Three Brothers is a difficult one to rate. While the pizza is objectively good, the pricing, hygiene, and ambiance are overall not as strong. Granted, being on the boardwalk, it always has people coming in and out, which I understand creates that environment. The pizza slices are huge,they're good and they're tasty. The problem is pricing: $20 for two rather large slices, I believe, is too much. I've paid $4-5 for similar sizing of the same pizza elsewhere. It just happens to be too much. The waters were also expensive, $5 each. The season was closing, so I understand that, but it doesn't justify the means. Great for a quick pizza on the boardwalk, nostalgia. Not good for great pizza on a random game night. read more

the food was just bad service was ok. the buffalo chicken pizza tasted like Cheetos I'm not even lying.

The service was not very bad but the prices are an obsolete madness too expensive and the girl who charged me took the pizza without gloves after having grabbed cash from 3 people that is not healthy at all read more

Place is a total scam -$50 for a large pie? Total rip off for below average pizza. Would never recommend or go back

I ordered a bowl at Mexican Food in Three Brother, and to start with, the lady serving seemed nice, and she gave me my food without sour cream, i asked for the sour cream and it had an extra cost to it, just for that, which should be included for an over priced bolw, and on top of that the serving portion for the sour cream was very small. Bad service read more

for $5 this slice was pretty good, bacon and chicken was good, good options here too. friendly service read more

Three Brothers From Italy - chicken bacon ranch - Pizza Near Me - Seaside Heights, New Jersey

Ok so the pizza looked legit. But alas it wasn't to be. The size was good, the taste not so much. There was just no pizza taste if that makes sense. I couldn't taste sauce or cheese. Just garlic salt. The grease was another issue. Too much grease. Sorry/not sorry 3 Bros. read more

I don't get the bad reviews here. This was a great tasting pizza and extremely cheap compared to other touristy areas. Don't be discouraged by a couple bad reviews, this was a great slice of pizza. Super tasty and inexpensive! Give it a try! read more

Three Brothers From Italy - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Seaside Heights, New Jersey

This pizza joint has probably 4-5 spots along the boardwalk. There's a reason why it's so popular. They serve up huge jumbo slices for around 5 bucks a pop. We ordered a whole pie, which came out to around 34-35 bucks. It's basically two large pizzas at a normal restaurant. The pizza was cooked fresh and came out within minutes. I think it could've been cooked for an extra minute as it looked a tad underdone. There was grease leaking all over the plate. You'll definitely be able to feed 6-7 people with a large pie! read more

Three Brothers From Italy - Pizza Near Me - Seaside Heights, New Jersey

See all

Horrible service. Owner was there and yelled at US after we waited 45 minutes for a singular pizza and asked the status. Completely disrespectful and a waste of $50 on ONE PIZZA. Unreal. Do not go here read more

I have been rocking the Three Bros life since I was a kid. Eat here if you want a solid slice of pizza the size of your head for a couple bucks. The prices have risen (albeit slowly) over the years, but you still can rock a slice for under $5. There are still several locations on the boardwalk in Seaside. One has been rebuilt since the fire a few years ago, so it probably wins as the nicest location these days. You honestly can't go wrong getting a slice that takes up two plates. Warning: if you get a full pizza to go, you'll need a large car!! read more

Three Brothers From Italy - Pizza and the beach-- does it get much better?? - Pizza Near Me - Seaside Heights, New Jersey

It is impossible for me to head down to Seaside, walk on the boardwalk and not stop in this place for a nice sized slice. The quality isn't the best, however, it all boils down to the specific taste that makes me really feel like I am down at the Jersey shore. I have been coming here since I was a young girl and I could never get sick of it. Many complain about the prices of the pizza here, however, you need to keep in mind that these are the BIGGEST slices you will find in the area. Therefore, don't think of it as your paying $5.00 for one plain slice, because technically you are paying for two slices. They have a a variety of pizzas to choose from, and plenty of places to sit inside. Extremely casual atmosphere with quick service. So whether you're on the beach, playing games on boardwalk, or get hungry from drinking all night, this is the perfect place to go for a quick fix. read more

Decent pizza for the price. Together, my sausage pizza and soda was $8.75. I'm not a fan of how greasy this pizza is, but I'd say the overall taste was pretty good! The dining area is very dirty. Many of the tables and seats are unclean. We intially ate pizza here and came back a little while for funnel cakes... and the same dirty tables were STILL dirty. It's worth a go, every once in a while. Giant pizza is a novelty, I get it. read more

Three Brothers From Italy - Giant slices of pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Seaside Heights, New Jersey

See all

As with my whole trip to the Shore/NYC, I checked Yelp before making a decision for lunch. This is becoming an addiction. Did we choose wisely? I ordered the Italian sausage sandwich and my hubby ordered pizza. His food arrived quickly to our table, mine was 10 minutes later without an apology - just a mumbled, the grill is acting up. I ordered it without onions and peppers and guess what? It arrived with them on. After picking them off the sandwich was ok, not the best I have ever had. The fries we ordered were slightly overcooked. There were several locations on the boardwalk for this restaurant...maybe we should have tried one of the other brothers.... At least they had a bathroom which became a changing room for going to the beach. No mirror in the bathroom though. Maybe the Shore girlies hog it preening for the beach and Guido's.? read more

Three Brothers From Italy - Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seaside Heights, New Jersey

Their pizza's great, but their prices are a bit steep. 2 slices and 2 drinks for $16.51? That's a bit steep. I get it that they have to make money, but it just left a sour note for me. However, I won't complain about the taste or freshness. They are excellent in that regard. read more

Three Brothers From Italy - The biggest slice of NJ you will ever have. - Pizza Near Me - Seaside Heights, New Jersey

So i walk in from the boardwalk starving and order a slice of pizza. At first I almost had a heart attack when they wanted me to pay $4.27 a slice and then I got the slice and understood why. The slice is huge. I took a picture of the slice sitting on a regular paper plate so you can really a we the size of the slice. It is definitely two slices in one. I also posted a picture of the pizza box that is bigger in width than a standard size picnic tabletop. So a fountain coke and slice was 8 dollars exactly but still in my eyes well worth it. I waited about ten minutes to be served in the middle of a August Saturday afternoon can't really complain about much. They may want to consider cleaning their bathrooms a little more often! read more

See all

I am beyond words for how this pizza affected me mentally and physically, to start this pizza was 7 dollars for one slice of soggy floppy uncrisped garbage. Beyond the taste immediately after the first bite I knew I was in for a dirty little time. Umm immediately my stocmach turned and got a hedache equivalent to lizzo sitting on my face. All three brothers should reconsider their career paths and not give people a come to god moment. Almost pulled trig #notdeece. read more

When I was in Seaside heights I had the chance to taste the best pizza ever I really mean this Three Brothers has what it take hands down on pizza and don't worry one slice is like four slices and it really cheap too so you won't leave hungry I can't wait to have it again this summer and u hope one day I will be waking up a to this pizza everyday. From MKE to you all Seaside heights Thanks I'm very jealous u get to eat this and look at the Ocean read more

Slice of pepperoni was a whopping $4.50. Had as much taste to it as the paper plate it was served on. Perhaps if I were drunk and coming out of Bar A, or one of other fine Jerclubs, my stomach would thank me for coating it with grease, but for a sober fan of genuine Brooklyn pizza, this just doesn't cut it. read more

This place get no stars as My wife and I stopped off the boardwalk to get some pizza for my 2 kids and we had a soda from another stand and my wife bought 17.00 worth of food and water and they would not let us sit at a table because it was a insurance regulation. Will never go back there again. I never heard of this such BS. read more

Three Brothers From Italy - What kind of BS is this. Insurance regulation really. - Pizza Near Me - Seaside Heights, New Jersey

See all

GREAT GREAT pizza!!! The slices are huge in this place. They are like 5 or 6 locations at Seaside Hts. Many different kinds of slices to choose from and always fresh. I recoomend this place to everyone to try. read more

Jersey Shore isn't what you see on TV...I had to say that...anyway this is the Pizza that you remember for the rest of your life! Shame on the mid west for making this thick tastless and charecterless pizza out here. The Jersey Pizza rules, it's thin and the crust is crispy the cheese tastes fresh, and I haven't been able to replicate it out here...anywhere! A must have when out on the east coast or at the Jersey Shore!! read more

Came here only for the funnel cake. $6 for a funnel cake which isn't too bad for the boardwalk, but I definitely expedted better. Maybe it's because I grew up on the crispy kind of funnel cakes when I went to the beach or maybe it's the style of Seaside Heights, but they like to make their funnel cakes dense and very cake-like. The edges weren't even crispy! They did put a lot of powder sugar on there and they were huge portions. I just wish that it was crispy :( Pros: - Not too inexpensive - Big portions of funnel cake with lots of powdered sugar on top Cons: - Funnel cakes need to be crispy and not dense like this one! Why I gave it a 3..... Don't get funnel cakes here, even if they aren't that expensive, unless you like the dense cake-like version of it. The portion was big (we had to throw away a third of us and there were 3 adults eating it!) with lots of powdered sugar all over it. Go somewhere else if you like the traditional, crispy funnel cake. read more

I'm from Chicago and we have way better pizza than this place, and no I'm not talking about deep dish. This was the first place we ate when we visited Jersey. I ordered the chicken ranch and the bf had pepperoni. They have the pizza already made and they pop in the oven to reheat it. Who knows how long its been sitting out there. The pizza was just ok. The chicken pieces were dry and there were blobs of ranch in different spots. The bfs pizza looked better than mine, but I didn't try it. I guess I tried the wrong kind of pizza. read more

Three Brothers From Italy - Chicken ranch and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Seaside Heights, New Jersey

The sicilian pizza was good, but all the tables were dirty and there was a lot of garbage on the floor, which doesn't make sense because it wasn't busy. . read more

Three Brothers From Italy - Storefront. - Pizza Near Me - Seaside Heights, New Jersey

This place is a Jersey Shore staple fo' sho'. Huge pizza slices, itty bitty prices. Summer summer come again! read more

The best pizza on the beach. Used to love their italian sausage sandwiches too, but I'm no longer a pork consumer, so I can't have those anymore. The pizza is always fresh because they STAY busy! Easily the best part of going to Seaside. read more

Their pizza used to be excellent but has declined over the last 3 years. Tonite was horrible...barely any sauce and very dry overall. Cardboard with cheese and mushrooms! Never again! read more

They suck! They have things on the menu that they don't even make! FYI, take down the freakin menu dummies!

I had been to the Boardwalk here about 10 years ago. I had a slice of pizza here on the advice of a worker at one of the amusement stands. The slice was HUGE!!!! It reminded me of the pizza in Greenwich Village in the city. So big you could ask to cut it in half and share it. I will be back!!! Nice assortment of all types of pizza and boardwalk eats !!!!! read more

Biggest most bad ass slice of pizza on the boardwalk. It's delicious and it's filling and the store is big so you have plenty of room to sit somewhere and enjoy the slice of pizza the size of your head. Love it here! read more

Two can share a single slice because they are huge. The pizza was decent. The sauce was average, nothing spectacular. They skimp on the toppings - e.g. pepperoni. The cheesesteak and peppers is decent too, again nothing spectacular- they use unseasoned frozen meat. There is plenty of seating space read more

Seaside heights boardwalk staple from what I'm told. These guys are every twelve feet on the boardwalk, some within sight of each other. Riddle me that! LOL. Huge slices, not terribly expensive and very filling. If you choose to get fries, bring a friend, by the way. The cups runneth over, and $5 can feed 2 people. Flavors vary from site to site, so if you don't see what you're craving, just keep walking, there's another location to choose from. One day they had some gorgeous broccoli and tomato white pizza that we didn't see the other 3 days. I also really enjoyed the mushroom and the chicken parm pizza. read more

Like everybody else says, these slices are HUGE. You've eaten the slice halfway and your brain is thinking "Hey, I should've finished this slice already" but NOOO you're still chomping down on a really good slice with just the right amount of cheese, sauce and a nice crisp but chewy crust. I dare say it may be as good as some New York pizzas and I'm a die hard New Yorker. My brother was going to buy two pies for seven people but boy am I glad we only ordered one! The pie is as big as two pies or more! A regular cheese slice costs $3.50 and we ordered a pie with sausage and mushrooms for only $30.50! We also got garlic knots but they weren't that good so keep with the pizza. We also saw alot of people ordering Italian sausage subs with peppers and onions. Delicious! You won't regret it! read more

GIANT SLICES! BIGGER THAN MY HEAD! I had the white slice with broccoli and fresh tomato on it. It was excellent. The deep fried oreos are also delicious and coronary inducing. MMM Boardwalk food! read more

The 3 Tests of a Giant Pizza Slice 1. Disastrous Cheese Slide - Pass The ratio of sauce to the rest of the pizza somehow causes a natural cheese slide disaster. It comes in two forms - It's either lightning fast as suddenly the cheese falls off in a massive sheet, like a kid who loses the ice cream off a cone. It's shocking. Or, when you know the storm is coming and are forced to hang an open mouth under the pizza in an attempt to save falling cheese. How you suppose to chew? 2. Translucent Plate Syndrome - Pass Is the paper plate now translucent from grease? If yes, your heart is probably fibrillating. What's worse is the pool of grease has affected the integrity of your crust. Crust without any bite. Gasp. 3. Frog Bog - Passed by the skin of your teeth You are fed, but you have no money to play Frog Bog (or I suppose another game of choice). Now where's the fun in that? If the pizza slice you are buying costs as much as an entire pizza, rethink this purchase. read more

Cons: Filthy. No gloves, touched money and went back to pick up pizza to put on a plate. Women employee wiped her baby and went back to work around food. We walked out without ordering. This happened a couple of other times. read more

The Second Best Pizza on the boardwalk. It is amazingly good. You should really try it out The only reason why it is 4 stars and not 5, is because My and my brother both bought sausage and peppers from here. One came out great, and the other one not so great. The resturants are always a little different read more

Yes the slices are large and for what it is, the food is mostly good. Prices are a little on the high side. $28 for a whole pizza no matter how big is too expensive. For tourists experiencing the jersey shore it's fine but for us locals there's better choices. Also, hiring a few local kids would be a nice touch to go along with all the eastern europeans you ship in for the summer! read more

DO NOT EAT HERE - UNSANITARY--staff handles money bare handed and then handles your pizza without gloves or washing their hands. They were also observed making the pizza after handeling money. They have been reported to DOH. All 3 locations were doing the same thing and came up with excuses when questioned. read more