Stopped in for Cinco de Mayo. I was immediately greeted by a really nice guy. I wanted to pig out so I ordered a king steak burrito, rice and beans. I even paid $6 for extra meat. The dining area was clean with a large painting on the wall and the tv had the Cubs game on. I received my food and went home. The steak was tender but was lacking flavor. I was also disappointed in the amount of double steak. If this was double I would hate to see what it would have been without it. The salsas were good, red really has some heat, which I loved. The green salsa was herbaceous but had an overpowering citrus taste. The beans were creamy and delicious, they didn't taste burnt. The rice was also lacking a bit of flavor. I added some of the red salsa to it which helped a lot. I would go back, but I'm not in a rush. read more

See all

So placed an order there I figured it would be very delicious hopefully homemade and authentic. I ordered the burrito with steak not much steak. It was nice that the burrito was grilled a bit and that's all the flavor I picked up was the grilled taste of the burrito, kind of watery lettuce didn't seem fresh not much flavor really disappointed read more

This is one of my top top favorite Mexican restaurants. The food always hits every single time, I love ordering their enchiladas with the green sauce. I typically get my food to go and they're usually busy and active. In my mind it's Evanston's local spot to grab authentic Mexican food. I order and I have always felt like the people working the cashier are friendly. One of the reasons I come back for the great service, and of course the food! read more

Year to date I've eaten, best guess, 20 chicken burritos from a wonderful talented team. Once I got 3 shrimp tacos. So generous with the shrimp I could eat 2. Beatrice A's 5 review is true! read more

Hidden gem I'm so happy to have found within walking distance of my place! Prices are very reasonable, staff is incredibly helpful, and food is delicious. Typically, I order to go and wait and I always end up waiting no more than 10 minutes! Service is quick! read more

No sit down service but that's no issue. Local, friendly, good food. A little pricy but what isn't lately. Way too much salt in the rice and beans. So much so that it kills the flavor. Other than that a good place to eat. read more

These guys do a great job, fast, friendly and the food is always delicious. I usually get pretty much the same thing, a large pork burrito, its huge, they get it ready for me super quick and im out. PS. they are no longer open on Sunday. read more

Their tacos are amazing. We love their carne asada tacos but also their tripe taco (extra crispy). The workers here are always so nice. They're located in a plaza which makes parking quite easy. Definitely recommend!! read more

$4.25 for one taco is pretty crazy. $17 for a taco plate is even more crazy! This is still fast food, right?

So good! Who knew that this joint existed, but clearly others do as it was really busy on a Tuesday night. With that said the staff was super friendly and the food was outstanding. My kids loved it and jokingly wanted to come back for their birthday dinner instead of a steakhouse. They cook everything fresh to order and the aguas frescas were also great. Rock solid spot! read more

Food is delicious and authentic. Best tacos in the area for sure. Not to mention how friendly the staff is. Everyone is a primo there.

The food was so good and came out super quick! Service was great and everyone was super nice here. Very welcoming people and greeted my whole family when we came in. The restaurant was very cozy and pretty clean. Will be coming back! read more

The Supreme Burrito #1 - Mexican Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

ALWAYS good food, very nice employees and owners - always friendly. We have been going here since it opened a long time ago - they consistently have really good food and we've tried so many items through the years. We've had catered food for personal and church parties, too. We just love this place and the staff. read more

I have never been disappointed with this spot. It's a hidden gem, but usually fairly busy when I've been there. The staff is friendly and professional. The prices are comparable to other quick service spots in the area. I've had numerous menu items- burritos, tacos, quesadillas, taco salads, horchata, rice and beans, guac and chips- all delicious. I have literally no complaints about the food. I normally just order and wait inside (its all cooked fresh!) and we never wait more than 10 minutes. There's a good sized parking lot, though its down my street so I walk there often too. read more

This place is what I love about small Mexican places. Order at the counter. Everything is made when you order it. Good prices. No frills. Nice people who run it and good food. read more

I love going here. The service is fast and friendly. The food is out of this world. The prices are excellent. The menu is expansive and inclusive. I only wish there was more space because this place is regularly PACKED read more

The food is consistently delicious. Staff is very friendly & accomodating . I have been going here since they opened - from their burritos to there huevos rancheros to their delicious tacos & horchata . It's the best Mexican place ever ! read more

I usually get the queen beef burrito and it is always delicious! I sometimes add avocado which is a nice option. Great, friendly service and I love supporting a family business! read more

The best fish tacos! The fish is grilled so good we order from here all the time. And the people who work there are so nice and friendly. We support them 100%!!!! read more

Iykyk kinda place. You could easily pass this place up without knowing how legit good the food really is. Service is quick and ambiance is no frills, and there is limited seating inside. Never have had anything bad here, and portions are big. read more

The Supreme Burrito #1 - Steak Tostada and Tamale - Mexican Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

Good prices and portion sizes. The shrimp taco had a generous amount of perfectly cooked shrimp, and the lengua was nice and tender. But there was way too much sour cream and shredded cheese in each taco for my taste - each taco turned out to have a gooey mess of cheesy sour cream mixed with diced tomatoes on top of all the meat. I would have preferred some cilantro and just a sprinkle of cotija cheese to go with the lettuce and tomato. read more

They have the BEST veggie tacos anywhere! They recently brought back fish tacos--also excellent!

I love both the quality of food, as well as the very friendly staff at Supreme Burrito. The food is very reasonably priced and very delicious. Almost all their dishes can be made vegetarian. I highly recommend this place for lunch and/or dinner. read more

The Supreme Burrito #1 - Vegetarian Burrito - Mexican Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

They're very kind as I entered and checked out to get a pick up order, but I feel like their burritos are very small -- minimal, not full of many ingredients. The shredded chicken was very dry. I did like the green salsa, though. I asked for extra cilantro and jalapeño. I did not see any cilantro, and there was tiny bit jalapeño in the burrito. For the amount of $17 plus I'm paying, I would expect a more hearty meal with leftovers. They are OK! Ambience is just like any other taco/burrito joint, nothing too different. read more

Supreme Burrito #1 is an Evanston gem - consistently fabulous food & great service, whether eating in or picking up!

Food is great, the staff are really friendly. Every time I go they are always welcoming no matter the time

LOVE SUPREME BURRITO!!! Always fresh, fast, and delicious!! The steak burrito and Al pastor tacos are my faves! They also have a great taco salad and Flautas. I don't think anything they make could be bad. YUM!!!! read more

Delicious food and friendly service. I love the Asada Burrito. Will definitely be back on a regular basis.

Food was pretty good , prices fair, very large portions, friendly people working there, OK for fast food restaurant. Better than Taco Bell!

This is the spot in Evanston they have a little bit of everything. You can't complain about the ambience they always have either music or a good show on the TV. You can always catch a game. Good vibes freshes food and the owner is the best!! Service is fast! Dine in or carry out plus delivery! read more

The Supreme Burrito #1 - Mexican Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

Stumbled in the The Supreme Burrito #1. I was drunk, wounded, and hungry for trouble and food. "Leave your weapons at the door," was the thick, Spanish accented greeting that found its way to me from somewhere behind the tall counter. I unbuckled my gun belt and it drop to the plank floor with a thud. "What's good in this joint," I said through a week's worth of beard and chipped teeth that hadn't been washed since the Reagan administration, "and don't say everything," I warned the counter clerk, who looked like Roberto Duran in an apron. "Toda," replied Duran with a grin. Anyway, I got the 3 taco dinner (steak, beef, chicken) m, came with rice, beans, and drink. It was to die for. Thank god it didn't come to that. So enough of the above fictionalization. The food is awesome and the service is just as good. GREAT PLACE! read more

I have ordered from this spot several times but I notice when they forget something from my order there is no mention of forgetting the item or even apologizing for the mistake. I've called to talk to someone about the problem but instead they talk so careless and say things like "thanks for letting me know" or "it's all good." Which is a horrible thing to say after forgetting the customers food. The customer service here is horrible unfortunately. They don't like to take any responsibility for their own mistakes! I will no longer order from here. They don't care to give you your money back. They will tell you to contact the apps like it's not their responsibility at all! By the way, the food here is mid anyway! read more

Amazing reliably deelish burritos, tortas, tacos & great horchata - They're guac is amazing and the people who work there are consistently kind ! The place is always packed with people coming to take out or eating there. That says some thing right there. Five stars I've been eating there since it opened years ago !! read more

The food was absolutely delicious only thing I really didn't like was how loosely it was rolled but it won't lose a star over that other than that the meat was delicious I got the Cali style burrito it was freakin amazing (other than how loose it was) and I haven't tried it but they make Soups as well something amazing for this cold time of year!! Service was speedy and not too explosive and the place reminded me of an old birria spot I used to go to just amazing place really read more

Fantastic food and service! Always go with the vegetarian options and they are very flavorful and consistent quality.

First visit and I was tremendously satisfied. Authentic and delicious. Very friendly staff. No long wait. I ordered the chicken taco dinner, and it was absolutely delicious! I'm thinking about going back today or tomorrow, to try enchiladas or burrito, or both. read more

My son loves this place and I can see why. Great people work there and the food is good and reasonably priced.

Thanks to Yelp reviews, we ordered for pickup and found the food and service to be just as good as others have said. A friendly and helpful person took our order and I was able to pay in advance to save time, some pleasant and happy young patrons who were just leaving held the door, everything was ready and fresh when we arrived, and the food was great! I had the enchiladas verdes, my Father had a steak burrito, the loaded nachos were great (since I'm a vegetarian they gave us a generous portion of meat on the side), and my husband said the quesadilla was one of the best he's had -- with creamy and delicious cheese, tasty hot sauces and everything very fresh. We're about 15 minutes away but this will be at the top of our list for Mexican takeout. read more

Supreme is an Evanston staple serving up fire casual Mexican eats from tacos/burritos to enchiladas and even breakfast options like huevos rancheros. It's pretty "hole in the wall" but I don't say that negatively at all! Some sort of Fútbol is usually on the tv and the staff is very friendly and on top of their game. In my opinion, this is a taco place through and through. They even offer lengua (tongue) for you adventurous eaters out there. Tacos come with traditional cilantro and white onion and burritos come with lettuce tomato and cheese. The Al pastor is to die for-it is so juicy and you can tell it has been marinating over night. Don't forgot to sauce your food up with the salsa verde because it is simply better than salsa roja. read more

So a while back Jeremy C. and I were talking about the serious lack of good, cheap Mexican food in the North Shore. Somehow I've completely overlooked this place even though it's been around for a while and is a short hop from where I live. My parents mentioned it however, and I came with them for dinner recently. First of all, they have some excellent prices here. Even for a Mexican restaurant, the prices are pretty decent. Most of their dinners are less than $8. We ordered a burrito dinner special, enchiladas suizas, and a chimichanga. The dinners come with refried beans, rice, and a little salad (lettuce and tomatoes with sour cream). Food was delicious. The tortillas in the enchiladas were a little crunchy, not sure how they managed to do that but it was so good! The guys behind the counter are super fast and very friendly. Our food came out in what seemed like less than 5 minutes. They were eager to offer suggestions and were patient with some of our indecisiveness. Will definitely be back! read more

See all