Our first visit to Santini's and it won't be our last. Why did we wait so long to give you guys a try? We ordered bone-in wings in two sauces, boneless wings and mozzarella cheese sticks. Everything was delicious. The wings were moist and flavorful, the mozzarella cheese sticks were hand cut, huge and amazing. We were there on a Monday evening. The dining room was slow, but carry-outs were hoppin'. The atmosphere is relaxed, but nice enough for a date night. Love the Chicago Sports mural on the wall. Our server took wonderful care of us and made sure that we had everything we needed. In addition, since it was our first time, she provided us with a carry-out menu and then led us about the specials throughout the week. Give Santini's a try, you'll be glad you did! read more

Good prices. Quality food. Everything made in house. I can get an 8" pepperoni pizza and side salad for $11. It has light sauce automatically. Pulled pork sandwich is pretty good and economical too read more

This pizzeria keeps getting better & better... Every pizza.. every sandwich & side dish is prepared perfectly! The restaurant itself is spotless & the entire staff is friendly & a breath of fresh air! read more

We love love love this place!!! Food is so good and quick!!! Kids are pretty picky and really like the pizza and spaghetti!!! The pizza of the month is always something we enjoy! This month it's Buffalo pizza(even the kids enjoyed it). Fried chicken salad has the best dressing(that's made in house). I will try to get pictures before we dig in next time!!! ‍ place is so good give it a try you will be hooked! read more

Never eating fast food chicken from kfc or chikfila again. The chicken is absurdly delicious, like melt in your mouth. The sprite was on the level of mcdonalds. The mural on the back wall is my favorite part of the ambiance. The service was fast and everyone is nice. Im glad I live 1 mile away. Don't change anything santini's, it's perfect. read more

Food is made to order! I ordered a side salad, Santinis pasta, and the sausage and peppers. First thing is the customer service is top notch! From the phones to the delivery of the food! Everyone is so nice! I absolutely LOVE that they put cold food with cold food and hot food with hot. Meaning my salad isn't being wilted on top of a hot item. read more

Santini's - Santini pasta added mushrooms and spinach - Pizza Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

See all

Solid pizza, solid estimated time on pickup, especially it being a Friday evening. Have tried the other pizza joints around; Aurelios, Bam, and Cappo's. This could be our go-to pizza place. read more

Great specials. The family that owns it now is down to earth. If you haven't been here in a while it is better than ever!

So this is a very. Hit or miss place. The service is pretty good and I've dined in twice, and ordered delivery and picked up twice. The pizza is kinda 'bland' in a sense of mainly consisting of a greasy taste. They also mus think "extra" sauce is less sauce because twice I've ordered extra sauce on my pizza and got minimal sauce. (The extra sauce was to dilute the greasy taste) However the calzone was actually pretty good, and the fettuccini pasta was also pretty tasty. But for me to get a full 5 star review most of the menu better be great. And in this instance, it's hit or miss.. I'll continue to order from them but from a select few items. read more

Santini's - Supposed to be extra sauce... :( failed twice.. - Pizza Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

Ordered pizza for pickup tonight. Got large sausage and onion and bread sticks. It was one of the best pizzas I had in a while. Very great taste from the sauce to the crust. Bread sticks were good also.Service was great also no problem as it was on time. Did order pickup but the ambiance looked good . Will definitely order again when I am on the area. If you want a good pizza and price to go with it. This is the place. Thanks team. read more

Have made numerous trips from the west side of Gary to Santini's in the last couple weeks. My new favorite spot. Have had the ground sausage pizza and the cheese sticks and loved them. The best cheese sticks ever! Me and my pal Amanda have tried something different this time, we had the Cuban sandwich and the Stromboli. Fantastic!! I highly recommend this restaurant. The food is AMAZING!! We will return for more. Even with the only call in and carry out orders during this time, it's worth the trip. read more

Santini's - The Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Valparaiso, Indiana

Love this pizza!!! It's delicious!!! We also had the fries and cheese sticks and everything was amazing! The staff was super friendly and welcoming. The place is really clean. We were very impressed with this pizza! We recently Moved from Chicago to Valparaiso and have been in search of a true Chicago pizza and Santini's is definitely a true Chicago pizza!! My husband and I will definitely be returning again soon!! Thanks Santini's for making us feel welcomed in Indiana!! read more

Just ordered wings and fries. The fries were great!! Would of been better off dipping my adidas in ranch and eating them. Worst wings ever. Wayyyy over cooked and the Buffalo sauce was as mild as ketchup. Lesson learned read more

Don't bother. They used to be amazing, and then got cheap with their meat on the Santini Cheese steak.

We have gotten carry out here several times. Every single time it has been very delicious! Cheese sticks are AMAZING! Highly recommend getting food from here. read more

The Mozzarella sticks were the best we ever had, and the pizza is always good. We love the mural on the wall too. My wife and I ate there Saturday night and although it was not very busy, it should have been. We like what this restaurant is doing and will come back. The owner introduced himself to us and we chatted with him briefly. It's a hidden gem! read more

To be honest I wasn't expecting anything from this place. It was one of the last places to pick up food before heading home so we tried it. This building has been home to a handful of greasy places that never made it very long. We tried one of the failed restaurants and the inside was one of those places where you don't want to touch anything and you just want to go in to get your food and get out as fast as possible. Well the owners of Santini's have completely gutted this place. It looks completely different and is really nice. Now don't get me wrong it's not a fine dining joint, but for the type of food they serve it's definitely more than I expected. As their menu says they serve pizza, pasta, and wings. I got the Italian Meatball Sandwich and must say it was the best meatball sandwich I've ever had. I could tell that the meatballs were homemade, they were so good. It was only about $6 and, after eating it, I can honestly say if they charged twice that I would've happily paid that. The only thing I don't understand is their address. The shirt our waitress was wearing said Valparaiso, but we were in South Haven and the address they have on their take out menus doesn't exist. To make it easy, it's on US 6 across from the Al's Supermarket and next to the Subway. read more

Went up there for dinner looking to try their most excellent mozzarella cheese sticks and they ran out this has happened more than once I think they should have had more being a holiday and they were open knowing that they were going to be busy so I ordered spaghetti and meatballs and was charged extra for the meatballs my spaghetti dinner consisted of a dollars worth of sauce and 50 cents worth of pasta for $8.95 $3.00 for 3 meatballs just a big disappointment for a restaurant that has been in this area for many many years the waitress was as nice as she could be I blame this on the owners of the restaurant for not caring enough for their patrons to make enough product to last a whole night. read more

Visiting the area from out of town and decided to stop for some pizza to make the kids happy. Was not disappointed. My 3 kids devoured an entire large pizza. I ordered the santini pasta and it was delicious. A creamy tomato sauce with just the right amount of heat and a good portion of chicken, green peppers and onions. Pasta came with some good cheese breadsticks and dipping sauce. Waitress was super friendly and attentive, even after my son accidentally spilled a drink, sorry . Located in an unassuming strip mall this place should not be missed. Wish we lived in the area so we could come more often. read more

Santini's has by far the best customer service! Family owned and it shows. Now the pizza, Very good! I'm not gonna lie Gelsasamo's has always been my favorite pizza, but both are unique in ways. Hands down customer service goes to Santini's.... if you want a circle of garbage call JJ's Pizza Shack or Little Ceasars.. Family express gas station has better pizza then both.. Thank you Santini's for all the great Pizza's! read more

Went here for the first time tonight. Looks like the may have remodeled. Food was excellent and service was fantastic! Will definitely be going again! read more

I love the pasta dinners here. A order of wings and a asta dinner is enough food to feed 2 people. the pizzas are great too. much better than most of the other pizza places around here. read more

Decided to try this place because some people raved how good it was. I was disappointed! The tomato sauce was watered down and tasted exactly like cheap canned spaghetti sauce. Also, the breadsticks smelled very sour, even my toddler who loves breadsticks wouldn't touch it because the smell was overpowering. Never again. read more

This was my first visit at the new location. Same great service and food with a nice Chicago themed atmosphere. read more

See all

Still the best pizza in NWI and probably most of Chicago. I've gotten your pies for 30 years and after every one I eat I say the same thing. Don't get me wrong I like all kinds of pizza joints but yours are honestly better in flavor, texture and consistency than anywhere else I've eaten. That's a huge compliment, thanks for keeping your standards up there after all these years. It's not just me either, whenever company shares pizza from you they always say "that's really good pizza" read more

Great pizza!!! All of the ingredients are fresh and the dough is home made!! Definitely a great place to enjoy pizza. And Clara our waitress was wonderful!! Will definitely back again read more

Wasn't happy. Crust was tasteless like one of those pre-made crust you can buy at Strack & Van Til. Sauce had no taste either. Didn't taste any herbs or spices, and it seemed like there was barely any sauce on it. Was full of grease to. Had to pat down with seven paper towels to soak up. We picked it up a bit past our pickup time, but apparently they don't even have a warming rack because the box was ice cold, and the pizza was as well. Just all around bad. Waste of $14 dollars. The leftover (which there was a lot of) went right in the garbage. read more

Excellent pizza. Will be going back many times. Perfect crust plenty of cheese , delicious

Better pizza than JJ's and great specials everyday. The new mostaccioli, pulled pork, and Cuban sub are great additions as well.