So my friend ordered from here during a game night around 11 pm on a Sunday since this is one of the few pizza places nearby open until midnight. We got the large buffalo chicken pizza. When it arrived, there wasn't a phone call, only a text saying it had been delivered. My friend felt bad because they weren't able to leave a tip after the driver came all that way late at night, and when they called, they were told not to worry about it. So my recommendation is to keep checking your phone because they may not call once it's delivered. I also think calling customers would help so people can leave a tip and so the pizza stays hot instead of sitting on the porch. If my friend hadn't checked the phone, we wouldn't have even known it arrived. Although the pizza was smaller than we expected, it was absolutely delicious and honestly crave-worthy because I'm still thinking about it. At first I felt a little disappointed because there was no tomato sauce and I had really been craving tomato sauce, but the buffalo sauce had this weirdly addictive quality to it and worked so well with the cheese. I can definitely understand why they don't combine it with tomato sauce because the buffalo flavor would probably overpower it, but I still secretly wanted the tomato sauce too. One thing that impressed me more than expected was the quality of the chicken on the pizza. It was sooo good. I don't know if it was grilled or what, but it was excellent chicken -- juicy, flavorful, and not even slightly hard or rubbery. The chicken honestly made me want to try their chicken bacon cheddar ranch and chicken broccoli Alfredo pizzas too. I just wish every slice had the same amount of chicken because I think the chicken was what I was looking forward to the most. I also still want to try their regular pizza with tomato sauce and will update this review when I do. Even though buffalo chicken pizza normally wouldn't have been my personal first choice, I somehow ended up eating 8 slices because it was that delicious and easy to eat. Definitely more pizza than I planned on eating, but something about it kept making me want another slice. Looking forward to ordering from here again. read more

Tomatoes II Pizzeria - Buffalo Chicken Pizza (Large 14'') - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

See all

I feel cheated and robbed! I would give this place zero stars if I could! This place has deceptive advertising! The bread sticks look delicious in the photo. But such is not the case! The bread sticks look like they are previously frozen and heated up in a microwave! The sauce was so spicy it hurt my mouth! I could have gotten a better pizza somewhere else! I paid $20.00 for these!! I'm never going here again!! Door dash refused to refund my money! And I have been a good customer for years! When I complained that the order looked nothing like it did in the photo, I still did not get my money back! read more

The best pizza joint in Pittsburgh. Great food, cheap prices, and they're open late. These guys are great at what they do.

This place is under new management. I love their thin crust pepperoni pizza. It is totally delicious the sauce tastes amazing it has a bite of a kick to it. Great blend of cheeses makes it taste fantastic. This my new favorite place to get pepperoni pizza. Best in Pittsburgh. My wife and kids love the pizza as well!!! I've been here 4 days out of 7 just for the pizza yummy read more

See all

Sorry but this place is a huge disappointment. I don't know why they show those pepperoni puffs on their main page, because that is NOT what you get. They are ok, but just plain, dry dough balls with cheese and pepperoni in them, not covered in cheese and parsley as shown at all. They also come with a very small container of horrible sauce that tastes like old ketchup. I also got a steak hoagie, that had two very dry pieces of what tasted like an old steak-um covered in some spicy seasoning that tasted very old and bitter. The French fries tasted very greasy and old also. The front door of this place had its glass broken and replaced by a large piece of plywood, that should have been a sign to stay away! read more

Tomatoes II Pizzeria - Pepperoni pillow puffs, nothing like the picture on their site - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

Ordered a Sicilian pizza and a meatball hoagie. Both were abysmal. Sicilian was essentially a flatbread with little to no cheese or toppings. Meatball hoagie was all bun with 3 (HALF) meatballs with little to no sauce. Strongly recommend against this establishment read more

Ordered via Eat24 for pick-up and found that our pizza was on time and still looked fresh out of the oven. We went for the chicken and spinach which also came with thinly sliced tomatoes and bacon. We also subbed white sauce since it seemed more apt for these toppings... Great choice! Toppings weren't very heavy handed but we still found the flavors spot on. In regards to service, we found the staff to be very friendly when we walked in. When we asked for a few plates, the lady behind the counter neatly bagged us a few heavy duty plates and napkins. I actually only expected a few paper plates to be handed to me. The only thing that could have been better was if the crust was just a bit more crisp. read more

Tomatoes II Pizzeria - Chicken and Spinach - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

Their chicken bacon ranch is amazing. Closest place for pick up and would be worth it at double the distance.

With all the pizza options, it was hard to decide where to get delivery. But I came across this one and I just had to try it because of the good reviews. We ordered a combo of pizza with one topping, wings (Asian zing flavor and a 2 litter soda. I was pleasantly surprised that it had more wings than I had expected. The pizza was good but I wasn't a big fan of the amount of cheese, it was a bit too much with the flavor. We really liked the wings! They were big and crispy with a good amount of sauce. Give this place a try, you might be pleasantly surprised! read more

Tomatoes II Pizzeria - Asian zing Wings - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

See all

Pizza was horrible! Sauce seemed liked jar NO FLAVOR & the cheese MADE ME ILL - I now see they use Italian cheeses so the pizza smelled like feet and flavor again was bland Pasta Carbonara - pasta was cooked to perfection -AL DENTA! Lovely - sauce was thin and bland Wish I had better to report Ordered online quick and easy with text message updates on timeframe of delivery and they were right on time read more

I love Tomatoes II! Their margarita pizza is absolutely wonderful and their delivery staff is superb. Over the years we have sampled quite a few of their pizzas and every single one we have received has been fresh and perfect. read more

Typical, average Pittsburgh Pizzeria. it amazes me how so many average pizzerias are in and around Carnegie are able to stay in business. So pick what's good. The wings are A+, pizza in general a B, salads B, sandwiches range from B to D. Lets start with the bad, steak & cheese and anything chicken hold a solid D to the meatball which is a B. Can someone tell me where to get a good steak and cheese please! I wish I could post a pic of my latest S&cheese from here, dried up steak with a slice of provolone on an over cooked roll. Not exactly the Philly style S&C I was hoping for. read more

I get takeout from Tomatoes II all the time. The crust is on the softer side and is quite yummy. I usually get medium size pizza to avoid a case of the droopies (is that a word - spell check say "no"). I just don't like droopy pizza. My go-to favorites are the meat and taco. The meat pizza is as you would expect, a carnivore's dream. The taco pizza is topped with taco meat, cheddar cheese, followed by crushed tortilla chips, fresh lettuce, and tomato. The chips provide a texture change which I really like. Small Pizza base price is under $10 so you can get a really good pizza at a great price. Delivery is fast if you are in the area. read more

Tomatoes II Pizzeria - Hot Pepper Balls - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

See all

Awesome little pizza place in Carnegie. We recently moved out of the city and it's hard to find a good pizza place and honestly Tomatoes II might be one of my favorites now. We usually get the White Pizza, hot pepper cheese balls, and another app (varies). I think the White Pizza is amazing! The flavors you get when biting into the first slice are out of this world! I would take this pizza over any other any day. I normally order on Yelp because it's easier. Our first time ordering on Yelp took a very very long time. I had to reach out to Yelp after an hour to figure out where our food was and the owner called me and apologized and our food showed up shortly after. No real issues but they're not far from us so I didn't expect it to take as long as it did. I would recommend this place to anyone looking for something different to try. I say get one of the gourmet pizzas because you can get a cheese & pepperoni pizza anywhere. Great little find for us! read more

I ordered from them for delivery. When their projected time had run up, I called and they said the pizza was on the way. They never showed up. I'd avoid ordering from them. read more

One of the best pizza deliveries in the south hills. We ordered the spinach and feta pizza with white sauce and enjoyed it. What exceeded our expectations was the breaded zucchini planks and hot pepper cheese balls. Typically by the time it's delivered to your house, deep fried appetizers tend to lose their crispness and become soft but not Tomatoes! Our zucchini planks and cheese balls arrived super crisp and hot just like if would have been dining in. Big thumbs up for figuring that out! read more

See all

Really good! I am from out of town and this really hit the spot. I ordered the ham and pineapple pizza. Right amount toppings... perfect! read more

Tomatoes II Pizzeria - Ham and pineapple pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

I really like this place. The wings are great, the hoagies are great, the salads are great, and the delivery is always on time and super friendly. The wings are probably the best I've had of their type. They are pretty heavily breaded and fried (some like naked wings- these are not them!) and we got bourbon flavor and it was awesome. The salads are always fresh with a good amount of toppings and dressing. I like the popcorn chicken salad. My only reason for four stars and not five is the pizza. It's just not my favorite and for whatever reason seems to be undercooked. I like a doughy pizza, but this takes squishy to a new level. It TASTES okay, so if I order more I'd just ask for it to be well done. The manager (owner maybe?) has delivered to our house on occasion, and he is the sweetest man with the best customer service. Glad a place like this delivers to my area!! read more

The Buffalo chicken pizza was awesome! Great thin crust, tender chicken(very), and great heat level.

I have ordered from the surrounding pizza joints. I dont want to disparage them because they employ people. Tomatoes Pizza crust is better, and delivery is time reasonable because I dont want you to rush thru my order. I want it prepared correctly. The chicken wings are big, juicy and well cooked with many sauces. I will be ordering more on football Sunday until they fire Coach Tomlin. read more

This was a good, solid pizza. I am not a huge fan of that standard doughy pizza (think Vocelli's, Domino's) so that's why it doesn't get five stars. I prefer a thinner, more New York style pizza, but again, it's simply personal choice here. That being said, this pizza had an excellent sauce with a subtle spice to it that really made it stand out. If I was ordering for a large group I'd go with this pizza place because I'm sure that it would please everyone. Also got a wedgie, that uniquely Pittsburgh mix between a calzone and a hoagie, and it was delicious. Definitely one of the better wedgies I've ever had. Lastly, the delivery man was exceptionally nice. I didn't believe it from the reviews (after all, how can all of these people be getting the same GrubHub/Yelp guy) but Tomatoes II sends their own delivery person out for those orders as well, and he really is the kindest delivery person ever. read more

Pizza was so good, calzone omg amazing, the wings were delicious. I will definitely be going back.

I've never been to the restaurant, but I've ordered their food almost every week for the past two months. Delivery times vary, it's usually fast (less than an hour, usually 30-45 minutes), but there was a time it was almost a 2 hour wait. That said.... the food and prices are so good I couldn't even get mad enough to discontinue business. The food is absolutely delicious! I love, love, LOVE their pizza. It's got some kind of spice going on that makes it different from every other pizza joint in Pittsburgh and keeps me coming back. The wings are pretty generous, the Cesar chicken wrap is delicious, and the hoagies never disappoint. But the French fries? They're the best. Greasey with real cheese, not cheese sauce, on top. You can tell the ingredients are fresh, and the food is well crafted. read more

Ordered food on friday they said it would be an hour wait and ask if that would be ok and I said as long as they didn't start cooking it then and the person said with a chuckle no no you will get hot food. Sure enough 45 minutes later the order was at my door hot fresh and delicious! All the food was great and I highly recommend the Sicilian pizza! Great job to the staff at Tomatoes 2 read more

Fantastic. Ordered an XL chicken and spinach pizza with white sauce and was not disappointed. The pizza was everything I thought it would be. Huge pieces of chicken, crumbled bacon, wilted spinach, all covered with gooey melty cheese. Service was amazing. Ordered the XL online and when the driver showed up he informed me they had ran out of XL dough balls so they brought a large and a small! You don't see customer service like that very often anymore. All in all very satisfied 10/10 customer service and food quality both greatly exceeded my expectations. I will definitely be ordering from Tomatoes II again! read more

TOMATOES II's delicious food experience is further sweetened by the amazing delivery staff they have!! I've loved interacting with both Jim and Will whenever they show up with piping hot Pizza or Mozzarella sticks! This is one store that truly cares about its customers and I'd recommend them to anyone - Utkarsh read more

One star is for prompt delivery. Otherwise, the food was awful. I ordered a small supreme pizza and 6 wings. The pizza crust was not fully cooked. The pizza sauce was barely there and had almost no flavor. They toppings used were as cheap as you could possibly get. I have never had a pizza the taste is so much like nothing. They also did not honor my request for no olives. Disappointed, I decided to try the wings. When I open the box the wings were sitting in a third of an inch of oil. They were over saturated in oil and unpalatable. I was excited to try a new place that had good reviews. I was shocked with how bad the food was. I will not be going there again. read more

We've ordered from them several times-both delivery and pick up. Their pizza is very solid and they have stuffed crust! I prefer a heartier sauce that is actually seasoned and theirs definitely delivers. Delivery times have always been accurate. They are our go to because we know they are consistently good. read more

Fantastic! Fresh ingredients! Grilled Chicken Salad, Appetizer Sampler Platter and Meat Lover's Pizza! Used the delivery app and it was great! Delivery man was polite and fast! read more

Tomatoes II Pizzeria - Grilled Chicken Salad...all fresh ingredients as if they just plucked them from the garden! Beautiful presentation for delivery! - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

See all

I don't normally write reviews on yelp unless I have a bad experience. So I will start taking these things serious. This place was good pizza was good got the chicken bacon ranch (mozzarella instead of cheddar) but it was good.. wings were ok but pizza was quality tasting. I would order again. read more

I do have to say it was delicious, great pie, delivery was on time would definitely order again!

Ok first: I ordered through Grub hub. Amazing! Second: I've never had tomatoes ll pizza. From the moment the delivery driver handed it to me, all the way to my kitchen counter, it smelled AMAZING! I opened the box and to my surprise it's real cheese! Not crappy oily fake cheese. Real cheese! I take a bite and it was as if the Pizza Gods were smiling upon me. I said, with a mouth full of pizza goodness, "I need to leave a raving crazy mad super fan review"! Third: By Zeus's beard this Pizza is amazing! Pepperoni and a Margarita pizzas. #getinmybelly Fourth: why are you still reading this?! Go get one! Or two! read more

Tomatoes II Pizzeria - Margarita Pizza!!! - Pizza Near Me - Carnegie, Pennsylvania

My go to delivery when I'm just not in the mood for cooking. They make everything easy when deciding and ask all the right questions if I forgot something. I typically do their game time combo and it's a large pizza, whole sub, wings, and soda for under $30! This feeds me for about 4 days and man oh man is it delicious! Steak sub is always toasted fresh and perfect in flavor.... nice crust to topping ratio on the pizza which is what I enjoy, and the wings are always fully coated in the flavoring i picked which I'm personally a stickler for so I like that aspect! read more

This place has been my go-to since I started Living in Carnegie. Can't tell you how many times I've ordered from them. All the menu options are great, I usually spring for the garlic knots every time! The staff is very polite, and personable. Always delivers faster than they say they will. read more

Got delivery for my hotel and it took a while, therefore it was not fresh --- the wings were pretty good and I could tell the Pizza would have been good had I been at the place live. Oh Well --- at least I didnt have to fight the traffic and I got to watch New Girl on netflix while I ate. read more

Best pizza I've had in a long time; and I have pizza every Friday. Fresh hand tossed dough and delicious sauce. We ate in but delivery available. Very friendly staff. read more

First time trying this place and I was pleasantly surprised by the great food, accurate delivery time and wonderful service! I look forward to purchasing again! read more

I placed a order through grubhub. I received a call from staff stating that they did not have chicken wings as they cannot find a distributor who has them available for order. The man who called me back was very kind and offered me a hoagie to replace the wings. I told him I would have to call back as my gf was the one who wanted the wings. After I confirmed with her I called back. I had asked for two appetizers. They did not have popcorn chicken as that was another item they could not order. I did not complain and understood. They let me order 3 appetizers and continued to apologize when they arrived to my house with the order. This was the first time I ordered from here and I will again. Food and customer service skills were on point read more

Chose this place because it was close and they had a good selection on the menu. I ordered a chicken salad and my boyfriend got a buffalo chicken sub. Both were delicious! Their prices seemed pretty good for the size too. We used online delivery, which was easy, but it might have been faster to just pick it up in store. read more

Delicious pizza, wings and hoagies! They also have amazing customer service. I haven't seen such service since I lived out of state. Very impressed! read more