came here for the first time the other day and the vibe is awesome, space is large and great for…read morebig parties, and food delicious. given it is the winter time off season it wasn't extremely crowded which was nice because the service was excellent, very friendly and fast. i was happily surprised at the amount of gluten free options they had - GF pizza (cauliflower crust), GF wraps, and GF pasta! i ordered a buffalo chicken wrap on a GF wrap with ranch instead of blue cheese and it was delish - came with a side of chips and a pickle. there are generous portions for the price and so happy to see more gluten free options available, especially since this is one of the few spots open in off season!

We were leaf peeping on a warm fall weekend having had breakfast at Campbells Diner on the way up…read morewe were not hungry but stopped for a drink and the view from the back door bar outdoor upper deck. Bartender was friendly and chatted with us for a quick minute as he served a large crowd. The burgers that went by as we stood there looked scrumptious and huge. I would venture to say the food must be good based on the looks of it and the size of the dining crowd. When we sat outside with the gorgeous view from the upper deck people below were getting pizzas that also looked delicious and I'd say about 18" with fresh looking ingredients. I cannot attest to flavor but the smells were awesome. Next time we will stop later and grab a bite for dinner.

Slickers is a staple when visiting old forge. A great time with good and good drinks. Love their…read morebucket drinks and think they're a great deal and a fun souvenir. We were seated immediately which was awesome seeing as it was 4th of July weekend. We ordered the spinach and shrimp dip for an appetizer and we ate that up immediately. My boyfriend got a bacon cheeseburger which he thought was really good and cooked perfectly (medium rare fyi). I chose the drunken chicken which was huge and the chipotle mayo was a nice addition! Overall very good and filling. Slickers is always a good time with friendly customers and staff. I've never had a bad experience here!

Upon arrival the place was pretty busy but we saw two open booths to our left. Due to being a…read morefamily of 5, they told us it would be a 10-15 minute wait for a table, outside and inside options were full. We didn't realize they were attempting to close the section to the left. We waited about 25 mins. Some other families arrived with 4 and were seated immediately. We were finally seated. 10 minutes after we were seated I went back to the hostess and asked who are server is since we still didn't have drink orders. It was the server that was serving the table next to us. She never said, "oh I'll be right with you", even after she went to that table 5 times. They kept asking for drinks and crackers and more items. After I approached the hostess I saw them flag her down and ask her to serve us, not sure if she was supposed to go home, on break or what the breakdown with service happened to be. After the hostess flags her down she comes up to our table and asks for drinks, no apology for the wait or having to flag her down to get service. I said we have been here for 10 minutes, we are ready to place our full order. We order everything. It takes 11 minutes to bring 5 waters, 2 sodas, and 2 bottles of beer. This is after the place has now cleared and is quiet inside. 85% of the tables and bar are empty. 28 minutes later our food arrives. She never came back to ask for refills. She had two tables at this point, ours and a family of 4 behind us. After the food was delivered and we were eating I glanced over to the bar to see the manager, hostess, bar tender all eating chips and dip at the bar due to it all slowing down. The server came right over to ask if everything was ok and began leaving before we could answer. We would like more drinks. Buser never cleared our table. I had to put dirty dishes on the table being cleared next to us. Service was negative stars. I have two stars because the food was really good, the environment was ok. Some cobwebs in corners and the building is a little shabby, but it goes with the vibe. I would rather have stellar service and ok food than great food and not great service.

This is our second time and the food has yet to disappoint. My husband ordered the maple mule and…read morehe said it was very good. We started with the poutine and it was great! All the ingredients tasted fresh, and there was a ton of gravy. Next, we ordered the steak tacos and the fish tacos. Unfortunately our tacos fell apart half way through. We ate them with a fork and they were just as good. The fish had a great batter, and the steak was tender. This came with corn and bean salsa. My only complain is, the restaurant and bar were almost empty so we decided to sit at the bar. The bartender was not attentive. We were finished for almost 15 minutes before he checked on us. We were ready to go and had to wait awhile. This happened when we were here the last time, too. If he service was as good as the food, I would give it a 5:5.

Amazing atmosphere!!! Manager and all staff were extremely nice and welcoming!!! Service was…read moregreat, as was all the different types of food we ordered during our stay. Highly recommend to anyone in the Old Forge area!!!

Wings and clams are amazing. Great food and service. If this place would stay open later it has the…read morebest bar scene in old forge. Brick Wally's with lots of TVs for sports. Pool table and plenty of seating. 10/10 and would come back again soon!

I ordered right off the menu. It was garlic something the…read more I grew up knowing the Tony Harper's in Raquette Lake. This is very different even though it's the same name. I ordered the garlic Parmesan wings, I never eat wings, hoping that it would have a really strong flavor. Boy was I wrong. There was no flavor whatsoever however, they were cooked perfectly though. I also got a local hard cider and it was amazing. We had to sit at the bar outside because I had my dog with me and there was nowhere else to sit. Service was average nothing amazing. I probably won't try it again.

We were in town for the Saranac Lake Winter Carnival, staying in Tupper Lake, and finally decided…read moreto check out P-2's after driving by countless times. As a sucker for Irish pubs, the combination of food and live music had us sold. Walking in, the place has that well-worn, welcoming vibe you expect from a long-standing local favorite. Even on a busy Friday the 13th, the bartender/waitress greeted us with a huge smile and instantly made us feel at home--she deserves a raise! We grabbed a high-top, ordered drinks and food, and everything hit the mark--solid, satisfying pub fare. The live music was a treat too; the guitarist/singer was fantastic. Overall, our first visit was a home run. Friendly staff, good food, and great music--can't wait to come back!

Great local pub. Michelle took it over from her dad, P-2. She has excellent food for a bar and the…read moreatmosphere is friendly and welcoming.

This is a great place to go to on St. Patrick's Day parade day morning in Utica. Service is great…read morethat day, the bartenders are attentive and friendly (especially if Linda is there). Any other time, if you are not a regular, this place might not be for you. I've been here several times with mixed experiences. The last time I was there was a Thursday in the summer of 2024. My husband, brother and I were excited to find seats at the bar and order dinner. The bartender was a short blonde woman and there was a male bar back. The bartender did not acknowledge us for over 15 minutes. We were actively looking at the menu on our phones and talking about what we wanted to try and attempted to make eye contact with her as she walked by us with no luck. She didn't even say "I will be right with you", literally no interaction. She was very friendly with everyone else around us seeming to know exactly what they were drinking and happy to get it for them. We left as we felt very unwelcome there and ended up having excellent service down the street at Lukin's.

This place is a home run. Admittedly we had limited options along our route as we were headed home…read moreto CT on a Monday after a long weekend in Seneca Falls. We found this little gem and holy toledo did we we strike gold. First of all, the hostess was super nice and greeted us right away even though she was clearly busy and hustling. We chose to sit outside at a picnic table to soak up the beautiful weather. The outside is fun with brightly painted picnic tables and murals on the building. Our waitress was very knowledgeable of the menu and offered great suggestions. She was great and we really enjoyed interacting with her. We started with rum punches which were made with freshly squeezed juice and they were out of this world. We shared the "everything" wings which were crispy and that sauce was delicious. We were tempted to lick the sauce off the plate. We refrained so we didn't get strange looks. I had the Kimchi Reuben which is made with house made kimchi I might add. My husband got the Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich. We both opted for Poutine Fries for our sides. Guys, this food was unique and spectacular. I'm just bummed it's 3 hours from home! But I'll definitely make an effort to be back.

It was such a vibe the food was great music was great and the bartender was so sweet I would…read moredefinitely go here again

Great bar, great food, great service. The decor was fun,…read moreeverything is clean and the patrons are nice. Perfect place to watch sports

This place was a life saver. So the story was, our car broke down so we had to limp our car to this…read moreplace. The food was excellent and they let us stay here long after our food was done while we waited to get picked up.

Absolutely amazing food very good home cooked meal rodeo burger ,chicken casidiea and chicken…read moresandwich was all very good great service and reason price.

Great food pub just outside the Blue Line! Stopped here for the first time on a rainy day and…read morefound out they just reopened after installing new floors! Nice cozy log cabin vibe with great burgers and wings! We just purchased a cottage near by so we'll definitely be back!

Food was very good. Cheeseburger noodle soup was yummy…read more Chicken salad with bacon and cheese was very good. Chicken was white meat and fresh. Spouse had ham wrap also good. Lots of ham. Walt was by himself bar and restaurant tables and did a great job handling and juggling everything. Very friendly. Inside, typical small town local bar. Doesn't appear to have beer tabs. Has lottery and note cash only. Appears to have a great local following. I would recommend a pit stop here. Ps bathrooms were spotless.

Excellent pizza and wings The delivery was right on time. Everyone there is extremely friendly I…read morehighly recommend this restaurant to everyone

Great selection of beers and great vibe setting. Service was friendly and attentive. Didn't have…read moretime for food but will be back! Thank you!