What a gem! I am so pleasantly surprised by the food choices in the Valpo area and I will be back, but I needed something light before some ice skating and the Rolling Stonebaker was in the perfect spot (THANKFULLY). I love a great wood fire pizza and this place is excellent. Small with a few tables, but filled with so many choices for both pizza, other items, and drinks. Love that they have a great spot to sell out of a window to those visiting the park area for events (SMART). The choices for pizzas had me wanting all of them, but I finally settled on the Sticky Finger and the Joker. I was so impressed with the Sticky Finger that I still think about those flavors all together. It was a perfect fit for my palate and I loved it. The Joker was also great and the hubby loved it. We had a peach old fashioned to share (needed that before busting our butts on the ice rink, liquid courage) and the staff was excellent with keeping our waters filled and making sure we were well taken care of. PROS: Great spot downtown, next to event center areas Wonderful choices to fit all tastebuds in pizza choices Cocktail choices that are fun CONS: Parking, at the center near the ice rink (you can walk there though) read more

See all

I have walked by this place countless times. Finally looked at their menu & got a special of their fig papa only without the cheese. It was SO good. It was the perfect bit of sweet & savory. Their vegan pizza is also quite delicious. It has a wide variety of toppings that make it so tasty. My husband got their Philly bread special and loved it so much. Unfortunately he went to get it again & it wasnt available. But we will be keeping an eye out for it! He got the potato Pizza & enjoyed it. Only downside is that it is on super thin crust. Not really a save for later thing since it makes it more soggy unless heated in an air fryer. The service is good too. They answer questions and are nice. Might just have a longer wait if its a busy time of day or weekend since theyre downtown. read more

See all

I love finds like this. Totally unexpected but absolutely delightful! When my husband said he wanted pizza I was a bit disappointed. We were in a city we had never been before and I was looking forward to a culinary adventure and then he says pizza...ugh! But then we find this cute little place and a culinary adventure we had!! The inside is small and cozy and our waitress was the kindest young lady! We didn't order drinks but it was a nice surprise to see that was an option. We started with the meatballs and let me tell you, there were delicious! It was a very generous serving and we ended up taking some of them to go. The pizza is fun and creative, but there's also the familiar toppings available for those less adventurous. We settled on one with bacon jam because hello, how delish does that sound? The pizza is the perfect size to share! They have a walk up window and it was jamming the whole time we were there. After tasting the pizza I can definitely see why!! read more

See all

We were greeted when we walked in. Small yet cute spot. They hada decent menu on paper but my tastebuds didnt agree with the brussel sprouts the bread pudding however was a hit. I forgot to take a picture. read more

The Rolling Stonebaker - Pizza Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

See all

We had a delightful server. Having not live In the area, she welcomed Us in and gave us some suggestions. She did not lead us in the wrong direction. Everything was delicious. We had the stoner bites and the featured pizza. It was out of the box, fig jam, Gorgonzola and prosciutto. It had good flavor that hit several senses, salty from the prosciutto , sweet from the fig jam. I can't explain the Gorgonzola other than yum. I would definitely order it again. read more

I love coming here! Their pizza is so good and comes out super quick. I've had the Sticky Fingers, Choke-n-shroom, and Italian Queen. They also have some really good triffles that are often featured at the Valpo events concerts. The pistachio and chocolate one was good and rich. I just had their strawberry rhubarb triffle. It was so good! The tang from the strawberry rhubarb compote complimented the sweet cream/cookie crumbles. They are in a prime location, which is great. I'll definitely be back to try more pizza and desserts. read more

The Rolling Stonebaker - Strawberry rhubarb triffle - Pizza Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

I love the pizza and the staff... so friendly. My husband and I come here every time we get to Valpo. It's a cute place but seating is very tight. read more

Nope, to their pizza. The restaurant is entirely too small, but we do like the window when we're out in the summer. Service has always been good. I guess I'm just not a fan of their pizza. They have a pretty good alcohol list and we tend to buy from them during the popcorn festival . read more

Really good, thin crust, crispy, chewy cheesy, awesome sauce pizza. If you like a thin crispy crust with some char and flavorful toppings, this is a must. The pepperoni was exactly what you want a classic pizza to be. The sticky fingers was also excellent, the bacon jam made for a nice twist (I would add jalapeños next time, some heat would be a killer with that combo!) Definitely heading back next time I'm in town, about a dozen more items I need to try. read more

Delicious pizza every time! Fresh ingredients and just the right crispness to the crust!

I think the place is really amazing here. The ambiance is really relaxing and chill. The customer service is absolutely amazing. The delicious food was quick and the quality is delicious, makes you wanting to come back for more. This will definitely be my go to spot for the summer. read more

The Rolling Stonebaker - Cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

See all

I loved it! Ordered it last night and I got the Sticky Fingers pizza and the Heirloom Tomato salad; it came with a super good pesto.. yummmm! My new favorite pizza place in Valparaiso! Delicious!! read more

The Rolling Stonebaker - Sticky Fingers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

Stopped in after a chiro appt. Husband LOVES wood fired pizza and didn't know this existed. So... here we are. The menu looks fantastic. And their drinks looks delish! I'd return, for sure! We started wjth the Holla Back Poppers. Because we live jalapeño's and spicy stuff. So good! And wow! The spice! Which made this app even better!! I had the Isla Mujeres drink (I believe). It was a passion fruity drink. Yum! Not sure what my husband had. He likes to drink a couple different drinks, because why not!? LOL We both ordered a pizza and shared. I got the Eggman pizza. Because I love eggs and I love pizza. And this did not disappoint. Husband had The Joker. More spicy. More jalapeño. :) both so good! Definitely a little gem in downtown Valparaiso. read more

The Rolling Stonebaker - Eggman - Pizza Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

See all

This place is disgusting because while they're preparing food, they're touching dirty racks, dirty money, not even going to wash their hands or at least put gloves on if you change them so what but I will never go back to this place either disgusting read more

We stopped by the window here today while walking around downtown. We ordered 2 veggie marinara pizzas. I like that they have a big to go window, so you don't have to go inside. The veggie marinara pizza was tasty, and vegan. I like that the pizzas are small and basically personal size. read more

Pizza was very delicious, Banana pudding dessert was amazing! Staff was nice. The place definitely has a cool little vibe of its own. Decor was nice to look at, originally name adult drinks. Indoor seating is limited but there's a large outdoor spot also. Location is great. I'm only sad the the pizzas are only 10 inches but even so we managed to fill up on delicious food. read more

The Rolling Stonebaker - a menu on the wall - Pizza Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

See all

Pizza was cold and overpriced for takeout situation. Extremely thin crust which is not our preference.

For anyone that thinks this is just a take out pizza place - you are wrong. The apps and non pizza items at this place are great and not what you would expect walking by. My only complaint is that the inside isn't larger and that they don't do delivery. read more

Small place with amazing food and drink. I had the Potato Head Pizza. It was a thin crust pizza with cheese, potatoes, and onions on it. It was so good. I also had the Warpigs Foggy Geezer. If you like a beer that has a hint of fruitiness to it, you will like this one. I did. There was a grapefruit taste to this one. This place has a friendly staff willing to answer questions. The prices are reasonable. There are not a lot of tables inside, very little room. But you can walk up to the window and order take out. Cute quaint place that I plan on going to again. read more

Great pizza and dessert! Unique recipes and friendly service. Very fresh ingredients. I enjoyed the thin crust pizza.

"This review is for Tuesday May 19, 2020" I originally wrote this on the 19th, but realized I wrote for the wrong location, and wanted to correct my mistakes by putting it here. So yesterday my Lady and I decided to take a drive from Hammond to Valparaiso and see if a restaurant we love getting Creole dishes from was open. Sadly found out they were closed permanently due to Covid19. While driving around seeing who was open, and what was new in the area. We happen to Find this place, The Rolling Stonebaker, decided if they were to be open during the week we would make a drive back out to try them out. Well come to find out they are closed on Mondays, but hey they were open for today (Tuesday to Sunday, unless this changes in future from when I write this). So These are the pizza we ordered, so we could give them a try: The Purple Pig Smoked Pork Shoulder | BBQ | Mozzarella/ Provolone Blend | Topped w/ A Tangy Purple Slaw. Strawberry Fields Strawberry, Basil, (and I may have to update review on other ingredients later) Eggman Roasted Garlic | Rictta | Prosciutto di Parma | Mozz/Prov Blend | Wood-Fired Egg | Arugula | Olive Oil | Parmesan | Balsamic Reduction First off just to say it out of all 3 of these pizzas my lady and I made an agreement that the Purple Pig is one of our favorites. It packs flavor. We loved mainly how the BBQ and the Smoked Shoulder go hand and hand with one another. The flavors are both sweet and tasty, what gives it even more flavor in my opinion is the purple cabbage they put on this pizza, it is a nice touch. Second we loved the different flavor you have with the Eggman pizza. We have never seen a pizza with a fried egg, but we were not going to judge it without trying it at lease. I got to say putting a fried egg on this pizza gives it just the right flavor. Third, there are two opinions here. My Lady loved this because the strawberry and basil as well other ingredient, to her she was able to taste all the flavors, but myself I honestly did not taste all the flavors, but it might be because with me I had tried all the other pizzas first and it inferred with my taste buds a bit. I guess I just like to eat my strawberries by them self. As far as each pizza goes, unlike other establishments these guys use a stone oven, with wood grilled (I think that is the proper wordage to use maybe). Unlike other places that use a pizza oven, I think Stone ovens give the pizza a different taste. A taste I prefer over other pizza places. Another thing I do want to point out, because of how things are now with Covid, and businesses slowly opening back up, one the gentlemen that took my lady's order, kindly brought the pizzas out to our car and when I asked if he could put the boxes of pizza in the back, buckled them in for us too, safety first right :) He was very nice and polite. Awesome Customer Service in our book! We tend to take random drives out to Valparaiso from time to time. So we will definitely be back to order either one these or a different pizza to try. read more

See all

Delicious fresh pizzas and interesting flavor combos! The corn pizza with cilantro and cotija cheese is my favorite thing on the menu.

My wife and I went here a while ago on a double date because we generally love downtown Valparaiso restaurants. The building is nice, but very small. Not only are there probably only half a dozen tables, but the tables are only a couple feet wide. The boyfriend of the other couple and I both got the sticky fingers pizza. We were both captivated at the sight of "sweet and spicy bacon marmalade." When the pizza came out, mine was a little burnt. I know it's a brick oven, which made it taste better, but I would have preferred it without burnt crust. I will say that both of us men thought our pizzas were really good. All the ingredients blended well, and the brick-oven taste was delicious. My biggest complaint was the size. It was a six-inch pizza (maybe a little bigger) on the thinnest crust I've seen in my life. I'm relatively thin, but I eat a lot, and the other guy we were with is a larger dude, so both of us were still starving after having finished our meals. I think we both enjoyed it, but we each paid $12 for what felt like even less food than a conventional appetizer. My wife got the Your Mom Goes to College, and she really enjoyed it, though it wasn't really my favorite. She and the other girl both enjoyed the restaurant, and I think would rate it higher, but my rating is for the man who needs to eat quite a bit for a meal: be prepared to buy two pizzas for yourself (and spend $25) or be prepared to leave hungry. If your appetite is usually on the smaller side, I'm sure this will be a fine place for you, and you'll enjoy it. Overall, I do like the food, and would gladly eat it again, just not for the price. read more

If you like eating pizza with cardboard then this is the place for you. Crust is hard and crunchy and lacks taste. Toppings are sparse. Not my idea of a pizza. Also, seems like you should be able to get them quicker since there is so little put into them! read more

Everything is delicious here! The meatballs are out of this world! I also love the soups in the fall/winter and breadsticks.

Awesome and consistent and consistently awesome. The closest thing to a problem is that the Choke and Shrooms is SO GOOD that it's tough to make myself try their new stuff. read more

The pizza overall is good. It's not as amazing as a lot of people hype it up to be. It also can take 20+ minutes depending on if they're running behind. Personally, I tried the pepperoni one and it was decent. It's definitely not my favorite style of pizza or pizza place but it's not horrible. I also think it is a little more expensive than a pizza it's size should be. It costs $9 for a pretty small pizza (maybe 10 inches)- It would probably only feed two hungry people. read more

Easily one of the best pizzas I've ever ate. Its a thin crust with so much flavor. They have so many unique kinds of pizza. My only regret was not getting another pizza, because when I went back to order another one, the line was so long. We had the Italian Queen and the Stoner Bites (Garlic Knots). I did also liked the quirky atmosphere and staff and their unique mixed drinks. Next time I want to try the Jalapeno and Corn pizza. read more

The Rolling Stonebaker - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

Went to Stonebaker today. My husband and I ordered two different pizzas. They were very busy but did a great job trying to keep up with the demand! Both pizza's were delicious! Hot out of the oven, it doesn't get much fresher than that! If your looking for something different, then go to Stonebaker's. They have traditional pizzas and also specialty pizza's and all come on a thin but tasty crust! I would highly recommend this place! read more

Amazing food and even better service in a cool little restaurant right on the square in Valpo, if you're in town you gotta swing in and try some of the weekly specials! read more

Wow, what a great little place in downtown Valpo. Came to see my son for family weekend at Valpo University and went to Rolling Stonebraker for a late Saturday lunch with my son wife and daughter. We ordered a mushroom cobbler, a stoner bites and two pizzas for four of us and they all were FANTASTIC! Stoner bites are a mandatory order item every time. They come with Parmesan cheese sprinkles and covered in garlic butter. The pizzas are crispy and delicious. I am almost downgraded to a four star review because of the seating (tiny place) but the food was too good to not give this place a five star review. read more

My favorite place in town. Have never had a bad meal. Take out order is always ready on time and the service is friendly. Would recommend to anyone looking for a good meal read more

Interesting pie's with perfectly fired (burnt) thin crust. One pie is more than enough for one person, but who am I to judge. Either way you can't go wrong nor would you regret giving this pie a try. read more

This place is just amazing. cozy little cabin with warm interior. Perfect for a brunch date. Their speciality is the wood fired thin crust pizza. we loved everything we ordered. read more

One of my TOP FIVE favorite places to enjoy a meal. They KILL it EVERY-TIME. Been going here for years: staff is amazing, food is amazing, drinks are yummy!!! read more

We end up getting food from here all the time. They really do a good job with their specials. It just keeps you coming back. I have enjoyed the choke and shroom since they opened, and many times I still get it with my order. Lately I have come to love the dates, although they do a damn good bread pudding or other special desserts as well. My new favorite pizza is the pickle. Sounds weird I know but it's fantastic. Also it's nice to get a cocktail to go on movie nights in the park. read more

Great I mean great pizza. What is able to be said other than this. They have amazing unusual pies that are wafer thin but amazingly crisp. read more

See all

Quick and easy place for on the go pizza! A great little spot right in the middle of town. Great for people who like basic pizzas or those who like to get a little creative. read more

A nice summer Friday night just screams wood fire pizza! Or first time here . The pizzas can be shared if you aren't too hungry, but we were. We ordered the garlic knots and one pepperoni pizza & one pepperoni & Italian sausage. Root beer was Triple XXX and it came in a glass bottle. The food did not disappoint! The nuggets were also cooked in the wood fired oven along with the pizza. I am surprised that other places don't do this. Since it was a nice night, they had their walk-up window open for those who wanted to order their food & eat outside. read more

Great pizza! Live eating here on the square. However we even rented their truck for a party and the pizzas were a huge hit. If you have an event I cannot recommend them enough. There was a huge downpour and they worked through the storm feeding it guests. They truly went above and beyond. To boot, the pizza is amazing. read more