Greeted warmly right when we stepped in. Visiting Karcher Caverns and told on our way home to Tucson, I 10 was closed to an accident. So we made a detour to Benson for an early dinner and let traffic clear. I'm so glad we did. Carrie (?) Our waitress was so helpful in what we ordered. My husband had a Rueban, brother a burger, sister a Cobb salad and I had the pork chops. The Rueban was the best I have ever had, yes my husband and I shared meals. Pork chops were perfectly cooked. What a pleasant cafe. Good food, great staff and pleasant ambience. We will be back when passing through. read more

My husband had the crispy chicken sandwich and I had Bob's Reuben (Cole slaw instead of sauerkraut). Both were delicious! Good coffee. Our server was very attentive. The diner has a fun atmosphere. We're tourists passing through, and enjoyed eating here. read more

We really enjoyed lunch here! The burger looked good but it was not mine. My sister liked it! The Reuben sandwiches were very tasty... and juicy! The onion rings thick & delicious. Fries were good too. Bloody Mary's were very good - they don't use that "zing" mixer that most places use now which has horseradish in it. I don't like horseradish in my Bloody Mary, so Horseshoe was great for using a regular Bloody Mary mixer. They didn't have the jalapeño poppers the day we went for lunch, so we went the next day and ordered 2 orders of poppers (6 in each order) and bloody Mary's. YUM. read more

See all

Nice stop for some friendly service and a variety of food options. Salads, burgers, portobello mushroom "burger" if you don't want meat, great sweet potato fries and a variety of pies. Short wait, fresh food, convenient to Benson attractions. read more

See all

To the owner- One shouldn't have to ask to be placed in available open seating NOT in a bar. The establishment is lucky I gave it a 4 star the first time. The 1st time, They placed us in a horrible location (bar), my husband asked to move- we got attitude. So yeah, asking to move again (the second visit)- isn't acceptable and we weren't up for another "confrontation "- DO BETTER- train your wait staff to ask if one objects to bar seating before leading them to a table instead of trolling comments read more

The Horseshoe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Benson, Arizona

Stopped here with a group of 8 after visiting the caverns. Got the Nashville Hot Chicken as did one other of our party. Theirs was huge! They traded with me because it was too much chicken. Our table also got some onion rings and fried pickles which were excellent. The server had a great disposition and seemed happy to be there. Yelp wants me to talk about the ambiance.... I didn't really go there expecting anything special and it was what you'd expect for a small town cafe. I'd most definitely eat there again if I lived nearby. read more

The Horseshoe - Nashville hot chicken with sweet potato fries (brother trying to steal them in the background) - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Benson, Arizona

Me and my family were driving back to Phoenix from Tombstone and we thought we should stop to eat as it was getting a bit late. Reviews on google seemed excellent and we were anticipating a decent meal and time. It took a little while to get seated as we arrived a bit before 6pm and it was busy. It only took 20 minutes waiting to get seated. Three of us ordered the fried fish special as it was something they were known for. Our server was pleasant and friendly. It took an additional 90 minutes before we got our food after being told several times it be just right out. None of our orders came with the tartar sauce as specified and I asked for it only to be told they ran out. I said I wouldn't have ordered it had I known. My fish was stone cold. The others had warm fish. Mine clearly sat for some time. My waitress did remove mine from the bill as I didn't eat it and instead had some of the others. My poor rating is due to the kitchen staff contributing to a long wait and poor execution. It's makes for a bad experience overall and no one was happy upon leaving. The place gives off a cool ambiance especially the neon sign outside and historic feel inside. I wish we caught them on a better day but frankly as we were traveling I doubt we be back. read more

The Horseshoe - Outside - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Benson, Arizona

Quaint, small town breakfast spot. The service was amazing. The food was pretty good. It broke my heart because I really wanted it to be awesome, but I have to keep it real. To be fair we're just passing through so I can't revisit and try again. read more

The Horseshoe - Eggs, homemade corn beef hash, country potatoes, sourdough bread. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Benson, Arizona

A really good, flavorful taco salad that will bring your taste buds back to the 80's & 90's w/ romaine (not iceberg lettuce). And it is Filling! Without even touching the shell. Keto friendly. Note - breakfast shuts down at 11 am (hence minus 1 star). Also - these ladies are really working! Want to see a work ethic? - bring your employees here! You might have a wait to eat, but it's not for lack of them doing everything they can w/ a great attitude & moving! Thank you ! read more

The Horseshoe - Taco salad is really good! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Benson, Arizona

I ordered the Cowboy Burger & fries. It was suppose to consist of Thousand Island, Swiss Cheese & grilled onions. Their burgers are 1/2 lb so I figured the waitress should have asked how I wanted it done, but she didn't. When it arrived I was glad that I asked for extra dressing as I couldn't find any dressing on the actual burger. Also the onions were not grilled, but raw. The burger was cooked thru with no red, but was kind of dry & tasteless. As it was pretty busy in there I did not say anything. The fries are the seasoned extra crispy ones (kind of like Burger King) & were good. The waitress never came back to ask if everything was ok? read more

We stopped here starving and left elated. The chicken sandwich with honey mustard is absolutely to die for. At the recommendation of our waitress I had the cole slaw. Best cole slaw I've ever had in my life. The place is warm and inviting and don't leave without trying the pie! (Lemon meringue for the win). read more

See all

I ordered a burger and a fried chicken sandwich for my sister and was happily surprised with the taste of the food . The place gets busy so you have to wait some time for your food but it was worth it. read more

Stopped in for some fish fry on a Friday Eve. It was great. Went back the next afternoon to get a Chicken Fried Steak to go. Again I enjoyed it at home. I'm so glad they decided to do extended hours on Friday & Saturday. The local atmosphere adds to the experience. read more

Great food and very nice staff. Tried the Chicken Sandwich with Mango Habanero sauce on it. Excellent.

I like it here but really wish they would go back to serving dinner there nightly, they want you to go next door to their bar instead and it's just not the same. I don't always want a bar, I want an old historic cafe/restaurant. read more

Good "home"cooking, great service, reasonable prices. Great selection of baked desserts.

If you are near Benson Passing through or here for a stay.. You cannot leave without a meal at the Horseshoe Cafe. The food is fantastic ,the service even better. If you skip n it you are missing out read more

The service it pretty good here! I ordered a crispy chicken sandwich here and it was pretty good other then the cheese so if you would like to try the chicken sandwich I would recommend to get no cheese or a different kind of cheese!! read more

Proper diner. Great selection, well put together menu. Offers a la carte as well. Good portions. Has cafe as well as bar seating. read more

The Horseshoe - This was two breakfast entrees - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Benson, Arizona

Great burgers and fries, great chocolate malts, excellent service, (Cindy) good prices and the place was clean! I think it's just perfect if you're exploring the area! Do yourself a favor and give it a try!!! You'll be glad you did read more

It was back in Spring of 2023 when we stopped by on our way home to CA, so it's been awhile. As a result, don't recall a lot of details. I had an excellent bean tostada. The portion was just right. I had a very cold Coke-Cola in a glass bottle- my favorite. They served a complimentary bread item that was tasty and crunchy. Service: sat at the back of the restaurant and service was good. Young lady was prompt and friendly. Ambiance: I don't recall too much about the looks of the decor inside. I did notice though or recall that there was a lot of to-go bags on a table next to the sit down counter. There were quite a few people that looked both local and travelers like us. read more

Another nice little local restaurant with simple but good food and friendly service. They have a good selection of home baked desserts right out front, a bar to the left with seating in addition to the regular seating to the right. We came then they had an all you can eat fish fry special. The server actually told us the wrong price for it, making it seem cheaper. However, she did make sure they honored the price she told us, which was nice. The fish itself was pub style, with nice big pieces battered and deep fried. When we're in the area we'll definitely be going again read more

Restaurant had great western theme very clean. Staff were super friendly. The food we had was definitely a 10 and the best ice tea we have had on our trip so far read more

The Horseshoe - Outside pictures were neat also had outside eating - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Benson, Arizona

See all

Excellent service for our party of 9, including 2 highchairs. Our server was great . We never felt rushed. The food was yummy.

Came in for breakfast and the food was good. Carrie was an amazing server, she made the dining experience wonderful. Thanks so much Carrie

This place was perfect I can not express that enough the food was great. I have the chicken fried steak, chicken fried chicken, both crispy and full of flavor. I also had an order of buffalo wing which was a perfect blend of heat and flavor. The cinnamon rolls are yum !!! We sat outside which was lovely. the train just added to the atmosphere. Amy was a delight and Vanilla was a tall glass of zesty spunk. read more

My review is directed primarily to vegetarians and vegans. Basically, I suggest that you not go to Horseshoe. You can find some things to eat for breakfast and lunch, yes, but not that much. You're probably going to be disappointed. For instance, breakfast. Yes, vegetrians can have pancakes or french toast or an omelette. But most of their specialties offer a choice of sausage, bacon, or ham. No veggie option. How hard could it be to have some sort of veggie burger in the freezer, so the vegetarians can have a hearty meal, too? Or some other side, like a little salad. They don't bother. And if you don't eat meat OR dairy, well, you can find something, but it isn't necessarily something you want. Lunch is that much harder. In the mood for a grilled cheese sandwich? I sure hope so, because there isn't much else you can get. And, bottomline, for supper? Nothing at all. Those of us who are vegetarian or vegan know it is not hard to have a few things on hand that will help us feel our meal is as good as everyone else's. The Horseshoe Cafe doesn't do that. My recommendation? Go to a restaurant in town that has lots of choices for you. There are several. read more

The food and prices use to be good here but they have changed over the last few years. The prices are higher and the amount of food you get is definitely less. I'm not sure if they have had a change in the cooks but it just doesn't seem as good as before. The service is still friendly. read more

Food was AMAZING, I had the country fried steak, so good! Service was really good, the lady was so nice. The place is really chill, it feels family owned. read more

The food is homemade, staff is always nice. All the locals eat here. It's a little pricey but good.

Stepping into the cozy atmosphere of this classic breakfast diner feels like entering a time capsule of Western hospitality. From the moment you're greeted with a warm smile, to the last bite of their hearty breakfast , every moment at Horse Shoe is a nostalgic journey through flavors and tradition. The menu has an array of timeless classics, from fluffy pancakes to sizzling bacon, all served with a side of genuine charm. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, you'll leave with a full belly and a fond memory of a true American breakfast experience. Carrie our waitress was kind and very quick, will make sure to stop by every-time I'm in town, if you're ever in the area this place is worth stopping by! read more

Excellent local spot! My husband had the chicken fried steak and eggs, and he said it was all perfectly done. I had the southwest Bene, and the flavor was good, but the eggs were slightly over done for my liking. But other than that, the service was prompt considering they were busy, and very friendly. Would recommend! read more

What a great stop! My father said "I want a burger and fries". Well this place delivered! Really good burger, great fries and pies! Tasty pretty pies! Fun atmosphere and quick good food! read more

Husband and I were on a road trip and was looking for a good spot for a burger and this place popped up. This place did not disappoint, the customer service was AMAZING and the ambiance was on point and the burgers were DELICIOUS! read more

The Horseshoe - My burger! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Benson, Arizona

See all

The best ever food!!! We will be back!! The epitome of old fashioned diner. The service and the food was excellent read more

The Horseshoe - Chicken fried chicken and homemade Corned Beef Hash!! Yum - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Benson, Arizona

The Horseshoe is a staple in Benson! They've been in operation since 1936 and the food is excellent!! Homemade pies and a simple menu! New owners, but same excellent quality food and service!!!! Anything on the menu is going to be a winner!! My wife and I always stop here to eat when we come to Cochise County! read more

Let's start with the positive! Staff is off the charts friendly! Though our waitress was new, service was awesome. Wine by the glass is not local, however wine by the bottle is! Really good wine. Everything was very clean. Hubby had Chicken Fried Steak. Said it was very good. I had Beef Stroganoff. The sauce and pasta was very good. HOWEVER, the beef was HORRIBLE. There was not one piece on my plate that was edible. If you are going to use a tough piece of meat, you must pressure cook it. Or use a better cut. This is the only reason we did not give a five! read more

The best - we go to apple annies twice a year and this is our stop for lunch afterward. the service is freindly, the food the best - have never been disappointed and the feel of the place is comfortable and very welcoming. Six stars! read more

This is an iconic small town diner experience. Everything is homemade. The severs are super attentive. Homemade country fried steak. Homemade pie. Did I say homemade? This is not an Applebee's, Thank God! If you are going through Benson, make sure you time your trip to be near here for breakfast, lunch or dinner. I was with a a renowned chef when we stopped. The chef said that this is a classic American small town restaurant that serves love. Do yourself a favor and come here. read more

Great old-school diner. Great breakfasts. Also liked the corned beef sandwiches. Excellent service.