Wings are the best in town, everything else on the menu seems to be hit or miss. Service is great, hometown place

Great wings, cool atmosphere and very reasonable pricing. The staff is awesome and they always go the extra mile. read more

Waitress had serious lack of menu knowledge....potato options, steak cut, etc. Dinner served all at one time...salad w dinner. Food prep looked good...but, meat was room temp., steaks were improperly cooked per order, vegs were mushy, settled for fries after baked was not an option....ALL cold. Expensive...especially when quality was so poor. Overall....very bad....will not go back. read more

Horrible food and terrible taste. We used to love the food but can't get over tonight's food. Also ordered pizza rolls and was told there would be 5,and there was only4 read more

Toby Hill Bar & Grill - These are not leftovers. This was the entire order - Gastropubs Near Me - Clarion, Pennsylvania

Wow what an amazing place. Sarah took care of us and was amazing. We were driving from San Francisco to Philadelphia and got in late. They were one of the only places open. We decided to try them out and we just astounded. The place is unassuming and laid back but the food was amazing. I was there on Tuesday... Steak night. They advertise a 12oz ribeye that was easily 2 pounds. Cooked and seasoned perfectly. It was by far the best steak I have had to date. It's was better than I can cook a steak! I ordered wings for an appetizer and they were big and meaty and the sauce perfect. All their sauces and salad dressings are house made and delicious. The food is amazing. The prices are definitely better than most restaurants and the service way better. The next time I'm traveling thru PA I am definitely planning my trip to be able to stop back here. If you are in the Clarion area I definitely recommend stopping here for a meal read more

Toby Hill Bar & Grill - Ribeye steak, wings and a great burger! - Gastropubs Near Me - Clarion, Pennsylvania

See all

The bar has a homey feeling to all who enter. You will never find better wings or wing sauces anywhere you go. So many drink options. Yup can't go wrong with a stop at Toby Hill! read more

The wings were good. Had lots of beer options so that was nice. I wish they kept the Pool table opened all night until they close. That is what makes a bar experience great! Atmosphere is great but service was little slow. "Bartender" doesn't really know typically bar drinks like a old fashion or martini. I'll go again but drinks are a little over priced. read more

I'll be back! My husband and I were traveling through on a long car trip and happened to stop by after doing a quick internet search...and we'll definitely be back! The outside is unassuming, and walking in it looks like any other local small-town bar, but the food, drinks, and overall experience really set it apart. We sat at the bar and had $1 Labatts on draft and ordered the best wings that I have ever had in my entire life. Seriously. They were meaty and fresh (fresh and never frozen is their claim) and so delicious. We picked Hell Sauce and it was peppery, tangy, and good and spicey, but not too spicy. My husband had the cheesesteak and I had the taco salad. Both were very, very, very good. Our order actually got lost in the kitchen and the bar tender bought us a drink to apologize. If you try Toby Hill, don't be dissuaded by the townies that hang out in front of the place or at the bar. There is a dining room in the back and we saw many families in and out on a Saturday night. Clarion University is in town and it sounds like this place is a favorite for students. The locals sitting at the bar were great to talk to and we felt immediately welcomed even though we were from out of town. My five star rating might be because I had low expectations walking in...but I truly have not had as good of a meal or experience at a bar like this in a long, long time. read more

Toby Hill Bar & Grill - Gastropubs Near Me - Clarion, Pennsylvania

Great beer selection! The crowd is college kids and townies. Bar tenders are quick, friendly, and get the job done.The decor is typical small town bar- beer decorations, some fishing gear, and a bull skull. They have karaoke some nights and other nights they have a live band. Great wings and fries. read more

This is, by far, the single greatest establishment I have ever been to, and trust me, you will not find those hyperbolic statements on my other yelp reviews. Anyone who gives this less than five stars is BANANAS. I have searched the country far and wide to find wings that are this delicious and also at this low price point. The combination is completely unmatched. The also have a great beer selecting ranging from all of the standard domestics to quite an array of crafts. Don't even get me started on the waffle fries..... DELICIOUS. You can get delicious food and beer for under $10. So great. There are a lot of college youths here, but its still a pretty tame joint. I would rank this 12 stars, but yelp only limits me to five. read more

This place doesn't look like it would be awesome from the outside, but it is so fabulous! Ashley was our server and she was beyond wonderful. We had the fried pickles, pizza logs, and each picked a burger. The "Hot Mess" burger was to die for along with the pickles. The breakfast and Capone burger were both very good. The waffle fries are also a must as they are seasoned to perfection. This place was beyond wonderful and the walls and ceiling are not to be missed. read more

See all

Have patronized this establishment in the past and it was ok. Highly disappointed tonight. Waited over an hour for our food even though they were not busy. Ordered grilled chicken and chicken Parm sandwiches. They were cubed chicken, not what we expected. Still would have been ok except the chicken parm was on burnt black toast. Bar waitress failed to inquire about our food much less apologize for the wait or the obviously improperly prepared sandwich. read more

The bar itself is pretty cool. The service was good and the wings are fantastic! The next time I'm passing through I will definitely stop again. read more

Nice little place to grab a beer or a burger. Specials are usually good, the bartenders are very nice and the prices are very reasonable, especially since I'm used to DC prices. It will be crowded on the weekends, and the back bar really could use a 'tender more often than not, or at least when karaoke is going on in that area. read more

Dive bar to the max. It's lacking on the outside.... To the point that I wouldn't even come in if it wasn't recommended to be by a bartender from another restaurant. Great bar tenders, quality food and a massive selection of beer. read more

I had a great time here! Didn't eat anything but the beer and shots were fun and the bartender was funny as well. Don't be scared to go in (like i was initially)! read more

Good beer selection - service is not great - fun environment. Bottle beer is nice and cold.

I would have given this place 5 stars if we hadn't waited so long to get our food. The food was awesome...exactly what the reviews say! Don't judge a book by it's cover. There is lots of seating in the back, we were a large group and were there around 4 o'clock on a Saturday. I had the Hot Mess and would get it again! My husband loved his burger too! The kids had the wings and loved them. Their sauces were awesome! read more

If going here be ready to here loud music and not be able to socialize with anyone. If you want wings, I would highly recommend elsewhere, as anytime i get wings here they taste like they have been sitting out for a few hours. Also, hopefully you don't bring more than 4 people, since apparently that is their max seating arrangement, and won't allow you to put tables together or bring an extra chair to the table. Hard pass. read more

Excellent service, bartender Sarah is awesome. Great food. Tons of beer choices. Outside looks questionable. But this is a hidden gem. Was passing through traveling and stopped, glad we did. read more

We almost left when we saw the outside. Don't make that mistake. If not the best food ever, it was a great road trip stop. Friendly place with good food and great prices. Check out the murals depicting famous albums on the walls. We had wings and Sweet potato fries. read more

Stopped in from the highway looking for a good meal and some football. Got both plus an excellent beer menu, coolest rock and roll mural I've ever seen. Sarah the bar tender waitress hostess does it all with a smile. read more

My husband and I were staying at a lodge in a town nearby and crossed though Clarion. We came by Toby Hill by chance. I'm SO glad we did! The food was much better than you would expect at a bar, our bartender was really cool and nice (I don't remember his name but he's in the Army national guard... If you're reading this, thank you for serving our country!), and the atmosphere is awesome. It's laid back, good music, a variety of beer. All around, just really great. Go here! You won't regret it! read more

Meeting in Knox, PA tomorrow and the closest decent hotel is in Clarion. Asked the desk clerk at the hotel to recommend a dive bar with good food and he immediately mentioned the Toby Hill Bar & Grill. Nailed it!!! Awesome craft beer selection and Jake really knows his stuff!! Wings with "Dirty Sauce" are the bomb. Just a little heat and almost, but not quite, to much garlic... I am in heaven. read more

I cannot believe I gave up a trip to Bob's Subs to eat here...and was not disappointed!!

Food wasn't the greatest, pizza rolls were burnt and the chicken wings looked like pidgeon wings. The sauce on the wings was good. The beer was good, not flat, but a little pricey, but since it is a college town, it is to be expected. Lots of TV's, but the layout is a little cramped and when they have a band in/open mic you can forget about talking to anybody or watching the game, never be able to hear. When the college kids make it down there, it gets really packed and difficult to move around in. No pool table, 1 dart board and a music stage. read more

Our food at Toby Hill wasn't perfect... the sweet potato fries still tasted distinctly of the freezer, but the other food was delicious and overall, it was a great experience at a great price. The wait staff was friendly and the food came fast. The menu has a lot of fun options and my swamp queen burger was memorable enough that I tried to recreate it at home. Our hot wing fanatic was a fan and felt the hot wings were hot enough for once. The low point was trying to get our check which took over 20 minutes. read more

Went with my sister and son and had a blast. We honestly asked the server if they would be willing to pick the place up and put it where we live so we could visit all the time. Outside yes, is a little dumpy but the inside is so fun. They have painted walls in the bar with a music theme which is very cool. The food was delish and the drinks were made well. My favorite was the HOT MESS burger. Go for fun time and ask for Ashley! read more

Friendly staff and good food, all for a reasonable price. I love the vegetable quesadillas, and they always have homemade soups and desserts. Taco Tuesday is the greatest, $0.50 hard tacos can't be beat! read more

Never again! Four of us walked into an empty dining room, asked where they would like us to sit. Waited 10 minutes. Twelve bikers came in sat next to us and got waited on first. We live here and would have been frequent customers and brought a lot of friends. Oh yeah. We are great tippers too. Oh well!! read more

Terrible service every time I go. This was the last straw. Sat around for an hour waiting for tacos on TACO TUESDAY! People who came in way later got served way before us. It was like my friends and I were invisible to the waitresses who were way more concerned about getting drinks out...except for my water which I waited a half an hour for and had to go to the bar to ask again. Went to Loomis and got served as soon as we sat down. Captain Loomis for the win! read more

Perfect dive bar with amazing food! We stopped on our way thru PA on a Sunday. Got the grilled cheese and fries (2.95), the Moby Dick fish sandwich which was huge, and some jalapeño poppers. Food was amazing! We're planning a camping trip back out here just to come again. Worth the stop! read more

Best baked fish dinner, I've had in a long time. Mac and cheese was awesome. 2.00 drafts. My new favorite place!!!

I've eaten here many times and stop in often to try out some new craft and specialty brews. They have a good selection of beer on tap. All the usual domestics and imports plus some great specialties that rotate constantly. They have a great bottle selection and there is something good for anyone's taste. The food here has always been good. The wings are great, and specialty burgers usually are a good pick too. I stop up on Tuesdays when I can for Mexican food night. It's not authentic Mexican food by any means but they have some very good, creative burritos for great prices. The decor and atmosphere of the bar is awesome. The back room has a mural painted around all the walls that you could look through for hours. Check it out if you stop in. The crowd is typically college kids and some locals. read more

Very good bar. Although it's sucks that they don't have a pool table. Very good bar tending service. Good selection from food and beverages. If your looking to go out after dark in clarion this is one of the first bars I'd recommend to you. read more

Visiting from out of town, hands down best wings and craft beer. Excellent customer service!

Great place to stop for a burger-- food specials are always outstanding! Gotta have the dirty burger!

Service is sub standard, ran like a college fraternity house by popularity and needs bouncers, probably because of a few of the bartenders attitudes. I would relate it to strip club, rude unless they want to nice. Food can be good or bad like the service. If you don't mind servers who are fake and rude it's ok. This is a cheap place to eat a decent burger. Menu is short. I tip 25 percent. read more

This is one of the best bars to order food in Clarion! Amazing spinach dip, wings, and pizza logs! They also have such a variety of beer on tap and in a bottle! Highly recommend. read more

i had a lot of fun here. my boyfriend's band played, which is why i was there in the first place. i wasn't sure what to expect... a bunch of drunk college kids? townies? what are townies like in clarion anyway? but the crowd was responsive, active, but not annoying and the staff was awesome. everyone was super friendly, knowledgable, and generous. the prices were completely reasonable and the alcohol selection was great! i didn't try any food, but i've been told it's all pretty darn good and the atmosphere was really cool. the place is pretty big, but it's separated into two sections, with two separate bars to cut down on bar traffic. the room where the stage is has a huge awesome mural on the wall too! read more