Had dinner at Theo's & really enjoyed it!! We had a reservation & were seated quickly after arriving. Waitress was very nice and recommended the breadsticks, which were so delicious. I got a house salad and the linguine. I really enjoyed the food! Definitely recommend & I'm excited to go back. read more

See all

The place was very trendy on the inside and had a nice little area to sit on the outside. The breadsticks were out of this world and their Fig Pig Goat pizza is out of this world and it a great size to eat a little and then take the rest home for another meal! The server was wonderful and very helpful when helping make the choice of what I wanted as an entrée. Will be back! read more

So cute inside! They had a number of spritz's that I loved! The elderflower spritz was the best! I loved the meatballs! The salad was kinda overwhelming and it had a lotttttt of feta cheese in it which was not typical to the chopped salad it was kinda overwhelming. Loved the meatballs they were so good and the breadsticks were delicious too read more

See all

Food is amazing and service is top notch. Restaurant has a lovely interior, worth lingering over a cocktail. A definite place to repeat visit! read more

Stopped here for dinner with my lovely wife. The server was as out standing as the food! The overall experience was superb and we both had zero complaints. 5/5 for sure. Would recommend the bread stick app with the not on the menu Alfredo sauce to dip...Amazing read more

Theo's Italian - Meat Sweats Pinsa - Italian Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

Yum! Started with an appetizer of shrimp and calamari which was very good. My wife went with a Fig Pig Goat pizza and I went with the Meat Sweats. The pizza comes out on a wooden board, the crust is crispy and delicious, but not too thick or thin. We were greeted by two very nice hostesses, who sat us immediately and our server, Max, was solid. The menu isn't overwhelming, but there are some things to try that are a little more daring/different if you'd like. Pastas, pizzas, breadsticks, etc. The ambience is nice/casual but not pretentious. We will definitely go back! read more

Theo's Italian - My wife went with a Fig Pig Goat pizza and I went with the Meat Sweats. The pizza comes out on a wooden board. - Italian Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

I have to say I've been going to Theo's almost every week for an over a year now and I've had a great time every time. Even when they've been busy the staff have seated me immediately or near immediately. Food and drinks have been excellent every time. Shout out to Alison for being the best bartender/server. read more

Service was great, we did the Devour Indy menu. Pasta was ok but we weren't blown away. To both of our surprise, the Brussel Caesar salad was by far the highlight. read more

See all

I can truly say that I have not had real, fresh made, pasta since I was last in Florence, Italy. Thus is no longer true - having just eaten Theo's Lasagna and tasted my wife's Ravaoli. As usual, Cunningham has brought us another gem of a restaurant here in Plainfield. The updated atmosphere from the previous restaurant makes for a good dining experience. But the true star of the afternoon has to be the delightful greeter and our very competent and helpful server. Kudos!!!! read more

First time here, it was 5 Star for the waitress we got, 3 stars for the food quality standards. We ordered the lobster pasta and the flavors were pretty much there taste wise but had absolutely ZERO lobster flavor or I think any lobster period. The "sauce" in it was delicious! but it was the most runny sauce I've ever had, it was more like a cream wine broth more than any sauce, needs thickening greatly. But I would order again, and ask for some Parmesan to add so it thickens up a bit. 7/10 for the execution 8.5 for taste. The artichoke buratta was ok but definitely never going to get it again for the price it was sold at. Taste to amount you get vs price just fell super flat and will be something we will avoid in the future. 5/10 value 7/10 taste. The shrimp and calamari was top notch! It wasn't over cooked and melted in your mouth for being fried which is hard to achieve in most restaurants. The sauce it came with also was delicious and perfectly spiced. 10/10 Overall this place was good enough to come try other items so we will be returning. For now 3/5 stars until next time, read more

Great food! Great service! Great ambiance! Enjoyed our Fig Pig Pinsa, Bucatini and Meatball. Highly recommend Burrata and Focaccia! read more

The food and service were both great the day we ate lunch here! Christina was our server and was very polite and knowledgeable of the menu. The food came out in a timely manner and was absolutely delicious! read more

See all

Ah Theo's, another Cunningham restaurant and they're doing just fine. The service was good and the food was also good. Orders around the table included the bucatini & meatball, four cheese ravioli, and the casarecce. All the dishes were really good. The house Old Fashioned was tasty and unique with its bay leaf and brown sugar. My wife order "the usual" and it was equally tasty! It may be that I am spoiled when it comes to Italian restaurants in Indy. I really don't have any complaints for Theo's and lord knows if you've read my reviews on most if not all other Cunningham restaurants then you almost always hear me rave about them. That said, when you've been to Iozzo's or Mama Coralla's it's tough to get that 5th star from me in comparison. I'll definitely be back to Theo's for another outing and I'll never be the veto if someone else wants to go. read more

Amazing service, Winnah was exceptional! She made our anniversary dinner all the more special. Food was delicious, had the Bucatini and meatballs, can't wait to go back to try something new. Definitely recommend. read more

Theo's Italian - Bucatini and meatball - Italian Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

Theos Italian has to be the best Italian restaurant in the area. You will definitely get what you pay for! Highly recommend. Service and management is top notch! read more

Theo's Italian - Cheese with crushed tomato - Italian Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

See all

Another great CRG restaurant! Stone creek moved to a larger location and this CRG restaurant took its place. Very nice atmosphere and food to match! Had some excellent wine with dinner and also had a fun server. Normal growing pains of a new restaurant. read more

See all

Had a small ladies get together here on a Friday night. We did make reservations and they were very accommodating. Our server was wonderful and the food and cocktails delicious. A couple of arrived early and sat in the bar for an Expresso Martini and the bar tender was a delight and Martini perfect. read more

Over priced No bread included Takes away from an Italian family style feel Under staffed read more

My family and I have always been huge fans of The Cunningham Restaurant Group this new restaurant is another hit! The food was very delicious and everyone there was super friendly. My personal favorite was the margherita pinsa. The dough was delicious, the fresh garlic slices was a great added touch, and the tangy marinara sauce was so, so good. My husband really enjoyed the lasagna pinsa. Their salads were also very good. I would highly recommend Theo's to friends and family! read more

Theo's Italian - Lasagna Pinsa - Italian Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

See all

Takeout was bad. First they use toxic black togo boxes. Front staff didn't even know the process for picking up togo order. They use seed oils also :( read more

Another Cunningham establishment in Plainfield.. they have this corner sown up for sure ! Our small group are all "card carrying" members of their loyalty program, so we were ready to try the newest spot. There was some confusion on our reservation, but it got sorted out.. at 6 pm on a weeknight they were getting busy. They sat 5 of us in a booth.. it was pretty cozy.. a table would have been nicer, but not available? We got our menu promptly and they poured our water glasses .. room temperature.. no ice .. Tap water.. Ok... unusual. So the menu is not large... Salads, pasta and Pinsa's. .. their name of the flatbread pizza, similar to Panera. We skipped any appetizers so I can't speak to this. I ordered a tequila margarita cocktail that was the best part of the meal, very tasty and a good pour. Of the 5 of us.. 3 ordered the Pinsa's .. one the Fig style , another a meatball and I had the margherita style .. 2 others ordered pasta and side salads. We also,had a order of breadsticks. The salads all got positive reactions.. they appeared fresh and a fair size. The breads were just right.. hot, cheesy and warm. Our mains came out pretty quickly and looked good.. I can say I was not impressed with my Pinsa .. not much seasoning at all and crust was rather chewy.. not my favorite.. I did bring most of it home and doctored it up with some oregano and a bit of sausage and garlic. It help make the leftovers edible. The two pasta dishes seemed to be a disappointment.. one of our group got hers taken off her check .. the other did not like the texture of her pasta but did ask for a to go box . The decor is stark dark and modern.. not very comfortable to my taste.. some may like that look. I will go back again down the road and try another dish, just not anytime soon. Our server did a fine job.. no complaints there. read more

Theo's Italian - The Pinsa - Italian Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

I received excellent service from Alex. The arugula salad and chicken piccata was delicious. I will eat there again when I'm back in town.

We love Theo's new menu. The shortribs are amazing ! Allison, the bar tender makes great drinks and always remembers your favorites. It's such a friendly Atmosphere there. The assistant manager, Sean or the manager, Doug always stop by your table to see how you liked your meal. Theo's has become one of our favorite restaurants to go to . They have fabulous meals for a special occasion, and they also have pizza and pastas for a quick dinner before or after a movie or a Saturday afternoon lunch. We can't wait to go back and try the other new items on the menu. read more

Good food. Decent service. My only complaint is bread isn't served free! Which I feel like most Italian places do! A "nicer" Italian dining experience. read more

Cunningham Group location specializes in Italian classics and pizza. Service was excellent for a busy Saturday evening. Very fresh and flavorful. In line with the better Italian places in town read more

Absolutely amazing. The restaurant was super clean, and the atmosphere was welcoming. The best that I appreciate is the service, it was exceptional! My husband and I ordered breadsticks and by far best breadsticks we have ever had, then our entrée was the Ziti, the house sauce with the sausage and veggies was wonderful and tasteful. We will definitely come back! Highly recommended! read more

Theo's Italian - Breadsticks with Alfredo sauce - Italian Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

See all

Nice addition to the CRG family and Plainfield! The breadsticks are amazing!!! Service is great and the team is learning so I recommend reservations for now until they get up to speed. Not super noisy like many open concept places! read more

Theo's Italian - Lobster Tortelloni Nero - Italian Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

See all

Good food and super friendly service. Nice establishment, but location can make parking a pain. Very good Italian food compared to what is available in the city. read more

Enjoyed all of our meals. Unusual pizzas not your typical toppings. I loved the pig, ham and goat cheese pizza. Friend had lasagna pizza and another friend ordered the 5 cheese lasagna entree. The breadsticks are fantastic. Prices are reasonable and excellent service. I did feel the lasagna entree was pretty small. The interior hasn't changed much from Stonecreek days. It was bright lighting inside maybe need to tone it down. I don't like to feel like I'm eating under a spotlight. Definitely will return. read more

The staff was all wonderful and knowledgeable about the menu. The breadsticks are HORRIBLE! So much butter that it squirts out when you bite into them. And the pool of butter on the plate was a solid dried film before the meal was over. The pissa and pasta was good. Not sure it's worth the price. Cunningham did nothing to remodel after Stone Creek moved out. read more

We love everything about Theo's. The GM there is amazing as well and has worked numerous times with the local sports teams as well. Thank you so much for all the support. read more

My wife and I had dinner there with my son, daughter in-law and granddaughter. We thought it was kind of expensive. Everything was alacarte. If you want bread with the entree you have to buy it. My entree was very tasty. My son and daughter had a chicken pasta dish which didn't have much taste and very little chicken. The bill was $165 and we didn't buy any alcohol. Sadly, the food is better at Olive Garden. read more

Everything was wonderful! We had the sausage bean soup for appetizer and it was amazing. My hubby has a gluten sensitivity and it was so refreshing to be able to get any of the pinsas (pizza) made with a gluten free dough. The taste was amazing. We got to speak with the cooks and managers. The service was amazing, the server went out of her way to make sure we did not order anything with gluten. We are def coming back! read more

Went there for the first time tonight. Not busy but not empty either. Atmosphere seems very similar to Stone Creek - not much modified which is fine bc it was a beautiful restaurant to start with. Pros: Very friendly staff, attentive, and prompt. Cons: The food was terrible. Like we didn't eat it bad. Started w breadstick and cheese dip. This is a loaf of ciabatta that's been sliced and DROWNED in olive oil with a side of carryout pizza cheese sauce. So much oil it squeezed out when you ate them and they were sitting in a pool of it. One order of Linguine: the chicken (boiled) was rubbery and it had zero seasoning. Imagine throwing a plain jar of Alfredo sauce on boiled chicken. I promise you there was not an ounce of seasoning. Second order: Bucatini and meatballs. I have never eaten a meatball that crumbled apart when you bit it. It was almost like cheap meatloaf consistency. I would have guessed it was in full liquid form at some point and the molded into a ball - no way this could be rolled or patted into a ball - it was like congealed beef powder. None were eaten after first bite. Third item: Four cheese ravioli. This is not ravioli. It is a pasta square with a 1/4 teaspoon of cheese then folded like a wonton. The Italian crabmeat Rangoon apparently. It tasted average but was maybe a single 6 inch line of these tiny "ravioli." Last complaint: the Parmesan came in a pizza place round glass shaker jar. Even Olive Garden grinds fresh Parmesan. Here's the thing...I paid $86 w tip for the above and one soda (rest had water). That's way too much to leave most of a meal sitting on a table then making a stop at Portillo's bc everyone was still hungry. Don't go. Don't try it bc it's new. Just don't....you're gonna walk away irritated. read more

I was so excited for an Italian restaurant to open in Plainfield, specifically one from The Cunningham Group since we frequent several of their other restaurants. Unfortunately, I was highly disappointed. The ambiance was definitely the highlight, a carryover from when it was Stonecreek. The service was pleasant, though I came in on a Sunday between the lunch and dinner rushes, so I can't say how they would hold up under pressure. The food, which should have been the star of the show, was underwhelming. I ordered the Fried Calamari and Shrimp appetizer and the Margherita Pinsa as my entree. The appetizer was overly saturated with oil and the aioli was salty with no real nuance to the flavor. The pizza, which is what I was most looking forward to, fell flat. The crust was undercooked and the sauce tasted generic. I won't be returning to Theo's, which is a bummer since I feel like Hendricks County is sorely missing Italian options. read more

Theo's Italian - Fried Calamari and Shrimp - Italian Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

See all

I had my birthday celebration in the private dining room upstairs!!! The ambiance was exceptional and the food service was amazing and quick. I opted for the family style meals... my guest were wowed and impressed!!! They continue to speak to me about... how wonderful the experience was and exceptional service!!! 10/10!!! Doug & Damien do an amazing job managing this new place!!! read more

Theo's Italian - Italian Near Me - Plainfield, Indiana

See all

Food is average and QUITE OVERPRICED. Starting with NO ICE in our water (hot day and sitting outside) was a clear sign of the lack of nuance and detail from a restaurant that tries to "wow" you with "upscale"-ness. Not impressed. Then a newbie male server, quite UNenthusiastic, took our order. A Manager brought out our food (the inside was empty of customers) if two salads and a chix parm sandwich. This was 4;30pm and the menu had only 8 (eight?!!) entrees, the rest 5 salads and some pizzas. Not impressed. Our food was...okay; $9 for SMALL salad with $5 EXTRA charge grilled chicken. Pricey! NOTE: NO MENTION OF BLEU CHEESE on the chopped salad. I HATE it (like MANY PEOPLE) and that's UNACCEPTABLE to not disclose. After about 10 minutes waiter kid asked if I wanted parm cheese for salad. I said "yes please". He never came back with it. Only remembering he forgot it while waiting for payment/tip. Not impressed. The PAYMENT METHOD is actually terrible as waiter did the card-scan at table, handed car reader to us making small talk while WAITING THERE until I tipped and finished. THIS IS TERRIBLY UNCOMFORTABLE imho for the customer. Not impressed. $60 for three SMALL meals, two were salads and one sandwich with only waters to drink. NOT IMPRESSED. MENU maybe was some lunch menu ? TINY amount of choices. I do NOT recommend this place at all to be honest. This was mayyyybe a $35 type meal it's no wonder why there are ALWAYS Indeed job openings for Theo's. It's just not a well-managed, well-run, detailed restaurant price-asking what they don't provide. read more

We love the Cunningham restaurant group so we were so exited to come try Theos for Devour. While the dinner was good, we noticed a steady water leak happening in the ceiling over the kitchen being that it's kind of an open kitchen. So I was worried about the sanitation and if it would fall into any food. And also there were alot of gnats around in the inside dining area. I'm not sure where they came from but we spent the dinner just swatting them away in between bites. Again, we love Cunningham and might come back again since our pastas were pretty good and the server was so nice. I just hope they can get that ceiling leak fixed. read more

What a wonderful find during a recent visit to the Indianapolis area! Awesome host and servers, beautiful atmosphere and the food was amazing. Had the to die for Caesar salad and sausage pizza. Highly recommend this place! read more

I ordered one of the pizzas and it was very tasty. Service was very good . Can be a little loud at times, depending on how busy they are