I have been going to Tony's for I don't know how many years but as long as I can remember well over 10 years now for every vehicle I ever had. Every single time I get treated so well. The owner does his best to give me a good deal so that there's a win-win. Every other shop I've ever tried to go to has always tried to rip me off so to tell you the truth, I don't know where I'd go if I didn't have this tire shop. Always good quality, tires, new or used. I've never had a bad experience. read more

Absolutely appalling experience. If I could give zero stars, I would. My car had to be towed to this shop, which is already a stressful situation for anyone. Instead of receiving even the bare minimum level of customer service, I was met with hostility, yelling, and complete disrespect. The person assisting me actually yelled at both me and the tow truck driver. I have never experienced such unprofessional behavior from a business. Rather than offering solutions or treating customers with basic courtesy, they chose intimidation and aggression. If this is how they treat people who are relying on them for help, I can't imagine how they treat others behind closed doors. There is absolutely no excuse for speaking to customers this way. Save yourself the stress, time, and aggravation. There are plenty of repair shops that value professionalism and respect their customers. This is not one of them. read more

As a previous worker for the owner Tony i would never reccomend anyone to get tires here. I had gone to collect my last paycheck after leaving to work elsewhere and Tony had threatend me saying if he sees me on the street he's gonna break my face, besides that i had done a bunch of work on his personal vehicle as i'm a Certified mechanic and a certified NYS safety inspector for vehicles and he tried telling me i had broke a bunch of parts on his car AFTER i had replaced a bunch of previously broken parts. Tony is extremely rude and disrespectful and basically told me i was good for nothing because i would enlighten customers that needed questions answered. Aswell as him selling used tires that had no treat/bubbles/plugs on the sidewall. If there was a way for me to put 0 stars i would. stay away from this place and get your car worked on by CERTIFIED mechanics. read more

I can't say enough good things about this shop. It's hard to find a place that's honest, knowledgeable, and truly puts the customer first, but that's exactly what you get here. This is a family-owned business, and you can feel the difference the moment you walk in. No upselling, no gimmicks--just straightforward service, fair pricing, and quality work. They got me in and out quickly, saved me money, and made the whole process completely hassle-free. Tony and the team really know their stuff and take the time to explain what you need (and what you don't). It's clear they care more about building trust than padding the bill, which is exactly what I need. If you're looking for a shop that values your time and your wallet, Tires by Tony is it. I won't be going anywhere else! read more

Tires by Tony - Tires by Tony storefront - Tires Near Me - Seaford, New York

Patient and excellent service. Highly recommended. Talk is cheap, I've recommended several customers to Tony.

The owner was too busy having a conversation with another gentleman instead of selling four new tires which I just went over to Mavis and got the tires that I needed. The guy didn't seem to care so I guess he has enough money if I can give it a zero I would. read more

Tony is the best in town, gets me in and out immediately, saves me from having to replace tires. Actually patches your tire does not plug it. LOVE IT HERE! He treats everyone equally and like family. He has a no BS attitude & he tells it like it is. Located on Sunrise Highway eastbound one block east of Seaford Oyster Bay (135) dont block the driveway! read more

Tires by Tony - Tires Near Me - Seaford, New York

Been coming here for years with no problem. Two days before Christmas some thieves tried to steal my tires. They got all of my lug nut locks off but got spooked and ran away before actually taking the wheels. We put glue in the grooves of the wheel lock as a deterrent until my new ones came. I told the guy taking the tire off (that coincidentally had a screw in it) that he needed to use a torch to heat up the glue in order to get the key on the lock He definitely didn't do this but I had no idea that he destroyed my key Four days later I went back to the shop because the patch from the screw hole was not holding. The owner told me there's no guarantees and walked away from me and was so nasty The worker then could not get the lug nut off my truck because they had previously destroyed the Key and told me that I did it. I had to take my truck to Mavis to have the lock welded off the truck and Tony's refused to pay for the removal or even fix the faulty patch. read more

I have used they're service numerous times and the service is always fast and fair. I strongly recommend them for tires and flat services.

Terrible! Owner was so rude! He told me he couldn't give me a price over the phone for 4 new tires so I drive there and he starts yelling about where I'm parked. "Why are you here!" Rude and disrespectful. What a sh*t hole!! read more

Very accommodating and overall a pleasant experience. Highly recommend supporting small businesses!

I had a flat on one of my 32.6" tires. My good friend recommended a tire repair place in Ronkonkoma. I was there for over an hour and they could not find the leak. My boss who lives in Massapequa suggested Tires by Tony. My tire was in very good condition and retails for $500.00. I was nervous when the technician jabbed the tool they use, into my tire under one minutes time of him looking at the tire. I have to say, the guy has a good eye bc he found the leak. I also have had no issues with this tire since. I 100% recommend this place. They're not extremely welcoming or warm & fuzzy but who cares so long as they do the job right! If you have a flat, go here! read more

I've came here before and never had a problem but today I went to go get a used tire and there was nowhere to put my car except in front of the bay which was completely unattended... They proceeded to come inside ask who's white car is that cursing at me, calling me all types of insults and names and told me they will no longer sell me a used tire... Insulted me on the way out... Real trashy business read more

This is the BEST place for tires. Honest treatment, fair prices and great service. Cant ask for more. Have been here a few times over the past 10 years and it's always been a pleasure. Today I went in for a flat and on a budget I got a used tire. I said I should probably get two and he checked other side and said it was fine and didn't need it. Most places would just take the extra money, but at Tony's I know I can trust them to treat me right. Thanks! read more

Tires by Tony - Used tire - Tires Near Me - Seaford, New York

Pretty solid place. They almost always have availability to get your tires serviced quickly. I've been there twice and they helped plug up my tires that seem to just always find their ways over screws and nails. The only small issue is that after they plugged up the tire, they filled it up far above the PSI needed which could've been a real hazard. read more

It took me so long to write this review, because two guys told me as the slammed my truck shut that they we're going to sue me . They gave me two bad tires and intimated me but if that's how you what to get to get your tire tony is your man read more

Tony was no nonsense and honest. They get the job done fast. They know their business. Highly recommended.

He is the nastiest man I've ever met. I asked him if the tire was balanced after he patched it. He said yes it's balanced. I said oh I thought you had to put it on a machine and balance and he said "I said it's balanced". I said don't yell at me ,I'm learning and he said "you know what don't come back anymore". He said "I don't take shit especially from women". I said I won't come back he said good don't! I told him everybody says this about you you're nasty. He's like the "Soup nazi on Seinfeld" !! read more

I love this guy. He's the best of the best when it comes to getting great tires at a great price. Go bring your car. Talk to him and you will walk out extremely happy. This is a gentleman. This is a friend and most of all he takes care of all of his customers, the bad reviews are probably his competition knowing that they can't compete against this guy and his business. Tonys son works here. Come take a look at the shop. It is spotless. This is the way of business should be run. 10 stars read more

They are super fast inexpensive and very nice!! They are my go to! They also had my tire rim from a light accident repaired quickly and inexpensively!! read more

Tires by Tony - Repaired rim.. walla.. like magic! - Tires Near Me - Seaford, New York

Been going there for flats forever. Saw a totally different side of the owner. Was there for the last time as owner was rude and accused me of accusing him that he didn't fix my flat the last time in. Imagine after being a repeat customer for years! He wouldn't let it go and continued to yell the entire time I was there. Unfortunate, as it is a convenient place for me, but I will not be spoken to the way I was while there..... read more

Never thought in a million years I would be blown away by a tire shop, but here I am. I've been going here for over 10 years and I never really gave them the appreciation they fully deserve. They are affordable, efficient and honest. These are all the things I look for in any service business. I drive from Lindenhurst and pass several tire shops on the way just to get to Tony. They always have my tire in stock for the best price (trust me, I've done my homework) and they will always patch the tire if they can. Absolutely the best tire shop on long island! read more

Always quick and friendly service! Reasonable pricing and I don't feel like I'm getting ripped off when I go in. Thanks for always having my back guys! read more

In and out for a tire plug in 10 minutes for cheap. Highly recommend these guys and they are local

Zero Stars- had to ask a quick question if they would be available today, as I was on my lunch our. The old man was sooo rude, snarky and dismissive. I've been there once before and they did a fine job but I will never recommend or go there again. There is such a thing as customer service. Especially since it is a family owned business that I was trying to support. read more

Father and son operation. Friendly, reasonable, quick and appreciative for the business. I had a slow leak which they found ultra quick and repaired. I was in and out in 15 minutes!!!I would totally recommend Tires By Tony. SUPPORT OUR LOCAL BUSINESSES!! read more

The owner is rude and abusive. One of my 4 new tires came off the rim as soon as I drove a few blocks away. He wouldn't replace the tire for and loudly yelled at me when I asked for a replacement. read more

This place stinks of remnants of a bygone era where the Mafia was in everything from sanitation to tire sales. Why? Because the f you attitude and lack of care I got at this place makes me feel like if I even remotely complain I'm going to get whacked by the silenced end of a 45 sticking out of a Newsday. Don't get tires here. Unless your kink is role playing being yelled at by your high school girlfriends racist grandpa over a issue they caused in the first place. I give the place a 9/11 because "Tony" wouldn't let me forget how he's been selling tires for 30 years. Good for you, you know a lot about Rubber. Too bad your dad didn't wear one. read more

They are quick to get you in and out . I also love that they're open at 7:00 am earlier than most other tire shops.

i was in TIRES BY TONY 6/12/24 and there was a woman that started yelling at 3 girls( customers) and Tony the gentlemen he is tied speaking to this woman to calm the situation down and she turned to him and said mind your business and get me a tire!! He refused to stoop to her level and refused service!! her review is BS!! TOYS TIRES are by far the best , cheapest prices will not be beat!!!! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED 5 star read more

I LOVE this place. You are in and out in like 7 mins. No bullshit waiting around like at Mavis or those other shitty places. The people on here complaining sound like typical yambag Long Islanders that dont' get catered to and throw a tantrum. The owner is awesome funny and friendly. GO there and give him business. He deserves it. Thanks again Tony. read more

This place is terrible. The staff including the owner is rude and so disrespectful to customers. Went there to replace 2 tires and was treated horrible. Nasty and rude service!! I would not ever go back there and certainly never recommend. Should be ashamed of themselves to treat customers this way. read more

I have been getting tires and flats fixed at Tony's tires for at least 20 years. Great prices and service Definitely recommend this place read more

Great service been going to Tony for years . Tony and his son are very helpful and never looking to rip ya off . Family run place , not to many left like this . read more

i have always gone here for my tires. never had an issue ever! until now. I have a jeep compass. first time getting new tires on it - my dad brought it in for me. After a few days, I noticed anytime I drove over 40mph my steering wheel would shake so bad and the drive was very bumpy. I'm a girl so idk anything about cars to be honest. Told my dad, and said it could possibly be from imbalanced tires after googling and he said okay seems right I'll bring it to the mechanic (we've been going to the same one for 10+ years & I needed an inspection anyway) . mechanic told us tires aren't good and ALL 4 TIRES WERENT BALANCED. That's what you pay for when you get new tires right? front driver side tire had 1000lbs weight to it alone. $200 bill later (and no that didn't include my inspection) I will never come back here ever again. not even worth it to argue to get them to foot the bill for their mistake. Theyll just lose business and I'll never recommend them to anyone anymore. read more

The owner is a total asshole,,,(NOT happy to give a star but didnt know how to erase it ,,,,,,,, August B"s review is very accurate (12/3/22) ,,, Dont know who his employee is (son , nephew whatever) but he takes direction from t Tony The employee gave me a price for a service ,,, I agreed . Tony came out and said a mistake was made and doubled it, I told Tony I wasn"t paying for his mistake and as I was driving away he cursed at me read more

0/5. Untrustworthy, Racist, and disrespectful business owner who pretends to be nice. I came in for a tire patch, and 3 days later the same tire was leaking from where they patched it. They charged me to patch it again and lied about it having a nail in it. When I confronted the owner they didn't own up to it and when I agreed to pay and tried to negotiate the price, the owner, Tony, was extremely rude and RACIST. He told me to "go back to my country" which is sad because I was born and raised in Queens, NY. This demonstrates the degree of his racist ignorance and I wouldn't recommend anyone put another penny in this guys pocket. read more

I've been going to Tony's tires for years and usually they're good. Today I went for a patch and I usually pull my own car in and out of the bay. Today someone else pulled my car out and I noticed a scratch on my door. I went to the workers and explained very politely that I believe they scratched my car and the owners son played stupid. He then went to get his dad. The owner came out with an attitude and starts arguing with my unprovoked. I ask him if his cameras work and he doesnt answer me. He just kept yelling another car hitting car and not his guys. He then walked back into his garage instead of trying to resolve the issue. read more

Tires by Tony - Tires Near Me - Seaford, New York

My left rear tire was very low on air so I went there and they took care of me right away. Turned out I had a screw in the tire so they were able to patch it up instead of replacing it. Everyone was pleasant to deal with, service was quick and you can't beat the price. I highly recommend them!! read more

Tony is a great guy who gets you in and out quickly. Asked him if I needed new tires, he said save your money they are fine. He could have taken me for a nice chunk of change. read more