Awesome new bagel/deli that opened up. 5 star food, goes without saying their bagels are insane. They make them all fresh daily on site which you can taste....Their iced coffee was realllyyyyyy good too! I grew up in East Meadow and went to EMHS many years ago, I wish Toasted was here when I went I would have came every day! The parking lot is super convenient also. I am excited to come back soon and try more of their food, I might go for a burger next time! read more

Toasted Gourmet Bagels - Exterior of Toasted - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Quick, easy, fresh. Can't ask for more from a local bagel shop! We've gone back a couple of times now! Becoming our Saturday morning favorite! Safe was very kind too read more

Got a dozen bagel on Saturday. Haven't been in awhile but looks I see all new people behind the counter. Not sure if changed hands again. Brought bagels in to work. All co-workers said the bagels tasted "off". Had a weird medicinal taste to them. Dumped them read more

The place has reopened with new owners, but it is still the disorganized, chaotic (despite not having many customers) place that it was before. They don't bake many bagels and you can understand that, given the lack of patronage. It's pretty expensive, the place is clean and the other items are okay; some appetizing but nothing to boast about and limited baked items. read more

See all

For years, I had driven past Toasted, intrigued by its catchy name, but I never took the time to stop in. Finally, I decided to check it out. I tried their whole wheat everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, and it was truly exceptional--perfectly made and delicious. I would definitely return. I also loved the charming icon in the corner of the store; it added a unique touch to the atmosphere. read more

Grub hub delivery from Toasted in East Meadow. What I like about the site is it gives you a choice of time delivery. Reuben taste good, in GH it's listed Sandwiches with bagel choice , info bar I noted Rye bread and got that. Moose sandwich is a roast beef with gravy on a hero roll, which to me didn't taste like quality beef but was ok. Total with tax and and a non cash adjustment fee was27 ish dollars.(see pix) read more

One of the best bagels in the area if not of Long Island !! The bagels are soft and fresh and delicious !! Will be back soon!

The food is delicious and the service was great! Nice quiet place to enjoy lunch. I definitely recommend this place.

This place calling themselves a bagel shop almost made us say eh about coming here - it'd be cuter if it was just a general breakfast joint. But nonetheless we came and were surprised even though casual, the lady who rang us up was very friendly and welcoming.. I also like that they bring the food to you even though this isn't a full service restaurant. The breakfast burrito was delicious- I was hesitant about it but luckily it wasn't overwhelming with the salsa flavor and mostly egg+cheese flavor. Then the French toast was huge! for $8, like 8 half slices; love me some powdered sugar on my French toast. They let you do your own mix ins for coffee. I hope we will come back here often.. need to try their bagels next but I'd be back for both those items too! read more

Toasted Gourmet Bagels - French toast, Cali breakfast burrito and iced coffee - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

I ordered 5 sandwiches total was $58! It's crazy how times have changed pricing especially for sandwiches and no sides. I was expecting a large sandwich being that I paid $9-11 for a breakfast sandwich, NOPE. The eggs in sandwich were so thin and one strip of turkey sausage. Terrible ! Talk about price gouge. If the prices for sandwiches are going to be $10 serving size should be generous!!!! There no reason an egg cheese sandwich should be more $6 dollar. Straight robbery read more

Toasted Gourmet Bagels - Egg and cheese with turkey sausage - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Best bagels I've had on Long Island. The new owner Nick takes real pride in the food, especially the bagels. Toasted is my new go to spot for breakfast. Can't wait for the new menu items. Definitely worth the trip, guaranteed! read more

I'm happy with the new changes. It's so good and I get to have varieties unlike before. I definitely recommend.

Today, October 25, 2024, I went to the New Toasted Bagel and had a delicious sesame seed bagel with bacon, egg and cheese! It was scooped and toasted to perfection! My coffee was also wonderful and now I realize that I should have gotten the larger size! The new staff was very friendly, accommodating and knowledgeable. I even met the very down to earth, owner, Nick who lives in the neighborhood with his family, which I love to hear! This will now be my breakfast and lunch place! I can't wait to try their entire menu! read more

A good place to grab a bagel and coffee after blood works. Clean is number one . Yes the bagel is toasted with cream cheese and coffee. Fresh coffee and fresh bagel. That what counts. read more

It WAS really good but NOTE-- this establishment is NO LONGER HALAL VERIFIED by CALL too bad they aren't making a conscious effort to make this known. DO NOT ORDER IF YOU ONLY EAT HALAL really heartbreaking, I loved this place before all this. read more

Stopped for a quick buttered bagel. This is a pretty decent sized place, with several inside tables. I asked for a toasted buttered whole wheat bagel. The bagel was ready in good time and reasonably priced. So far, so good. The problem here is that when I took my first bite I thought there was a butter shortage. While the bagel was fairly large, the amount of butter on it was very small. I would have been far happier paying a little more for more butter. I won't return. read more

Truth- zero stars. Went in Sunday morning. I ordered everything bagel with lox and scallion toasted. My sister ordered a flagged with same spread. The bagels tasted OLD and not even warm. Usually TOASTED bagels would at least be warm. Mind you we ate at the premise. My sister also found a fish bone in her sandwich. The spread was not tasty. I would also like to say NO MASK was worn by any of the staff. Also a woman came back Bc she had just received the wrong order. Not a good sign. She was visibly upset, she did get her money back. Then these men sat across from us (pictured) and they clearly were owners or at least part of management Bc they kept on going behind the counter or in the kitchen. Talking so loudly. And their cologne was so overpowering. Not setting a good vibe at all for customers. Like do your business in an office. Not in front with the customers. Definitely not coming back to this place. read more

Toasted Gourmet Bagels - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Stopped here quick over the weekend. Bagel was fresh and service was quick. I got a small side of tuna to try and I thought it was ok / a little too much on the Mayo creamy side for my tasty but it was still fresh. It was clean inside and busy. I'd like to come back and try some of their sandwiches/wraps which they had a huge menu of! Posted pics of the take out menu for reference. read more

Toasted Gourmet Bagels - Menu - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

See all

We've been waiting to try this new spot in town and today was the day we stopped in for breakfast. Bagels and coffee, blueberry and cinnamon raisin bagel, how coffee and French vanilla ice coffee Yummm! The freshness in the bagels and coffee truly made us happy! It cool that they have more then just breakfast but also lunch goodies like salads and sandwiches and wraps so if you're in the area definitely stop by and enjoy this spot. Who every designed the interior did an amazing job, we loved the layout of the place. read more

See all

Nice open deli shop store inside. Clean and friendly staff. I love there Turkey paninis. Where can you find a great halal Turkey panini on Long Island? This is the place. It does come with cheese but I said no cheese. I wish they updated there hours to the store on google. I remember driving deep to this place and online google it said they close at so and so. When I got there they were already closed. read more

Toasted Gourmet Bagels - Turkey Panini - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

I will never understand why people open up mid level businesses in an area that had that type of food established. If I lived in Idaho and barely knew what a bagel was, this would have been great but I live in NY, this is not up to the standard of bagels that we have. I won't be back here because there are just better options pretty close by. read more

Great bagels and chicken salad. Nick, the owner is so so friendly and helpful I will definitely be going back.

Ordered my breakfast here today via Uber eats. I made an adjustment on my order & forgot to edit the note. This place was kind enough to call me instead of canceling my order or simply not giving my items like other places do. The individual who called me, sounded like a young lady and was very professional and asked me what i wanted, what i ordered, and asked if i wanted a read-back on what i placed on Ubereats. Despite the mistake i made on my end, they honored it for me. I was so happy and grateful! I ordered 8 bagels, sausage edd and cheese on an egg everything, scallion cream cheese on an everything bagel, pancakes, iced coffee, and hot chocolate. I must say my son said this was the best pancakes ever (kind of jealous cause he said i make the best pancakes ever) haha but i am glad that he enjoyed and ate all of his pancakes! The bagels are just how i like them, nice big and fluffy. Def so happy with the bagels. They were generous with the scallion cream cheese, and the sausage egg and cheese was nice and full as well. Usually i prefer my coffee from Starbucks but wow this iced coffee is DELICIOUS. This is my first time ordering from here, and it most definitely won't be my last! Thank you so much!! read more

See all

I only got a bagel here so I can't speak to the rest of their food. However, if you are planning to get bagels, go literally anywhere else. I ordered a very simple egg bagel untoasted with extra cream cheese. First, they made the sandwich on a plain bagel they did remake it. However, in the process of remaking it, I did see the woman attempt to toast the bagel. After I had asked for it to be not toasted, at this point I was in a rush, and I asked for my money back because this is twice they've made the bagel wrong. They would not give me my money back, and only after I pointed out again the bagel was wrong did somebody else go over and help. for it to be not toasted, at this point I was in a rush, and I asked for my money back because this is twice they've made the bagel wrong. They would not give me my money back, and only after I pointed out again the bagel was wrong did somebody else go over and help. The bagel was not cheap, it was $4.15. It was also one of the worst bagels I've ever had. The texture was, the cream cheese had no flavor, and it tasted as though they had cut the bagel with the same knife they used to cut greasy sandwiches. I wound up, throwing the bagel away and going somewhere else. read more

Bagels are a bit stale. Cashier was nice. I guess if you're desperate for a bagel, like I was, come here.

Moh - the new manager and his team were wonderful to work with. I called and told them what I needed and they helped me create the perfect menu for my sons birthday party. The delivery was on time and the food was absolutely delicious. Every single person raved about the wraps and sliders. It's tough to make a delicious veggie wrap and even the meat lovers enjoyed it. I will be ordering again! read more

See all

All the bad reviews are nonsense when I run out of breakfast at the house this is an excellent place to get breakfast... as an athlete that doesn't eat pork for performative reasons it is high quality safe way to make sure my nutrition stays on track ... if you want high quality clean eats this is the place to go for breakfast! read more

A new business with no desire to provide value or service. Stale pumpernickel bagels!!! Very good Egg everything bagel. $15.60 a dozen and NO EXTRA BAGELS INCLUDED! $14.56 a pound for unmixed lox spread with next to no lox in it because its not mixed into cream cheese. Undersized cheap paper thin bag to hold 12 bagels so they end up on the ground in the parking lot of this place. Thats what I mean by NO DESIRE TO PROVIDE SERVICE. Go to Sante Fe on East Meadow Ave or Bagelious( EXPENSIVE BUT THEY HAVE BAGS THAT HOLD A DOZEN BAGEL PURCHASE!) read more

Today was my third time at toasted, and my third disappointment. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel. Can we guess which ingredient they forgot.....BACON!!!!!! Really not sure how you forgot the BACON and a BACON egg and cheese. Thank god I checked the order before left the parking lot, because I went back into the store and the manager at the counter stated "what's the problem" in a condescending tone. I told him they forgot the BACON on the BACON egg and cheese. Instead of insisting on making me a new sandwich with BACON on it, he blamed his inexperience staff for the missing BACON. I had to ask for a new sandwich to be made. PS the BACON is made from BEEF. Therefore, this is not really BACON!!!! read more

My first time visiting and I was disappointed. First with the name toasted I expected toasters to be around. I didn't see any. Second, they say they had lots of different cream cheeses but had no tofo Thirdly, I asked for ham and they said they don't carry it but I could get bacon with my eggs. I did find a sign in tiny print saying no pork products. Fourthly, the signs were very confusing, with two separate places to order. I didn't know where to go That caused a person to cut in front of me. All and all I would say it's an ok breakfast place, but there are better ones around. I added a star because I haven't tried there lunch yet. As the saying goes, you only get one chance to make a good first impression. They failed and I won't be back read more

Love their variety of bagels and various cream cheese spreads. Modern looking and pleasing ambiance, well kept and clean, friendly and family owned local business. Service has always been great. This time had the everything bagel with olive cream cheese, so yum!!! read more

Toasted Gourmet Bagels - Everything bagel with Olive Cream Cheese Spread. A"Just amazing! - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

This place is trashhhhh. I went with the old owners-that was bad. New owners might be worse haha. Every time I go there's something missing from the order. But I mean if u wanna get exactly what u didn't ask for pull up here. Been twice in 2years and it's getting worse read more

Have been here several times, coffee delicious, love the tuna on everything bagel. This is my go to place. Staff courteous and always looking to please customer. My wish is that people who have complaints give this business a chance, they are new it's a trial and error process! Many good wishes for a successful business. read more

I just visited Toast for the third time and disappointed again. The last time I went they overcharged me 8$ because the staff did not know how to properly charge for my items. They were nice and gave me my refund after I realized I spent $25 on 2 bagels. This time I went my husband ordered a cream cheese bagel which barely has cream cheese on it. The food is good but the staff needs real training. Overall a decent bagel shop but some of the employees definitely need training. read more

Toasted Gourmet Bagels - Cream cheese bagel... - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

I went to this place for the second time today. I got a blueberry bagel with Nutella cream cheese, and iced coffee with Cinnabon creamer. The coffee is amazing. The bagels are amazing. The cream cheese is amazing. The prices are amazing. The service is amazing. I have no complaints at all. Not only are the employees very kind, but the owner makes sure to come out and greet his customers. Love this place. read more

Toasted Gourmet Bagels - Blueberry bagel with Nutella cream cheese, iced coffee with Cinnabon creamer - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

So I have been having stomach pains and cvs was out of laxatives so I decided to go to toasted. For some odd reason there bagels have the same effect Especially their pumpernickel. So I decided this morning to get one with there lox spread. Let me tell you I do believe in magic after visiting toasted. So I get there this morning at 630 and the sign says there under construction? I'm very confused after the 2 year construction to open how there still under construction? Is it me or is this place finally closing down so we can try again to get a good deli and or bagel store here. I guess Rome wasn't built in a day so the construction on toasted continues.. read more

Toasted Gourmet Bagels - Cooks playing soccer - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Ordering process went fine. Bagel itself tasted nice and fluffy. However, don't suggest you get anything with meats there. My brother in law asked for pastrami on his breakfast sandwich and literally got one slice of pastrami! What?! For my sausage egg sandwich, I literally received one link cut in half... this is not the right way to do egg sandwiches on bagels. I've never had sausage links in breakfast sandwiches let alone one where they cut them in half. read more

Toasted Gourmet Bagels - Sausage egg bagel where they cut one sausage link in half... unacceptable - Bagels Near Me - East Meadow, New York

Awesome Halal breakfast options here!! Very happy a place like this is in East Meadow! Husband likes the early bird special (added the Turkey bacon) and my sesame seed bagel with scallion cream cheese tasted delicious! Thanks Toasted! read more

Bruh i ordered a sausage egg and cheese.. i was given egg cheese and sliced hotdog... HOW DO YOU MESS UP BREAKFAST?!? HOW SWAY.. How are you selling ppl sausage and giving them HOTDOGS.. so many bagels joints on the island and deli's.. stay clear of here. Also one of the guys behind the counter was kinda racist towards an African american customer who for some reason he told to go to the back cuz he had to help other before her. But everyone had already been helped, kinda suss he made the girl cry. Deff go to another deli read more

Egg sandwich with bacon was amazing and the rice pudding was delicious too the place so clean and the service very good..