

Highly recommend dirty cheesecake, the red velvet shake Is amazing! Staff are extremely nice and very patient! Lucas is the best, very polite and honest, great costumer service! read more

Pretty little bakery Super chic and cute Everything looked delicious & everything we got was good read more

See all

Love this place I've been going for a year their Nutella shake is the best love the macaroons!!! read more

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis - Bakeries Near Me - North Babylon, New York

Everything looks so delicious. The Ferrero Rocher Milkshake was so good. They actually use fresh hazelnuts and the flavor was so deep and rich. The Chocolate Covered Cheesecake was yummy. Between my husband and myself we shared two desserts which were perfect for a late night snack. The place is so colorful with desserts and flower decorations. Need to go back and try more desserts. read more

See all

Delicious macarons, also had the chocolate dipped raspberry cheesecake and it was absolutely amazing, loved it! read more

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis - Bakeries Near Me - North Babylon, New York

See all

Amazing milkshake, must try! Small place with only two tables and friendly staff. There cheesecake on a stick is fun and really worth trying as well. read more

See all

As always the food was immaculate. Melina was very helpful and patient, as I was very indecisive haha. Thank you, will be coming back! Very organized and clean place. read more

This place smells amazing when you walk in. They have tons of cheesecakes, cakes, macaroons, and cupcakes! I was looking to get some baked goods for my sister's birthday. They have many flavors of cupcakes, and many flavors of cheesecake it was hard to just pick a few. Their shop is pretty small, and there's no sitting area so keep that in mind. If you do a Google review for them they give you a free macaroon! I got the strawberry cheesecake, and it was really good. The cashier was friendly. Would come here again. read more

The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis - Vanilla & chocolate cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - North Babylon, New York

See all

The inside of the bakery is so cute. The staff is pretty nice, and I thought it was super cool that they torch the creme brûlée to order! The cheesecake is delicious, not too heavy. They're open very late until midnight to satisfy that sweet tooth. It is a little pricey, so it wouldn't be an everyday indulgence sad to say. The desserts are delicious nonetheless. read more

See all