We ordered a pizza a few weeks ago. We picked it up and when we got home it was the not what we ordered. We called and they agreed to a remake which we had to go back to the store to pick up. They told us they would give us a credit for a future pizza of equal value. Tonight we called to get our credit and they had no record of our credit. Finally they offered us a $5 credit but after refusing and wanting to speak with a manager and an 8 minute wait they hung up on us. We will never patronize Tommy's Pizza again. read more

We have been eating Tommy's pizza for over 15 years and have slowly noticed that in the past five years, the Dublin location has been declining with its standard of customer service and quality. This evening, we ordered a large pizza and a sub. When we got home and we discovered the pizza was completely burnt on top with no cheese And was completely inedible (unless you want to break a tooth). We took it back, asking for a refund and thought they would offer to give it to us for free due to the inconvenience of having to drive back-and-forth due to their error. However, they would not do both. They said they would remake it or refund it. That's all. I feel it is my duty to warn people about how terrible this customer service is. This is not the first time this has happened to us, however, we are forgiving, and wanted to give them more attempts to show us that they were worthy of our business. Sadly, after this evening, I can tell you I will never eat there again. read more

I ordered chicken parmigiana, garlic bread, salad with ranch, and a side of extra marinara. I received my food package on its side spilling out of the container, not because of the delivery driver, but because it was placed sideways and the bag was sealed. I also received bread and a very large side of ranch dressing. No salad and no extra sauce. I called to get it corrected, but the host said the manager was too busy in the kitchen and would call me back sometime and then suggested I come pick up what was left out at another time. Why would I want salad and marinara another day of the week. Also it was for delivery not pick up. Very disappointed in the Dublin location this time and about 4 months ago when we picked up our pizza and garlic bread on time and it was already cold. Also the chicken parmigiana was very salty. read more

Tommy's Pizza - No salad, no sauce extra side of sauce - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

5 stars is for 5 star service, quality and consistent big flavor i get each and every time i come to this particular location. Keep up the excellent work Tommys. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

It is a small pizza joint with the greatest pizza in the area! We were four people and ordered a chef salad and a large pizza: half pepperoni and half with cheese, pepperoni, onions and black olives. The service was great, and the place is clean and cozy. The prices are average. It is worthwhile to go or order some local pizza. read more

Wow, this is not the same place we used to enjoy. Just picked up 2 subs and a few appetizers, the meat tasted very strange, forgot the Italian dressing on the side. Ended up throwing the subs away unfortunately. Broccoli bites were cold in the center and we don't live far away so they didn't sit long before trying to eat. $32 bucks wasted, won't return. Sorry. read more

Tommy's in Dublin is trying really hard to put themselves out of business. On a Saturday night in football season, they AGAIN, were only offering pizza and subs for pick-up and delivery. Could not even get a darn salad! No cheese balls, appetizers, or entrees, either, which is what my out-of-town guests wanted. It has been this way FOREVER. They keep claiming not enough workers. And their dining room appears to still be closed. Skimpy toppings on the pizza, which was delivered cold through Door Dash. They should just hang it up. Staff is always rude anyway. read more

What a bummer. All the restaurants are closed in Ohio! I'm traveling for work during the shutdown and staying at a local hotel. DoorDash is still operating, so I ordered food from a local business. I ordered cheeseballs, meatballs, and a pizza. I ate every stinking cheeseball (they're that good!) and two pieces of pizza. Also phenomenal. I haven't tried the meatballs yet, because at that point I was full. Great food! Thank you for being open during this time for emergency responders. read more

Tommy's Pizza - 11" Small (Cheese) with mushrooms and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Best pizza I have had in Columbus. So disappointed they have gone to carry out only since pandemic. It is one of those pizzas that has to be eaten right out of the oven. Hope they return to eat in someday. Three stars because of seating situation. read more

By far the worst pizza I ever had, dry, a whole pizza is missing pepperoni and cheese. I called and they said that they talked to their cooked and he said he thought the pizza looked good. They offered me a $5 credit. They were extremely rude and nonchalant about the whole situation. Never eating here again. And to make matters worse mt kids hated the pizza and they love pizza. read more

Tommy's Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Ordered pick up via Doordash , sadly the pizza, Italian sub, & onion rings were all over cooked. Unfortunately, it might be time to seek out another local pizza restaurant as our " regular go to spot " we have only been satisfied with our orders 50 percent of the time read more

Delicious and fast service! Order was done on line and was easy. I'd order from there again next time I am in town.

Just the best. Disclaiming as food is art and art is personal but for me Tommy's is the best. Crispy crunchy cracker crust and tasty toppings. Go To zza read more

Well I just finished eating my pizza and what a delight. I'm traveling through the area and decided to order in. The pizza was hot and fresh! I even got fried mushrooms which were hit. I will definitely try this again when I'm in town. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Fried mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Their pizza shop in Dublin is the best because it has the crispy cracker crust the shop on W Lane Av and the Upper Arlington shop seem to have veered away from. I was warned about the customer service in this store (Arlington) but I didn't have a problem. Except for OSU location you need to check when dining room is open. Dublin"s dine-in was blocked off. I couldn't even use their restroom. UA location has scaled back their dine-in hours also. I have been going to Tommy's for over 50 years. On a good day you can't beat their pizza. I do miss the distinctive taste the Italian subs used to have. read more

I cannot say enough about my love of Tommy's pizza. While they will be going away when Tommy retires it is the best pizza I have ever had.

Some of the best pizza in Columbus! I know for sure they have the best sauce here though! The veggies are always fresh, never soggy. Wonderful salads and sides. We lived in UA for 3 yrs and were fans of Tommy's and felt lucky it was right around the corner. Then we move out here and find out it's one a mile and a half away here, made it even better lol read more

I've been a Tommy's pizza fan for a LOOOOONNG time. Something has changed I was hopeful it was just a random bad night last time I had it but I gave it another try this evening. Crust is not the same. Used to be crisp cracker crust. (not just the edge pieces) And it seems like there is some kind of oil used to bake it? Leaves a coating in your mouth. And there use be a good garlicky taste to the cheese also not the same. I'm disappointed. Hope it's just a supply chain issue and you change it back to the OG Tommy's fan favorites. read more

The other day I had a craving for an Italian sub. A good one, not from Subway or Jimmy Johns or whatever. And I realized while running errands that there was a Tommy's nearby. The last time I had Tommy's was, jeez, almost 30 years ago, at the one near campus. It was good, if memory serves, but so much has happened since then that I wasn't sure what to expect here. Plus, even though I knew where it was it was still hard to find, tucked back into a corner of, well, Tommy's Plaza. It's not much to look at, inside or out. The menu is fairly basic- pizza, subs, Italian dinners. I was a little skeptical until the food came out. Then- wow. Exactly what I had hoped for. I got the basic Italian sub. Plus, wanting to try the pizza I remembered, a mini pepperoni (thinking it would be pretty small.) Either is a good lunch, so I had plenty of leftovers. The pizza was piping hot, and I was jonesing, so I started with the sub. A great rendition of a classic: good, hearty bread, crispy outside and soft inside. Good meats, decent veggies, and dressing dripping off but still not making things mushy. Just what I wanted. The pizza was bigger than I expected, and another great version of a classic. Thin crispy crust, greasy but not overly so, good cheese and sauce, great pepperoni (and plenty of slices.) I had the leftovers cold later and they were still great. They have lots of other toppings, including all the usual suspects but also shrimp and oysters. Service was good- friendly, efficient. Prices- I think I paid $14, which is pretty darn good for the quantity and quality. It's not fancy, but it has been around awhile because they know what they are doing. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Mini pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Tommy's always hits the spot. We get the Italian Sub, the meatball sub and a pepperoni, sausage, green peppers and onions pizza.

Although I am out of state I had a longtime friend from Columbus OH rave and rave about Tommy's pizza. Today my wife and I found ourselves driving north from Lexington KY through Columbus at dinner time. We were driving withing 5 miles of Tommy's Dublin location on the interstate, so we had to stop for dinner. Contrary to some of the reviews (for the campus store I think) our server was timely, very efficient and courteous. We had our drinks and a salad within 4 or 5 minutes. The restaurant was moderately full and scrupulously clean. No problems there. When our pizza arrived, in about 14 to 16 minutes it was brimming with great aromas. Being a pizza snob, I disassembled a slice to get a handle on the ingredients before I sampled them together for harmony. Here are my observations: We all know about Tommy's layered pseudo cracker crust. Crispy at the edges and more tender as one goes towards inward slices. Surprisingly it got crispier as it cooled! The star was the pepperoni. I was able to recognize it, as I once drove over 250 miles R/T to score a case of it. It is one of the most respected pepperoni's for flavor profile by elite operators and reasonably hard to obtain. Trust me, Tommy's is using one of the best, if not THE best pepperoni available. I can't prove it, but my taste buds know with a high probability. The sauce was balanced and bright. The mushrooms were fresh and copious. Now for he cheese. There was loads of glorious cheese. I personally think it is a blend of 3 cheeses due to the melt and the color. It was very nuanced and balanced on its own. I am going to try to investigate a possible blend in the future. Now when you put this masterpiece together, it is near perfection for this style of pizza. Each bite, balanced and with a bit of a kick depending on how much pepperoni was in the bite. I would not overload this style with 4 or 5 heavy, dense and watery toppings. I think you will throw off the balance. Stick with the cheese and pepperoni and add ONE other topping if you must. You will not be disappointed. I will be back, and next time I will order something larger, or perhaps two pies, so I can take one home. read more

Tommy's Pizza - The BEST, pepperoni and mushroom Tommy's pizza at Dublin restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

My favorite pizza in Ohio. Keep it simple with the pepperoni. It's amazing. This place is always busy, so plan ahead. read more

My husband and I order Tommy's a few times each year. We've now ordered Tommy's twice since May to try & support local business. Last night our pizza was perfect. The crust was super crisp (not burned) which I love and there was just the right cheese to toppings ratio. We've only dined in once (pre-covid) & service was a tad slow but for carry out we've never had any issues. We will be back. read more

They definitely save a small fortune on rent at their Dublin location. It's nearly impossible to find if you're unfamiliar. Also, it should be noted that you can disregard their listed hours of operation as they will close the store whenever it suits them. The more you know! read more

I maintain that Tommy's Pizza is a perfect example of a Columbus style(crispy thin crust, cut in squares) pizza. I usually order a large pepperoni with a basket of fries. Additionally, their quality is consistent. I have never received an over(or under) cooked pizza. In regard to service and the environment, the service is great and the restaurant is nothing fancy. However, I focus on quality of food and service. Restaurant environment is not what keeps me coming back. read more

This pizza was pretty decent. It was not The greatest. I heard a lot of people talk about it and it is like they have not ventured to any other pizza restaurant in town. Before I lay claim that a pizza place is the best in the city or one of the best. I have to had tried out a huge vast majority of places. Okay pizza and okay customer service. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Our favorite local pizza restaurant. We always order the special - a large pizza, garlic cheese bread and a pitcher of pop. The food is excellent, the service is always great and the restaurant is extremely clean. It is a great place for families and also for a casual date night. I highly recommend Tommy's Pizza. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Last 2 of 3 pizzas lacked cheese and flavor. Been a fan for 40 years. Step it up guys! read more

Tommy's Pizza - "Extra" cheese pizza. Been a fan of Tommy's for over 40 years. Last 2 of 3 pizzas not good. Lacked cheese & no flavor. Step it up guys!! - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I have always loved Tommy's pizza, and have lived in Columbus for 50 years. My folks were in town last night so we went there for a blast from the past. It was not especially busy and our server was horrible. First she came and took our drink orders and took way to long to come back. Then when the pizza came my pops likes to put extra parmesan on his, I was able to catch here before she ran away and ask for some. Again way to long when bye, I saw her at the front desk doing something, obviously forgot, so I went up and got it. Our drink were empty somewhere along the way, I had to speak up to get her attention as she finally walked by. Way to long went bye again, I saw here at the front desk doing something so I went up and asked. Her response "I have better things to do" WHAT!!!! My folks were with me so I let it slide. Then she brings the check, again on the slow side. I was coming back from the rest room and she feels it necessary to say very sarcastically and with that kid attitude "Sorry for your horrible service" I went back to the table and asked the guy clearing the table for a manager. As it turned out he was the manager so I expressed by displeasure about her comments. He was very dismissive and said he would handle it, as server girl kept looking at me and giving me the evil eye. You would think he would have at least given out a coupon for a free pizza or something. He was lucky my folks were there otherwise I would have really expressed by displeasure. Sorry Tommy's but if that is the way to treat your customers then there are plenty of other pizza shops. read more

The pizza here is the best around, no joke. But good luck getting it in a timely manner or even getting decent customer service if you need ANYTHING. And if you venture to the rest of the menu, the food is pretty sub-par for Italian. I think it's the pizza that's keeping Tommy's in business because there's really nothing else standout about this place. read more

Was very disappointed to find out that the chicken noodle soup I ordered for lunch was Progressive Soup, probably out of a can! I do NOT recommend ordering soups from here. The meatball I ordered however, was very good, as was the red sauce. I'll now know to stick with the pizza/subs. read more

Tommy's is different. It's not fancy, it's greasy and it does has plenty of cheese. It's cut into squares but it's definitely a little chewy and buttery. They don't skimp on toppings, either. The sausage and meatballs are fantastic. It's oily as heck, though, but that's how pizza should be. Prices are reasonable and pizzas come out pretty quick. read more

I had high hopes for this delivery. I ordered the cheese balls with a side of bbq sauce (slight up charge for the sauce) and a small pepperoni pizza. I first started to unravel the Saran from the cup of bbq sauce and found 2/3 of a black hard shelled small bug in between the Saran and the outside of the lid. I tossed the sauce and went for the pizza. Clearly I was starving to keep going...picking off anything black that could have been the other 1/3. Ughh after 2 pieces my hunger subsided and I got more grossed out. Glad I was done before my husband noticed the hair on the side we hadn't eaten. Yuck. One and done Tommy. read more

Tried Tommys's yesterday and was disappointed. Crust was chewy not crisp. Less pepperoni. Just not as good as remembered. Won't be going back. read more

Our first pizza experience in Columbus. I went off the reviews and it was pretty good pizza. However, the large pies were small for the price we paid. This spot is a nice welcoming restaurant that gives you old school vibes. As soon as you walk in you are met with the overwhelmingly scrumptious smell of fresh pies. Don't get me wrong, this is very good pizza but for the price you pay the pizzas are small. This place wouldn't be an ideal choice if you were feeding a lot of folks. But I personally feel that a large cheese would go great with a few beers while watching a game. It's worth checking out. read more

Nestled serenely near the banks of the picturesque Scioto River, this locally owned and operated establishment offers much more than the atmosphere of a "business;" it has the feel of family. On every occassion that i patronize Tommy's Pizza, it feels like I'm settling in for a meal amongst family and friends. The quaint, cozy dining room only further facilitates the good vibrations. Their lunch specials , in particular, cannot be trumped, and leave other local business shaking in their boots come mid day. Employees...ney, friends, warm this already intimately laid out venue. Carli warms my ventures to Tommy's with her welcoming smile and exuberance. Another of my Tommy's companions, Sidney, reminds me of my younger days, when i was bright-eyed, bushy tailed, and, for lack of a better word, alive. My heart is warmed with every bite of my All The Way. Lynn, a Tommy's institution, has evolved into the Mother figure I've yearned for since I was 6. In closing, go to Tommy's. Enter expecting good pizza, great prices, and one of Columbus' best locally owned businesses. But once you leave, two things will be wildly evident: you will have made friends for life, who will change the way you think, act, live, breath. And in addition, you'll be aching to come back. read more

We order weekly from this location having moved away from the Lane Ave area. Last night I had delivered an Italian sub and mini cheese pizza well done. The pizza was burnt unable to be eaten while the sub had a soggy bottom bun. When I called them to see if a refund or credit was an option, they told me the delivery service was responsible. What? They were the ones preparing the food! At the Lane Ave location, they refunded a delivery that was someone else's order and were very accommodating by giving us a refund. Not happy with this place. read more

Fantastic pizza! We've only done carryout and service was quick and friendly. Their crust is crispy on the outside and airy, but chewy inside. The veggie pizza had lots of toppings that were fresh. The pizza was cooked enough- in my opinion most places don't get pizza done enough. It's a little drive for us, but it's so good we will be back. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Medium veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

We are new to the area and one night last week we were looking for our new favorite pizza place. We tried Tommy's, and it was a pretty disappointing experience. Unfortunately, the wrong pizza was delivered to us. When I called Tommy's I was told it wasn't their problem it was Door Dash's problem and there was nothing they would do. Normally I would've eaten the pizza anyway, but it was pepperoni pizza and I'm a vegetarian. I will admit my husband and sons who are not vegetarian liked the pizza, but it was disappointing that they gave the wrong pizza to door dash and then refused to correct their mistake. The receipt attached to the pizza box had the correct order on it, they simply put the wrong pizza with it. I'm guessing someone else probably wasn't thrilled with the green pepper pizza they got instead of their pepperoni. read more

Great pizza! Crispy crust, great toppings. Meatball sub is amazing. Chicken tender app was delicious and it was obvious the ranch was made in-house. read more