I really wanted to love this place so badly, it was the only option for me on Uber Eats that involved customization with your Mac and Cheese. I placed my order and was excited for it to arrive and waited to take my bite and felt disappointment. The pancetta bread they gave me on the side which I paid extra for was soggy and burnt. The mac and cheese was not cheesy and lacked flavor completely. The only thing that was good with my order was the chocolate fudge cake though. read more

The Wheelhouse - sad bread. - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I hope this place shuts down. Honestly. For the first year or so in operation, it really was good. But I can't even begin to express how awful it is now. From the chef to the cashier and servers - not nice people and not accommodating. The food is so bad man. Cold soup that's watered down. Every grilled cheese soggy with unmelted cheese. Dude even my San Pellegrino is flat. Please don't order from here. The menu might be intriguing but you will not get what you hope. Ever. read more

The Cubano sandwich was my definite favorite, along with Hibiscus Spritz. Had I lived nearby, I'd be coming here for the $17 bottomless mimosas. The place was pretty busy when I got here for brunch, and I sat at the bar, but staff were friendly and they were very accommodating for seating situations as well. They don't serve hard alcohol, but the seltzers, beer on tap, and other drinks are pretty damn good. I love that my food came with two sides. You can pick the side options, I got a soup on this winter day along with some classic tots. I liked that the butternut squash soup was not too creamy and not too salty. Overall I'd come here again if I lived nearby. Apparently they also have some events for art I believe. I didn't pop in at the time, just caught the convo! read more

The Wheelhouse - Hibiscus Spritz - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The Philly cheese steak was delish but the Mac and cheese was awesome. Our server was very attentive. Perfect sidewalk seating.

The food is absolutely fantastic. I have ordered takeout and eaten in, and both times had excellent service and delicious, fresh food. Don't miss this gem in Brooklyn! Also nice to find a spot with a couple of IPA's in the menu. I'll be back for sure! read more

Yet again, another NY eatery that doesn't disappoint! Great little hole in the wall hipster joint with some of the most delicious plates around! Must try the Morning Wood (lol), and the Grass-fed Burger Melt! The ambiance was quiet, clean with an ice touch in decor! Will be back! read more

The Wheelhouse - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Sticking out like a sore thumb in a not quite yet gentrified section of Bushwick, this new gourmet grilled cheese shop has some incredibly delicious food. Once you step in, you get the hipster Brooklyn feel right away, from the decor to the clientele. They employ the Meatball Shop-style ordering system with menus that you mark off with magic marker to pick your selections. We had a good sampling of most of the items, all of which were excellent: - Tater Tots ($4) Great, simple tots with some Parmesan cheese sprinkled on top. These were nice and crispy and delicious with the thyme seasoning. - Crispy Fried Brussels Sprouts ($5) These were really incredible, and even better than any that you would get at a fancier restaurant for double the price. In a twist from any others I've had, this rendition had some peas in the mix as well, which added some great flavor. The sprouts were really crispy and delicious. - Roasted Tomato Soup ($5) The staple to order with grilled cheese, this soup was awesome. It was nice and thick, and even thicker with some stringy cheese added on top. This is a must to start and goes really well with the sandwiches. - Morning Wood ($9.50) More than just a cute name, this sandwich is really great. Made with white cheddar, applewood smoked bacon and a fried egg, it's an excellent and satisfying grilled cheese. Greasy, crunchy and fatty, it's got all bases of a great sandwich covered. - Iavarone 1927 ($11) Another delicious grilled cheese, this one had provolone, mozzarella, prosciutto, roasted red peppers and basil on ciabatta bread. It looked similar to the Morning Wood, but it had a very different flavor and is also worth trying. - Charlie Brown ($7) This was an amazing dessert sandwich - melty Nutella and bananas pressed in crispy whole wheat bread with powdered sugar on top and a massive scoop of dense vanilla ice cream on the side. Make sure you save room for this, or get it even if you are full, because it's incredible. They also have shakes and a create your own grilled cheese menu, with additional fillings and toppings, such as short rib, which would make for a great sandwich. Even though it's not in the most accessible area, I would definitely return for more of this great food. read more

See all

I cannot believe I witnessed the cook who was supposed to make my shrimp pasta not change her gloves after touching the door handle where she went downstairs to get a pan and other appliances to prepare. Not only that. The cook then opens up a shrimp taco order to make my pasta. I really could not believe my eyes. I've had food here before but this was something I never experienced. They lost me for good at this restaurant. I wonder what else they do that doesn't align with the food protocols of NYC. 6/11/2024 read more

Great food. Appetizers are the best part. The Mac and cheese and tater tots are both delicious and filling.

The Wheelhouse is amazing and I'm honestly bummed that I lived around the corner for years and never knew about them. These sandwiches are super nuanced and delicious. You really cannot go wrong. Gluten free options too! My only beef is that they're not always consistent about having gluten free bread, which is a huge bummer because that basically eliminates everything in the menu. Also sometimes their live music is a little weird and since the indoor space is pretty small, it's impossible to not make eye contact with the performer...awkward! Should note though that the Wheelhouse was giving away hundreds of meals to hospital workers during the pandemic. Not all heroes wear capes y'all! Support this business!! read more

I've been coming to this place since they first opened- food is (if I had more Thumbs I'd give em) bit awesome atmosphere and vibe and bartender Kelvin made the night most memorable read more

The Wheelhouse - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The cheesy portobello sandwich was so delicious and fresh. My friends also enjoyed their sandwiches. The outdoor space was also very nice to sit and enjoy lunch. read more

The Wheelhouse - Cheesy Portobello Sandwich - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've dined in and ordered delivery. Both times, I've ordered a variation on the mac + cheese, and both were excellent. The first time, I got a regular cheese type, which was filling and awesome with sriracha. Service was attentive. I'd go back. For the buffalo chicken version, which I'm still enjoying from my delivery order, there was a good portion of chicken, and it was real grilled chicken! None of that sketchy cubed stuff. The use of sauce was perfect, the portion size excellent for stashing some for later, and it arrived hot and in a timely manner. In my opinion, the Wheelhouse is a spot to bookmark for sure. read more

Local owned, the owner is very involved and the nicest coolest guy! Tomato soup and grilled cheese is delicious! Tot option is great. Dog friendly read more

Comfort foods like grilled cheese are not meant to be changed, messed with, or substituted, UNLESS YOU DO IT LIKE WHEELHOUSE!!! Braised short rib grilled cheese???!!!! Whatttttttt?????? On ciabatta bread????? BEST IDEA EVER!!!! If I didn't live 2 hours away I would eat that daily. If I had kids, they'd eat it everyday as well, hell I might go have some kids so I can feed it to them. The service was great, everyone was super friendly and helpful. The place is really cool and has a welcoming feel, I will definitely be back, trying to get my boss to move us to that part of our territory. Thanks for a great experience!!! read more

The Wheelhouse - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Tonight's mood: go to yelp search bar, type in brussel sprouts. I was surprised to see that it was a common search! My fellow sprout people, wya??? You feel me! I ordered on the Yelp EAT24 app for delivery of the 4 cheese grilled cheese with pickle and comes with small side salad, in addition to the Brussel sprouts, and tater tots. Upon arrival: Looked very clean and fresh for delivery - super fast too! Under 30 mins (but I live nearby). Okay, so thankfully, the Brussel sprouts were banging. Probably my favorite part of the order. The glaze was perfectly not too sweet or salty. And the ratio was perfection as well. The Brussel sprouts weren't super fried so I felt like it was still "healthy" night accomplished. However, not gonna lie, the other two parts of the meal.... not exactly my fave! Taters: still arrived slightly warm which is fantastic for delivery, but for some reason there was this slight after taste that wasn't quite right... not sure if it was oil or maybe the grill / gas, but the after taste reminded me of a chemical-like taste. Wasn't too thrilled about that. Grilled cheese: I only saw two cheeses in my Sandwich, and it wasn't really a generous helping. Don't expect a super thick grilled cheese (probably continuing on this "healthy" train haha) - so the actual sandwich was on the thinner side. That kind of skimping for $13 was a little bummer for me. I could be wrong on what I was expecting, but I saw a little cheddar and a little moz and that was it. I would have just ordered the regular Grilled cheese for $9 because that's how much I felt like it should have been. *Extra $1 Pickle bit: I thought the extra pickle I ordered was going to be an on the side type of thing, but they actually put it inside! It didn't bother me that much, but I took them out and had them on the side. I guess it all goes down the same but I know some folk can get a little picky about this! All in all, I have to agree with some people on here- I feel like it was a 3.5/5 for me, but I will have to try some of their other staple items in person next time to give a fair review. Not running to try again but I'm not mad overall! Stay tuned for the update! read more

The Wheelhouse - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I ordered the biggest chicken noodle soup. It arrived in a small cup, didn't even fit a bowl when I poured it out. Then, there was little to no chicken. Then it tasted awful, no flavor in the stock, absolutely bland and awful. Total waste of time and money. read more

The Wheelhouse - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Today was my second experience with the Wheelhouse, the first time we ordered online and had the food delivered. It was a solid takeout experience so my guest and I chose to sit down and enjoy the dining experience there as delivery is never as good as food fresh out of the kitchen. The wheelhouse is on the small side, figure 5 tables with a small bar. Wine and beer only. Boylan soda and NYC tap water available. The menu is limited but everything that's there sounds and tastes great. My guest and I sampled the tater tots, solid dish with fresh fried potato goodness....better than the junior high school garbage the lunch lady used to give us. Next up was their Macaroni and cheese which was delicious, creamy cheesy goodness. Both the tots and macaroni and cheese can be ordered with a large selection of toppings, onions, bacon, jalapeños to name a few. Next we sampled the short rib sandwich on toasted bread, delicious.....slow cooked short rib with melted gruyere and sautéed onions....yum The Cuban was slightly less successful but still a very solid rendition. Sandwiches are accompanied by a choice of salad, potato chips or tomato soup. Desserts are available however there was no place to fit it on this day. Our server Peter was a great guy, very personable.....an asset to the restaurant. Happy hour and brunch available. Parking in That part of Bushwick can be a bit tricky but The Wheelhouse is definitely worth the trip! read more

See all

I live only a few blocks from The Wheelhouse and have never stopped in tho check it out. Well today, I decided to give it a shot. I got here at around 6pm (Saturday) and it was pretty empty (although the space itself isn't very big). I sat at the bar and ordered the Cubano with a side of tomato soup. Mouth. Watering. Goodness. I'm getting hungry again just thinking about it. The menu has such a variety and I'm already excited to come back and try some of their other signature sandwiches. The service was also very fast. To drink I got the Maeloc Hard Cider (under the recommendation of the bartender and someone else sitting at the bar). This was also quite good (especially for a non-beer drinker such as myself). This restaurant is definitely with checking out if you're in the Bushwick area! read more

The Wheelhouse - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Haven't visited them in person yet but I placed an order online and the food came quickly and was excellent! Definitely plan on making my way over :) read more

French onion Mac & Cheese!! Complete game changer!!! Such a amazing flavor so cheesy and delicious, I will always order it when I come here. I also built my own grilled cheese with smoked Gouda, Gruyere cheese, sautéed onions, and mixed greens that was cooked perfectly. To compliment my grilled cheese I got a side of the tomato soup so good! When ever I am in the mood for a grilled cheese this is my go too spot. read more

The Wheelhouse - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is one of the worst places in Brooklyn. After waiting almost 45 minutes for them to confirm my order via DoorDash (which they never did), I was forced to call the store in order to cancel it. After trying to contact them three separate times, the phone was answered by an extremely rude woman who put me on hold and then hung up on me. I called back, thinking it could've been an accident, and it wasn't picked up. The order STILL isn't cancelled, so they're basically holding my money hostage and I'm genuinely disgusted. These people are at best unprofessional and at worst, thieves. This place should be closed down immediately and I hope it does. I plan on stopping there on my way home to demand my money back. There's so many other places in the city that deserve your business and the respect of the community. read more

Gonna make this short: eat the Cuban sandwich. But since Yelp doesn't let me post something so short I'm just going to write until it's long enough. Eat the Cuban sandwich, it's really good. Like really good. That was enough. Eat the Cuban sandwich, you won't regret it. read more

#I don't normally eat bread or cheese anymore. But this was pretty good. There's a TV to watch #football. No one there is watching it though, if you're into that vibe. I hate watching football with sports fans. read more

See all

Avoid the 4 cheese grilled cheese unless you enjoy spending $12 on two slices of bread with a light dusting of cheese. I'm not fully convinced they put all 4 cheeses in the sandwich. It was such a disappointment and I left feeling hungry and dissatisfied. :( Only positive was $5 for KCBC which was either on sale or the girl rung the price by mistake since I was there after happy hour had already ended. I've been in here a few times before, but it definitely felt like the food and vibe has gone downhill. read more

The atmosphere in the evening here is everything. The dimmed lighting, candle lit tables, open windows, board games, and not a huge crowd... thoroughly appreciated the vibe of this Bushwick spot. It was cute and cozy, nice for a chill date night or a laid back spot to catch up with friends over a brew. I had the grilled cheese with cheddar and gouda, with tomato soup. Basic order, but good for me. The quality of cheese was great- I just wished they were melted into my sandwich more. I also was hoping for a bit more flavor (and by flavor, I mean butter) from the grilled cheese but the tomato soup was good. The option to build your own grilled cheese is a nice touch. Friendly and attentive service. Overall, recommendable spot for the food and mosdef the vibes. read more

The Wheelhouse - Classic Grilled Cheese Sandwich - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been coming here for a long time, maybe since it opened. I'm glad it's still around because I like the location and the ambiance. I can say with certainty that the ingredients in the sandwiches are better than Subway or what you may get at a bodega. I never really went this early in the day before; today I went right when it opened probably around 11 AM. I noticed that the board on the sidewalk said there was a half soup half sandwich special. I made the mistake of ordering chicken noodle soup. The broth was terrible and had absolutely no flavor. It was as if they plopped sad pieces of chicken and noodle in warm tap water. I had a couple bites then gave up. I rushed down the street and got real soup at El Fogon on Flushing Ave. I get it, you guys are a sandwich shop. So take chicken noodle soup off of the menu...or at least put in a bouillon cube or 2? Sheesh read more

I was hesitant to try this place since I'm not really a sandwich person, but it's so close to my apartment. I'm glad I finally tried it! It can definitely get pricey depending on what you order, but expected from something that looks so hipster in Bushwick. My first time I ordered the short rib sandwich, which came with a side salad, and the fried brussels sprouts. The short rib sandwich was really good! Who knew short rib would be good with blackberry jam? The jam and the caramelized onions give a great sweetness to balance the short rib and gruyere cheese. The sandwich and side salad are enough to fill me up, but I don't regret getting the fried brussels sprouts because they're really good, too! I've tried recreating them at home, but it's just not the same. The burger melt and Cuban sandwich are good, too, but I think the short rib is my favorite. The tater tots are good, but I don't know if you can ever go wrong with tater tots. I think they're a little expensive ($6) for what you get. Overall, seems like a great place for friends at any time of the day. They've got board games and special events happening on different days, and they're open pretty late if you just want to hang. read more

Not many places do the impossible burger justice, so I was really excited to find this spot that does an awesome patty melt with it. It's a shame that when I ordered delivery, they left out the salad that's supposed to come with it. When I called to see what could be done, the guy on the phone was incredibly rude and said "do you want me to shut down the store just to get you a salad?" and only refunded me $3 (basically tax). For $23, just a sandwich is a little crazy. Honestly, I could have forgiven it if the guy hadn't been so rude and uninterested in being helpful. The attitude he gave me was unacceptable. Peace out, Wheelhouse. read more

All I have to say is, mac n cheese. Mac n cheese mac n cheese mac n cheese. Get it. Delivery was on time and the food was still super hot (and it is COLD tonight.) A+ Did I mention mac n cheese? read more

The Wheelhouse - Literally. THE BEST. Mac n cheese of my life. - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I recently ordered takeout here for a late lunch. The waiter told me that it would be about 10-15 minutes (20 minutes tops). When I arrived, the waiter informed me that it would be another 8 minutes. Ultimately, I waited ~40 minutes for my food and was thoroughly annoyed. Aside from that, the food was good and hit the spot. I ordered the Outcast and my girlfriend ordered the Panavia Tornado. Perfect for a cold rainy day. The Mac and cheese was the highlight. read more

Came here for brunch on Sunday and wow! Great food and service. We actually started with the breakfast side of tater tot's. They were crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside but not greasy. We would definitely order these again. I had the four cheese grilled cheese and she had the cheesy portobello that had caramelized onion. Everything was delicious. Would definitely recommend. Thanks for the awesome bite! read more

The Wheelhouse - Cheesy Portobello Sandwich with side salad - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

They arrived earlier than expected. Followed covid protocol and even texted to let me know my food had been delivered. Food was great as usual. read more

This is one of my favorite low key brunch spots in the neighborhood! Their $17 bottomless drink pours are generous and you can't go wrong with any of their brunch toasts (the pesto and Brie are particularly great!) and you can also get their go-to grilled cheeses. Great draft selection too! read more

The Wheelhouse - Pesto, pancetta and roasted red pepper toast during brunch - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

wow... how to describe a sandwich that fully changes the vibe of your day? it was an EMOTIONAL sandwich. a MOVING sandwich. a sandwich with feeling... sorry i need a moment read more

Last year we ordered from here while in New York. We were blown away by the grilled cheese and the creamy tomato basil soup. My husband and I were super excited to reorder from them when we arrived and what a disappointment. I'm not sure if their was a change in ownership since last year but I know for sure we never received burnt grilled cheese and soup that was so watered down we ended up tossing everything out. :( I don't like giving bad reviews but man....waiting this long to get this was wack. Hopefully it was just a bad day, but I will give them one more try and change the review if this proves to be the case. read more

The Wheelhouse - Burnt Vermont Cheddar Grilled Cheese... :/ - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Another great example of a high quality Bushwick bar/restaurant. I wanted to give this place 5 stars but I don't like coming out of a place smelling like the kitchen. This is the only downside. The food was excellent. I had a burger sandwich with bacon and cheddar and the well renowned tomato soup. I was a little apprehensive on the soup because it was so hot outside but it was served at a good temperature and tasted delicious. Nothing worse that lava hot soup. This was perfect. The sandwich was also excellent. Served on toast rather than the traditional bun but this is a grilled cheese place after all! Nothing to say about the burger other than delicious. Perfectly cooked. All this washed down with a couple of Montauk beers. Nice to see some good local(ish) brews on the menu. Give it a try. If you don't mind coming out smelling like the kitchen then this is a great spot to linger. read more

The Wheelhouse - Burger and tomato soup - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ugh. I hate being disappointed when I order from a new place. Maybe I didn't order the right things or maybe it was an off night. I ordered a grilled cheese, tomato soup and cesar salad from DoorDash for almost $40. The grilled cheese was mushy, they could have used nicer quality bread. Please also see the image of the soggy little cesar salad that arrived. The audacity of this cesar salad. I have nothing else to say. Please step it up. I may be a regular shmegular person ordering from DoorDash, but I know this is not an adequate experience. Thank you! read more

The Wheelhouse - Sad little cesar salad via delivery - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I live a hop skip and a jump from here and have been by three or four times since I moved a few months ago. There is a TV (on mute) so my cable-less boyfriend and I like to come grab a beer and a snack and watch football undisturbed by rowdy drunkies. The sandwiches do border on pricey, but they are really big (I can't finish a whole one on my own) and they come with a salad or a cup of tomato soup. Each sandwich I have had was great. The BBQ was a little too salty for me, but it didn't ruin the sandwich or anything. I think my favorite so far is the fish sandwich, but nothing has been a let down. Appetizers are yummy - have had the tots (crispy and delicious) and the broccoli rabe (lemony and delicious). I have a slightly unhealthy obsession with soup. Both times I have ordered it here it has been Split Pea with ham and it was so. good. The staff is always friendly and they play good music. read more

LOVE the Wheelhouse. Great atmosphere and interior decor; Patrick, the owner, is a great guy. The food is perfect-- exactly the kind of comfort food you want on a cold day. read more