Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Smithy

    4.0 (121 reviews)
    Closed 5:00 pm - 9:00 PM

    The Smithy Photos

    THE SMITHY ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Casual
    Outdoor seating
    Good for groups

    Recommended Reviews - The Smithy

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Surf and turf excellent. We had a party of11and it  went very smoothly. The food was excellent and the service was excellent as well.

    We had the surf and turf and it was excellent, The service was excellent as well. I highly recommend.

    Rachel B.

    We had such a nice time visiting The Smithy last night. The host was very friendly and gave us a seat very close to the fire place which was lovely. The service was very polite and informative, as it was our first time there. The salad bar was very fresh with a few different choices. The cracker station with cheese block was a fun and different option rather than your usual bread basket. I decided to go with the filet mignon and baked potato and my fiancé ordered the striploin and lobster tail. We both enjoyed our meals very much. The ambiance was cozy and the service was warm and welcoming. We wish we lived nearby, we would definitely come often. We will definitely visit the next time we are in town. Thank you for such a nice evening!

    Sonia S.

    Really enjoyed my meal. The steak was perfectly made. I'm very particular of my steak and they made it exactly how I like it Will be back soon

    Best porterhouse I have seen in a while. Huge filet.  Ron loved it. His birthday meal, he said it's the best he has had, perfectly cooked!

    First trip to The Smithy did not disappoint! Took Ron for his birthday. Ron, a trained chef with very discerning taste, loved it. Said porterhouse was the best he has had and wants to go back next week. We will. My birthday ! Well worth the half hour ride. Everything very very fresh. Great salad bar too. I loved the cod and many fish options ! Recommend the baked potato with butter and sour cream, just like grandma made served in tin foil too. Beautiful atmosphere, much to see on the walls and lovely antiques, fireplace. Great for this time of year too. RJ recited all of the many specials with ease ! Great service, very attentive.

    Clam chowder
    Sara N.

    We came here for my moms birthday, per my brothers recommendation, as he is a frequent visitor who lives nearby & really likes this place. My hubby ordered clam chowder which he enjoyed, & I partook in the salad bar, which was good. We all got steaks, which were cooked to perfection, & seasoned just right. My brothers girlfriend really liked her salmon as well. This place has a nice ambience, but service was definitely on the slower side.

    Steak and Baked Potato

    See all

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - The Smithy

    Osteria Romana - Monroe - Risotto Allo Seafood - OO

    Osteria Romana - Monroe

    4.2(237 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    $$$

    There's free valet here but I'd bring cash to tip the valet personnel. It was a nice touch…read moreconsidering their parking lot is small and full. The interior of this place is incredibly beautiful and so inviting. I sat at the bar and saw many items on the menu that looked so good. I was in the mood for seafood and really wanted their zuppa di pesce but didn't want a whole portion because I know I wouldn't be able to finish it. The bartender told me that I could order a half order which was incredibly exciting. I checked out the rest of the venue and the outdoor area in the back which was kind of magical. I tried a few mocktails, they were good, the coconut one was best. The dish I ordered was delicious, as well as the bread served with olive oil that had roasted garlic in it. I loved everything about this experience. I learned that they have an all you can eat buffet every Sunday for only 40 dollar. Can't wait to try it. Thank you Osteria!

    The ambiance is still very nice. We went on a Monday evening so it wasn't very loud, but I can see…read morehow it could get so because we had a table of very loud women next to us. Can't imagine if we multiplied that by any additional tables. I just want to bring up the bread. Such a wasted opportunity to serve something so inexpensive that has such an impact on the overall experience. The bread is bafflingly bad. It's dry, and hard and tastes like nothing. The garlic infused oil that should improve the old stale bread is served with the hard skin still on the garlic. That's not edible and it's also not easy to remove once it's all mixed together. A small complaint about the lasagna. It's mostly cheese and very difficult to find any pasta among the soupy cheese and tomatoes. The taste is good but it's a bit of a rip off to serve something like lasagna with one or maybe two layers. The chicken parm was still delicious as was the polenta appetizer. Service was friendly and prompt. If they could just fix the bread and garlic situation and maybe bulk up the lasagna with some noodles, we'd be back.

    Photos
    Osteria Romana - Monroe
    Osteria Romana - Monroe - Chocolate Lava Cake with Ice Cream

    Chocolate Lava Cake with Ice Cream

    Osteria Romana - Monroe

    See all

    Prime One Eleven - Scalloped potatoes

    Prime One Eleven

    3.3(371 reviews)
    1.4 mi
    $$$

    From the moment we started, everything was excellent. We ordered the Steak & Cheese Egg Rolls and…read morethe Fried Calamari as appetizers. The egg rolls were packed with flavor, and the dipping sauce was absolutely delicious. The calamari was perfectly crispy with great seasoning--cooked just right. For the entrées, I had the Delmonico Ribeye, which was cooked to perfection. It was warm, juicy, tender, and full of flavor. We also ordered the Steak Burger 111, which was equally impressive--juicy, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The drinks were also great and reasonably priced, which was a nice bonus. To finish the meal, we had Matilda's Chocolate Layer Cake. It was rich, delicious, and the perfect way to end the meal. Overall, everything was spot on from start to finish. Great food, excellent service, reasonably priced drinks, and quality throughout. We'll definitely be back again!

    Very loud, very pricey and very slow. We had a group of 6…read moreand we could not hear each other speak over dinner. The place was packed which I thought was good because it was a sign of a good spot. But we noticed most people were at the bar. The server was friendly but obviously overworked. Basically brought us water and took our order. Never checked up on us during the meal. Food was very good to be fair and the portions were adequate. We just felt it was nothing great. They just took our order, dumped our food and that was it goodbye. Plus it was so loud it was just not enjoyable. There are so many places to eat in the area for great relaxing meal but this isn't one of them. We go out weekly but will not be back here.

    Photos
    Prime One Eleven
    Prime One Eleven - Oysters and clams on the half shell! Second time we went they are, so it's pretty decent!

    Oysters and clams on the half shell! Second time we went they are, so it's pretty decent!

    Prime One Eleven - Cappuccino

    See all

    Cappuccino

    The Smithy - seafood - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...