Can't wait until they reopen. Best food around, on top of amazing customer service! Father and son team showed food was prepared with love.

Regular market-goers know that the Pantry is a tried and true fave. Their menu airs on the "heavy" side of lunch, but there are great salad and wrap options as well as their AMAZING salmon. Order the salmon with broccoli and you'll forget it's healthy, it's that good. Their mac and cheese is some of the richest, yummiest I've ever had. The menu may be a little overwhelming the first time you go because it covers so much ground, but you really can't go wrong. I've never had a bad meal, plus they have great specials too. The service is friendly and speedy. One thing I really wish they'd change is all the plastic... food comes in a styrofoam container and automatically comes in a plastic bag with a plastic pouch of plastic utensils... and there's no refusing it, I've tried :/ read more

This little place is really great. The menu varies and ranges from club sandwiches to salmon dinners complete with two sides. I've always gotten a good value for the money. I'm a fan of the daily soup change read more

Great food and great service! Just wish I worked closer to it. Nothing I would change, more chicken in sandwich than I expected made it very filling. read more

The Pantry - Grilled chicken ranch wrap with mac and cheese - Specialty Food Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Tucked in the southeast corner of City Market, this gem awaits. I'd heard from some people that it was some solid food so I had to see for myself. I was their first customer of the day and ordered my meal of salmon, with the two sides (I got Mac&cheese and broccoli). The salmon was flavorful and a big portion, I couldn't even finish it all. The broccoli was cooked perfectly with enough flavor, but not coated in butter and/or salt. And the Mac & Cheese was sooo good- not greasy or too much/little cheese. I wanted to just keep eating it all. AND it was $10... $10.80 with tax... I mean, what a steal for what I got! Definitely give this place a try on your lunch hour downtown! read more

The Pantry - Salmon with broccoli and Mac & cheese - Specialty Food Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

If you like Caesar Salad, then I highly recommend the Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap! Great grilled flavor of the chicken paired really well with the mini salad (including a few croutons!) inside the wrap. And the portion was generous too! If you need more than this, they do have some sides, but I haven't tried those yet. Located in the south east corner of City Market, there is an order window with some of the entrees written out on small black boards. They also have printed menus on the right of those. When it is your turn to order, they take your payment, give you a number, and then you wait for it to be called. I grabbed one of the bar stools nearby that looks like it is from an unused kitchen (maybe they have classes or demonstrations there.) For dining, you either take your selection to go or haul it up the stairs to the seating that overlooks the market. This is a place I would gladly return! Review #2297 read more

See all

This place was ok. It is just located in the City Market where there are tons of great places to grab a bite. So, the bar is set pretty high in that place. I ordered the chicken salad and it was decent and they put a lot of it on the croissant. However, it was so heavy that it wold not stay on the bread and just feel into my tray when I picked up the sandwich. The potato chips looked and tasted homemade. They were pretty good too. They have limited drink options and no fountain drinks. I went to the cookie shop and got a drink (along with some after work treats). This place is not bad and the food is decent. It is actually closer to a 3.5, but that is not an option so I went with a 3. read more

The Pantry - Specialty Food Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Ladies and gentleman: I just had a food baby. His name is Fried Chicken. He, like many other babies, was the result of gluttony and lack of self control...I just couldn't. seem. to. put. the. chicken. down. Hell, at one point in the meal I ended laying on my couch with the paper plate on my belly and ate only the skin off of one of the pieces- because it was that damn good and I knew I wouldn't be able to make it to the insides. I've long heard of Chef Brad Gates Fried Chicken Wednesdays and the day finally came for me to step up to the counter and place my order for the $10 meal that comes with a generous serving of Quebec Mac n' cheese and a cord salad/relish. I'll admit that the sticker price of $10 gave me a bit of shock at first for lunch, but when they handed me that fresh pile of three hefty piece of chicken, I quit my internal bitchin' because this, my friend, was not one meal but two. When meals of this nature come way, I like to justify the price by saying, "well, technically it's $5 each meal." Tucked away in the southeast corner of City Market, The Pantry makes use of local ingredients and shines even brighter in my eyes with multiple herb plants growing on the counters and windowsill. I'd like to think that the herbs found in my meal came directly from those charming plants. In addition to daily lunch offerings, Chef Brads Gates also runs a catering business. Many of the meals/menus that are available are piled on a shelving unit at the store's front. I look forward to spreading the cheer of the fried chicken and sampling many other menu offerings down the road. read more

The Pantry - Yeah, he's a big deal:) - Specialty Food Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Salmon (crisp to perfection), broccoli (seasoned well), mac and cheese (creamy goodness).... Phenomenal!!! I can't wait to go back! It's in the City County Building near the Market Street entrance. read more

The Pantry - Salmon, broccoli, mac and cheese.... Phenomenal!!! I can't wait to go back! - Specialty Food Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

It's not too bad. Definitely the "foodie-est" food vendor in City Market. Lamb burger was cooked well, but could use a little more salt and some kind of sauce (tzatziki perhaps?) to moisten it up a bit. Macaroni and cheese is definitely made from fresh cheese and not from a packet. Fried chicken could use some additional seasoning as well. Wait times are a little longer (5-10 minutes) than other vendors because everything is made fresh. read more

The Pantry - Specialty Food Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The Pantry is my go to in City Market. Their chicken is delicious and they have several items on their menu with it in it. The chicken Cesar wrap with a side of steamed broccoli is my favorite meal they have but they are known for their chicken fingers. They give you a huge portion of the chicken fingers and the breading is unlike any other!! They do cook everything fresh to order so expect to wait 10 mins sometimes on your food if their is a line. Try to go a little before noon or right around 1 to beat the crowd. On days they are offering chicken fingers, they sometimes run out before 1PM. read more

The Pantry - Caesar salad- not on the menu but they can make it! $10 - Specialty Food Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The food here is amazing. The Mac and cheese is probably the best I have ever had. There is nothing I've got from there that I haven't liked. Got the Parmesan chicken sandwich that was amazing. Some of the best food at the city market. I highly recommend the chef salad if you feel like a salad. It is loaded with goodness. read more

I'm discovering more places around the City County Building for lunch almost weekly! I usually bring my lunch but once in awhile I venture out for something different. Brad' s Kitchen has never disappointed! From their freshly made chef salad to OMG MAC AND CHEESE to today's Fish and Chips! As usual, the service was fast and friendly. The FISH AND CHIPS was DELICIOUS! Fried catfish nuggets with the lightest, tastiest batter and creamy cole slaw! I had to give my cole slaw away to a friend-- can't have seafood and cole slaw on the same day, but she stated it was delicious as well. I just wish the meal included FRIES instead of bland potato chips ! read more

The Pantry - Specialty Food Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Food here is fantastic! I came for lunch on a weekday and had the mini Cuban sandwiches and mixed greens (the menu changes daily). The Cubans were perfect portions and were "standard" Cubans -- ham, shredded pork, dill pickles, Swiss cheese, and mustard. I hate when someone offers Cubans and it's not the standard. Not a problem here! Also, the bread was crusty and perfectly grilled. The mixed greens were fresh and included fine shreds of other veggies. If you are picky, be forewarned, it is hard to pick things out! The dressing was ok, a little sweet for me. I also thought the service was a tiny bit slow, as I was the only customer and there were three people behind the counter. They have a great selection of cheeses and offer free cheese tastings -- I think they are on Saturdays at 11. I will definitely be back. read more

OMG---Love the buffalo chicken wrap, mac&cheese,ceasar chicken wrap, quesadillas...haven't had anything that wasn't good! Excellent value at the City Market! read more

Love the City Market and all the new vendors. Today I tried The BEST chef salad at The Pantry! It was a huge portion with dark, leafy greens, bacon, ham, turkey, hard boiled egg, cheese, avocado tossed in a delicious light vinegarette! Under $10! Very tasty and highly recommend! Forgot a photo...ooops! read more

The Pantry Used to be very good, but once Brad Gates and his team left the service and quality of the food unfortunately went downhill.

Forgot to take a picture, but my husband and I came here for lunch today. He got the game and cheese panini and liked it a lot. I got the BBQ slider and mac and cheese - both were delicious! For me the slider and small order of mac were plenty for lunch, and only $7! The only reason I gave four stars instead of five was that for a place in city market, I felt they were slow. Other than that, I would highly recommend! read more

The Pantry is another of my regular lunch places in Indy. The food is always excellent if you're willing to wait. I really enjoy The Pantry's food. My usual order is a grilled chicken breast with a side garden salad. Boring, right? Well, they save me from my boring order and make that the best dang grilled chicken and greens you can get, anywhere! The salad dressing is very unique and great, but it can be a little too salty sometimes. The airline chicken breast is always very moist, tender, and flavorful. I also particularly enjoy their club, nachos, and burgers. Everything I can order here is a step above most lunch places' food. The service is good - I like that with the open kitchen, you can watch them cook and 'plate' your food. My only complaint is that it tends to be very slow - you can wait 15 minutes for your take-out lunch on an average day. This delay is because they cook to order, so your food is always guaranteed to be fresh. I highly recommend going to The Pantry for lunch if you have the time to wait. read more

Brad is an all around tribute to the ginger take over! From finger licking fried chicken, to succulent beef satay...it really doesn't matter the dish, it's divine! His food is carefully crafted by hand ( I've seen him slaving away cutting individual ravioli so by hand...trust me he does it all!) which proudly displays the true craftsmanship of a true chef. On top of having simply an amazing culinary gift, Brad and his team are a true testament to classic hospitality. I once asked Brad to cater my father's surprise 50th party at Flat12. Now being a young college student, my resources were limited, but I wanted only the best for dad. I told Brad of my needs and he threw together a buffet menu that not only blew my guests away, but did not break my budget. Brad even gifted my family with extra appetizers and desserts to ensure that my guests were fed and happy. I will push any newly engaged couple, any family party, any corporate event, shoot any folks in need of a quality caterer to Brad Gates. He is by far one of the best chefs in Indianapolis. read more

See all

Just stopped by the counter today for a REALLY late lunch and I was that annoying customer that comes up a few minutes before closing. So glad I caught them and they were willing to still let me buy food. The mac and cheese was yummy! And I got plenty of chicken tenders. read more

First time trying The Pantry...Ordered chicken quesadillas...it was pretty good but would've been better with pico rather than just raw onions. read more

Insanely Good lunch spot. The Mac and cheese is unreal. Well worth the wait and cost. read more

See all

Chef Gates is world class and cooks things to order. His culinary training was top flight and he has been chef de cuisine at some of the best restaurants in NYC and elsewhere. While his luncheon service at The Pantry is great, it is really an adjunct to his catering business. Way worth the visit and the short wait (since he cooks to order). My latest sojourn was for the fish cakes and mixed green salad. Delicious. In the City Market, the southeast corner. Go now. read more

As a lactose intolerant individual, I tend to avoid tomato soup. There's always an element of cream that tastes wonderful in the moment but causes me pain later lol. Well today I tried THE BEST Tomato Soup that I've ever had! And to top it off, it was made with Coconut milk, so regrets later on this evening. It was a Tomato Heirloom and Red Curry soup: creamy, delicately tomatoey with a hint of spice from the curry. There were also bits of crunchy green veggies incorporated throughout (not sure if it was scallions or basil) but it was delicious. read more

i could live in Sliderville!! Love the club with turkey, Goose bacon, & avocado...frequent sliders include bison (i love theirs) & their Cuban slider read more

The Pantry - Specialty Food Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Do yourself a favor and get the MAC N' CHEESE, it is the best I've ever had and believe me, I have had a lot in my life! I'm a vegetarian so there's not a ton of other food I can eat, but I also will get the seasonal veggie or a small salad and they compliment the mac nicely. :) Wait times are longer than other places at City Market but I don't even care, I'd probably wait all day. read more

This used to be one of my favorite places to eat. And I dont know if they switched owners or what but it has gone down hill. The food is still good but no nearly as good as it used to be. Also today when I stoped to get a salad the cashier asked me if I was Pregnant!!!! No I am not!! I dont even look it thank you! The old people need to come back and run it again. read more

The sliders are all very good. The BLT is large and memorable. It will remain in your thoughts long after its time has past. One of the best options to eat at in City Market, maybe the best. read more

The Pantry - Half club, ridiculously good sandwich. - Specialty Food Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Wow! Chef's salad is HUGE! Very tasty with everything you'd want in a salad. I couldn't finish it all for my lunch so I will take the rest home. I will be back to try their BLT next. Lot's of fishy choices as well - fare which the City Marker lacks. read more

Excellent mac & cheese along with steelhead trout slider made up for the sour puss attitude of the lady taking orders. I'd eat here again, but would hope to not receive the same cold glare. Funny, she was all smiles and the young man in the business suit. read more

The front desk was really cool with me. And the food was great! It took around ten hours to get my food but...

Came across the pantry while cruising the city market; decided to give it a try. Yes, more expensive than the competition because it is locavore and organic, but my bison and Gorgonzola burger was absolutely wonderful. Perfectly charred and served medium rare on a delicious roll, with a slab of tomato with taste, I savored every juicy bite. read more