Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Mustard Seed

    5.0 (1 review)

    The Mustard Seed Photos

    THE MUSTARD SEED ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Mustard Seed

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Liz C.
    174
    249
    2944

    1 year ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Lindsay L.

    Lindsay L.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Mustard Seed

    You might also consider

    Overpass Pizza - 12" thin crust pepperoni pizza

    Overpass Pizza

    4.6(38 reviews)
    16.9 mi
    $

    This was our first time visiting Overpass Pizza and we were so surprised! It's in an unassuming…read morelittle building - off the beaten path. When we arrived we were seated right away but it was buzzing with locals and pick ups (good sign, right?!) We really enjoyed looking at all of the local memorabilia on the walls and our service was EXCELLENT! The woman that served our table was very friendly, upbeat, and knew exactly how to take care of her guests. Our food came out very quickly and we enjoyed all of it. We had the 12" thin crust pepperoni pizza and some garlic bread. Next time we'd like to try either the deep dish or some of the house special pizzas. I was pretty shocked to see that our total was over $45 for the 12" pizza, bread, and two drinks with tip. But really everything else made it worth it. And we got a slice of the most delicious almond cake on the way out for free - score!

    7/5 stars...yes, it's that good!!…read more Dad was visiting in Lafayette, and wanted to try something new. Found this gem, listed as one of the best pizza places in Indiana, and I was NOT let down. Pros - Service- Our two waitresses who were working and helping all the tables were amazing! Friendly, joking, amazing. - Food- I order a personal meat (thin crust), app of breadsticks, and my Dad got the pepperoni pizza sandwich. All were amazing! Hot, fresh, tons of toppings, and very affordable. - Atmosphere- The atmosphere was great. Fun and had a few funny signs (see below). While this place is small, it is friendly, good, and we'll worth checking out, no matter where you are! Cons None

    Photos
    Overpass Pizza - Funny sign in the restaurant

    Funny sign in the restaurant

    Overpass Pizza - Cheese bread

    Cheese bread

    Overpass Pizza - Order of breadsticks. Sauce was great (I wish they sold it).

    See all

    Order of breadsticks. Sauce was great (I wish they sold it).

    Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    3.6(11 reviews)
    58.6 mi

    I have ordered delivery from the Downtown location before but this was my first time visiting any…read morelocation in person. It's very cool on the inside with vintage and Indiana-themed decor, tin ceilings, and, of course, a potbelly stove. The staff were friendly. But brother and I were very confused about the ordering process. There wasn't a lot of directional signage showing where to start and each step of the process. I watched a few other customers go through and they didn't seem like they had a problem so maybe it was just us. Next time I would probably just order online and pick it up so I could avoid the in-person ordering process altogether. I had the turkey sandwich and it was pretty good. I would say definitely a step up from your typical sub sandwich chain in terms of flavor and toppings options. I tried the chili mac as well. The chili is definitely à la Wendy's but I enjoyed it. The mac and cheese was good as well. I'd probably get either on its own but not together again. I also tried the Potbelly/Zapp's collab chips, the Hot Pepper flavor. They were good but are definitely not for everyone. When I visited, most of their fountain soda options were out of order so I settled on a no sugar added Pineapple Passionfruit juice/soda which was actually pretty good. We'll definitely be back - especially to try out their milkshakes!

    So excited to have a Potbelly on the south side of Indianapolis! They are one of the better chain…read moresandwich shops in my opinion and when I went in, the person working behind the counter took the time to talk to me about the menu and asked me what I liked. I had the meatball, which was really good and the meatballs tasted homemade - they actually ran out after me so I got the last batch!

    Photos
    Potbelly Sandwich Shop
    Potbelly Sandwich Shop
    Potbelly Sandwich Shop

    See all

    The Mustard Seed - breakfast_brunch - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...