Full disclosure, this review was written by a hungry, cranky, perimenopausal woman. I got all irritated by the website and went down to the shop in person cause I wanted pizza and I was pissed. I stomped in with a mildly bad attitude and an ugly outfit from doing yard work all day. I stomped out with three very delicious slices of pizza. The shop was having some issues with the computer system as happens sometimes with computers like it or not. The shop is not much to look at. The pizza however made me very happy. I got the Bianca, margarita, and balsamic eggplant. They were all good but the Bianca was my favorite. There is a little table to eat outside but this seems more like a take out place. I went in pissed and came out happy, that is powerful pizza. read more

Ordered pizza last night a meat lovers with half jalapeños it was horrible way overdone tasted like cardboard. I ate half of a piece so disappointed. read more

Got pick up with the host family I stayed with - mushroom pizza had a honey drizzle to it - had one slice of leftover pepperoni- garlic knots were dripping oil but well flavored. - large pizza was big had leftovers - decent New York style pizza! read more

Food was not worth it. Not good. Garlic knots had no flavor and pizza was NOT like NYC. read more

The crew of four stopped in to T B P, because we heard from a very good source (one of the four) that they served up some authentic New York style pizza, and we were so happy we stopped in. We ordered a thin crust half cheese, and half pineapple, and 18" Sicilian half cheese, and half anchovy. We ordered some zeppoles for desert which were ok. Both came out perfectly cooked, the crust was outstanding and the pies were the best that we have had in Florida. The pies rival any New York pizza that I have had. Three brothers is now my goto pizza place for me in the Clearwater area. read more

Im mad I only have 1 picture cause I've been here a couple times. The pizza is great! Calling in my order is always a breeze and the food is always hot. Plenty of parking in this plaza. I love this location cause I can get the select items that are made with FRESH PASTA I got the Hot combo, comes with a cheese filled manicotta, eggplant rolletini, and 2 meatballs. I call that BALANCE I also ordered the Greek salad and the lettuce was crisp and plenty of toppings. It may come in a small container, but threw that baby in a bowl and you can definitely share with someone else. 10/10 will always come back. read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Palm Harbor - Hot Combo - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

We had the meatball appetizer, which is a must and a wonderful pizza! Crust is cooked perfectly and all the toppings so fresh!

Food was excellent & packaged well. I love the caprese. Pastas were perfect as were sauces. I had the vodka sauce, hubby had Alfredo. Zero complaints. Thank you! read more

See all

The people who work here seem friendly if you talk to them. Otherwise, they seem busy and not really into chatting. In order to get to these people--and the pizza--you must go around a corner from where the sign is located. It's almost like a hidden pizza shop. As far as the pizza goes, the crust is excellent and the sauce is good yet not great, imo. Overall, it's good pizza but not amazing. Then we have the Chocolate Chip Cookie. It's baked in-house so I expected a lot, but it was disappointing. I wanted to love it--at least like it--but it was a no-go. Three people tried a piece and all said it was okay. That said, the price for the pizza is fair, which leads to a good value. read more

See all

Best pizza we've found in Tampa area!!!!!! Excellent crust, ingredients, flavor. Just the best!!! Thank you!!! read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Palm Harbor - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Takeaways: Mid tier food, great pizza, would recommend take out/delivery over dining in. Food: The food here was nothing special. Not bad, especially considering how small the place is, but definitely nothing to write home about. Didn't seem homemade. However, they do say that most of their pastas are made in house, which is nice! It's clear that most of their efforts are focused into their pizzas, because they have some incredible pizza ideas. They have a "pizza of the day" which is a pizza that the chef comes up with day of. When I was here it was a mushroom soup pizza, which was very good! Their pizza options are VERY extensive and VERG unique, hard to pick just one! They also do serve select pizzas by the slice. Service: As mentioned before, the place is very small. We were the only other dine-in customers, and there was one waitress. She was extremely kind and helpful, but the food did seem to take longer than necessary, considering the quality of the food. However, they seem to have a never ending demand for take out/delivery, so that could definitely be the reason for the long wait time which is definitely understandable. Ambiance: To be honest, I wouldn't eat in store again. It's very clear that it is mainly a take out/delivery operation. It seems like they weren't even expecting anyone to dine in. There was stuff splayed out all over the tables and it seemed like the building was mostly storage and HQ for delivery drivers. We sat outside, where they had one table sitting under a leaky roof. read more

See all

Out of town and looking for pizza while on vacation. Was delicious, fresh and timely delivery!

We ordered the identical items as we did the first review; however this was a night a day difference. Our previous experience , the flavors were unique and stood out from the competition. But this time the food was mediocre. First time was "why haven't we found this place sooner ?" This time we all didn't finish half our foods . Ingredients were not as fresh . margarita was under cooked with the sauce being too tart. The meat lovers was a lot of meat but just tasted salty altogether. Wings were specifically ordered with the sauce on the side, those instructions were not followed. Too spicy to be finished. Granted this is a busy Friday evening with 1 hour wait ...but from experience in the restaurant business ...consistency is key. Not sure that we will be back with the inconsistencies. Hate to stick with chain pizza but we know what we'll be getting with no surprises. read more

See all

Ben picked up a pizza for us for dinner tonight. We had received their menu on a door when they first opened this location and then I had a friend tell me about it so it was about time we tried it for ourselves. This is a NY style pizza joint so really you have to be careful on what you order as too many toppings don't hold up well on thin crust pizzas. We ordered the everything pizza, my side without pepperoni and the center was kinda soft from the toppings. You can tell the toppings are fresh which is a very good thing. The sausage is sliced vs being the ground kind. Honestly, I prefer the ground sausage but it was still good. Ben did say when he walked in to get the pizza that the place smelled amazing so we will have to try some of their other options available. It is a little on the pricey side but you get what you pay for. read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Palm Harbor - Everything Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Food is really good. Excellent value. However. Both the regular and the Sicilian pizza are incredibly salty. I think it's the sauce. read more

I'm now addicted to this place. We ordered from here two times in two days. That's because I enjoyed this place so much. I had a hankering for Italian so we ordered take out on Labor Day. I couldn't stop thinking about their pizza sauce so the next day we ordered delivery. We are a mile and a half outside their delivery zone (dang it!), but since they were slow on a Tuesday they said they would still do it (woohoo!) Here is what we got: Margherita pizza - this is what started my addiction. The tomato sauce is slightly sweet (I randomly prefer this pizza cold). They use real mozzarella slices on the pizza. The crust is thin and crispy. We got a 12 inch the first time and today switched to the 16 inch. I've been slowly eating my way through the pizza all day. Just get the larger size, it's worth it. Gnocchi - it's an appetizer, but it could seriously be a meal. It is cheesy, creamy, and oh so delicious. I got it without bacon (because I'm Jewish, not crazy. I know the bacon could have put it over the top, but alas, I can't). I heated up the leftovers today and I'm kicking myself that I didn't get another dish of it. Penne Alfredo - Very similar to the gnocchi, but with less cheese. It is also absolutely divine. There's no calorie counting here, but don't worry about it. You deserve this dish. Parmesan truffle fries - These fries are crispy and I could taste the truffle oil. I thought they were well done, but since my stomach can only hold so much food, I'll probably hold off ordering this again. Caprese salad - I thought I would get sick of that much mozarella, but they have good cheese. The balsamic reduction really brought together this simple dish. If the ingredients are fresh, this dish is a total joy, and luckily the ingredients were fresh. I loved it. My husband also tried the chicken parmesan sandwich and chicken wings and said both were great. If you order online, it won't let you place an order until 30 minutes after they open and 30 minutes until they close. If you want your food immediately at 11 a.m. (like I did), make sure you call! There's more stuff on the menu that looks delicious. I can't wait to try it all. read more

See all

We have been ordering from Three Brothers-PH for years. In fact we left a stellar review just a few months back. Tonights' order-was a crime. Ordered a pear salad that was wet, rotten, and stinky. The kind of salad/"food" that can make you very very ill. The pears were rotten, the salad was rotten, and it smelled like it was taken right out of the trash. The pizza, a medium half sausage ,half veggie was slimy, wet, soggy had absolutely NO FLAVOR. We threw the entire meal away. Called to complain as soon as we picked up the order and they credited the salad but did not report the pizza (realized it was horrible after we threw the salad (spoiled mush) away- at this point dinner was ruined. We work so hard to treat ourselves but just threw our money away tonight. Shame on you TBP will NEVER NEVER return! read more

So many pizza places to try, & so little time. You have to admit there are a lot, & almost all claim to be NY style. Three Brothers Pizza comes fairly close to the mark. I ordered a large pepperoni pie, & it was definitely above average. The crust had a neutral flavor, meaning it was just sort of there with no yeast or cornmeal taste. The sauce however was very good, & the cheese was fresh & abundant. The pepperoni was tasty, plentiful, & seemed to be very good quality. I'm still holding out for a 5-star pizza, but 4-star is still very satisfying. By the way, on Mondays & Tuesdays, their pizzas are basically $3 off. read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Palm Harbor - A coupla slices - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

See all

We ordered from here a few times and the food is consistently good and delivered hot and on time!

So far I've been here 4 times and every time has been delicious. I've also recommended it to two different friends and they said 2 thumbs up as well. My favorite is their portobello mushroom pizza with rosemary crust and shaved Parmesan. Very nice staff and from what I understand there really are three brothers. They certainly have pizza making skills stuff. But since they are very good, they are popular so call about an hour before to make sure it will be done when you want it. Maybe even a little sooner if it's a Friday or Saturday or delivery. read more

See all

Pizza specials are pretty good on Monday and Tuesdays and I usually don't care for desserts at all pizza joint but the fried Oreos are pretty tasty! read more

Oh no Three Brothers Pizza! A swing and a miss. The Yelp reviews were so positive. We decided to give it a try. We did not get pizza and that may have been where we went wrong. Here's a rundown of our unhappy meal: Wife, Chicken Marsala. She reports it was tasteless. She could not detect any wine or garlic. Just a total lack of spices. Daughter: Penne Portabello Marsala. No wine in preparation. No taste. Just meh. Me: Spaghetti with shrimp. Received chicken. Server tried to argue that I ordered chicken. Was corrected fast with a plate of shrimp to add to my chicken. It passed. But for the money, all entrees should come with a small salad. Salad was a $6 add on. Bread served with meals also had no taste. Service was good. My wife hardly touched her meal. Daughter ate about half of hers. Owner/chef offered a new plate of Vodka pasta that we turned down as we were done with the place. About a mile away is Joey's Italian. Much better and for same price, you get a larger portion AND a salad plus garlic rolls. Minor nit; stacked pizza boxes in the dining room and a tv with the sound up. Did not make for fine dining. Nope... scratch 3 Brothers from our list. While I appreciate the offer of free dessert, which I did not take, this hidden away place will stay hidden for our eating out plans. read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Palm Harbor - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

I love the grandmas pizza! Try it! It's amazing!! The delivery driver was very nice and respectful.

First time trying this place & we did a take-out, pizza only. We like to take baby steps with new pizza places because we've been disappointed too many times. HIGHLY impressed all around. When I called in the order, Alex was more than pleasant & helpful! Pizzas were ready for pickup at the designated time. So far so good....but how was the pizza? It's the real deal! Crust was perfect, the sauce was perfectly spiced. And we were pleasantly surprised that they had cup & char pepperoni! (Small curled pepperoni with crispy edges.). Yep they nailed it!! Looking forward to a dine-in meal to try their entree's & pasta very soon! Couldn't be happier with our first experience! Keep up the good work, guys! read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Palm Harbor - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

See all

As I continue to search for real quality pizza in Tampa, Three Brothers is definitely one of the top I have found. I called in the order and when I arrived, while very busy, my order was ready for pick up. The pizza is very good with a nice crust, sauce is good and the right amount of cheese. I would highly recommend Three Brothers Pizza. read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Palm Harbor - Garlic cheese bread - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

See all

Delicious pizza every time. Always ready when I call ahead and easy pick-up. Authentic NY style.

Best pizza in PH...Three Bros and Fireside. This is our go to pizza place for delivery or pickup. Consistently good.

Pretty good calzone!! It was so cheesy it was awesome! I ordered online, the girl at the counter was very nice. Quick pick up and go. Two thumbs up. They have tables outside if you aren't comfortable eating indoors. read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Palm Harbor - Build Your Own Calzone sausage and basil. - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

See all

Yesterday I ordered the chicken Philly sandwich. Not the best, the hoagie roll was not toasted the roll was not a quality roll. The service was slow & it took forever & they were not busy !! Also had their pizza a few weeks ago. They were very cheap with the toppings & cheese & the crust was not that good. I am not sure was happened to the quality of food they put out now but it has gone down hill !! Time to find a new place in palm harbor !! read more

I ordered 5 large pizzas for delivery in the ELW area for a party. Delivery was right on time. Help and advice from Joslyn at the pizza parlor prior to the event was invaluable in helping me order the correct number of pizzas. All were delicious. I ordered Margherita, Meat Lover, Everything, Pollo Prosciutto, and Veggie. Next time I order the large size pie, I'll ask that they be baked a little longer to crisp the center (I should have taken Joslyn's advice on this ). read more

Fantastic relaxed family Italian place . Loved the family dishes chicken franchise is great ! plus they are a great local business that supports first responders and the hospital . I give a 5/5 for the type of business it is just a great family place good prices . Love the Buffalo chicken pizza too !. Just all around a great place and we've been to their other locations . read more

We had three brothers last night and it was amazing !!! I can't believe I forgot to take a picture of the penne portebello but it was OUT OF THIS WORLD ! All the flavors of everything were great ! Although the fries were soggy I'll blame the packaging the flavor really packed a punch and was enjoyable !!! We will for sure try other things again ! The only thing disappointing to me is the size of the fries for $6.95 and the side salad for $6.95 I truly feel like the portion did not fit the price ! And typically with a $15.35 pasta meal most places it comes with a salad ! But now that I just looked at the pricing again it looks like I paid more on the Uber eats app then what the cost is on the three brothers menu which really sucks since I also had to pay other fees to be also jacked in price . Guess on the next trip around it will have to be in person . read more

See all

By far the best pizza I have had in the five years I've lived in Florida. I actually was losing hope and would only get pizza when visiting family back home in Boston. These guys have made me a fan from the first visit. The Sunday sauce pizza was delicious. I usually prefer a while pizza or San marzino only type sauce but this was creatively decadent. You know it should be on pasta but they have it on a pie. The eggplant pizza was also just as tasty. I think next time I would ask for the ricotta to be left off as these pizzas are so perfect on their own. read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Palm Harbor - Eggplant pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

See all

We get take out from 3 Brothers PH. I enjoy their Sunday meat sauce pizza. The eggplant appetizer is good. My kids gobble up their pretzel bite appetizer served with a cheese sauce. I ask them to undercook them a bit so they aren't overdone. Polite customer service Currently it's the closest to the pizza I'm used to from NJ in this area. read more

Ordered a couple pies for Super Bowl Sunday! Had a flyer for Three Brothers Pizza indicating NY style pizza. Pizza was just ok. Haven't found that great pizza spot yet in the Clearwater area. read more

Best pizza in north Pinellas. Consistently good food. Highly recommend the Stromboli.

Terrible. Used to be Queens pizza and top quality cheese on pizza and good crust. We always used to get the supreme pizza and large Greek salad. Always good. Now the pizza is no better than dominos. And, the large Greek salad is a side salad with some sprinkles of feta cheese on it. Sorry but that is not worth the $10.95 for a salad. I will have to remind myself to never order from here again. Sad. read more

Three Brothers Pizza - Palm Harbor - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Pizza was cold , undercooked . Called to let them know and they just didn't want to hear it . Call me a pizza snob since I'm from the NY area , but damn y'all need to cook The Dough. read more

As a New Yorker, this is a pretty good pizza considering you're in Florida. Everyone knows lots of bland seasoning used in cooking all across Florida.. read more

Chef Christian knocked it out of the park today the chicken Francaise with added mushrooms was amazing. I'm so particular about this dish and 3B got this right!!! read more