I honestly think frozen pizza tastes better. The cheese wasn't fully cooked, the crust was soft, and there was way too much cheese. The flavor reminded me of Domino's rather than a traditional New Jersey pizza. The inside of the restaurant felt more like Chipotle than a classic neighborhood pizzeria. For a New Jersey pizza place, this tasted and felt more like Midwest pizza, but with a high price tag. There are far better local options nearby. read more

I liked that they have a decent amount of GF options like the pizza (vegan or cauliflower), hoagie bread, and cheesy garlic bread. We started with the cheesy garlic bread and I got a margarita gf pizza. The cheesy bread came out hot and full of flavor. Off to a great start. My pizza came out mostly hot and a little bland but had a good crust and crunch to it. The sauce isn't my favorite though. My sister wasn't a fan of her pizza since the pancetta pieces were huge and hard to eat and too salty. The place was fairly empty although they did have takeout orders but we were waiting an extremely long time for someone to take our order, to come back for entrees, and to get the check and to go boxes. Overall, just a very mid experience, especially for $100 plus tip. read more

See all

One of the very best pizzas ever. Tender thin crust. Perfect mix of tomato and cheese in the sauce. Mushrooms sooo fresh

Was trying to find a decent pizza while I'm in town and came across Tino's and gave it a try. It's a Wednesday night about 7 pm and no one in the dining room. I got scared right away. Two employees working the desk and said we can sit anywhere. Both very polite and accommodating. We made it simple, hot wings and a cheese pizza. THE PIZZA: baked in a real pizza oven which is always welcome. Fresh mozzarella and drizzled with EVOO. I want set the table up with shots of that pizza sauce! Excellent! Now THE WINGS: the buffalo is a Tino's blend...I'm guessing a tame version of Frank's Red Hot mixed with something sweet. They was OK, I was looking for more of a traditional buffalo wing with a bit of punch. NO FRYERS HERE....baked wings only. Again, I would prefer a fried wing...but I get it, Tino's style and I can appreciate that. Great job to the boys in the kitchen!!! read more

Tino’s Artisan Pizza - Small extra cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Madison, New Jersey

See all

Been meaning to try this place for a long time after seeing how busy the Jersey city location gets.. severely disappointed. Firstly, the location was 90% empty on a Friday night. I didn't think anything of this frankly it's not important. The important part is that there are several employees working for only a few tables.. so I'm not sure why no one ever came to take our order. One of the busboys ended up coming up to us and asking if anyone is taking our order and he was shocked when we said no. Throughout the service, we did not have a dedicated waiter or waitress. We had whomever felt like coming over to us. Truly don't know why this happened. The food... the GF cheesy garlic bread was good. My sister's pizza looked like it was 3D printed lol. It also had a crazy amount of sauce. She was happy with the gluten free crust however. Not her favorite, but pretty good she said. My Amatriciana pie........ The color of the pancetta was completely gray and pink (you can see in pics) and soggy. Usually, pancetta is cubed up and pan fried until the fat has been rendered off. The pie was so salty and was complemented by bitter roasted garlic. It was roasted too far which eliminated the usual nuttiness of roasted garlic. I'm still disgusted thinking about the meat that was deemed acceptable to be served to me. My pie, unlike my sister's or boyfriend's, had a pool of oil under it as well. The total bill was $101. New Jersey is known for pizza so I'm confused as to how this place has so many locations. Very comparable to blaze pizza but more expense and not as tasty. read more

See all

We love Tino's. Their food is delicious and their artisan pizza's are unique and different from the many other pizza shops in town (and in the general area). We get takeout from here a lot, but they also have a decent number of tables inside and on occasion will eat there. It hasn't been busy inside the few times we have eaten here, so a great spot to bring our kids for a meal. The cacio e pepe pizza is my favorite, but I haven't had a pizza or dish that I didn't like. Our son like the chicken nuggets and it's a big win that they are baked and not fried. read more

We have been here probably 100x since my initial review. The service is generally really good. The pizza is definitely better as well. If you dine in, it's so much better! Not saying take out isn't good but something about eating it fresh out of the over..yum! It's still BYOB but the wines they have aren't all that great. We go here probably 2-3x a week to get either their chicken bites (kids love em and they are baked), pizza (faves are Pesto, Cacio e pepe and no choice), sandwiches (cheese steak used to have these spicy peppers on them but they took them away so I stopped ordering them. Tuna is good though) and salads (Farro although the last few times it's been the Farro-less salad. How do you forget to add farro??? - it's when I do takeout and I am in a rush to check). Overall the best pizza spot in Madison. Great ingredients and the family loves it. ENJOY! read more

Great pastas, and pizzas. The gelato is very fresh, service was very welcoming. Take out is done at the outside window so dine in is nice and focused. Not the largest restaurant so big family dinners are a tough ask. read more

Great thin crust pizza. Awesome salads, especially the Caesar. Looking forward to trying the sandwiches. I recommend this place highly.

Absolutely amazing. This pizzeria is simply incredible. They have amazing pizzas to try, the ingredients taste fresh, and it is all well baked. It tastes very similar to the NYC pizza I grew up with and you just can't beat that! The staff are super friendly and the restaurant is very clean. Definitely the best place for pizza around this area! read more

I arrived after 8 pm on Saturday. The host was very welcoming, but warned my party the restaurant closes at 9:00 pm. We should have listened. Everything felt rushed, the pizza and appetizer were doughy (not fully cooked). The highlight of the meal was dessert, it was delicious. I must admit, after reheating some slices in the oven, the flavor improved and the dough had better consistency. read more

Another Pizza Friday Night! Cacio E Pepe (V) Fresh mozzarella, shaved parmigiano, pecorino Romano crema, black peppercorns, EVOO I ordered this and topped it with prosciutto and basil. Let's just say I had more slices of pizza than usual, haha. The flavors just burst in your mouth. Very heavy parmesan flavor so if it's not your cup of tea, then I wouldn't recommend it. I also had some Mike's hot honey at home so I added that on top as well. You have to try! THE CRUST, we all were like wow this crust is sooo yummy. It was crunchy but still soft on the inside, the way we like it! I saved those for last because it was like a yummy breadstick haha. I will definitely be getting this again! read more

Tino’s Artisan Pizza - Cacio E Pepe (V) I added prosciutto and basil - Italian Near Me - Madison, New Jersey

I was there years ago and it was ok. The angry sarcastic response by the owner to a negative review made it clear it's not a place I want to go back to-sarcastic wise guy. No thanks. Was goona go tomorrow but not in this kind of enviornment. He needs to learn the customer is always right and get some humilty! read more

I love ordering from here!! I have dined in and done take out. The cheese pizza is good but my absolute favorite is the Bori. I wouldn't originally pick those toppings but it is amazing, such a good combination and I get this pizza almost every time. I have tried the Cacio e Pepe, not my favorite but my husband loves it. The Fragola and beet salad are delicious!! The balsamic dressing is great! FYI - they have special deals on Tuesdays read more

We ordered meat ball pasta. It was really bad...we couldn't even finish. If you don't know how to cook, please don't charge people $20. It's not worth it at all. Tasted like $8 value read more

Tino’s Artisan Pizza - Italian Near Me - Madison, New Jersey

This is the best pizza hands down. I just ordered the cacio and Pepe pizza. The best. So good. 100/10

Terrific pizza and terrific salad. We ordered delivery. Have never been there. Good sauce. On the sweet side. Crispy crust.

Tino's is our go-to eatery whenever we're in the Madison area. The restaurant is part of a strip of stores and has plenty of parking. Our server, Ryan, approached us quickly and tended to us perfectly. One thing that we always thoroughly enjoy is the dishware that Tino's presents. Their appetizer dishes are made in the UAE (United Arab Emirates) and beautiful. So beautiful, that when we returned home, I went out onto the Internet and purchased a few. Not only are they gorgeous, but they are always a talking point, whenever we present them to our guests. Our Burrata appetizer was so good. The mix of pear, arugula, cheese, and balsamic pearls made for a delicious course. The mixture of all of these ingredients was refreshing and the perfect start to a meal. Our entree, Margherita Pizza, was the right size to share. Each slice was nice and small and each bite was tasty, fresh, and we ate the entire pie. The other Tortollone entree was just as enjoyable and cheesy. If you have room for dessert, Tino's also has an assortment of gelato. I cannot recommend this restaurant enough. You will definitely enjoy a memorable meal and will most definitely return, for many more. read more

See all

Been here twice after shows at the Shakespeare Theater 1) great and friendly service. The main guy took time to highlight different menu aspects and to see what our preferences are 2) Food - Dora pizza was great and kids enjoyed, Raffaella pizza (we added sausage) was fantastic with a kick of spice 3) parking super easy - large lot. Would recommend read more

This place is no joke! I am going to start with the atmosphere- I hate going to places when the door is open and it's freezing cold. Its place warm, cozy and totally inviting. We started off with a small bottle of wine. Perfect for just two people. It was wonderful to see if they had Zevia soda. He started off with gluten-free meatballs which were absolutely amazing. They definitely tasted like my mom's The octopus salad is not to be best. It's salty, fresh tasting just completely delicious capers, and all. The truffle pizza was absolutely amazing. The Margherita pizza was outstanding! I have celiac disease, so I compare all my pizzas to Eataly. The gluten-free crust at Tino's is second to eataly very high score They customized the pizza for my son who is so picky he loved it Our new favorite place read more

See all

We picked up an order. Got a strawberry salad with balsamic. Very good. The eggplant rotalina was delicious. The cacio e pepe on sourdough flatbread was amazing. Friendly staff. We will be back! read more

See all

We are visiting Madison and we ordered pizzas the other day. My brother said "this is some of the best pizza I've ever had" then he asked my 6 year old niece what she thought. She asked him how much he loves her and he said, "to the moon and back to infinity". Then she said, "That's how much I love this pizza." I think you can't get any better than that! I love that they also had gluten free options for us and I like an idiot put in the wrong phone number on my order and they personally made sure we got our pizzas delivered after a snafu because of my mistake. I can't give them enough stars! read more

All I have to say is Wow! I was really impressed with Tino's. I love the simplicity and clean ingredients. There was no pooled oil on top, ingredients were fresh and absolutely delicious. The crust was crispy and thin, yet the edges were thick. We ordered the American and Sausage with peppers and onions. Looking forward to going back to try some of the other dishes they offer, with a side of pizza of course! read more

Pizzas are delicious if eaten in. Great menu selection and all are excellent. Service is inconsistent at best; servers need to be more attentive and customer-focused. Ambiance and decor are nice, especially in warm weather when the "open air" option is open. read more

This place was absolutely delicious! The pasta was amazing. Eggplant is some of the best I've ever tried. The Nutella pie... amazing! Enjoyed ever bite and can't wait to go back. read more

Tino’s Artisan Pizza - Nutella pie - Italian Near Me - Madison, New Jersey

I've saved this place on my yelp as a place to go for awhile, I am not sure why I have not gone..but I have missed out. This place is amazing - probably one of my top places to get pizza in the area. It is FRESH which I love. We did a pick up order so I can't say much about the service for dine in. I will say our order was ready when they said it would be and the service was quick when I went in to get my order. They had a lot of orders and were super busy but managed it well. We got the veggie pie was great, tasted amazing. I love how fresh it this restaurant is - I really enjoyed this experience and we will be back for sure to try new (and the same thing again) on the menu! Check this place out if you are in the Madison area! read more

Tino’s Artisan Pizza - Italian Near Me - Madison, New Jersey

Good pizza spot, service can be quite slow here but at least the food is good. Finding a decent pizza spot in NJ has been a challenge as none of them meet my expectations given the price points they charge, but this one is solid. It's not New York pizza, but it's flavored well and priced decently. Nice atmosphere as well, I think it's BYOB read more

There's so (too?) many pizza places in NJ but I'm always down to try a new place. Tino's has been on my list for a while and I'm glad I finally ordered from them. I got the Balsamico sandwich and the X Pie. The sandwich was yummy but I wish it had more mozzarella. Also, we ordered takeout so some parts of the focaccia got super soggy which is kinda sad. The pizza was pretty great. I really loved the dough - it's thin and chewy with good flavor. The biggest downside is that the pizza is more expensive than the other local places. But I'll probably come back eventually to try some of their other pies. read more

Tino’s Artisan Pizza - Balsamico sandwich - Italian Near Me - Madison, New Jersey

See all

Take out experience at Madison location. Have tired them before in Jersey City. Nice cozy restaurant overall. Easy to order over phone, was given 15 mins timeline and food was ready as promised and quick transaction. Coming to food, it was great - well made - flavorful. The ingredients tasted fresh and nicely seasoned. Have tried few pizza joints in the area and this comes closest to a gourmet tasting pizza. Well done Tino's pizza team !! read more

Very good pizza - definitely on the pricier side but it is considered "artisan pizza". We got the "Tino's Margherita" and the "Parm Pie" - the pizzas were extremely similar except the Parm Pie had breaded eggplant on it. Both were good - had fluffy dough with a tinge of burn to the crust, and the eggplant was a nice touch. I would go back but it would be as a splurge since for the price, I would consider it more of a personal pizza - I was able to eat the whole thing by myself in one sitting. I guess this shows the tastiness but also sets portion expectations. Would recommend trying! read more

Came here for a late night meal to go, I ordered a Margherita pie with pepperoni. It was all fresh ingredients which was lovely, but the dough was a bit too flat/hard for my personal preference (I love a few air bubbles and softer crust). With a little more seasoning this would be a really solid pizza. The restaurant interior was more casual but very clean and tidy. read more

I don't have enough superlatives to describe Tino's Artisan Pizza. It is simply outstanding. If you live anywhere near Madison, you must try it. To start your Tino's addiction, eat at the restaurant. Don't get take out. Bring a bottle of wine (BYO), sit down, and enjoy the atmosphere. The reason I'm telling you to eat at the restaurant is that I want you to taste this food right out of the kitchen, right out of the oven. This is not your everyday pizzeria. It's elevated artisan pizza and other Italian delicacies prepared in the most thoughtful, authentic way with a modern twist. Don't be afraid to adjust your order. Like all fine restaurants this is never a problem. If you are lucky, you will meet Tino himself. This man is a pleasure to talk to and you will quickly see why he has built a successful chain of restaurants in New Jersey. My wife and I recently moved to Berkeley Heights from the Princeton area and we were thrilled to find Tino's in Madison. We were longtime customers of the Kingston (a suburb of Princeton) Tino's where it all began and you can see my review of that location. A few weeks ago we had the pleasure of catching Tino at the Madison location and he was gracious with his time. He treated us like we were his best customers. This guy get it. He won't ever sacrifice quality. The food is consistently great. Our favorite pizzas are the Rafaella and the Rucchetta. Mama's meatballs are just like that: Mama's meatballs. So good. (insert chef's kiss) Of the salads we love the burratta salad and the La Pera salad. When you go, say hi to Denny the manager/waiter. He is an asset to Tino's Artisan Pizza. This young man understand hospitality and customer service in a genuine way. read more

Tino’s Artisan Pizza - Italian Near Me - Madison, New Jersey

See all

Tino's has organic everything and the Pizzas are good but I am the biggest fan of there Gorgonzola, mix green, pear and walnut salad. The beet salad is also one of my favs. Madison for the most part is closed Mondays and thank goodness Toni's is open. The staff are great, the ambiance is inviting. Highly recommend. read more

Good pizza can't go wrong here . Nice location with parking. Got takeout fast and efficient. Looks nice inside for eating in

The Pizza here was tasty, in the center it got a little soggier because of the weight of the ingredients, but crunchy on the outside. We tried the Tartufo red pizza (tomato sauce, mozzarella, mushrooms, sausage, truffle oil) and it was aromatic. The mushrooms were cooked thoroughly and you could taste they were fresh and not from a can. The pepperoni and sausage pizza (called Dora on the menu) was also great. None of it was overly greasy, in fact they weren't very oily at all. The eggplant rollatini appetizer was also a hit, nice and crispy on the outside, with a delicious smooth ricotta filling inside, and in a sauce that provided good balance and didn't drown out the other flavors. read more

See all

Ordered a mushroom pizza and garlic bread for pick up. Showed up 5 mins earlier and my order was ready. The pizza is big enough to split between 2 people if you get an appetizer. we ordered the pizza well done so it was nice and crispy. The pizza is very thin which is how i like my pizza. The flavors were great. Can't wait to order again read more

Tino’s Artisan Pizza - Missy's Garlicky Bread - Italian Near Me - Madison, New Jersey

See all

My wife and I stopped in, as we're from out of town. We were deciding between pizza and chipotle. I comparison here, Tino's is not your average pizza joint. A menu featuring organic, farm to table, gluten free etc. We started with the meat balls, which were amazing! Good use of fennel..., we then went with the sausage and mushroom which they sprinkle truffle oil over, and the anchovy pies. As the name describes, the anchovies were a little too salty for us, but we typically don't use salt in our food. Friendly waitress, and server. And the place is clean!! read more

Spectacular Yummy pizza with great service and friendly staff. Specialty pizzas are absolutely delicious. We had three different types and our favorite was one from the blackboard with fig and Gorgonzola and balsamic. We can't wait to go back again. read more

I've been there 5 times since they opened and they have given me no reason to go elsewhere for pizza. My daughter requested them last night for her birthday party and our guests loved them all. Fresh savory crust, sauce was delicious, and you could tell the high quality of product in all the organic proteins and veggies. The cheese was as fresh as you can get! Excellent service as well when we dined in the first two times. The cannolis are made fresh for dessert. Delicious way to wrap up the meal. The owner Tino is very outgoing and passionate about his food. Great addition to Madison NJ! read more

See all

Short review from a short visit, took a takeout pie that was long on toppings and very yummy, $18. Formerly urban fire, similar layout & still byo but the oven is now gas fired and it's no longer fast casual. Sit down inside or out and order, Tino's peeps bring your sandwich, salad, pasta and pizza. Next time I ask for extra oven power to make the crust a little more toasted cos all those toppings soak in fast! Vegetarian rating: five stars for the many great choices. read more

Tino’s Artisan Pizza - Exterior - Italian Near Me - Madison, New Jersey

See all